Cruise line glossy brochures and their enticing adverts promise a carefree and trouble-free vacation, BUT they don’t tell the whole story. There are several important things that can and do significantly impact us as passengers that the lines seem reluctant to talk about or be upfront about.
Welcome aboard, I'm Gary Bembridge and join me as I unmask five unspoken things that directly affect us all, and why I believe you need to know more about them.
ABOUT TIPS FOR TRAVELLERS: If you want to get cruising right, Tips For Travellers makes it easy to plan and have the incredible cruise experiences you dream of every time. All my Tips For Travellers advice, tips and tricks tips draw on everything that I have learnt on the 101 cruises I have done to date.
00:00 Start 00:27 Hidden Operators 04:45 Being Watched 06:30 Man Overboard 07:28 Not All Countries Equal 09:02 Hidden Cruise Contract Issues
Cruise line glossy brochures and their enticing adverts promise a
carefree and trouble-free vacation, BUT they don’t tell the whole story. There
are several important things that can and do significantly impact us as passengers
that the lines seem reluctant to talk about or be upfront about.
Welcome aboard, I'm Gary Bembridge and join me as I unmask five unspoken things
that directly affect us all, and why I believe you need to know more about them.
Most passengers assume that everything on the ship is operated by the cruise
line itself. However, this is far from the truth. Several high-profile
on-board facilities and activities are run by third-party contractors.
This has significant implications for us passengers as buried deep in the
cruise contract, cruise lines say they will not accept liability for
those contractors' activities even if we have serious issues with them.
One that surprises many is that on several lines the medical centres are run by third parties.
While lines that are part of the Carnival Corporation, Norwegian Cruise Group,
and Royal Caribbean Group appear to have their own cruise line operated medical centres,
some other lines have them staffed and run by external companies like Vikand,
Vanter Cruise Health Services, and Marine Medical Solutions.
At time of recording lines including Viking, Virgin Voyages, Ritz Carlton, SAGA, Azamara,
Crystal, Disney, Windstar, and Sea Dream are listed as clients of those companies
Almost all cruise lines contract out their spas and fitness centres,
and most to a company called OneSpaWorld. Based on their website, they currently
operate spas for 21 cruise lines. This includes Carnival, Celebrity, Crystal,
Cunard, Holland America, Norwegian Cruise Line, Oceania, Princess, Royal Caribbean and Seabourn.
Despite the unique branding of each line’s spa, such as the Lotus Spa on
Princess and Mandara Spa on Norwegian, they are all run by that same company.
The spa staff, who do not work for the cruise line,
rely heavily on commissions from selling products and up-selling services to us passengers. Hence
that heavy sell at the end of every treatment and constant push to buy treatment packages.
In one of her posts about her time working as a massage and beauty therapist in ship spas,
Lucy who runs "Cruising as Crew" YouTube channel and blog said "It is very sales
driven. You will be given targets and expected to hit them. This comes
from the expectation that you will sell something to every guest that you have"
Other than MSC Cruises, it seems the shops on most cruise ships
are not operated by the lines themselves. Instead, third-party companies run them.
The two main ones are LVMH’s Starboard Cruise Services that runs shops for 15
lines including Celebrity, Carnival, Holland America, Royal Caribbean, and Virgin Voyages.
The other is the UK-based Harding+ which runs shops for 14 lines including Cunard,
Fred Olsen, Oceania, Princess, P&O Cruises and Regent.
This means that the staff in these shops are not employed by the cruise line but
by those companies, and their income is largely commission-based. This explains
the frequent promotions and sales events on board
Additionally, those port shopping advisors on Caribbean, Alaska, and Mediterranean
sailings who give talks with prize draws for attending, free gifts, and collectables,
and also provide maps of recommended shops in port, are also not employed by the cruise line.
They work for companies like LVMH’s Onboard Media and PPI Selling At Sea,
and the cruise lines receive significant fees for these arrangements from stores
paying to take part and commissions from sales.
Many lines do not hire their own photographers nor
run their own photo shops, and these are run by contractors.
Hence why photographers are often pushy about taking our
photos as they are reliant on generating sales.
Speaking to on-board photographers they confirmed to me they earn a
small basic salary, and most of their earnings come from taking
lots of photos of us and encouraging us to buy them and photo packages.
I think many passengers do realise that cruise lines do not run the Art Auctions and sales on
board, as the two main companies running them make it clear they are not part of the line.
These are Park West that are on most lines,
and the UK-based Claredon Fine Art which is on Cunard and P&O. But again, as with the others,
it means you are not dealing with the cruise line if you have issues.
You’re Being Watched
Most cruisers don’t appreciate that they are being recorded and can be tracked constantly.
Cruise ships are equipped with extensive surveillance systems,
including CCTV cameras in every public area and corridors. The only areas on
most ships not covered by cameras are inside the cabins, restrooms, and spa changing rooms.
Most lines also use sophisticated facial recognition technology to identify passengers.
The photo taken at check in, or the one you submitted when checking in online,
is used by this to do everything from identifying you in any photos the ship photographer takes,
so they can then be found by you on entering your cabin number,
to identifying individuals by name involved in or witness to any incident,
and used in some cases for checking passengers on and off the ship.
Some cruise lines, like Princess Cruises,
have taken tracking a step further with their wearable Princess Medallion device.
This not only opens your cabin door, allows you to order and charge drinks and onboard purchases to
your cabin, but also tracks your location around the ship and enables crew to address you by name
by showing your picture and name on their devices and at restaurant check in when you approach them.
On your next cruise look up and around and you will see CCTV cameras everywhere.
And remember that while they may not be on your balcony, CCTV cameras do have visibility on them.
Something to consider if you are thinking of any “adult” or nude sunbathing activity out there!
There is one surveillance technology that most cruise ships do not have,
but many feel they should.
It appears that few ships have Man Overboard Detection Systems.
These systems, which use thermal cameras and micro radars to detect
when someone has gone overboard, cost around $200,000 per ship to
install according to one of the companies that makes them (MARSS’ MOBtronic system)
Cruise lines are reluctant to comment or say how many ships do have them,
but the most recent reports I could find claim that only 30 ships, all from Carnival and Disney,
have these systems installed. There are over 300 cruise ships sailing.
Data from CLIA (the Cruise Line International
Association) reports that between 19 and 25 people go overboard a year. So,
without these systems, cruise lines can only confirm and react after being notified of a
man overboard incident and then confirm by reviewing CCTV footage and any sightings.
Passengers from different countries often receive different treatment when booking cruises, this
includes fare inclusions and exclusions, booking terms, deposits, final payments, and even fares.
This is largely driven by rules, regulations,
cultural differences, and market and competitive norms.
For example, USA residents have the option of refundable
deposits but UK residents booking in the UK never have that option.
USA residents booking a Cunard Queens Grill suite at time of making this has
the drinks package included in the fare, but any other country resident does not.
UK residents booking a Viking cruise have 90-day final balance payments,
while in the USA it usually must be paid up to a year before the cruise.
Australians booking a cruise will have gratuities included as tipping is not part of the culture.
I could quote many more examples as there are many cases where the lines have different perks,
terms and conditions based on the country you reside in.
Most lines also only allow you to book a cruise with an agent in the country you reside,
and even if due to exchange rates changes fares for a cruise you want
to do are more attractive to book in another country, they will not allow you to do this.
When we book a cruise, we automatically accept the cruise line terms and conditions in their
cruise contract. But few ever read the small print which contains some surprising things.
For example, we agree the cruise line can search our baggage, person,
and cabin at any time, and that they can confine us to our cabin,
or in the ship's brig (on board prison), with no compensation for a range of reasons,
such as suspected norovirus and covid or, of course, disruptive or criminal behaviour.
We also agree that we can be disembarked at our own cost if the Captain decides we should.
Importantly, they also say they can change itineraries or not call on
advertised ports if they deem it necessary for any reason – again without compensation.
I get contacted frequently by upset passengers that a
key port that they booked to cruise for is dropped or could not be called on.
Of course, this can be out of the control of the cruise line due to weather, or as is the
case as I make this where lines are not stopping into San Juan due to unplanned pier repairs.
But it may be due to financial or other reasons like lines are currently abruptly
dropping calling into some Icelandic ports following a sudden addition of new fees.
Some lines say that they can take photographs and video images of
you and may even use them in marketing or advertising material, without paying you.
But at the same time, some say they can stop or restrict you
taking photographs or videos on their ships.
This happens. For example, the vloggers Ben and David of Cruise with Ben and David have
spoken about being stopped filming on MSC in the past.
Some lines even say they can require you to take down any images or posts you've
placed on social media or blogs. My friend Sarah was once asked to take a post down,
much to her shock after posting about some issues on a maiden voyage.
There is one area that is full of surprises and things the lines do
not talk about much when it comes to crew.
For example, I was shocked to discover from a senior officer on a recent cruise,
that on many lines people doing the same job on a ship get paid different salaries based
on which country they come from and the prevailing wages there.
To find out more about this and other things you probably don't know about cruise ship crew,
join me over in this video. See you over there.