I Can't Afford My $1,200 Car Payment 📈 Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a Free Personalized Plan. https://ter.li/5h1r0i
Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/phuofx • 🏘️ Free Tools & Resources to Reach Your Home Goals - https://ter.li/bq1s4j • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
[Music]
brought to you by y refi refinance your
defaulted private student loans today at
y rei.com Ramsey so I am 23 years old um
I roughly have about 90,000 in debt um
47 of that is uh a car loan my payment
uh per month is
$11,200 okay um when I bought the car I
was making roughly 150 per year um lost
both those jobs and now I make about 60
per year and um just wondering should I
voluntarily surrender my car um I really
can't afford it anymore with um between
rent and cost of living um I have 47 on
the car about 37 in student loans and
6,000 on credit cards um I did uh
complete baby step number one working on
number
two um my mom also mentioned that she
thinks I should file for bankruptcy I'm
not sure if that's the best solution but
I just wanted to get your guys' thought
on
that no on the bankruptcy side I'll just
I'll just say that yeah first and
foremost we're not there we're not even
close so there's some some good news for
you I think Mom wants you to get a clean
slate and she's kind of wanting you to
just shortcut this and and be free from
the pain uh but there's better options
here and so let's talk about the car
instead of a voluntary you know repo
could you sell it and come up with the
amount you're underwater
on uh the car is only worth about 25 so
did you roll negative
equity uh I might be able to but no did
did you from a previous car how do you
owe 50 Grand and the car is worth less
than half of
that uh the the a
the per um interest on it is
25% oh my
goodness when I bought the car it was
during Co um I needed a new car um
didn't have much credit and uh they
would only approve me for a brand new
car I could not get approved for a used
card and you said sure 25% sounds good
that's reasonable let's go I need this
$50,000 car oh and when you're making
150 this is the problem you feel like
okay well I can afford payments and if I
can afford the payment everything's fine
and and that's the backwards way of of
going into when it comes to buying a car
but that's what a lot of people do I can
afford the payment so regardless of how
much interest it is uh I can afford it
and then life happens as you've
experienced okay uh job-wise Alex what
have you what were you doing before you
said you had two jobs that you lost what
were those uh I was a payroll manager
for it company and then I was an
assistant manager for a uh retail store
okay and what happened to those jobs uh
the retail store ended up uh closing
down um and um I wasn't able to get
relocated and the it um firm also shut
down oh okay so both companies closed
what are you doing now uh I work in it
still um on like the administrative side
okay
okay um single
family kids single okay where are you
living uh Cleveland okay are you living
alone renting uh rent uh with a roommate
um 1300 split between the two of us okay
that's good um okay so yeah I mean the
getting the car out do the 25,000 that
it's worth where did you pull that
number from from a dealership or from
like Kelly Blue Book uh Kelly Blue Book
and a couple other like just look uh
like browsing seeing like what similar
um but it's not tradein value that's
private party value yes private party oh
man yeah cuz the problem is you need to
come up with the difference even if you
do a voluntary repossession they're
going to sell it at auction for way less
than it's even worth and you're still
going to owe the difference yeah so it
doesn't really it doesn't solve all of
your problems to even do the voluntary
repo that's why we're trying to find
another solution where you come up with
the difference I'd rather you be 25
Grand in debt driving a beater than 47
grand in
debt yeah and that's that's kind of my
thought process too trust me I know this
was probably the worst financial
decision I've ever made uh but yeah I
rather drive a hoopie at this point then
you know D are you able to keep current
with your other bills Alex right now
making
60 yes this this credit card debt is not
ongoing to keep lights on and everything
no I'm slowly paying that off thankfully
I mean honestly Alex if I were in your
shoes I mean I would figure out a way I
mean it's about 18K for the difference
of the car and you're probably not going
to be able to get a loan for the
difference well you said you you owe 47
on the car 43 oh 47 oh I wrote 43 47
okay so you're 22 22 under so that I
mean ideally we'd say hey go to your
local credit union get a a loan for the
difference maybe 25 Grand and three of
that on a beater car but I don't know
that they'd even grant you that loan at
this point have you
tried no I haven't tried um I kind of
wanted to search all my options
beforehand sure yeah that's the the
least harmful of the options is to go to
a credit union and see if you can get
the difference in a loan and maybe a
little bit more in order to get a beater
car get rid of this payment and then
you'll be climbing your way out of this
and then hopefully in the meantime we
can get your income back up to six
figures cuz clearly you're skilled
enough and you're willing to do the work
yeah for for sure yeah if you can get
that 60 up for a full-time job and find
something 75 or 80 right in like a
perfect world and then the side hustle
is what I mean that's what I would be
doing Alex and I'm like if you can make
God I mean you'd have to make 3,000
extra a month I me I'm trying to do the
math of how to do this within a year um
to get to even save the amount for the
difference right so Best Bets you can
take a loan for the difference and like
George said earlier a a local credit
union is going to be your best bet
versus a bank um they're the ones that
are probably actually going to sit down
with you and run more numbers and look
um but so that would be my first option
and then if not that's probably what I
would do I would probably try to get out
of this car before anything else even
before the solves half your problems y
yeah if you can get out of that and then
now the second half at least it's
bearable and you can climb out of that
pretty quickly even making what you make
it's it's a solvable problem but I do
think income is the biggest part and
then your lifestyle is going to have get
cut down to nothing for probably the
next 18
months yeah and so this is no eating out
this is hey the roommate wants sorry I
can't hang out I'm working three jobs
it's it's not going to be a fun Journey
but the good news is you're young enough
that you have a lot of time to make up
for
this so all hope is not lost you don't
need to go file for bankruptcy George
would you if you were him would you save
the 25,000 first get the car out and
then do the dead snowball or would you
start I just don't know how quickly he's
going to save up 25 yes that is cuz I do
Wonder Alex too if you got if you paid
off the six credit cards and did just
the traditional debt snowball how much
um payments monthly will be freed up
because those are paid off so even just
working down the debt snowball but
knowing you have a freaking $1,200 car
payment till you get to it to pay off is
not fun um but in the meantime I almost
would just work the Deb snowball till
you get there but yeah uh thanks for the
call Alex good luck to you we learn from
our mistakes George we learn from our
mistakes why refi refinances delinquent
private student loans for struggling
borrowers learn more at
yy.com Ramsey