Frederick 'Johnnie' Walker - The U-Boat Purge Continues (Part 3 - July to December 1943)

Solid Waves - Marine Corps Channel
24 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 25, 2025
In our previous episode, we saw Commander Walker become Captain Walker and receive command of a
hunting group of Sloops. We left the action on the 1st of June 1943 aboard HMS Starling.
And now, the continuation.
On the bridge of HMS Starling, Lieutenant Byrne, currently officer of the watch,
grabbed the telephone.
Yes, what is it?
Submarine on the surface, transmitting on bearing 225 degrees. Must be about 20 miles away, sir.
That was one Archie Pitt, the high-frequency direction finding operator.
In line with Walker's instructions, Byrne quickly ordered,
Port 15, midships, steady, steer 225, full speed ahead both.
Once he felt the deck rumble as Starling picked up speed,
he opened the voice pipe to the captain's cabin.
Captain, sir?
Yes, what is it?
Submarine on the surface, reported by high-frequency direction finding.
Right-o.
Seconds later, Walker materialised on the bridge,
quickly checked the situation, and got to work.
Sound action stations, make to the group, keep station on me, course 225, speed 18 knots,
ships to be 4 miles apart.
The second support group quickly swung out in line abreast,
akin to an ancient line of galleys, as crewmen in various states of dress
made the short distances between wherever they'd been at the time and their battle positions.
Luckily on a sloop, you never have that far to go.
Wild Goose began signalling by light,
have picked up U-boat on high-frequency direction finding bearing 228.
Starling's own high-frequency direction finding confirmed its bearing of 225,
and the navigator ran the two lines together,
and estimated a distance to the contact between 15 and 20 miles.
Shortly after 10-hundred, the distance had closed,
and lookouts reported seeing a vortex of water.
Moments later, the ASDIC team reported a contact at roughly the same location.
This, as it turned out, was U-202,
making its way home with only 30 tonnes of diesel left.
Its commanding officer had been called to the conning tower
by the report from a lookout of the masts of a convoy.
He'd taken a look through the biggest pair of binoculars that he had aboard,
turned to the man who'd made the report, and said
or at least that was the polite version that went on the record.
U-202 immediately dove to 500 feet and went silent.
It was a tactic that had worked well in the past.
Meanwhile, up on Starling's bridge,
Walker asked the chief engineer to come to the bridge,
and when he did so, he pointed to one side.
Chief, there's a U-boat out there.
Kite's going well, isn't she?
Watch her for a couple of minutes.
Kite was drawing ahead of her compatriots.
Walker was still concentrating on the horizon when the engineer vanished down a ladder,
and moments later, Starling started vibrating even harder and began to claw back Kite's lead.
By 10.15, Starling was decelerating as she began to stalk.
The ASDIC contact was passed on to the other ships,
and Walker ordered his ship in for an attack run,
while Wild Goose and Kite came in close to maintain contact.
During his time at Western Approaches Command and working with the Western Approaches Tactical Unit,
Walker picked up a common tactic in Atlantic Wolfpacks was for one submarine to go dormant
whilst another nearby sub set up a shot at the escort that was heading for the first sub.
Just in case this was the case, he ordered Signet, Woodpecker and Wren
to patrol around the edge of the attack zone just in case.
For the first time outside of drill, Starling hoisted the black pennant and charged.
Six depth charges went over the stern,
while launchers on either side sent four more soaring through the sky.
After a few seconds, the sea erupted behind them,
and Starling swung about and trained her guns, but nothing came to the surface.
Kite and Wild Goose had maintained the contact,
and witnessed U-202 dodge and weave like a snake in tall grass.
Starling reacquired, but as more depth charges went into the sea, a pattern began to emerge.
Each time it heard a ship pass overhead, U-202 would change course,
and then when the depth charges began exploding, it would change course again.
Making holding the contact rather difficult amidst the noise created by all the explosions.
Walker tried something different, running all three nearby ships across the contact in a line.
In theory, this should create a square of depth charges centred on the submarine,
from which no escape was possible.
But with contact being lost several hundred yards before the drops could be made,
even this seemed to do no good against the cunning U-202.
Walker thus changed his tactics yet a third time, forming a V-shape and slowing right down.
Starling was about 1500 yards behind the U-boat at the tip of the V,
and was directing the other two ships in at 5 knots.
They were creeping along so as not to be heard.
The first warning U-202 should have would be the splash of depth charges.
This prompted a new behaviour.
U-202 began randomly speeding up, slowing down,
changing course and depth and dropping numerous bubble decoys.
Whilst this did keep her alive for now, Walker settled for this particular approach,
as it meant that the sub was burning through its batteries and air much,
much faster as it had to keep moving, rather than wait for Walker to do something.
The calculation he'd made was that the sub would probably try and surface just after dark to try
its luck with torpedoes, and that its batteries might then have an hour or two left.
The sub would therefore probably try and make a break for it on the surface around midnight
when those ran out. Evening came and went, and no torpedo attack materialised.
But then, two minutes after midnight,
Submarine surfacing, bearing green 30, sir.
Very well, starshell, commence, commence, commence.
The flares of the starshell illuminated the conning tower of the sub,
which was already powering ahead as it engaged its diesels.
Every gun in range on all six sloops opened up, a 4-inch shell was seen to hit just after
the conning tower, sending billows of red smoke up into the night air.
More shells of various sizes began to slam home as Starling raced into RAM.
The range closed below the capability of the forward guns to depress,
but as the sloop approached, it became clear that the sub was in a bad way.
Wanting to preserve his ship for later, if he could, Walker ordered the sloop hard to starboard,
breaking the sub as he passed by with the 20mm Oerlikons on the port side and sending a pair
of depth charges set to shallow detonation either side of the U-boat using the port side K-guns.
The charges detonated in the wake of the Starling, and the sub was seen to be bodily lifted clear
out of the ocean on plumes of water. When the smoke cleared, the sub was sinking by the stern,
the conning tower broken, and the crew were in the midst of abandoning ship.
Starling's boats had actually already been manned and launched in the hopes of capturing the sub
whilst the water was still in the air, but it was clear that the shattered vessel was already
starting a terminal dive, and so the boats diverted instead to hauling survivors out of the water.
Twenty-six sailors and four officers, including the commanding officer,
were rescued and then held aboard the boats until the identity of their sub had been ascertained.
Then they were hauled aboard Starling and Wild Goose and the wounded taken to the ship's doctors.
Thanks to their efforts, only one of the German sailors would succumb to their wounds.
After thanking Kapitän Leutnant Gunther Poser for what he described as
an excellent bit of group training, Walker ordered his ships to splice the main brace.
The group then headed back to Liverpool, lending the prisoners an accordion which one of the U-boat
crew played with some skill, leading his fellows in a number of German songs which were appreciated
by the crew for their cadence and tone, if not for their ability to actually understand a word
of what was being said. Upon arrival, to much congratulations, Western Approaches Command
tabulated the results of the voyage as follows. 1. The creeping attack, and the variations of it
devised by Walker on the day, were shown to be a powerful new tactical weapon under action
conditions. 2. Nevertheless, U-boats could dive deeper than the current set of depth charges
could be set to explode. Nearly four years after the start of the battle against them,
the escorts still did not have a weapon capable of destroying a U-boat at its maximum dive depth.
3. Time was essential to make quite certain of a kill. 4. There were some signs that German morale
was weakening. This last had come from interrogations of the submarine's crew, some of whom
it turned out had been less than thrilled to be assigned to the U-boat corps. It also emerged that
quite a number of Walker's attack runs had actually been perfectly spot on, but U-202 had
been taken down eventually to 820 feet, which was 120 foot past her test depth, and that had given
her a 300 foot cushion of water between the hull and depth charge even on its deepest setting,
even if it exploded directly above the sub. Ironically enough, Walker's son Timothy had
just gone to sea aboard the submarine HMS Parthian, headed for the Mediterranean.
The loss of U-202 capped off a disastrous time for the Kriegsmarine's U-boats. During the month
of May, they had lost more U-boats in 31 days than they had during the whole of 1941, and almost
half as many as they had lost in the entirety of 1942. Having re-provisioned, Walker's ships
learned that they had been assigned to a new area, the Bay of Biscay. This was the primary
transit route for U-boats heading to and from the Atlantic. Coastal Command had gradually been
putting more and more aircraft over the area in a bid to force the U-boats to remain submerged,
which would slow down their passage and occasionally allowed the aircraft to pick
one off. Long-range Junkers 88s had tried to stop the Liberators, Catalinas and Sunderlands,
and this often led to epic dogfights in the skies as multiple multi-engine bombers and flying boats
tried to pick each other off with a variety of fixed, turreted and pintle-mounted machine guns
and cannons. For the crews of Coastal Command, this was exceedingly dangerous work. There were
no Allied ships in the area, and the chances of being picked up if shot down at all were slim.
The seas were usually fairly rough and empty, and in the rare event that a ship showed up,
it was almost certainly going to be German. Now though, even more resources were brought
in on the Allied side. A second support group would be sent out in late June. The bay had
been divided into two broad operational zones, Musketry and Sea Slug, and the second was to
the former in concert with Allied aircraft. Anything on the surface would in theory be
found and then either sunk or forced to dive by aircraft, and anything that dove could be
hunted by the second. HMS Signet and Starling were missing, the former having been reassigned
to another escort group, the latter was completing some minor repairs and would follow a few days
later. Walker therefore temporarily sailed in Woodpecker. As well as another support group
was operating in the Sea Slug area, squadrons of Mosquitoes and Bow Fighters were being deployed
in numbers, not just to spot and harass U-Boats, but to turn the tables on any German aircraft that
might try and interfere. Starling ended up having a little adventure of its own on its way to catch
up. First it ran into a storm which flattened the breakwater, then an ASDIC contact actually
turned out to be a wreck, they only discerned this when they dropped a depth charge attack
which yielded wreckage in the form of many many dead eels. A random empty landing craft was
encountered and sunk by gunfire, and then a chase after a submarine which had been reported by an
aircraft found them sailing through a minefield. Finally a search for a dinghy from a shot down
aircraft likewise proved unsuccessful. Further south the first few days of the joint operation
have proved rather frustrating, this kind of close coordination between aircraft and ships
had not really been tried before at least in this role, and working out if an aircraft's report was
actually a U-Boat or just a bit of flotsam or was even in the right position had proved somewhat
irritating. One aircraft had radioed that it was definitely a U-Boat and it was in fact circling
the U-Boat and could see the conning tower, the hull and everything, but gave a position that
once it was plotted on the charts apparently told them that there was a U-Boat circling the
town of Chambly which is a few miles north of Paris and mainland France. Thus on the morning
of the 24th of June the crews of the second were a little bit tired and settling in for another long
day when suddenly the ASDIC operator reported that a submarine had been contacted a thousand
yards ahead along with a somewhat weird whistling noise. Action stations sounded, Walker vaulted up
a ladder to the bridge and the officer in charge of the depth charges who had been lowering himself
into a bathtub made for his action station at full speed pausing just long enough to wrap a
towel around his waist which would be his primary battle dress for the next little while. Starling
leapt forward and the first pattern of depth charges dropped hoping to catch the submarine
by surprise. The water astern fountained up and the ship began to swing about for another pass
when suddenly everyone started to look aft. The spray from the depth charges was still in the air
as a U-Boat surged upwards from the depths. As Walker recorded, for the enemy to surface in the
exact spot where the eyes of the whole group were concentrated at the first conceivable moment after
the pattern was fired gave such a copybook result that one felt momentarily a sense of disbelief
that this was happening. The sub for some reason now decided to make a break for it on the surface
and the sloops came alive with gunfire. A forest of shell splashes erupted all around the sub
and its bow started to dip. Apparently the captain had realised that this method of escape perhaps
wasn't going to work as well as he thought. Walker ordered Starling in to ram and signalled the other
ships to cease fire. Someone in the flotilla got the message a little bit late and a shell screamed
off of Starling's bow, taking the ball ring, a deck mounted steel frame through which anchor and
mooring cables can be run, with it. Walker blinked, raised an eyebrow and pressed on. Starling then
caught a particularly large swell at the very last moment which lifted her up and over the U-Boat
and so instead of being knifed in the ribs by the ship's bow, U-119 became the unfortunate recipient
of a 1400 tonne elbow drop, the ship's momentum then carrying it forward amidst a scream of
tortured metal as the sub was rolled over by the friction. The sub then went completely inverted
and began to sink as the air rushed out of the ballast tanks to be replaced by water.
Luckily this ensured that Starling's screws weren't hit. As the sub passed by the depth
rails, the towel-wearing John Filiuel sent a shallow pattern astern after it just to make sure.
However, he hadn't counted on the fact that Starling had been significantly slowed by the
collision and she didn't quite get out of the way in time and she then leapt into the air
as the depth charges went off, taking with them every lightbulb on the ship along with much of
the crockery. Woodpecker was actually sweeping in to finish off the sub anyway whilst Starling
tried to assess the damage. The bow was bent at 30 degrees, the ASDIC dome had been scraped off by
the submarine's passage and either the impact or the depth charge explosion or both had caused
flooding in the forward magazines and in various other areas. The crew then set about emergency
damage control as the bow settled by about 3 feet and it turned out Starling could only limp along
at about 10 knots. Nearby, Wren and Wild Goose had detected another U-Boat closing in, presumably
trying to get revenge. The operational ships in the group did their best but it seemed to have
little effect. Walker determined they were probably attacking bubble maker decoys and
summoned Wild Goose alongside, transferring over and taking command, swapping with Commander Weems
who now had to try and keep Starling afloat and get her pointing vaguely in the direction of home.
Walker brought half a dozen key crew members across with him and quickly established that
the new sub was using a similar tactic to U-202, going very deep, which meant that ASDIC lost
contact rather sooner on the attack run than if she'd been shallower and the sub was then using
this time plus the depth to evade the worst of the barrages of depth charges. Walker quickly
organised his creeping attack, first using one ship with a string of depth charges and then
several firing as many as they could. This slow speed operation would only work if the depth
charges were set to maximum depth, otherwise the sloots would be going far too slowly to evade
damage by their own weapons. Although thus far hard to hit, U-449 was brand new and her captain
was also on his first patrol in command. It seems that unlike the more experienced U-202 which was
really prepared to push the envelope, he probably stuck to the submarine's test depth or close to it
and so that afternoon it seems that she took as close to a direct hit as you could reasonably
expect to get from a depth charge, the wreckage that bubbled up in the aftermath of that particular
explosion being a complete mess and clearly more the result of a violent explosion than an implosion.
Starling was limping home further to the north in considerable danger not just from possible bulkhead
failure but from more U-boats whose primary transit lane she had to cross to get back to
Plymouth. They were thus alone when the second splice the main brace signal of the day came
through, preceded by a personal message. To Starling from Captain Walker, Goodbye my gallant
Starling, God be with you. A few hours later, detached after confirming the destruction of U-449,
HMS Kite caught up with and then escorted Starling most of the way to Plymouth,
handing her over to a Hunt-class destroyer that had been dispatched from the port to lead her
in the rest of the way. Starling proceeded at somewhere between 10 and 12 knots, sighting the
Bishop Rock lighthouse on the 26th of June. The chief engineer looked at the clock and realised
there was an outside chance that they might make it into port before the pubs closed if they could
pick up a bit of speed and soon Starling, damage or not, was doing 14 knots, motoring on past the
bathers on the breakwater to some amusement as she was heavily down by the bow with the stern
up in the air and the tips of the propellers thrashing in the open, but proceeding apace
amidst a huge bow wave like an especially determined bloodhound, at least if bloodhounds
could track at sea. They hauled up alongside the Devonport South dockyard, rapidly handed over the
ship to the dockyard workers and their large pumps, and then leave was piped at 8.30 in the evening
and a mad rush for the pubs almost toppled a few of the dockyard men off the gangways.
Walker and the rest of the second would arrive four days later having run low on fuel,
having not encountered any further U-boats and arriving at a somewhat more sedate pace.
Walker then set about prioritising Starling's repairs and found Lieutenant Byrne, who lived in
Kingston-upon-Thames on the outskirts of London, and offered him a first-class sleeper compartment
on the next train to leave the port, as long with an additional day's leave and a taxi from the
station in London to the Admiralty and then back to his home if he would take Walker's official
report with him. That was an offer that didn't really need repeating, although Byrne found
himself using some of his additional leave sitting in front of a lot of gold braid recounting the
attack on U-119 almost blow by blow. With Starling needing more than a few days work,
Walker decided to head back out to the Bay of Biscay on the 3rd of July whilst remaining aboard
Wild Goose, but this patrol netted only some survivors from U-607 which had been sunk by a
Liberator who'd then dropped a life raft nearby for the survivors. Walker suggested instead of
aircraft and ships operating separately and only really communicating when they had something to
say, the aircraft should instead be assigned to the support groups and spiral out from the ships
and then drop markers when they saw something as well as circle it which would allow the ships to
close in when visibility was good or when visibility was low or the aircraft was going
after something on the horizon or over it, they could use the high frequency direction finding
antenna to take a fix on the aircraft's location again as long as it remained overhead. The second,
reinforced by HMS Woodcock, headed out again on the 23rd of July. This led to an interesting
interlude. The Admiralty had declared the operational areas for sub-hunting in the Bay
of Biscay to be prohibited waters and decreed that any neutral vessels found there would be sunk.
This was partially due to concerns that the Germans might try to run supplies under neutral
flags or set up spy boats again under neutral flags but also because the southern portion of
the Bay of Biscay was seasonally awash with Spanish trawlers whose presence would make
spotting surfaced submarines very difficult. On the 25th, the first in a succession of Spanish
fishing trawlers appeared, apparently completely ignoring the Admiralty's instructions.
The second was thus obligated to stop each one in turn, bring the crew aboard and then sink it
with gunfire. The fishermen for some reason thought this was a fantastic experience and a
number applied to join the Royal Navy for the duration of the war there and then. Some of their
lack of concern was discerned when one captain, asked if he was at all upset about the loss of
his ship, revealed that most of this particular fishing fleet was actually owned by a company in
Vichy France and thus all he had to worry about was claiming hazard pay from his employers and
kicking back for a few days rest on the sloop's quarterdeck. Eventually so many Spaniards were
enjoying the pleasure of a cruise courtesy of His Majesty's ships that the next big trawler
they came across was allowed to stay afloat, loaded up with their temporary guests and sent home.
This brief period of light-heartedness ended on the 30th when a liberator radioed that it had found
three U-boats on the surface. Its position was way out but a Sunderland and a Catalina
that had been attached as Walker had asked to the second fanned out in the approximate direction of
the transmission and managed to find subs again. This time they transmitted back a somewhat more
accurate location. Another liberator relieved the first one and two Halifaxes also showed up,
the five aircraft circling at a distance and making the occasional attack run which the three
U-boats apparently decided to try and resist with anti-aircraft gunfire, coordinating between the
three of them to remarkably good effect. These were the resupply or milk cow submarines U-461
and U-462 along with the Type 9 U-504. By the time the conning towers were spotted by the second
at about five minutes past ten in the morning the score was U-462 damaged by bombs and unable
to dive in exchange for which the newly arrived liberator had been shot up such that it had
retired from the action and would eventually either ditch or crash land safely off the Portuguese
coast or slightly on it some hours later, it depends which account you read. Walker decided
that speed now was of the essence and hoisted General Chase, a most unlikely signal for a
submarine hunting group but a welcome one and the sloops promptly began racing each other to try and
get their first. As the sloops closed in the Sunderland used the attention that was being
focused on the liberator to make an unopposed attack run on U-461 sinking it with a direct
hit on the stern. Oddly enough the Sunderland's call sign was also U-461. Thus distracted U-462
and U-504 didn't notice the sloops until they started smothering U-462 in shells forcing it
quickly to scuttle after taking repeated hits. U-504 then came under fire but with a few minutes
grace, thanks to U-462 being the primary target, it managed to dive. Walker quickly boxed the sub
in and then moved to attack although he took additional time to let the chase run through
and just past the drifting survivors of the first two subs instead of promptly setting off hundreds
of pounds of explosive right smack in the middle of them, balancing pragmatism with humanity.
He would record later,
The first attacks failed so Walker set up his creeping attacks again and after a couple of
passes a massive wreckage welled up. Having established that it was definitely the remains
of a U-boat and not decoy material, Walker then turned back to pick up the survivors from the
U-461 and U-462 which included an unfortunate engineering officer from U-462 who had been
trying to clear the U-boat's deck gun of a jam to return fire when he'd opened the breach and
been promptly hit in the face by an empty brass cartridge and knocked overboard with a broken nose.
Only 10 of the Type 14 supply submarines had actually been built and the second and its
aircraft had just sunk 20% of that fleet. U-464 had been lost the previous year, U-463 had been
sunk in March and U-487 and U-459 had gone down less than a few weeks earlier which meant that
the resupply fleet of subs was now at under half strength and by the end of the year only two of
them would be left. The patrol wrapped up with picking up the rather forlorn crew of an FW-200
Condor who'd run into a bowfighter four days earlier and then they also picked up what was
left of the crew of U-454 which had been sunk in a mutual kill with a Sunderland. But there was to
be one last round of excitement. Aircraft sightings seemed to indicate that the Germans, rather fed
up of Walker's shenanigans, had dismatched a large formation of Narvik-class destroyers to get rid
of them. The Narviks, more properly known as the Type 1936As, were each about twice the displacement
of a Sloop and much faster and much more heavily armed. However the second was riding on something
of an adrenaline high and so instead of running away they seemed to have concluded that this was
obviously just a chance for an even bigger and better kill and soon battle ensigns were being
hoisted aboard all the ships and the Sloops headed off at full speed planning for a night engagement
heading down the bearing that had been reported by the aircraft. That evening they almost fell
upon the 40th escort group which was doing a job similar to theirs when they sighted their masts
but they managed to recognise their friendlies in time. Belatedly the Admiralty realised Walker's
men were actually serious about this and having anticipated potential German destroyer interference
they ordered a cruiser they'd stationed further west to proceed at speed in support of the Sloops.
But it seems that whatever ships the Germans had sent out apparently thought better of the
whole idea during the night, retiring back to port without encountering the second and its
rather hopeful four-inch gun crews. The second then headed home and at the start of August the
Kriegsmarine temporarily suspended operations from the Atlantic ports. By this stage Staling
was back in the water and so the formation headed back into the Bay of Biscay but now of course it
was largely empty of U-boats which meant that the only excitement came in the form of the rather
bizarre behaviour of large groups of Junkers 88s which would appear, circle outside of anti-aircraft
range for a bit, occasionally dart in close and then fly home again. The only time anything flew
close enough to actually be shot at it turned out to be a low-flying patrol of Mosquitoes who were
hoping to catch one of the Junkers 88 formations unawares. Sadly though when the group returned
from its patrol, heading for Liverpool this time, they were greeted by the news that His Majesty's
submarine Parthian, with Timothy Walker aboard, had been sunk, probably by a mine whilst on
operations in the Mediterranean, with all hands lost. Eileen Walker had arrived at the dockside
just as the lines were made fast, having heard the news some time earlier and arranged with
the Admiralty not to have it transmitted to Staling while it was on active duty.
There was the usual swarm of people who had all sorts of urgent matters to discuss with Walker
since he was still Captain D Liverpool as well, but they found their path blocked by a solid
formation of the 2nd's officers once they'd heard the news. They would later clear a path to a
waiting car for their captain and his wife after both had spent some time fully absorbing the news
in Walker's cabin aboard Staling. Back in the Bay of Biscay, the close of August revealed what the
The first support group, along with the destroyers Grenville and Athabascan,
were conducting a sweep when 18 German bombers appeared. Five made an attack run. Each then
strangely appeared to split in two, with one half rapidly outpacing the other. It turned out that
this was actually the first successful combat debut of the HS-293 guided missile. Athabascan
and the sloop Egret were hit. The large destroyer took the blow and staggered but managed to
recover. The smaller sloop exploded and was lost with only 35 survivors from a crew of over 200.
The damaged Athabascan picked up those left in the water while Grenville played dodge the missile
as the rest of the German formation rather inexplicably chose to then fire off the remaining
HS-293s singly instead of in a wave, as they'd just done. It turned out somewhat later that the
sloop HMS Biddeford had actually been hit by an HS-293 a few days earlier but that missile had
failed to explode and thus only caused damage to the ship. Now the circling with occasional darting
in behaviours of the German bombers previously made sense. The crews had been training in the
this new weapon. Although 2nd support group in particular had an unusually heavy anti-aircraft
battery for an escort formation most such vessels did not and patrols in the Bay of Biscay were
therefore temporarily suspended. Although the 2nd itself was sent out with some electronic warfare
specialists to try and attract an attack it was hoped prototype jamming equipment could be used
to make a missile dive into the water for recovery and examination. But no obliging,
bombers appeared brave enough to try and take them on, perhaps because of the sheer aggression
that the formation displayed whenever bombers were sighted, which along with the fact they had
six guns in twin mounts, two forward and one aft, may have led to their being mistaken for small
cruisers like the Arethuses, which would be much more difficult targets and possessed armour plate,
which the HS-293 was not really designed to engage. Therefore the only excitement of that
particular deployment was when the group's personal Catalina on semi-permanent secondment
to the formation was attacked by a number of Ju-88 heavy fighter variants, which resulted in the
flying boat making for the cover of one side of the formation whilst the combined anti-aircraft
firepower for the sloops drove off the German aircraft on the other side. A few U-Boats would
try their luck sneaking along the Spanish coast, but unless they had a direct sighting,
the second couldn't just start wandering up and down inside Spanish territorial waters,
and so instead they rescued the crew of a shot-down Liberator. Although of the seven
crew who survived the crash, four had died as the result of exposure after having been refused
water by a U-Boat that they had encountered shortly after being shot down, two passing
thereafter. This behaviour hardened the attitudes of many in the second support group somewhat
towards the German submariners. In September, Staling went back into dock for a refit,
and the second was re-oriented in light of the suspension of the sweeps of the Bay of Biscay.
The second was now comprised of Staling, Wild Goose, Woodcock, Magpie and Kite alongside the
shape of the escort carrier HMS Tracker. They sailed in mid-October to the accompaniment of
a briefing that covered yet another new weapon. Back in mid-September, while Staling had been
refitting, two large convoys heading from the US to the UK had merged in the face of over 20 U-Boats
gathering to attack them. Along with aircraft support, losses had been kept down to a half
dozen merchant ships in exchange for three U-Boats, but three of the escorts had been sunk
and another had been damaged, all of them had been hit in the stern. Investigation quickly
concluded that the Germans had deployed an acoustic homing torpedo. A quickly invented
noisemaker called Foxer was designed to try and fool them, but despite the new torpedo being able
to be fired at extreme range, as of course it would do its own course correction, the Foxers
largely rusted away on deck. Walker, as it turned out, rarely used them, preferring a far more direct
approach to give the enemy commander something else to think about than firing their torpedoes.
One tactic he proposed was to pretend to be the outer screen of a convoy's escort formation.
This would hopefully lure the U-Boats into trying to sail around the second,
which would of course bring them in closer, enabling Walker's ships to pounce on them more
easily. But before they could put any new tactics into practice, they had to survive a Force 10
storm. The formation was making revolutions for 10 knots, but only managing three. The waves topped
50 foot, and the wavelength of the swells was five times the length of the sloops,
forcing them on a long and difficult roller coaster ride for days. They couldn't slow down
because they'd lose steerage and go a beam of the water, and they couldn't speed up because then the
force of the ship smashing through the waves would be too much for the bows. Tracker was caught out
by the wind and went over almost on her beam ends, gradually struggling back upright while the hangar
crew chased after a pair of swordfish who'd broken loose and were leading the crew on a merry chase
around the hangar. This would not be the first time that Tracker was seen wallowing and rolling
heavily in the wind. Tracker was equipped with a mixture of swordfish and seafires, the swordfish
for anti-submarine patrol work and the seafires to take on long-range German aircraft, but right now
the weather precluded their use. Cracked rivets and parting welds bedeviled the sloops, with every
cabin springing leaks and depth charges breaking free and chasing each other and the crew around
the quarterdeck. The quarterdeck itself was moving worryingly independently of the rest of the ship
Eventually though they managed to find convoy ON207, escorted by the 2nd and 7th support groups
and the B7 escort group. Between them they could call on the services of Tracker and another escort
carrier, Biter, assuming that the sea let up for five seconds, and along with the combined 16 escort
ships plus the two escort carriers, that was a formidable convoy. But of course the weather,
as bad as it was for the carriers and the sloops, was even worse for the U-boats and so the only
excitement of that particular mission came when the weather dialed itself back a little bit at
the end of October, at least wind-wise, the seas were still quite heavy, and Tracker decided to
try flight operations. When one of the swordfish came back to land it made a textbook approach
despite the rolling, only to find at the very last second the entire carrier dropped away
into a very deep wave trough, coming back up again moments later to slam into the still
descending aircraft, now well forward of the arrestor wires, the impact sending the poor
aircraft bouncing over the side and into the sea, although the sloops were able to rescue two out of
the three aircrew. The weather built up again to even fiercer levels on the 1st of November
before finally beginning to blow itself out suddenly on the night of the 5th through 6th,
at least so it seemed. Taking advantage of the relative calm the crew began bailing out water
from so many places it really shouldn't have been and trying to address the various cracks and splits
in the hull plating, whilst the ships themselves tried to regain their formation which had been
abandoned in the face of the storm. The line had just about been re-established when a starshell
arced into the sky to port, followed by a signal from Kite, she'd spotted a U-boat which had
dived. Walker ordered Tracker to turn to starboard and take cover behind Wild Goose and Magpie,
he wasn't going to have a repeat of Audacity on his hands if he had anything to say about it.
He took Starling across the carrier's bows to support Kite. As it turned out the sub had
indeed been gunning for Tracker and it was only Kite's radar and sharp reactions that
had saved the carrier, forcing the U-boat to worry about the sloop instead. Woodcock also
showed up a few minutes later but after a few passes in heavy swells, Walker decided that
complex operations in darkness and high seas were far too risky and instead he configured his three
ships to box in the sub, maintaining ASDIC contact and decided to then trail it until daylight.
As the sun rose, Starling directed Woodcock to sneak in at five knots with her own ASDIC off.
She let off a pattern of depth charges into the sea, these were new ones that could go
much deeper, whereas the previous versions could only reach 500 feet at the maximum setting,
these were set for between 600 and 800 feet to cover the depths it was now known that U-boats
could hide at. A few minutes later as the rumble of the charges faded, the ASDIC operators heard
sounds like a can being crushed in a fist, along with the shearing of metal. U-226 had been fatally
wounded and was now passing through crush depth. The boom of the final failure of her hull was
heard on the ASDIC and shortly thereafter something else exploded much closer to the surface,
which was followed shortly thereafter by an upwelling of wreckage.
Splice the main brace was signalled and the ships began to shake out for the day,
but just after one in the afternoon the high frequency direction finding team picked up the
signal of another U-boat about 20 miles away. Woodcock and Kite were sent off to guard tracker
whilst Wild Goose and Magpie were heading out with Starling after the contact. Tracker sent up
a Swordfish and a Liberator also appeared. Although the aircraft weren't able to hit the sub,
they did force it to dive, which in turn obviously limited how far it could go in the time it would
take the trio of sloops to reach their location. Walker did some quick calculations and estimations,
if he took into account the location that the U-boat had been on the surface, the relative
position of the major convoy routes in relation to that and the fact that the Liberator had shown
up out of the west, he guessed that the sub might try to head north in order to try and evade and
then work back its way afterwards. An hour after they reached the dive point his estimation proved
to be correct. Searching to the north of it, Wild Goose signalled that she had a submarine at 1800
yards. Starling went for the attack but then things took a slightly weird turn. Walker assumed
that any experienced sub by this point would try and evade and so he made his attack run in
anticipation of that. The sub however just kept its course and speed dead straight and so Walker's
attack missed by a long way. Wild Goose then went in with Starling guiding it in a creeping attack
but then for some reason the highly experienced Wild Goose only released some of the 26 charges
she'd been ordered to, released those late and at least one of them detonated at a very shallow
depth, throwing Starling's gyro compass completely out of alignment. Tired and stressed, Walker lost
his temper, throwing his cap on the deck and stamping on it. The contact then promptly vanished
from both ships' ASDIC systems. Walker was in the middle of composing a rather acidic message to
Wild Goose when suddenly there was a loud underwater explosion played over the bridge
speakers from the ASDIC hut, followed by the unmistakable sounds of a submarine breaking up
and oil welling up alongside the middle section of a torpedo. Thus ended the slightly bizarre
career of U-842. Walker paused for a moment, tore up the note sheet and replaced it with another
splice the main brace signal. The weather now decided that it was done being calm and the storm
grew once again, which turned out to be just as well as a torpedo promptly leapt out of a large
wave apropos completely nothing and then exploded on the port aft quarter just a little away from
Tracker. The Sloops did their best to hunt the submarine in question even though they didn't
really know where it was whilst sailing perpendicular to the rising seas,
but it turned out to be a job just to stay afloat and ASDIC was almost useless amid the noise of the
storm. The crack in Starling's stern was bad enough that light could be seen from below decks
and another torpedo was heard heading for Tracker, but it had no better luck than its predecessor.
Finally the weather eased on the 10th, whatever submarine had been hunting them long gone,
and the battered second made its way into Argentia in Newfoundland, which was a base
that was on lease to the US Navy at the time. The ships were battered, rusty and with so many
popped rivets, jammed guns and hull cracks it was hard to imagine that the second had left the UK
only a few weeks ago looking as if they were fresh out of the yard. With a voyage that Walker
described as perpetual paddling for those aboard, the second was glad of the hospitality of the
Americans, letting the crews relax while the worst of the damage was patched up. Hull strengthening
awaited them back home and with patching up done, four sloops headed off, stopping in at St. John's
for some shopping in anticipation of getting home for Christmas. Woodcook had been sent home ahead
with another convoy as her forward guns and ammunition lockers had been jammed and lost
respectively to a particularly big wave. Tracker had been detached to another convoy and so it was
Starling, Wild Goose, Magpie and Kite who were directed first to an eastbound convoy that they
could escort home before being redirected to convoy SL140 far to the southeast. It was already
protected by its own escorts and the frigates of 4th Support Group but even this combined force
was struggling against an assault by between 13 and 14 U-Boats who number-wise matched the escorts
at a roughly 1 to 1 basis. It would take three days of high-speed steaming for 2nd Scouting Group
to reach the convoy. They took up one flank and set about chasing ASDIC contacts but with a threat
of massed air assault looming and many other submarines in the area, the sloops were on
something of a leash and they had to break off several promising attacks to try and catch up
with the convoy again. However, thanks to their intervention freeing up the faster frigates of the
4th Support Group as well as the services of the escort carrier USS Bogue, the convoy managed to
make it through without loss. The Wolfpack wasn't so lucky, losing a total of six U-Boats with another
two damaged either in direct attacks on the convoy or in the operations immediately surrounding said
attack. The day after 2nd Scouting Group arrived, the submarine assault was thus called off and the
rest of the voyage passed rather peacefully. The second arrived back in Liverpool in early December,
they were back in time for Christmas and a long overhaul and repair. Preparations for D-Day,
although this was still over five months away at this stage, were cluttering up the docks and the
sea lanes needed to be kept clear because even more men and suppliers were coming in to strengthen
Operation Overlord. But for the men of the 2nd Support Group, that was all going to be for next
year. One slightly tipsy sailor climbed the mast and fixed a small Christmas tree to the radar
antenna of Starling as she rested in dry dock. This was met with great approval, his subsequent
off-key rendition of some hymn or other was largely lost to the wind and not met with such great
approval, but it was all taken in good humour. For Walker, this was a chance for a short break ashore,
but unknown to everyone, the coming year, 1944, would be Walker's last.
That's it for this video, thanks for watching, if you have a comment or suggestion for a ship to
review, let us know in the comments below. Don't forget to comment on the pinned post
for dry dock questions.
