耶魯大學公開課:古希臘歷史簡介 自我學習之用,侵刪::M6HUI9GK4_1
6 次觀看·2025年2月25日
Now, I'm going to ask you this question.
Why are you here?
That is to say, why should you, we, all of us, want to study these ancient Greeks?
I think it's reasonable for people who are considering the study of a particular subject in a college course to ask why they should.
What is it about the ancient Greeks between the years that I mentioned to you that deserves the attention of people in the 21st century?
I think the answer is to be found, or at least one answer.
The truth is there are many answers, and some of them is it's just terribly interesting.
But that's very much of a, what's the word I want, the opposite of objective, subjective observation by me.
So I would say a less subjective one is that I believe that it comes from their position,
that is to say the position of the Greeks at the most significant starting point of Western civilization,
which is the culture that most powerfully shapes not only the West, but most of the world today.
It seems to me to be evident that whatever its other characteristics,
the West has created institutions of government and law that provide unprecedented freedom for its people.
It's also invented a body of natural scientific knowledge and technological achievement
that together make possible a level of health and material prosperity undreamed of in earlier times.
And unknown outside the West and those places that have been influenced by the West.
I think the Nobel Prize Laureate V.S. Naipaul, a man born in Trinidad of Indian parents,
was right when he spoke of the modern world as our universal civilization shaped chiefly by the West.
Most people around the world who know of them want to benefit from the achievements of Western science and technology.
Many of them also want to participate in its political freedom.
Moreover experience suggests that a society cannot achieve the full benefits of Western science and technology
without a commitment to reason and objectivity
as essential to knowledge and to the political freedom that sustains it and helps it to move forward.
The primacy of reason and the pursuit of objectivity,
therefore both characteristic of the Western experience
seem to me to be essential for the achievement of the desired goals almost anywhere in the world.
The civilization of the West, however,
was not the result of some inevitable process
through which other cultures will automatically pass.
It emerged from a unique history in which chance and accident often played a vital part.
The institutions and the ideas, therefore,
that provide for freedom and improvement in the material conditions of life
cannot take root and flourish
without an understanding of how they came about
and what challenges they have had to surmount.
Non-Western peoples who wish to share in the things that characterize modernity
will need to study the ideas and history of Western civilization
to achieve what they want.
And Westerners, I would argue,
who wish to preserve these things must do the same.
The many civilizations adopted by the human race
have shared basic characteristics.
Most have tended toward cultural uniformity and stability.
Reason, although it was employed for all sorts of practical
and intellectual purposes in some of these cultures,
it still lacked independence from religion
and it lacked the high status to challenge the most basic received ideas.
Standard form of government has been monarchy.
Outside the West, republics have been unknown.
Rulers have been thought to be divine
or appointed spokesmen for divinity.
Religious and political institutions and beliefs
have been thoroughly intertwined
as a mutually supportive unified structure.
Government has not been subject to secular reasoned analysis.
It has rested on religious authority, tradition and power.
The concept of individual freedom has had no importance
in these great majority of cultures in human history.
The first and the sharpest break
with this common human experience
came in ancient Greece.
The Greek city states called poleis were republics.
Differences in wealth among their citizens
were relatively small.
There were no kings with the wealth to hire mercenary soldiers,
so the citizens had to do their own fighting
and to decide when to fight.
As independent defenders of the common safety
and the common interest,
they demanded a role
in the most important political decisions.
In this way, for the first time,
political life really was invented, observed
that the word political derives from the Greek word poleis.
Before that, no word was needed
because there was no such thing.
This political life came to be shared
by a relatively large portion of the people
and participation in political life
was highly valued by the Greeks.
Such states, of course, did not need a bureaucracy
for there were no vast royal or state holdings
that needed management
and not much economic surplus
to support a bureaucratic class.
There was no separate cast of priests
and there was very little concern,
I don't mean no concern, but very little concern
with life after death,
which was universally important
in other civilizations.
In this varied, dynamic, secular
and remarkably free context,
there arose for the first time
a speculative natural philosophy
based on observation and reason,
the root of modern natural science and philosophy,
free to investigate
or to ignore divinity.
What most sets the Greeks apart
is their view of the world.
Where other peoples have seen
sameness and continuity,
the Greeks and the heirs of their way of thinking
have tended to notice disjunctions
and to make distinctions.
The Greek way of looking at things
requires a change
from the characteristic way
of knowing things before the Greeks,
that is to say,
the use of faith, poetry and intuition.
And instead, increasingly,
the Greeks focused on a reliance on reason.
Reason permits a continuing rational inquiry
into the nature of reality.
Unlike mystical insights,
scientific theories
cannot be arrived at by meditation alone,
but require accurate observation of the world
and reasoning of a kind
that other human beings can criticize,
analyze, modify and correct.
The adoption of this way of thinking
was the beginning of the liberation
and enthronement of reason,
to whose searching examination
the Greeks thereafter
exposed everything they perceived,
natural, human and divine.
From the time they formed their republics
until they were conquered by alien empires,
the Greeks also rejected monarchy of any kind.
They thought that a human being
functioning in his full capacity
must live as a free man
in an autonomous polis
ruled by laws
that were the product of the political community
and not of an arbitrary fiat
from some man or god.
These are ideas about laws and justice
that have simply not flourished
outside the Western tradition
until places that were outside the Western tradition
were influenced by the West.
The Greeks, however,
combined a unique sense of mankind's
high place in the natural order.
The Greeks had the most arrogant view
of their relationship to the divinity
as I will tell you about later in the course
of any people I know.
So on the one hand,
they had this very high picture
of this place of man.
But they combined it,
excuse me,
and what possibilities
human beings had before them.
And they combined it
with a painful understanding
of the limitations
of the greatness
and the possibilities before man.
This combination
of elevating the greatness in reality
and in possibility of human beings
with the limitations of it,
the greatest limitation being mortality,
that together composes
the tragic vision of the human condition
that characterized classical Greek civilization.
To cope with it,
they urged human beings
to restrain their overarching ambitions.
Inscribed at Apollo's Temple at Delphi,
which became,
well, the Greeks came to call it
the navel of the universe,
but it certainly became
the center of the Greek world
and which was also seen
as a central place of importance
by non-Greeks
who were on the borders
of the Greek world.
That temple at Delphi
had written above the temple
these words,
know thyself,
and another statement,
nothing in excess.
I think those together
really mean this,
know your own limitations
as a fallible mortal
and then exercise moderation
because you are not divine,
you are mortal.
Beyond these exhortations,
they relied on a good political regime
to enable human beings
to fulfill the capacities
that were part of their nature,
to train them in virtue
and to restrain them from vice.
Aristotle in his politics
made the point neatly,
and I quote him,
As a man,
I'm sorry,
as man is the best of the animals
when perfected,
so he is the worst
when separated from law and justice,
for injustice is most dangerous
when it is armed,
and man,
armed by nature
with good sense and virtue,
may use them
for entirely opposite ends.
Therefore,
when he is without virtue,
man is the most unscrupulous
and savage of the animals.
Aristotle went on to say
that the justice needed
to control this dark side
of human nature
can be found only
in a well-ordered society
of free people
who govern themselves,
and the only one that he knew
was the polis of the Greeks.
Now the second great strand
in the history of the West
is the Judeo-Christian tradition,
a very different tradition
from the one I've just described.
Christianity's main roots
were in Judaism,
a religion that worshipped
a single all-powerful deity
who is sharply separated
from human beings,
makes great moral demands upon them,
and judges them all,
even kings and emperors.
Christianity began
as a persecuted religion
that ultimately captured
the Roman Empire
only after centuries
of hostility
towards the empire,
towards Rome,
towards the secular state in general.
And it never lost
entirely its original character
as an insurgent movement,
independent of the state
and hostile to it,
making claims
that challenged the secular authority.
This too is unique to the West.
Just like the Greek experience is unique,
this kind of religious organization
is to be found nowhere else
in human society.
So the union
of a universalist religion
with a monarch
such as the Roman Empire,
who ruled a vast empire,
could nonetheless have put an end
to any prospect of freedom
as in other civilizations.
But Christianity's inheritance
of the rational,
disputatious Greek philosophy
led to powerfully divisive quarrels
about the nature of God
and other theological questions,
which was perfectly in the tradition
and uniquely in the tradition
of Greek philosophical debate.
What I'm doing is making a claim
that even the Judeo-Christian tradition,
which is such a different one
from the Greeks,
and in so many ways
seems to be at odds with it,
even they were dependent
upon one aspect of the Greek culture,
which is inherent in Christianity
and important in Christianity.
That too was ultimately a Greek source.
Well,the people
whom the Romans called barbarians
destroyed the Western Empire
and it also destroyed
the power of the emperors
and their efforts to impose
religious and political conformity
under imperial control.
The emperor in the East
was able to do that
because they were not conquered
by the barbarians,
but in the West,
you have this situation
where nobody is fully in charge.
And here we have arrived
at a second sharp break
with the general experience of mankind.
The West of the Germanic tribes
that had toppled the Roman Empire
was weak and it was divided.
The barriers to unity
presented by European geography
and very limited technology
made it hard for a would-be conqueror
to create a vast empire,
eliminating competitors
and imposing his will over vast areas.
These conditions
permitted the development
of institutions and habits
needed for freedom
even as they also made Europe
vulnerable to conquest
and to extinction.
And Europe was almost extinguished
practically before there was a Europe
very early in its history.
The Christian church
might have stepped into the breach
and imposed obedience and uniformity
because before terribly long
all of the West had been Christianized.
But the church, in fact,
never gained enough power
to control the state.
Strong enough to interfere
with the ambitions of emperors and kings,
it never was able to impose
its own domination,
though some of the popes sure tried.
Nobody sought or planned for freedom.
But in the spaces that were left
by the endless conflicts
among secular rulers
and between them and the church,
there was room for freedom to grow.
Freedom was a kind of an accident
that came about
because the usual ways of doing things
were not possible.
Into some of that space,
towns and cities reappeared
and with them new supports for freedom.
Taking advantage of the rivalries
I've mentioned,
they obtained charters
from the local powers
establishing their rights
to conduct their own affairs
and to govern themselves.
In Italy,
some of these cities
were able to gain control
of the surrounding country
and to become city-states
resembling those of the ancient Greeks.
Their autonomy was assisted
by the continuing struggle
between popes and emperors,
between church and state.
Again, a thoroughly unique
Western experience.
In these states,
the modern world began to take form.
Although the people
were mainly Christians,
their life and outlook
became increasingly secular.
Here and not only in Italy,
but in other cities
north of the Alps,
arose a world view
that celebrated the greatness
and dignity of mankind,
which was a very sharp turning away
from the medieval Western tradition
that put God and life
in the hereafter
at the center of everything.
This new vision is revealed
with flamboyant confidence
by Pico della Mirandola,
a Florentine thinker,
who wrote the following.
God told man that we,
meaning God,
have made thee
neither of heaven nor of earth,
neither mortal nor immortal,
so that with freedom of choice
and with honor,
as though the maker
and molder of thyself,
thou mayest fashion thyself
in whatever shape thou shall prefer.
Oh, supreme generosity
of God the Father!
Oh, highest and the most
great felicity of man!
To him it is granted
to have whatever he chooses,
to be whatever he wills.
Now, this is a remarkable leap,
even beyond the humanism of the Greeks,
something brand new in the world.
According to this view,
man is not merely
the measure of all things
as the Greek sophist protagonist
had radically proclaimed
in the fifth century.
He is, in fact, says Pico,
more than mortal.
He is unlimited by nature.
He is entirely free
to shape himself
and to acquire whatever he wants.
Please observe, too,
that it is not his reason
that will determine human actions,
but his will alone,
free of the moderating control of reason.
Another Florentine, Machiavelli,
moved further in the same direction.
For him, and I quote him,
fortune is a woman,
and it is necessary
to hold her down
and beat her
and fight with her,
a notion that the Greeks
would have regarded
as dangerously arrogant
and certain to produce disaster.
They would have seen this
as an example of the word
that they use,
and we'll talk about a lot
in this course, hubris,
this kind of violent arrogance
which comes upon men
when they see themselves
as more than human
and behave as though
they were divine.
Francis Bacon,
influenced by Machiavelli,
urged human beings
to employ their reason
to force nature
to give up its secrets,
to treat nature like a woman,
to master nature
in order to improve
man's material well-being.
He assumed that such a course
would lead to progress
and the general improvement
of the human condition.
And it was that sort of thinking
that lay at the heart
of the scientific revolution
and remains the faith
on which modern science
and technology rests.
A couple of other
English political philosophers,
Hobbes and Locke,
applied a similar novelty
and modernity
to the sphere of politics,
basing their understanding
on the common passions of man
for a comfortable self-preservation
and discovering something
the Greeks had never thought of,
something they called natural rights
that belonged to a man
either as part of nature
or as the gift of a benevolent
and reasonable God.
Man was seen as a solitary creature,
not inherently a part of society.
That's totally un-Greek.
And his basic rights
were seen to be absolute,
for nothing must interfere
with the right of each individual
to defend his life,
liberty and property.
Freedom was threatened
in early modern times
by the emergence of monarchies
that might have been able to crush it.
But the cause of individual freedom
was enhanced
by the Protestant Reformation.
Another upheaval
within Christianity
arising from its focus
on individual salvation,
its inheritance of a tradition
of penetrating reason
applied even to matters of faith
and to the continuing struggle
between church and state.
The English Revolution
came about in large part
because of King Charles I's attempt
to impose an alien religious conformity
as well as tighter political control
on his kingdom.
But in England
the tradition of freedom
and government bound by law
was already strong enough
to produce effective resistance.
From the ensuing rebellion
came limited constitutional
representative government
and ultimately
our modern form of democracy.
The example and the ideas it produced
encouraged
and informed the French
and the American revolutions
and the entire
modern constitutional tradition.
These ideas and institutions
are the basis
for modern liberal thinking
about politics,
the individual and society.
Just as the confident view
of science and technology
as progressive forces
improving the lot of humanity
and increasing man's capacity
to understand and control the universe
has been the most powerful form
taken by the western elevation of reason.
In the last two centuries
both these most characteristic elements
of western civilization
have in fact become increasingly
under heavy attack.
At different times
science and technology
have been blamed for the destruction
of human community
and the alienation of people
from nature and from one another
for intensifying the gulf
between rich and poor
for threatening the very existence
of humanity
either by producing weapons
of total destruction
or by destroying the environment.
At the same time
the foundations of freedom
have also come into question.
Jefferson and his colleagues
could confidently proclaim
their political rights
as being self-evident
and the gift of a creator.
By now in our time however
the power of religion has faded
and for many
the basis of modern political
and moral order
has been demolished.
Nietzsche announced the death of God
and Dostoyevsky's grand inquisitor
asserted that when God is dead
all things are permitted.
Nihilism rejects any objective basis
for society and its morality.
It rejects the very concept
of objectivity.
It even rejects the possibility
of communication itself.
And a vulgar form of nihilism
I claim has a remarkable influence
in our educational system today.
The system rotting from the head down
so chiefly in universities
but all the way down to elementary schools.
The consequences of the victory
of such ideas I believe
would be enormous.
If both religion and reason are removed
all that remains is will and power
where the only law
is the law of tooth and claw.
There is no protection
for the freedom of weaker individuals
or those who question the authority
of the most powerful.
There is no basis for individual rights
or for a critique of existing ideas
and institutions
if there is no base
either in religion or in reason.
That such attacks
on the greatest achievements of the West
should be made by western intellectuals
is perfectly in keeping
with the western tradition.
The first crowd to do stuff like that
you will find in the 5th century B.C.
in Greece
in a movement called
the Sophistic Movement.
These sophists raised most of the questions
that my colleagues are now
spending all their time with now.
Yet to me it seems ironic
that they have gained so much currency
in a time more or less
in which the achievements
of western reason
in the form of science
and at a moment
when its concept of political freedom
seem to be more popular
and more desirable to people
in and out of western civilization
than ever.
Now I've been saying kind things
about western civilization
but I would not want to deny
that there is a dark side
to the western experience
and its way of life.
To put untrammeled reason
and individual freedom
at the center of a civilization
is to live with the conflict
the turmoil
the instability
and the uncertainty
that these things create.
Freedom was born
and has survived in the space
created by divisions
and conflict
within and between nations
and religions.
We must wonder
whether the power of modern weapons
will allow it and the world
to survive at such a price.
Individual freedom
although it has greatly elevated
the condition of the people
who have lived in free societies
inevitably permits inequalities
which are the more galling
because each person is plainly free
to try to improve his situation
and largely responsible for the outcome.
Freedom does permit
isolation from society
and an alienation of the individual
at a high cost
both to the individual and society.
And these are not the only problems
posed by the western tradition
in its modern form
which is what we live in.
Whether it takes the shape
of the unbridled claims
of pico de la mirandola
of the Nietzschean assertion
of the power of the superior individual
to transform and shape his own nature
or of the modern totalitarian effort
to change the nature of humanity
by utopian social engineering.
The temptation to arrogance
offered by the ideas
and worldly success
of the modern west
threatens its own great traditions
and achievements.
Because of western civilization's emergence
as the exemplary civilization
it also presents problems
to the whole world.
The challenges presented by freedom
and the predominance of reason
cannot be ignored.
Nor can they be met by recourse
to the experience of other cultures
where these characteristics
have not been prominent.
In other words, to understand
and cope with the problems
that we all face,
we all need to know
and to grapple with
the western experience.
In my view, we need especially
to examine the older traditions
of the west
that came before the modern era
and to take seriously
the possibility
that useful wisdom
can be found there,
especially among the Greeks
who began it all.
They understood the potentiality
of human beings,
their limitations,
and the predicament
in which they live.
Man is potent and important,
yet he is fallible and mortal,
capable of the greatest achievements
and the worst crimes.
He is then a tragic figure,
powerful but limited,
with freedom to choose and act,
but bound by his own nature,
knowing that he will never achieve
perfect knowledge and understanding,
justice and happiness,
but determined to continue the search,
no matter what.
To me, that seems
an accurate description
of the human condition
that is meaningful,
not only for the Greeks
and their heirs in the west,
but for all human beings.
It is an understanding
that cannot be achieved
without a serious examination
of the western experience.
The abandonment of such a study
or its adulteration
for current political purposes
would be a terrible loss
for all of humanity.
And at the base,
at the root of that civilization,
stood the Greeks.
These are the reasons
why I examine their experience,
and I trust why you are thinking about
learning about it.
Thank you.
I'll see you guys,
some of you,
next Tuesday.
