A History of Ice Cream

Ice Cream Recipes
122 followers
It is July 2024, and 40 years ago, President Ronald Reagan declared July to be National Ice Cream Month.
And that's one of the few things that we know for sure about the history of ice cream,
a treat so popular that some 32.5 billion pints are sold worldwide each year.
The history of ice cream is both ancient and modern.
It is so steeped in myth and mystery and legend that it can give you the shivers on a hot day.
Yesterday was the 4th of July, and of course a holiday in the United States,
when I suspect many viewers enjoyed a good barbecue.
But it is also a good bet that a good many of you also enjoyed some ice cream,
a particularly popular treat in hot July.
But that might raise a simple question.
For how long have people been enjoying ice cream?
The answer isn't simple, in that ice cream is older than you might think,
and of course it depends upon your definition of ice cream,
something that can be confusing even today.
The story of ice cream includes several well-known tropes.
Among the most popular is the claim that ice cream was first brought to Europe from China by Marco Polo.
You will often find that claim on webpages detailing the history of ice cream,
but when it comes to history, the oft-told story comes up cold.
There are many questions about Marco Polo.
Those are the subject of another episode of the History Guy,
but a lack of elocution is not a complaint.
His work, The Travels of Marco Polo, chronicles a number of adventures,
many of dubious veracity, and whatever you want to say about him,
Marco Polo didn't mind taking credit for things.
Which makes the ice cream claim more suspicious,
because as the website History Myths explains,
if the Wiley Venetian ever saw or tasted such a memorable food,
he makes no mention of it in his journals.
This and other stories about the history of ice cream have a similar origin, to sell ice cream.
History Myths quotes Robert Brantley of Colonial Williamsburg,
an expert on the subject, that these stories were created during the 19th century
by ice cream sellers who were looking for a marketing angle.
To understand the true history of ice cream, we first have to churn through the myths.
There are at least two candidates for the originator of ice cream.
Dr. Cavaferric of the University of British Columbia
attributes the origin of ice cream to the Achaemenid Empire in what is modern day Iran.
He writes in a November 2018 edition of Indian Express
that the origins of the ice cream refreshment can be traced to ancient Iran,
where the technology to manufacture and store ice was invented as far back as 400 BCE.
He explains that Persia, that is modern day Iran,
has been making ice cream for the last 2,000 years.
As evidence, he points to the Yakhchal,
a specially made building used for storing ice
that was discussed in a History Guy episode about the origin of ice making.
These structures not only allowed the ancient empire to store and possibly make ice,
but Carrick argues its shape may have influenced the design of ice cream.
This ice dessert reached famous lips.
The website ZME Science explains that ultimately the Persian Empire met its maker
in the form of Alexander the Great, who waged war on them for 10 years.
War making is hot, tiring stuff,
and accounts from Alexander's campaign say he took a particular liking to the local fruit Isis.
Accounts describe the dessert as a honey-sweetened dish chilled using snow.
Further, the International Dairy Foods Association explains,
biblical references also show that King Solomon was fond of ice drinks during harvesting.
During the Roman Empire, Nero Claudius Caesar, AD 54-86,
frequently sent runners into the mountains for snow,
which was then flavored with fruits and juices.
Carrick posits that it was Arabs who conquered the empire
who may have taken Persian sharbat, a drink made from fruits and herbs,
and enriched the existing mix of fruit and syrup and snow-chilled honey with milk and sugar.
This was the conception of the modern-day granita or gelato.
He explains that Iranians still enjoy a frozen dessert called faluda,
which he describes as a traditional Iranian ice cream.
He writes, in the past, ice was stored in big bowls,
and milk in smaller ones, and by rotational motions,
the cold was transferred from ice to milk.
This process helped the milk turn into crystals, and then finally, into ice cream.
However, the website Ice Cream Nation notes an important caveat.
It seems clear that mankind has been able to mix snow and ice
with different appealing flavors since the beginning of our history.
One might argue that these Isis do not really qualify as ice cream.
In fact, modern faluda, made with starch and fruit juice,
while sold in ice cream shops in Iran, is actually closer to sorbet,
which is made by mixing fruit and ice.
History miss-suggests, instead, another origin.
Ice cream probably originated in China,
but very little reliable research has been done on the subject.
As early as the 7th century, a frozen milk product is described in a Chinese document.
Another description, this one poetic, survives from the 12th century.
If those two bits of evidence leave historians skeptical,
there's more reliable mention of ice cream being served at the Mughal court in the 14th century.
ZMR Science explains that a dessert of buffalo milk, flour, and camphor
developed during the Tang Dynasty sometime in the 8th century AD.
King Tang of Shan reportedly employed 94 ice men responsible for the making of the dish.
I suspect that it was the new guy's job to milk the buffalo.
While this might sound less than appetizing to our modern taste buds,
the science website explains it was a definite precursor to what we know today as ice cream.
Recipes then would have reached Europe via the Silk Road,
somewhat like the story of Marco Polo bringing back ice cream,
although history mis-posits that what was really spread was the technique for freezing things
using the endothermic effect of mixing ice and salt,
which draws heat from adjacent liquids, allowing them to freeze,
with an incidental effect being the ability to make ice cream.
However, whether the idea originated in China and came via the Silk Road,
or was developed by Arabs from Persian origins and was brought to Europe via Arab traders,
none of these ancient recipes were what we would today call ice cream.
The general consensus is that the treat was developed in Italy,
which was subject to strong Arab influences.
Another popular story is that Catherine de Medici introduced ice cream to France
at her wedding to King Henry II in 1533.
However, this story is another that Brantley attributes to 19th century ice cream sellers.
History mis-notes that the wedding occurred over a century and a half
before the first known French ice cream recipe.
Rather, they argue, ice cream's European debut probably took place in Italy,
probably in Naples, probably in the latter part of the 17th century.
It spread through the royal houses of Europe.
Early English sources mention a 1671 feast of King Charles II,
where one plate of ice cream was served,
and a 1688 banquet to celebrate the birth of the son of James II.
Perhaps as controversial as the origin of ice cream is how the treat crossed the pond.
Various stories attribute Martha Washington, Dolly Madison,
and Thomas Jefferson as bringing ice cream to America.
Again, these famous origins are likely concoctions of ice cream sellers,
but they do include a kernel of truth.
Thomas Jefferson did, for example, have this recipe for vanilla ice cream in his diary.
However, history mis-notes that ice cream was definitely mentioned at a dinner party
held by Maryland colonial governor Thomas Blayden in 1744,
some four decades before Thomas Jefferson was sent to France as ambassador in 1784,
where he apparently collected his recipe.
The same year, the Washingtons acquired a cream machine for ice for Mount Vernon.
The International Dairy Foods Association notes that records kept by a Tattam Street New York merchant
show that President George Washington spent approximately $200 for ice cream
during the summer of 1790.
Dolly Madison did serve what the IDFA calls a magnificent strawberry ice cream creation
at President Madison's second inaugural banquet at the White House in 1813.
USA Today writes that it was a British confectioner named Philip Lindsay
who brought ice cream to the American public.
In 1774, Lindsay put an ad in the New York Gazette
announcing that he would make ice cream available to the masses.
It didn't take long to sweep the soon-to-be nation.
However, ice cream was still expensive.
The person you have to thank for most of the availability of ice cream in the U.S. today
is Jacob Fussell.
In her 1995 book, Chocolate, Strawberry, and Vanilla, A History of American Ice,
Ann Cooper Funderburg explains that in 1851,
Fussell was running a dairy business for a Pennsylvania Quaker.
In servicing daily routes, Fussell sold cream
but found both the supply and the demand to be unreliable
and occasionally he would have an excess of cream that he couldn't sell.
His response was to build a factory to turn the excess cream into ice cream
which was then packed in ice and shipped to Baltimore.
His business moved often and grew and by 1909 was producing 30 million gallons of ice cream
every year.
It was largely owing to him that ice cream began to be mass manufactured
and more readily available,
although the IDFA also credits technological innovations
such as steam power and mechanical refrigeration,
the homogenizer, electric power and motors,
packing machines and new freezing processes and equipment,
as well as motorized delivery vehicles.
The industry got a boost in 1874
when a man named Robert Green substituted vanilla ice cream for sweet cream
in a popular drink that included syrup and carbonated water.
The ice cream soda became instantly popular
and soda fountains operated by men,
who owing to the pull handles of the carbonated water were called
soda jerks, became common throughout the nation.
The IDFA explains that the ice cream sundae,
which excluded the carbonated water,
was invented in 1890 in response to the complaint
that ice cream sodas were too decadent for the Sabbath.
Although the spelling was changed to S-U-N-D-A-E
to remove any connection with the Sabbath.
Ice cream got a boost with the invention of the ice cream cone,
although that story also includes a popular myth.
The story is often told that a street vendor named Ernest Hemwy
invented the cone at the St. Louis World's Fair in 1904.
The story is that Hemwy was selling zalabies,
a type of Syrian cookie resembling a thin waffle,
when a nearby ice cream vendor ran out of dishes.
Hemwy rolled up one of his warm waffles into a cone,
thus inventing the ice cream cone.
It's a popular story, but it isn't true.
Mrs. A. B. Marshall, for example,
an Englishwoman whose ice cream recipes
helped to popularize ice cream in that country,
suggested serving ice cream in cones in 1888.
A man named Italo Marchioni patented a mold
for making ice cream cones in 1903,
a process that had reportedly been developing since 1896.
Possibly the first ice cream in cones to be sold
were sold by Marchioni on Wall Street in New York.
Here, he is connected to the Hemwy story, though.
According to Marchioni's daughter,
Marchioni was selling lemon ice at the fair,
and when he couldn't keep up with the demand for waffle cones,
he asked Hemwy to roll up some of his waffles.
In any case, it is widely agreed that the World's Fair
greatly increased the popularity of ice cream sold in edible cones.
Today, cones are often served with soft-serve ice cream,
a type of ice cream that is softer
because more air is used in its manufacture.
And again, there is controversy regarding who invented the treat.
Charles Taylor of Buffalo, New York, patented a machine in 1926
that introduced more air into the ice cream manufacturing process,
and that many consider to be the first soft-serve machine.
Today, the Taylor Company manufactures soft-serve machines
for the McDonald's Corporation.
However, entrepreneur Tom Carvel developed his own process
for making soft-serve ice cream in 1936,
and is generally considered to be the first to market soft-serve ice cream.
Entrepreneur J.F. McCulloch and his son Alex
also invented their own process for making soft-serve ice cream in 1938,
and opened a shop selling the product in 1940 that they called Dairy Queen.
But a new wrinkle in the story of the invention of soft-serve
came when the Bishop of London claimed at the 2013 funeral of Margaret Thatcher
that she was part of the team that developed Mr. Whippy Ice Cream,
a popular soft-serve brand.
The genesis of the story is that the future Prime Minister
once worked as a chemist at the J. Lyons Company,
which operated Mr. Whippy franchises in the U.K.
However, despite numerous stories following her death,
she certainly didn't help to invent Mr. Whippy,
which sold in the U.S. for more than a decade
before her employment at the Lyons Company.
In fact, her work at the company is not well documented,
and it's not clear whether she was involved with the ice cream product at all.
Ice cream today comes in many varieties.
Sherbet is sort of a transition stage between sorbet and ice cream,
including fruit juice, but also milk,
and likely was developed at the same time as ice cream in Italy in the 16th century,
but got a boost during the Second World War as it uses milk,
and cream was in short supply.
Today is popularly sold in a push-up container
that was introduced by the Popsicle maker Joe Lowe Company in 1967.
Frozen custard was invented in 1919 in Coney Island in New York
by ice cream vendors Archie and Elton Core.
Frozen custard differs from ice cream by the addition of emulsified egg yolks,
which give a smoother texture,
but also usually uses more cream and less milk than regular ice cream,
giving a higher butterfat content and includes less air in the churning process.
On the other side of the scale is ice milk,
which uses milk products with less butterfat than ice cream.
By rule, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration requires
that a product be at least 10% butterfat to be called ice cream.
Ice milk is lower fat than ice cream,
but also is known for a grittier texture.
In 1995, the FDA changed its rule,
allowing ice milk to be sold as light or low-fat ice cream,
and the term ice milk is rarely used today.
Frozen yogurt was invented by the H.P. Hood Company in Massachusetts in the 1970s.
It uses ingredients similar to ice cream,
except that it includes bacterial cultures found in yogurt,
making it lower in fat and giving it a more tart flavor.
Although the fat content is lower,
frozen yogurt often includes more sugar than ice cream.
Gelato, which is simply the Italian word for frozen,
was invented in the 16th century along with ice cream.
It uses less butterfat than ice cream
and is churned at a slower rate so that it contains less air,
served at a warmer temperature.
While people often ask which of these types is healthier,
nutritionists tend to respond that they are all high in calories and sugar
and should only be occasional treat.
Two, quality and nutrition depends upon the individual manufacturer
and the quality of the ingredients used.
Like the product itself,
the history of ice cream can give you a bit of a headache.
We don't really know who invented the stuff,
and it was developed by many people over a very long period of time.
Much of what we thought we knew about the history of ice cream
turned out to be mere myth.
Much of that used to sell ice cream, I guess,
because we don't know who invented it.
It isn't as exciting a story as Marco Polo or Martha Washington.
But despite all that, ice cream has continued to maintain its popularity.
We don't need to know who invented it to know that it tastes good.
It brings joy to people of all ages,
from the youngest of children to the oldest of presidents.
I hope you enjoyed watching this episode of The History Guy.
And if you did, please feel free to like and subscribe
and share The History Guy with your friends.
And if you also believe that history deserves to be remembered,
then you can support The History Guy as a member on YouTube,
a supporter on our community and locals,
or as a patron on Patreon.
You can also check out our great merchandise shop
or book a special message from The History Guy on Cameo.
