#finance #financial The world's largest construction project is carving a path through the Saudi desert, but will the 170-kilometer-long megacity known as "the Line" ever become a reality? Journalists cannot freely report from Saudi Arabia, so we analyzed satellite imagery and spoke to experts to separate the vision from reality.
Not only have the cost and the timeline for construction shifted in the sand, but recent reports suggest that thousands of migrant workers have died while trying to deliver Mohammed bin Salman's "Vision 2030."
00:00 - Intro 01:43 - Mohammad Bin Salman's Dream City 02:25 - Luxury Island And Ski Resort 03:21 - Construction And Design Of The Line 05:39 - Solving The Problem Of Expanding Cities 07:11 - Circular Vs Linear Cities 08:32 - The History Of Linear Cities 10:16 - Delays And Spiralling Costs 12:12 - Human Rights And Cleared Villages 15:49 - Sustainability Pledges 16:45 - Environmental Impact Of Construction 18:06 - Keeping The Line Cool 19:32 - Water And Desalination 20:27 - Bird Migration 20:53 - Progress Update 21:27 - Credits
The world's largest construction project, known simply as The Line,
has already started to leave its mark on the Arabian desert.
Saudi Arabia's billionaire crown prince wants the 170-kilometre-long megacity
to be visible with the naked eye from space.
Satellite images show how the landscape is transforming.
Where there was once sand and rock, you can make out deep trenches,
thousands of trucks and excavators, and entire new towns.
Workers and their families are already promoting their new lives here on social media.
But satellite pictures also show us villages that have been wiped from the map.
And the controversial project appears to be struggling,
with media reports of cancelled contracts, scaled-back construction and spiralling costs.
Plans to welcome the first residents to The Line back in 2024 never materialised.
So is building what architects told us is essentially a giant greenhouse
in one of the hottest and driest places on Earth really a good idea?
We're talking about some of the hottest temperatures ever recorded in this part of the world.
We analysed the very latest satellite views from above and spoke to experts.
Would I want to live in The Line? No, I absolutely wouldn't.
To find out if Saudi Arabia's desert dream
stands a chance of being anything more than just a mirage.
The Line is the brainchild of Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, or MBS for short.
In 2023 he told the Discovery Channel that he will build his extraordinary megacity against all odds.
They say a lot of projects that happen in Saudi Arabia can't be done.
This is very ambitious. They can't keep saying that and we can't keep proving them wrong.
The multi-billionaire prince is no stranger to lavish spending
and futuristic construction projects.
It's all part of his Vision 2030 plan to diversify Saudi's economy away from fossil fuels
and into sports, entertainment, technology and tourism.
In fact, this whole region, dubbed Neom in 2017,
is going to be home to an array of fantastical projects.
Like Sindala, a once barren island just off the coast
that has already been transformed into a luxury beach destination
with hotels, a golf course, beach club and marina.
And work has started in the mountains on what MBS hopes
will one day be a desert ski resort called Trijena.
And here the clock is ticking, the resort needs to be ready by 2029
when it will host the Asian Winter Games.
The mountains don't get much rain and even less snow
so it will need to rely almost entirely on the artificial kind.
Of course, MBS already has his own palace complex in Neom.
With private beaches, lush green gardens, a golf course and 10 helipads.
Construction on the line began in October 2021.
What we can see on satellite imagery today
is a giant scar cutting inland from the Red Sea
through the mountains and out the other side.
But beyond the epic earthworks,
there's little sign of the megacity presented in glossy promotional videos.
Just think, a skyscraper city that runs uninterrupted for 170 kilometres.
That's the distance between Philadelphia and Washington DC or Naples to Rome.
So the line is designed to be a city like no other city that's ever been built.
Everyone thinks the line's a building.
It's not, it's a frame, it's a city
and it has a framework and a grid structure to it.
The glass-clad monster is also supposed to be 500 metres high and 200 metres wide.
To give you an idea of what a mirrored glass wall in the desert might look like,
take a look at this.
The Mariah concert venue built by the Saudis in 2019.
This is the largest mirrored building in the world, for now.
But it is only three storeys or 26 metres high.
If built, the line will be one of the top 10 tallest buildings in the world, far the longest.
Animations produced by Neom promise suspended gardens,
waterfalls cascading down buildings and all your daily needs within a five-minute walk.
A high-speed train is planned to take citizens from one end to the other in just 20 minutes.
There are even flying taxis.
In fact, prototypes recently took to the air at this facility, just four kilometres from the line.
One consultant who worked on the megaproject told Business Insider
that the city is designed with a wealthy minority in mind.
Yet the line promises to eventually house 9 million people
within a footprint of just 34 square kilometres.
That's more than five times the population of Manhattan in just over half the space.
And according to Neom, this is what Manhattan would look like
if it was squashed into the same footprint as the line.
It might seem crazy, but urban planners say we do need to rethink how cities grow.
In the last 75 years, city populations have rapidly expanded.
More than half the world, 4.4 billion people, now live in cities.
And the UN predicts it will be nearly 7 billion by 2050.
But this expansion is not sustainable.
Look at the rapid growth of Las Vegas in this time-lapse of NASA satellite imagery.
Or Lagos, Nigeria, over a period of 40 years.
And Paris has expanded 200 times in size since 1800,
even though its population today is only 22 times bigger.
The team at Neom believe that cities need a reset.
The cities are falling into the trap of the traffic jams, the pollution, a social disconnect.
If humanity is not ambitious in this precise moment, when are we going to be ambitious?
The line is designed as a solution to both urban sprawl and population explosion,
as MBS told the Discovery Channel in 2023.
Supporters of the line have praised MBS for being bold and innovative.
The energy within Saudi Arabia at the moment is incredible.
I think Neom is, you know, the pinnacle of that change.
And it's really exciting to be part of that.
But not everyone is convinced by the design.
The greatest architects and environmentalists were visionary.
They pushed the boundaries.
You know, we need to build globally.
You know, why would you do it live?
For thousands of years, we've mostly built cities that have dense walkable centres
expanding outwards over time in a circle.
Walkable interaction is the basis of cities.
Businesses happen historically and now where you get easy interaction between people.
And if a city the size of the line were instead built in a circle,
more people would be in walking distance of each other.
And what many people love about city living is the buzz of unpredictability.
London, New York, Bangkok, they are big, they are messy.
And you find all these fascinating places.
The thing with the line, it lacks imagination, actually at the level of experience.
Shape aside, will anyone actually want to live in an enclosed linear city in the desert?
There's no precedent for a city where millions of people
live in a building and may not go outside.
Something like the line would be a massive social, psychological experiment.
This is not the first grand plan for a linear city,
but history shows us that they rarely make it off the drawing board.
Toward the end of the 19th century, urban planner Arturo Soria
proposed a 55 kilometre long central tram line in Madrid with houses on either side,
but only around five kilometres were ever built.
And it's now absorbed into the sprawl of Madrid.
Around 30 years later, Edgar Chambliss designed Road Town,
a linear city with a monorail below ground and a walkway at the top.
In the 1960s, two Princeton University professors devised the Jersey Corridor,
a 32 kilometre linear city featuring two parallel buildings
running between New Brunswick and Trenton.
They hoped the city could one day stretch from Boston to Washington, D.C.,
but neither of these American dreams ever made it to brick and mortar.
Perhaps the closest example we have to something like the line is Corviale,
a one kilometre long social housing block in Rome for 8,000 people.
Never fully completed, it fell on hard times.
And this is what it looks like today.
It seems MBS is undeterred by history.
According to the Wall Street Journal,
when urban planners suggested alternative designs, the crown prince brushed them aside.
You know, megaprojects and megacities have always, you know,
they often include a desire by a government to portray power
or equity or some other ideology to a national or global audience.
But there is evidence that MBS's ambition may be stalling.
Satellite images from May 2023 show earthworks in full swing across the length of the line.
Almost a year later, Bloomberg reported that the line was being scaled back
and workers dismissed.
Recent satellite imagery does appear to show less activity on the ground.
The focus for now is a section of the line called the Hidden Marina,
where residents will be able to sail under the city and then straight out to sea.
NEOM executives call it the largest excavation project in the world,
moving over 90 million cubic metres of material.
But it is now understood that only this 2.4 kilometre section of the line
is expected to be built by 2030, instead of the full 170 kilometres.
It wouldn't be the first Saudi megaproject to hit the brakes.
Ambitious plans to build the world's tallest building, the Burj Jeddah,
have been on hold since 2018,
following a number of arrests of senior figures involved in the project
as part of an anti-corruption crackdown.
Construction on the one kilometre high structure only restarted in January 2025.
While Saudi authorities claim it was always the plan to build the line in modules,
others suspect funding challenges.
Over the last year, reports of experts have indicated that the country
might be starting to feel some strain of the financial pressure of the project,
with some plans scaled back.
Oil price and resulting revenues have also been lower in the last year or so.
Saudi Arabia also hoped foreign investment would prop up a lot of the spiralling costs,
but experts have said that this may not have reached the kingdom's desired levels.
Analysts estimate that it could cost more than $2 trillion to build the full line,
four times the original budget.
But already, progress on the line has come at a human cost.
This region has been home to the Huwaitat tribe for centuries,
a Bedouin people known for their horse-riding skills.
Satellite photographs from 2020 show the Huwaitat villages of al-Quraybah,
Sharma and Gayal located close to the path of the line,
but in these images from 2024, they're gone.
In January 2020, residents of these villages were served eviction notices.
They protested on social media, posting videos with the hashtag
Huwaitat Against Displacement.
Human rights group Al-Kest has been monitoring the evictions closely
and say the majority of the 20,000 Huwaitat tribe members have been displaced.
Many videos show that security forces were violent with the locals
to force them out and many people fled to their houses.
But not everyone fled.
Abdul Rahim, a government employee at the Ministry of Finance,
decided to take a stand.
According to Al-Kest, on April 13, he was shot and killed by Saudi special forces.
Saudi authorities claim that he fired first and labelled him a terrorist.
There is no evidence whatsoever of him shooting first.
Since Hamad bin Salman came to power,
everyone that is deemed or seen as a potential threat or a dissident
will be charged under terrorism charges.
And all trials are held behind closed doors.
The question is why this lack of transparency?
Anyone who warned him online was arrested.
Al-Kest say 47 tribe members have been arrested,
including many of Abdul Rahim's relatives.
They say three have received severe prison sentences
and three others are sentenced to death.
Reports of intimidation and inhumane evictions have not gone unnoticed.
The UN sent an open letter to the Saudi government
concerned about the harsh treatment of the Huwaitat,
including reports of torture.
Campaign groups like Al-Kest have applied pressure to international companies
contracted by NEOM.
Most are staying put.
Not UK-based Solar Water,
which pulled out of a contract to build a solar-powered desalination plant in 2022.
The founder and chief technology officer told us
You cannot move people away from their homeland.
I was very upset.
All the fishing villages along the coast, they're no longer there.
Human rights groups and trade unions have also drawn attention
to thousands of cases of exploitation of workers
on Saudi megaprojects, including NEOM.
A documentary by ITV reports that as many as 21,000 migrant workers
from Nepal, Bangladesh and India may have died in Saudi
since the launch of the 2030 vision in 2016.
If Saudi Arabia's pledge to uphold human rights
as part of this vision is under scrutiny,
so too are its promises of sustainability.
The world's number two oil-producing country
has pledged to generate half its energy with renewables by 2030,
but in 2023 it was still at less than 1%.
And in the NEOM region,
they're looking to meet 100% of their energy needs with renewable power.
Solar farms can already be seen in satellite images here,
close to the workers' camps.
And a new wind farm can be seen emerging from the desert here, further north.
The energy needs now, and for a future megacity, are off the charts.
According to NEOM, the whole region, including the line,
That's similar to the annual electricity consumption of the Philippines.
But even if the running of the line can one day be, as promised, emissions-free,
the construction is far from it.
It took around eight years to build one World Trade Center in New York.
The line would be the equivalent of building thousands of them.
And the taller a building, the higher its carbon footprint,
requiring stronger materials such as steel and concrete to withstand the force of the wind.
Concrete is incredibly carbon-intensive.
Steel is incredibly carbon-intensive.
Professor Oldfield has estimated that building the line
would generate more than 1.8 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide,
equivalent to four years' worth of the UK's total emissions.
Even if you were to build a normal city of six to eight storeys tall,
it would have a very big carbon footprint.
I think it's just going to be two or even treble with the line
because of its height, because of its structural gymnastics,
because of its kind of hedonistic design,
is going to have a material requirement which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions.
And then, once built, this giant glass, steel and concrete structure
that designers say will blend into the landscape
will need to be kept cool enough for people to live inside it.
One of the biggest problems is that it's essentially a big greenhouse.
Now, you don't need to have a PhD in physics
to understand what happens when sunlight hits glass, it heats up.
Compare that to traditional Saudi buildings,
which are made of mud, stone and clay and designed to be naturally cooled.
The irony of Neom is that although it's presented as being this futuristic city,
it's a lazy city.
The architectures are lazy.
Before the fossil fuel boom, architectures were generally a lot harder working.
They were built to keep heat in or keep it out.
If they can't keep the heat out, the consequences could be deadly.
In June 2024, Saudi Arabia was hit by an extreme heat wave.
Over 1,300 people died on the Hajj pilgrimage in Mecca,
where temperatures reached over 50 degrees Celsius.
2024 was the hottest year on record.
And scientists predict that average temperatures in Saudi
are likely to go up by two degrees Celsius by the middle of the century.
Perhaps the most precious resource in a desert megacity is water.
The region gets around six centimetres of rainfall a year.
And it's estimated that four fifths of Saudi's ancient underground aquifer
have been sucked dry by desert farming in the last three decades alone.
Currently, more than half of Saudi's water is supplied by energy-hungry desalination plants,
which spew out an estimated 60 million tonnes of CO2 per year.
Salty waste brine is then often discharged back into the sea, harming marine lives.
Neom has said renewable energy will power 100% of the desalination plants,
something that has never been achieved before.
With ambitious plans for re-greening the desert and growing crops,
finding sustainable water is still a crucial issue facing the line.
Conservationists also see the line as a death trap for wildlife.
Take a look at this map of bird migrations through the region.
Around 2.1 billion birds from over 100 different species,
including endangered ones, pass through the area.
Bird collisions with glass is an enormous problem.
The figures in the States are in the many hundreds of millions a year.
And that's just one nation.
Back on the construction site, little by little, progress is being made.
The latest satellite images of the hidden marina show a new excavation in progress
and hundreds of trucks busy shifting dirt.
Neom executives have admitted it may take 100 years to complete and fill the line.
But now there is a more concrete date in the diary.
A stadium suspended 350 metres high up on the skyscraper
is to be one of the official venues of the 2034 World Cup.