New Ukrainian FRAGS Go Through Russian Tanks Like Butter

Ground Warfare Vehicles
10 followers
Russia’s cope cages are failing—badly. Designed to protect tanks from Ukrainian drones, these improvised defenses have only made things worse. Ukraine’s drone warfare has evolved, rendering these "armor" additions nearly useless. Now, with purpose-built anti-cage munitions in play, Russia’s armored fleet faces even greater losses. Can Russia adapt, or will its tanks keep exploding?
Support us directly as we bring you independent, up-to-date reporting on military news and global conflicts by clicking here: / @themilitaryshow
#militarystrategy #militarydevelopments #militaryanalysis
#themilitaryshow
SOURCES: https://pastebin.com/82tTrUqD
ATTRIBUTIONS: https://pastebin.com/Xevspz9q
Russia's cope cages just can't cope anymore. Since the start of the war, Ukrainian drones
have been a nightmare for Russian armored vehicles. Russia, once boasting the world's
largest tank fleet, was blindsided by the reality that its multi-million dollar battle tanks could
be destroyed by drones costing only a few thousand dollars, armed with leftover Cold War munitions.
Desperate for a solution, Russia slapped together cope cages, welded metal projections meant to
shield their tanks from drone strikes, but as it turns out, these so-called defenses are only
making things worse. So why were the cope cages ever used, and how has Ukraine's drone warfare
rendered them even more useless? In this video, we're breaking down why Russian tanks have
suffered so much, and why things are about to get even worse for them. As of November 18th,
2024, 3,569 Russian tanks have become casualties in Ukraine. 2,502 of them have been completely
destroyed. That's over 20 percent of Russia's total pre-war tank fleet of 16,970 units,
according to global data. Russia has lost an additional 1,753 armored fighting vehicles,
5,008 infantry fighting vehicles, 550 armored personnel carriers, and 312
infantry mobility vehicles. Traditional anti-tank weapons like anti-tank guided missiles,
man-carried equipment like the Javelin and Enlur, and anti-material rifles like Ukraine's
massive alligator sniper rifle have been responsible for many of those destroyed units.
Artillery has played an even bigger role. However, drone attacks have destroyed many other vehicles.
At the start of the war, Ukraine used large military drones like Turkey's Bayraktar TB2
to wreak havoc on Russian armor, but smaller bomb-dropping or kamikaze drones proved even more
cost-effective. A tank like Russia's T-72 can cost between $1 and $2 million per unit. The T-90,
supposedly Russia's most advanced main battle tank it can actually put into the field,
sorry, T-14 Armata, can cost between $4 and $7 million apiece. In contrast, Ukraine's small
drones have a price tag of $1,700 per kill, according to Alexander Kamyshin, Ukraine's
former minister of strategic industries. Since Ukraine is outnumbered and outgunned,
those drones are the ideal weapon for waging a war of attrition, and Kamyshin claimed at
the beginning of the year that the FPV drone was becoming the main battle weapon of the Ukrainian
people. Little wonder why President Zelensky made the production of a million of them one
of his government's highest priorities for 2024. It already became clear that Ukraine
would surpass that goal by February, and that was bad news for Russia's Cope Cages.
Russia was outfitting its armored vehicles with Cope Cages even before the invasion started.
They first appeared on Russian tanks in late 2021 and were reportedly designed primarily to
counter drone-launched munitions, with some observers speculating they might also offer
limited protection against top-attack missiles like the Javelin. The Javelin was introduced
into service in the US military in 1996 and was designed specifically to counter Russian tanks.
Rather than impacting the main body of a target, the projectile targeted the turret,
impacting it at a downward trajectory at high velocity. A tank turret is much less protected
than the vehicle's main body, and the Javelin can go through over 30 inches of rolled homogenous
steel armor, according to US Army training documents. Although modern tanks feature
advanced composite armor that combines steel with ceramics, high-density materials like tungsten or
depleted uranium, and even spaced armor for added protection, they still cannot withstand
such impacts. They can't be engineered to, either. Giving a tank enough armor to withstand an impact
from a Javelin round would make it weigh over 200 tons, which is completely impractical for
basic mobility, let alone transporting these tanks to their theater of operations. To make
matters worse, Russia's tanks are particularly vulnerable to impacting rounds because they don't
protect their ammunition racks in a sealed compartment. One hit can set off a chain
reaction that destroys the tank and its crew. The only feasible way to counter something like
the Javelin is through active protection systems that can undermine the missile's guidance system,
or even counter it before it can impact its target. But the Russians nevertheless tried
to find something else. They respected the Javelin enough to try to come up with an improvised
countermeasure. Steel cages with grill-like structures appeared over the tops of Russian
tank turrets in late 2021. The projections were spaced a few feet above them. The concept behind
these constructions was that the incoming Javelin projectile would impact the cage first and explode
prematurely, which would limit damage to the tank beneath. This is not a new concept. Early in the
Cold War era, tank engineers built structures spaced away from their vehicle's main body to
protect them against anti-material weapons, and sometimes it's possible to improvise and see
success. During the Battle of Marawi between May and October 2017, Filipino forces protected their
vehicles with wooden plates attached to the outsides, which were effective in getting
incoming RPG-2 rounds to explode prematurely. The wooden armor helped the Filipino security
forces defeat the ISIS-affiliated terror group known as Abu Sayyaf. The United States and its
allies tried something similar against the RPG rounds they encountered in the War on Terror.
They used slat armor to protect their tanks from these projectiles.
The problem is that comparing an RPG to a Javelin is like comparing a cat to a tiger.
Unlike an RPG, the Javelin has a tandem warhead that's designed to defeat explosive reactive
armor, IRA. IRA works by detonating outward when hit by a projectile, forcibly driving metal plates
apart to damage, deflect, or disrupt the incoming threat before it can reach the target vehicle's
main body. However, the Javelin defeats this system with its tandem warhead design. The first
activates the IRA, neutralizing it, while the second penetrates the main armor to destroy the
target. Rest assured, if IRA can't stop a Javelin, a Cope Cage certainly won't.
As Russia moved into its quagmire, it quickly discovered that the Cope Cages weren't stopping
Javelin rounds. The Javelin quickly became an icon of Ukraine's resistance, with medieval-inspired
portraits of saint-like figures holding the American weapons spreading online. Meanwhile,
the Cope Cages were an icon of Russian incompetence, which extended to far more
than the one domain of warfare. However, the Russians still used the Cope Cages because
they realized the growing importance of small drones, a lesson imparted on them as early as
10 years ago, at the height of the Syrian Civil War. The Cope Cage might not be effective against
a Javelin round, but it could have some effect against drones dropping simpler weapons like
anti-tank grenades or even smaller mortar rounds, since these will hit the cage first.
Since Ukrainian drone pilots made sport of dropping grenades into open tank hatches in
early days, the adaptation saved lives of Russian tank crews. The Cope Cages also have
had success in stopping small loitering munitions armed with lighter explosives.
We have often mocked Cope Cages on this channel, but the best proof of their effectiveness,
at least in part, comes from images of Ukrainian tank crews outfitting them to their own vehicles.
By August 2023, images of Cope Cages welded to a donated Challenger tank began to surface.
The cage armor extended around the tank and above the turret, meaning that Ukraine is
Okay, so the Cope Cage isn't completely useless. It probably did save some tanks from being totaled,
particularly earlier in the war when Ukraine's drone pilots weren't as skilled as they are now.
What did they do? Ukraine's small drone pilots turned increasingly to kamikaze munitions and
began to avoid coming in from the top. The thing about an FPV drone is that it's small,
fast, and maneuverable. Ukraine's drone pilots have gotten so nimble that they can navigate
their UAVs inside apartment buildings and look for a target hiding out in a specific room,
with such precision they can easily move around or under Cope Cages, and they can impact their
target vehicle with sizable weapons that have a decent chance of destroying even a main battle
tank, let alone lighter vehicles. These drones most often impact Russian vehicles from the side.
The poor internal design of Russian tanks means that there will always be an elevated chance of
an impact setting the ammunition magazines off and blowing them up in jack-in-the-box style
explosions. So Russia adapted again and began to design ever more elaborate cage armor for
their tanks. The most effective adaptation likely involved outfitting era to the cages,
if the panels hadn't been stolen by logistics officers looking to make a quick buck.
Some cages have incorporated sandbags to enhance protection by absorbing and dispersing the impact
energy of incoming rounds. This approach leverages the loose, dense material within
the bags to complement the cage's defensive structure. There are worse ways to adapt,
though. When it realized that Ukrainian drones were maneuvering around cage armor,
Russia started to field armored vehicles that looked like they might be out of a Mad Max movie.
These cages cover the entirety of an armored vehicle's body and were seen as early as the
Syrian Civil War. Sometimes there have even been spikes projecting from the cages,
as seen in video widely circulating on social media. Russia continued to evolve the Cope Cage.
Another elaborate design appeared at the Army 2023 Defense Expedition that August.
The cage was attached to the turret and elevated through tubular poles. Metal mesh was used to
enhance visibility. To add protection, the mesh was combined with triangular slats with parallel
peaks and valleys. The Russian brass may have determined that this design is far better for
stopping loitering munitions. Among the most notable of the so-called Mad Max monstrosities
were the Turtle Tanks that appeared in April 2024. These vehicles featured a sloping outer
shell with a sheet of metal covering the top and extending down the sides. While several were
deployed, one Turtle Tank was destroyed in an artillery strike that same month. Such an approach
to cage armor doesn't inspire total confidence, as it could limit the crew's situational awareness,
mobility, and their ability to leave the vehicle in case of an emergency. The Turtle Tank, for
example, meant that the turret could not be moved. These modifications also make a tank much easier
to find at a distance. From there, an artillery strike is likely coming, and no Cope Cage is going
to cope with that. This is why these elaborate cage designs are the exception rather than the rule,
despite their increased visibility online. Most Russian vehicles seen online don't have
these elaborate Cope Cages. A Russian study found that cage armor works best against common
anti-material rounds like RPG when the rods of the cage are 10mm in diameter and the spacing
between them is 80mm. This design allows for a 65% chance of disrupting an incoming round.
Since Ukrainian drones are often armed with such rounds, this is a surprisingly reasonable level
of protection. In general, a design featuring narrower rods with more spacing is more effective
than thicker rods with less spacing. The problem for Russia is that the more effective design is
not standardized outside of protecting the sides and rear of a tank. The fact that there is no
standardized Cope Cage suggests that the Russians have yet to find a reliable way to protect their
tank turrets with slat armor in the way that the side or rear armor can be protected. If there
were a Cope Cage or system of elaborate cage armor that actually worked well, it would quickly see
widespread use. But so far, the Turtle Tanks or Mad Max Tanks of the world have been comparative
rarities, and the skill of Ukraine's drone pilots explains why. Even if the Turtle Tank hadn't been
destroyed by artillery, Ukrainian drone pilots would have easily been able to fly under the shell
and deliver their payloads. Unfortunately for Russians, they have yet to find a reliable
alternative to cage armor either, though not for the lack of trying. In the first half of 2024,
it became evident that electronic jammers would become an increasingly important part of any
military force thanks to the ubiquitous use of small drones that were hard to counter through
kinetic methods. Jammers would be needed to protect both infantry and armor from these
constant menaces. Early in the year, Russia looked like it was learning this lesson and adapting.
T-72 tanks equipped with jammers began to appear on the battlefield. The new tanks understandably
made Ukraine's drone pilots nervous. But when these tanks began to be captured in April,
the Ukrainians found that their jammers were unlikely to work. They pointed straight up,
meaning they were unlikely to protect a tank from a drone coming in on the sideways trajectory.
The jammers were also not assembled well. The antennae were manufactured in a factory,
but bound together through improvised methods. This lack of effective standardization made
Ukrainian troops question the jammers' effectiveness at all. As 2024 came to a close,
Russian tanks continued to suffer from the Ukrainian FPV drones, so Moscow has yet to
solve the jammer problem in a systematic way. We can expect Russian tanks to continue to rely
at least in part on the Cope cages as 2025 begins. Unfortunately for them, Ukraine just got a whole
lot better at countering these two, and all without expensive javelin ammunition.
From the beginning of the war, Ukraine has had an uncanny ability to bring new stuff to the field,
whether in the form of new weapons like its long-range drones or in repurposing old weapons.
Ukraine's use of 3D printers has helped its defense industry in the process. Ukraine started
showing its innovation here by taking Soviet anti-tank grenades and 3D printing fins for them
to make them good drone-delivered munitions. However, these rounds would be ineffective
against well-made cage armor because they would detonate prematurely. But now there are two
rounds designed to defeat the Cope cages. Meet the FRAG munitions, manufactured by a domestic
Ukrainian company called Shockwave Dynamics. Both rounds come off of 3D printers and have a
platter-charge warhead. What does that mean? Let's look at what these bad boys can do.
The first type is the FRAG 05975. It's an explosive charge that weighs 0.9 kilograms
and hosts hundreds of ball bearings on its body, just behind the outer layer. This round is
primarily designed for anti-personnel missions. To see why it works against cage armor, we must
first compare it to an impact from a normal round. Kamikaze drones often carry conventional,
cylindrical, high-explosive warheads when they impact or explode near their targets.
Upon detonation, the fragmentation spreads out in an omnidirectional ring. Infantry in a vehicle
like an armored personnel carrier who'd take cover behind a cage are better protected because the
can disperse the force and prevent this ring of high-energy debris from getting through.
The FRAG 05975 round, though, concentrates its force forward and backward to give it more directed
debris spread. This concentration is effective at getting through the cage and impacting targets
behind it. One of the first confirmed uses of the anti-personnel FRAG round came on January 4th,
2024, in the Robertine area in Zaporizhzhya Oblast. The footage shows five Russian soldiers
congregating near two destroyed T-90 tanks, one of which had seen its turret blown off in a
jack-in-the-box explosion. Three of the troops were running. Five seconds in, we saw why. A
small Ukrainian FPV was chasing them. The explosive the drone was carrying then detonated about five
seconds into the clip. The airburst sent explosive fragments in a wide field that impacted all of
them. One of the soldiers stopped moving forward. Another struggled underneath the charred tank.
The third struggled to stand after the detonation. Two others seemed to successfully move away when
the video feed cut off. If these troops had been taking cover behind cage armor, they would have
had nowhere to go. All of the force would have been concentrated on them and all would have likely
not made it out. The second round is the FRAG 09576, which weighs 1.3 kilograms and is used
in anti-material roles. A traditional anti-material shaped charge will often detonate prematurely upon
impacting cage armor, failing to deliver its lethal punch to the main body of the target.
The EFPS, however, uses a shock impact core designed to penetrate protective cages and
strike the vehicle behind them, making it far more effective against such defenses.
The FRAG 09576 and the FRAG 05975 rounds both made their debut in December 2023,
and each has distinct damage radii. The FRAG 09576 has a radius of continuous damage of 5 meters
and an effective damage radius of 8 meters. Meanwhile, the FRAG 05975 is larger with a
radius of continuous damage of 8 meters and an effective damage radius of 14 meters.
These FRAG rounds are mounted on drones using nylon clamps. Since the munitions are designed
for remote detonation, the clamps allow operators to align explosives for maximum efficiency.
This setup also positions the munitions with the drone's camera, giving pilots a clear view of the
target and ensuring precise detonation. Unlike Cold War-era munitions that Ukraine previously
adapted for drone use, these FRAG grenades are purpose-built for modern drone warfare,
providing enhanced accuracy and destructive capability.
Russian social media and military bloggers raised the alarm about the new Ukrainian rounds as soon
as they began to appear. Russia's Marines were among the first troops confirmed to have encountered
it. They warned,
Landed a quadcopter drone with a new 360-degree shrapnel ammunition.
Be attentive and careful. The enemy uses newer and newer weapons.
Documents from Shockwave Dynamics state that the armor penetration for a FRAG's round is 25mm.
It's primarily designed for destroying more lightly armored vehicles protected by cope cages,
such as infantry fighting vehicles and armored personnel carriers, but that does not mean it's
useless against tanks. One circulating video showed a drone armed with a FRAG's round crashing
into a Russian tank. After the explosion, the footage showed a penetrating gash toward the
top of the turret. This would have been damaging to the crew inside. The increased use of rounds,
specifically designed to penetrate cage armor, deliverable via small drones,
means that Russia's beleaguered tank fleet is facing even more hurdles in the near future.
Until it can find a way to adequately protect its tanks against drones with jammers,
we can expect the cope cages to continue to struggle to cope as the war enters its fourth
calendar year. One thing's for sure, Russia's tank fleet, which had sent shivers down the
spine of Western leaders since World War II, has seen its reputation go up in smoke. Literally.
The term cope cage might be a term that originated with Ukrainian propagandists,
but it's stuck, and it's become a calling card for Russia's lost reputation,
all thanks to the ingenuity of Ukrainian weapons designers.
What do you think is coming next in the tank war in Ukraine? Will Russia finally find a way to
equip its armored vehicles with proper jammers, or can we expect more improvised cope cages in
the near future? Don't forget to let us know in the comments. Also, make sure to hit the like
button and subscribe for more military analysis from military experts. Now go and check out
Russia's Back Finally Breaks The Worst Week Ever, or click this other video instead.
