Death Note, as a complete series, has a disturbing truth behind it. One that has gone unnoticed by the vast majority of those that have decided to watch and read this incredible but not entirely flawless series over the last two decades.
Many love Light Yagami’s plotting and quick thinking, many more love the stoic and mysterious character of L, but what is it this series is actually telling us at its core and did the author and artist behind Death Note craft the best series they could? Let’s find out.
MUSIC USED:
-Beethoven's 9th -Bones (over by Martha Kovalchuk) -Golden Township of the Rising Sun (Cover by SeMi Piano) -Biotope (Virtue's Last Reward) -Clarification (Virtue's Last Reward) -荒廃した街で (Devil Survivor)
You know, most people I know have seen Death Note, but most people I would wager
don't actually know what Death Note really is about.
So it's a show about pizza.
Despite the original manga only running for about two and a half years in Weekly Shonen Jump,
the series has, since its debut in 2003, sold over 30 million copies on just three volumes alone,
spawning a wildly popular anime adaptation, four live-action films,
two of which are based on completely original material, a J-drama, multiple video games,
multiple stage plays and musicals, and even, regrettably, an American remake film produced
by Netflix. Critically, it remains one of the most highly acclaimed and oft-discussed manga
in circulation to this day, though interestingly, this seems to primarily be maintained in the West,
while in Japan, the manga's notoriety has waned enough to where it didn't even show up in the
top 100 when TVSI surveyed Japanese readers in late 2020. While using the phrase monolithic
would generally come off as arrogant, it's difficult to describe Death Note as anything
else. While most of the series that Jump publishes, even the titanically popular ones
like Dragon Ball and One Piece, exist as entities within Jump's collective branded canon,
Death Note exists almost entirely as an entity unto itself, separate from it all. Heck,
the mere mention of a notebook that causes death is something which acts as a reference to the
franchise, with countless parodies and homages that have sprouted from it over the years.
Even actual, literal, real-life murders have been committed in tribute to this very franchise,
and while screwed up on so many levels, it only further speaks to the iconography the
story itself possesses as a piece of literary canon. It is, however, this public discussion
that I feel like something has been lost. Not just insofar as the back-and-forth on various
specificities regarding its story, but even the central ideas on the manga itself have been lost,
pressed under a mountain of adaptation and misinterpretation to where the original meaning
has been almost entirely lost. For this analysis, I think it's worth looking back at the original
work and consequently asking a simple question. What exactly is Death Note really about?
Death Note's two mangaka, writer Tsugumi Oba and artist Takeshi Obata, are two men with interesting
personal histories, to say the least. While it has never been confirmed by a direct source,
a popular rumor about Tsugumi Oba is that he is and always has been nothing but a pseudonym for
gag mangaka Hiroshi Gamo. Gamo's work was very much a prototypical Jump gag series of the time,
dense in absurdism and wordplay and geared heavily to Jump's child audience. While this did make him
something of a favorite amongst Jump's offices, demonstrated in a mostly kayfabe feud he had with
competing gag manga author Yasui Kita, that's all key to end his own series outright blaming
Gamo for his inability to get off the ground. The well dried up and after two attempted runs
in 1998 and then 2000 failed to garner publicity, Gamo more or less vanished from the public eye
entirely. Obata, on the other hand, is a bit of a different story. Achieving the much vaunted
Tetsuka Prize in 1985 and performing his first formal serialization, Cyborg Grandpa G, when he
was just 20 years of age, Obata had gained a reputation as a budding talent over a series
of collaborations in the 90s before hitting it big in 1998 when he, together with Yumi Hota,
created Hikaru no Go. The series was a runaway success, spawning a resurgence in Go as a game
and lasted to mid 2003, just a few months before Death Note debuted. The reason I bring these two
backstories up is to offer a point of contextualization on the series as a whole. Death
Note is not the work of some young author coming into Jump to shake things up with a bold new vision
but a collaboration of a 40 year old washout under a false identity and a superstar artist still
riding his fame, working together under prior relationships they had within Jump itself.
Looking at the timeline of the end of Hikaru, the one-shot's publication, and the official
serialization of the manga itself, it becomes clear that Death Note has been essentially primed
in a pipeline from the start, with the one-shot itself just meant to gauge audience reception and
establish the false identity of Oba to the public. Its artistic deviations from Jump's norm are not
a visionary working against a hierarchy, but instead a hierarchy purposely deviating from
itself for revenue. And this is all to say that a common statement made about Death Note insofar
as its relationship to Jump is that it doesn't fit in with the rest of Jump's publications and
on a surface level observation, looking at what was being published at the time, this is correct.
At a time where Jump was primarily embracing bright fanciful narratives full of youthful
boyish optimism, Death Note is harshly cynical, decidedly grounded in its scope, and operates less
on dramatic climaxes as much as meticulous build-up and articulation. Of its cast, only about a dozen
are given substantial page time or focus of any kind, and even then the manga, with one exception,
notably avoids dedicating substantial flashbacks to explaining character backstories and motivations,
instead choosing to center the story squarely around a singular serialized narrative
without any breaks of any kind. This was compounded of course by Light himself, not just in the
obvious fact that he is a literal mass murderer, but Light in many ways was not someone Jump's
target reader base was set to relate to. Unlike the scrappy outcasts and delinquents who defined
protagonists in the publication for the last 15 years, Light is a top-level student set for the
best university in the country, beloved by his peers, popular with women, and is the son of a
deputy director of the Japanese NPA. He is not someone to be associated with, but an archetype
of ideal Japanese youth, and the manga crucially uses that as shorthand for his entire characterization
that feeds into every aspect of his personality and actions. What especially sticks out about this
is when one reads Death Note's original one-shot pilot. The pilot, while it retains much of the
basis insofar as the idea of the Death Note and Shinigami, including the character of Ryuk,
it is otherwise radically different, and in a way that makes it far closer to a typical Jump manga.
The one-shot's protagonist, Taro Kagami, is an ordinary 13-year-old kid who, after accidentally
killing his bullies with the Death Note, is utterly horrified by the deaths he's caused,
to the point of being unable to sleep. He refuses to use the Death Note after understanding its
true purpose, tries to actively cooperate with the police, and goes out of his way to stop his
best friend from using the notebook, even at risk of his own life. Everything that Light is not.
What is most striking, however, is the inclusion of a single plot point that radically goes against
everything in the actual series, the Death Eraser. Using an eraser provided by Ryuk,
Taro is able to erase the lines of text written in the notebook and undo the deaths it has caused,
the only caveat being that the body still needs to be intact for this to work.
There are no downsides to this, and the story even demonstrates this directly in the climax,
where Taro demonstrates its power by using the notebook on himself, and then having the eraser
bring him back. The one-shot ends with the Death Note being destroyed, and, in an interesting
foreshadowing of the manga itself, Taro and Ryuk years later observing how the Death Note has
become an urban legend, the final page essentially asking the young readers what they would do if
they had such an item. Now, considering that the pilot was, again, most likely made after the
serialization was fully planned, it's interesting how it seemed to have been purely built not off
advertising the actual premise of the manga, but instead the idea, the idea of a Shinigami's
notebook that kills whoever's name is written inside. This is, in a way, illustrative of the
series as a whole, because what the Death Note was sold on was its idea and the conceits that spawned
from it. In a jump which was more or less defined by the three central manga running within it,
Death Note was the edgy counterculture piece, the outsider that broke all the rules, and because
of that, warranted attention as the rule breaker. It was, in a sense, Jump's alternative art, but
the weird thing is, it still kind of fit.
Death Note's anime has some of the most killer music in all of anime, and what better way to
experience that than with Raycon's everyday earbuds that now look, sound, and feel better
than ever. They're so light you'd barely even know they were on your ears. These bad boys are
deathly cool and take note of all these awesome colors. I'm rocking the flare reds and they fit
perfectly on my ear thanks to the optimized gel tips. I can flail around like a madman and they
straight up won't budge. The fact it's got eight hours of constant playtime and a 32-hour battery
life means they're always ready to go whenever I need them. They're super customizable too. For
example, you can swap between three sound profiles to really tailor the sound to your preference.
You can dial up the madness with the bass sound, use pure sound to clear vocals on your podcasts,
or simply leave it on balanced sound for a one-size-fits-all approach. You can also pick
noise isolation or awareness mode to decide whether you want to be totally immersed or keep
track of what's going on around you. It's as simple as holding the left or right earbud respectively
for three seconds to cycle through these modes. These things have over 50,000 five-star reviews
thanks to their awesome audio quality, and that comes at half the price of other premium audio
brands. You'd be taking a huge L and not picking these bad boys up. So what are you waiting for?
Click the link in the description or go to buyraycon.com forward slash not mark
to get 15% off your Raycon purchase.
Writer Tsugumi Oba has stated in multiple interviews that he'd never intended Death
Note to be seen as being about the moral quandary of the Death Note itself. That the series was
intended first and foremost as a work of entertainment, and this shows itself in the
framing and the structure of the story. Even though the entire premise revolves around Light
and his accomplices committing mass murder essentially every day, the manga seems to
deliberately do everything in its power to downplay that as much as it possibly can.
Outside of a handful of circumstances where it's used on scene, bodies are purposely almost never
shown in spite of the hundreds they are inferred to have killed, any and all references to societal
ramifications with Light's crimes are kept to a minimum, and instead the series is mostly situated
around long monologues regarding the meticulous point-by-point nature to which Light and L perform
their battle of wits. Tonally, the manga is surprisingly light given the subject,
with persistent use of comic relief designed to power its narrative. Nearly every scene Light is
in, Ryuk, Misa, or Matsuda, will say or do something dumb and the gag will be that Light
as the straight man barely responding to it. Multiple times the series will do a sudden
tonal shift to have stuff like Light and L bonding over a very intense game of tennis,
or have Matsuda go through a comedy of errors as he tries not to be killed by the Otsuba group.
Misa, despite being a mass murderer herself, is never treated as anything more than Light's
perky female sidekick, and her flippancy under which she commits her crimes is never really
stressed. Even Light's trademark grin, used often as a mark of tension, is used multiple times as a
gag where he wears it where it isn't appropriate, as if even that part is just for the fun of it.
And I stress all of this because...
Demystifying Death Note as this mature philosophy piece, which it most definitely is not,
exposes what its actual core appeal is. The back and forth of Light and L. With Ryuk a purely
passive observer who serves primarily as a source of exposition and to give Light someone to talk
to, Light and L are the only characters of significance with an active role in the narrative.
Each scenario the manga sets up in Part 1 is designed around exploring the angles in which L
sets up traps for Light to fall into, all the while Light attempts to get out of them,
with each minute detail given attention and dissection as a possible opening.
A really good example of this comes in Chapters 16 and 17, when L has Light's
room bugged in order to monitor him. On a base, this is a really interesting scenario,
because L has put Light into a deadlock. Either he'll be exposed using the Death Note,
or he'll be indirectly exposed when the Kira killings start declining while he's under
surveillance. The manga is aware of this, and thus the intrigue comes in watching how Light
combats it, first by laying out how he figures out that he's being monitored at all,
and his counterattacks of having Ryuk locate and remove the cameras, then laying out each
calculated action he takes to ensure he can continue his murders without being seen,
and safely disposes of the evidence. However, the manga crucially does not give Light a complete
victory, as his cover strategy still crucially leads to an aberration in Kira's murders that
increases L's focus on Light. This in turn leads L to enroll at Light's university,
completely shifting their dynamic while progressing the story to its next stage.
This kind of interplay demonstrates what Part 1 is all about. It is a hyper-stylized reinvention
of the classical Holmes vs. Moriarty scenario, the mythologized battle between the eccentric
genius detective and the criminal mastermind, with the added twist of Moriarty as the main
POV character. L's character, consequently, is designed as the perfect opposite to Light. His
unkempt appearance, unnatural posture, and calm demeanor all contrast against what defines Light,
Soichiro and Misa, the most important characters in Part 1 besides the main duo,
accentuate this. Soichiro as a Watson provides an added conflict in how he is both directly
aiding L, yet also refusing to believe Light as the culprit, while Misa, upon her introduction,
provides Light his Mara, a loyal accomplice who, while not an intellectual fighter,
provides a direct actor who gives Moriarty slash Light a host of actions not possible as a lone
actor. And framing all of this is the series' final essential element, the rules.
Concluding nearly every chapter is a relaying of the various rules with which the Death Note,
Shinigami, and associate elements function under and how they work. The notebook kills by writing
someone's true name while picturing their face. Unless specified, the cause of death will be a
heart attack initiated 6 minutes and 40 seconds after the name is written. All thus needed is
not the notebook, but the paper within, and so on. These rules go extremely in-depth,
laying out numerous theoreticals, and the vast majority don't factor into the story at all,
but all of them go a ways in establishing something important, what is and isn't possible
for Light and other characters to do. Even if something is seemingly irrelevant, the fact that
it is a possibility is something which the reader is made to consider. Light even exploits the
importance of this mechanic by hinging a crucial tactic on forging rules, essentially invoking the
And that is Death Note's appeal in a nutshell, the point in which the mind games go so far to
where even the in-story mechanics are being exploited as tactics. This kind of back and
forth built into part 1's structure takes on a really interesting turn in the latter half.
While Light loses his memory and the story switches to a more traditional jump narrative where he and
L team up, this is, generally speaking, viewed as a weaker part of the story, as the mind battles
take a back seat and the story kinda drags its feet through 20 chapters filled with repetitive
scenes of the same generic businessmen talking about the same topics ad nauseam. But what makes
it work is in how the conflict creates a fascinating new dimension to the core dynamic of Light and L,
through which the two characters together exchange theories and try to deduce just who exactly the
new Kira is. The reader gets a far better idea of both what makes the two so similar and yet
so different. The wait for the core conflict to resume is something which is actually made
a focal aspect of the plot, exploiting the reader's curiosity as to when and how that
will happen. And it's when that moment is reached that gears shift and we have to re-examine the
series from an entirely different angle. By far the most polarizing critical assessment
of Death Note is a simple one. Was the latter half of the story even necessary? It is hard to
argue against the fact that the latter half of the manga, which I'll now call Part 2 for brevity,
is decidedly unpopular. Not only does the 2006 anime substantially power it down to 12 episodes
in spite of adapting the only slightly longer Part 1 in 25, but both the live action films and
J-drama substantially alter the narrative so to end the series with Part 1, working in plot aspects
of Part 2 but crucially ending the series so that it concludes with Light and L's final fight.
Ask anyone on any anime discussion platform out there and they will say Part 2 was a mistake,
a failure of design and all kinds of other negative statements that overall color how the
story is viewed today. There is overall a lot to unpack about what does and does not work and what
exactly what is there is supposed to mean. So let's dig into that by first addressing the
common criticisms at play. Firstly, by far the key central complaint towards Part 1 is an obvious one
that the story continues after L's death. Not only is L himself the most popular character in the
series, as one look at my anime list will tell you, but the very core appeal I talked about is
something which cannot function if either Light or L is dead. This would naturally suggest the
story's culmination to be at this point, but instead the story goes against this and continues
on with a character who, while crucially not actually a copy of L, still greatly resembles
him in demeanor all the while sporting a design which is essentially a palette swap. Tellingly in
regards to this attachment to L is in how both live action adaptations have him ultimately be
victorious over Light, albeit at the cost of his own life. This I think stems from a misunderstanding
on the narrative purpose of L's death and also how it works as a thematic undercurrent for the
larger story as a whole. In Killing Off L, Oba not only opens up the narrative into a scenario where
Light has won, but divorces the conflict away from L, the person, and instead to L, the idea.
Nier, despite his similarities to L, is pointedly not L in many ways. He is far more emotionally
calm and displays a philosophical understanding far larger than what his predecessor ever displayed,
and that emotional disconnection he displays allows the conflict to shift away from a two-man
conflict to something more universal in scope. I'll get into this more later, but for now I just want
to say in order for the story Oba and Obata were telling to work, Light needed to beat L.
Nothing more, nothing less. Another complaint I see lobbed at the series is that the loss of L
causes the series to no longer have anyone for the reader to root for. Light and his accomplices are
monsters, Mello is an immoral terrorist and criminal, and Nier, while not terribly different
from L morally, is too much of a passive stuck-up kid to really enjoy following. By consequence,
the story becomes draining to follow as there is no one to connect with, essentially giving into
the nihilism underpinning the story as a whole. This too is something I think is wrong. While they
may not be the primary drivers of the main narrative, the Japanese task force is given
substantially more focus as characters throughout the second part, and with this focus comes a
crucial amount of emotional grounding that was just absent entirely from Part 1. Aizawa, who in
the first half of the series was largely a background character, notably takes a major
role as one of the main POV characters, as we see him slowly accept who Light truly is, and watching
the feelings of these ordinary men reacting to an ever-deteriorating situation, losing their
collective mentor, and then slowly realizing what they'd been fighting for was in large a lie, is
seriously compelling stuff that contextualizes the narrative through to its closing moments,
and I'm honestly surprised it's not talked about more. But indeed, these points do frame the
difference in Part 2, which makes it both so polarizing and, at the same time, fascinating to discuss.
While Part 1 was centered purely on the deadlock of Light and L, Part 2 takes a far broader approach,
touching on the global idea of Kira and his worship, the ideals of fixing society which
Light's motives are built around, and overall constructing a complex, interconnected web of
ideas which together all build to a singular point where Light's worldview is succinctly rejected.
Rather than designing the narrative around the singular point of two characters fighting,
Oba instead switches to the arguably high route of positioning the story about Light's eventual
thematic and literal defeat, and that is, if anything, a far more interesting story than
L defeats Light could ever be. Unfortunately, while the ideas in play are not bad, the actual
handling in-story demonstrates a number of fundamental problems in the design that causes
the manga to fumble the execution. By far, the biggest problem Part 2 struggles with is in its
structure. While I wouldn't exactly call the series rushed, each major conflict is resolved
more or less at the same speed as beforehand, and there's rarely a plot point that feels like it
should have been delved into more. The sheer breakneck speed at which story elements and
ideas are introduced, discussed, and resolved becomes almost dizzying. Only a few chapters
after L dies, the story shifts into full gear to have Mello kidnap Light's little sister,
in the process setting off a plotline in America with a vastly more dramatic scope than anything
in the series. However, this ends almost just as quickly, with Mello being written out of the
story almost entirely, and the manga is forced to pivot into both Nier's plotting against Light
and introducing Mikami and Takeda as Light's new accomplices. However, since Nier cannot directly
go against Light until it's time for the climax, the only thing the manga can do is wander around
through subplots until that point, and then it suddenly remembers Mello is still alive and hauls
itself to kill him and Takeda off in the span of a single chapter. An event which comes incredibly
abruptly in spite of being what a major amount of the finale is built upon, and this is essentially
the core issue underpinning Part 2. Because the only logical story direction Oba has is to have
Nier defeat Light, the entire narrative until that point is just delaying the inevitable,
and consequently the story is left overcomplicating itself to compensate. Chapters are routinely
interrupted by lengthy monologues designed to recap information, and it becomes often difficult
to remember who knows what, not helped also by how often the series will reveal that what
characters thought they knew was just false information. While individual subplots such as
Kira's global worship or Aizawa becoming Nier's inside man on the task force are interesting,
as well as narratively and thematically relevant, the way these storylines pivot between one another
never really feels cohesive, and there's a lot of space where it feels like the story could have
used its time better. Probably the biggest victim of this kind of narrative crunch is Nier,
unfortunately. While the complaint about him being a carbon copy of L is inaccurate, the lack of any
real breathing room combined with how passive a character he is means that his role for much of
Part 2 is largely relegated to just occasional cutaways which seem to exist mainly to remind
the reader that he even exists. His relationship with Light lacks the personal edge that made L
so compelling, and his tactical maneuvers are mostly just in recapping things the readers
already know, while again the point still sees the engagement suffer because of it.
Conversely, Light's role is dramatically reduced, as the shift in focus means he's rarely put in
the actual conflict until the end. Up until the climax, Light in Part 2 is a bit of a cipher,
as the fact that he's already effectively won means there's nowhere for him to go until he's
beaten. He doesn't really affect Nier or Mellow as much as they vaguely affect him, and his
relationships with his accomplices, despite them being what the climax in part hinges on,
is crucially underdeveloped to where it's not quite clear what he thought of Mikami even by the end.
And that's the thing, while Part 2 tries to expand the scope to a thematic ideology,
it consistently is unable to juggle the weight that entails. Ideas like Kira's worldwide influence
and worship are left feeling unexplored and underdeveloped. Characters like Mikami feel
forced in without proper build-up or payoff, and there is overall a dragging pace. While the shift
outside the two-man battle formula is commendable, it comes at the cost of the thrilling mind games
which Part 1 enjoyed, and is overall, in layman's terms, a bit of a drag. Which makes it all the
more impressive then, that despite the myriad of flaws the second half suffers from, the climax
is genuinely gold. Even though it is effectively just seven chapters of the remaining characters
standing in a dark, abandoned warehouse and talking, the series finale is easily the tensest,
most dramatic, cohesive section of the entire narrative. Skillfully managing to weave a proper
culmination to every idea that had ran through the story, and giving greater purpose to the
twenty-odd chapters which all existed to set this up. The climax especially serves to demonstrate
full purpose to Nier, as his calculated approach allows the finale to carry itself without any
unneeded actions or snapbacks, and watching him refute Light so simply is, in a sense, delightful.
While it's not perfect, I can't really imagine a better way for Death Note to end.
If the overall story was about Light's crusade against evil, then what the story needed to end
is this. Not a grand battle with the fate of justice on the line, but on a question being
answered. The true, thematic conclusion to the tale. Which finally brings us to the ending,
and the meaning of this story.
Without question, the biggest and most persistent misconception about Death Note is what exactly
it's about. Most sources, YouTube reviewers, geek culture news sites, and just random people on
social media present this about the idea of justice, and how the series is reliant on the
if Light's crusade is right. Light is a mass murderer, yet in killing criminals he is arguably
doing the right thing by punishing evil. As Light himself states, in being presented with a god
which punishes all evil, people are made to become kinder, and war, premeditated murder,
and organized crime are all but eradicated. Crucially, what these arguments do is press
forward a single straightforward claim, that the series provides no true answer to the core dilemma.
If Light was truly right to perform his crusade, or if El and Nier were right to have him stopped,
what is justice is up for the reader to ultimately decide. Only problem though,
there is an answer. And it's pretty plainly that Light is wrong.
From the very start of the manga, Light's murder spree as Kira is never shown as anything other
than a negative. Never once in the series are we ever shown positive results from his murders.
Indeed, it's explicitly noted that crime goes past the rate it was before Kira became a thing
after the murders temporarily go away. Besides Misa, who is not meant to be seen as sympathetic
in the slightest, no one is ever shown being benefitted from Light's crimes, and the only
one who suggests such, Matsuda, is repeatedly called out for it by other characters. Moreover,
the idea that Light is anything but a villain is laughable. Even though Light sincerely does
believe he is doing the right thing, his characterization is shown to be petty, unhinged,
and remorseless insofar as the innocent lives he takes, and he displays an extraordinary absence of
sympathetic and humanizing traits. Never once does the manga or creator ever portray him as
a fallen hero, all it does is refer to him as childish and, quote, pure, this is important,
and indeed he can't be, as everything he does by the end is stuff he was planning to do from the
start. Even when he dies, the reader isn't invited to mourn him, but just think about the sort of
This is all clinched in the most thematically crucial moment of the entire series when,
after an extended six-page rant expressing all of his modems and worldview,
Light's entire ideology is destroyed when Nier bluntly tells him that, as he cannot dictate
what is objectively right or wrong, Kira is therefore nothing more than a murderer.
Seeing as L and Nier openly state they are not fighting Kira for the reason of justice,
but respectively personal interest and pride as the world's greatest detectives,
this actually gives a different message entirely, that justice does not exist as an objective
concept, but only what one perceives in their own mind. Hence, forcing that justice onto the
world as a god is wrong, not because of ethics, but due to that very contradiction itself.
Where this gets really interesting, though, is when one discusses the anime,
and specifically how it impacts the viewer's interpretation of Light.
I've been kind of avoiding talking about the Tetsuro Araki-directed anime thus far,
primarily because I think the manga is more valuable as a source text,
but a lot of the misunderstandings the series has are rooted in Araki's directorial choices
as an adaptation. Most crucially to this is the way it frames Light's character and the
story through homages and invocations of Judeo-Christian art, literally using a direct
comparison to Michelangelo's The Creation of Adam in the OP to depict Light receiving the
Death Note from Ryuk, a presentational idea which doesn't even make sense when you break it down.
The soundtrack is persistently laced with booming chants associated with Christian imagery,
most often used when Light's plans are in play. Whereas the manga is mostly told in
plain light and staging, the anime adds a heavy color gradient which stresses the
apocalyptic atmosphere. Rather than simply presenting a shot of him noticing the notebook,
Light's discovery is framed with heavy shadows that show the darkness symbolically pulling him
in. When Light declares his desire to become the God of the New World, while the manga shows a shot
of his eyes to express his conviction, the anime instead frames it against the setting sun,
this very act displaying a defiance of the heavens themselves.
Light in the anime is at once Lucifer and the corrupted first man, tempted by the evil Apple
of Enlightenment. Everything about the adaptation is designed to reinforce this interpretation,
in spite of how utterly against the manga it is. Light's inner monologue which demonstrates
his willingness to kill anyone, even his own little sister, is heavily cut down upon,
while the anime pays way more focus on the grandeur of his killing spree and ideological
fight with L. Notably, the anime cuts out the majority of Light's motive rant in the climax
outlining his entire worldview, just having him argue that he's made the world better and thus
did what no one else could. All of this together goes to create a very different character,
one who is not a twisted distortion of Japanese youth, but instead some sort of dark messiah
who twists the world to his whim. Now, while some of these changes are likely just the adaptation
itself at play, I mean, part two of the anime is heavily trimmed down from the manga and Light's
persistent thoughts would have worked quite poorly in an active visual medium, but what cannot be
viewed as anything but an intentional change comes in the anime's ending. And this is where
things get irritating. For the most part, the manga and the anime have the same events play out.
After Light's final gambit to kill Nier, the task force and the SPK via Mikami is foiled,
and Light has his secret identity exposed. Light attempts to kill Nier via the spare notebook piece
in his watch, is gunned down by Matsuda, and then slowly bleeds out before Ryuk puts him out of his
misery with the Death Note. In the manga, this is done to make Light look as pathetic as humanly
possible, writhing around in pain as he begs for someone to help him and kill everyone else before
culminating in him desperately pleading repeatedly how he doesn't want to die as the futility of his
existence becomes apparent. Ryuk then writes his name in the Death Note and Light's body drops
lifeless to the ground. The conclusion of Light Yagami in the manga is a two-page spread of his
dazed corpse, as unsightly as the countless people he killed. In the anime however, Light somehow
manages to run away from the task force after being shot, despite the obvious fact that he
should effectively be immobile at this point, and we are also treated to a slow montage of Light's
slowly flashing before his eyes while sad music is playing. There is no desperate pleading for
his enemies to die or his own survival, and instead Light's final moments are him quietly
passing away on a staircase, with just Ryuk there to comfort him and say they had a fun time together.
As the anime erases the manga's epilogue, this is essentially the note the series closes on,
framing it around Light's tragic rise and fall from grace, an idea which is pretty much as far
away from the manga as you could possibly get. In other words, according to this, Light tried to do
the right thing, and he should be born for it, in spite of the horrible crimes he committed along the way.
This kind of reinterpretation, an attempt to justify a misconception about the text as the
actual truth, continues into all other adaptations of the story, essentially piling on top of each
other this idea that falls apart the moment you actually read the original text. The live-action
films, while they have to have Light's crimes escalate much quicker as a way of moving the
it gives his motives and Misa's backstory far more focus than the actual source material ever did,
and thus makes them substantially more sympathetic as characters, including giving
Light a far more humanizing death scene than the one he gets in either the manga or the anime.
The J-drama discards Light's most defining character trait, his immense intelligence and
ego in favor of him being an ordinary university student who does give a shit about his family
and Misa and is shown saving people as Kira. The Netflix adaptation, however, goes the whole
nine yards and transforms him into the stereotypical bullied outcast kid who just
wants to make the world better and is horrified by the idea of killing innocent people who are
in his way. With, by the way, all of the original negative traits Light had backported into this
version of Misa, which is just another classic Netflix girl-bossification of a character which,
in attempting to fix a quote problem with the source material, instead turns the character
into a rabidly misogynistic stereotype. Now, my point with listing these changes isn't to
illustrate all the ways adaptations try to make Light more sympathetic, but to instead display
a consistent pattern in how Death Note's myriad of adaptations approach the source material.
Light's numerous villainous traits, his readiness to murder innocent people who get in his way,
his complete lack or care for anyone but himself, and his utter refusal to see anything he does as
morally reprehensible all openly get in the way of what most people imagine Death Note to be about,
and thus adaptations seek to rectify this by changing the story to suit this desire.
It's not as much about changing the story to the adaptation's own vision per se, but instead
correcting the original narrative to what they think it should be. That, or they're trying to
make the story about Light and L's epic bromance, which they do quite a lot, mind you. The really
ironic thing here, though, is that for all of the posturing about biblical imagery and right and
wrong the adaptations do, none of them actually seem to properly understand what the original
manga is about. That being, essentially, a societal critique. In the early 1990s, Japan went through
something of a societal collapse. After an entire decade of rapid financial growth, sudden widespread
policy changes in 1989 led to a bubble burst and nationwide recession that would last the next 20
years. The group perhaps hit hardest by this was the, quote, lost generation. The Japanese youth
who, after spending their entire lives being extensively pressured to study their asses off,
get into high quality universities and from there inherit the world from their parents,
entered the workforce to instead find a world with no jobs, a collapsed marketplace, and an
older generation which seemed only interested in throwing their own problems onto others.
Many, many texts have been written about the influence of this generational disillusionment
and how it permeated so much of the art and culture developed after that bubble burst,
but what matters here is a single terrible event. In March of 1995, a series of coordinated attacks
were carried out across the Tokyo subway system, wherein packages of sarin gas wrapped in newspaper
were carefully placed inside the trains during rush hour and then punctured by umbrellas as the
culprits fled the scene. The attack in total killed 13 people and seriously injured a thousand more.
With it being only sheer luck the number wasn't higher, the event itself ended up sending all of
Japanese society into a panic. In the wake of the incident, the organization that had carried out
such a large-scale event was identified to have been a controversial religious group based near
Mount Fuji, one which had been growing ever since that very bubble burst. They were an
organization that society would describe as nothing but evil. They would make members
demonstrate loyalty by killing friends and family. They killed anyone who sought to criticize or
investigate them and killed their loved ones alongside them. They would take part in depraved
drug-fueled parties designed to free their souls. Their charismatic leader was a man who spoke of
the coming apocalypse and World War III, stockpiling weapons and developing bioterrorism plots in
secret. Their goal was to overthrow the Japanese government and bring about a war only they as the
chosen few would survive. Going so far as to mail a bomb to the governor of Tokyo and for the crimes
they committed, their highest ranking members were all sentenced to death. The organization's name
was Aum Shinrikyo. What made Aum Shinrikyo's crimes so important to Japanese society wasn't
the severity or horror of what they had done. Japan had over the last 15 years seen many terrible
crimes that struck at the darkness of the human heart. The devastating Yamaichi Yakuza war, the
prolonged 46-day murder of Junko Furuta, the depraved child killings of the Otaku murderer.
All these crimes were terrible, but they were still the practices of those outside. Organized
crimes, social outcasts, mysterious villains, they were all people society didn't have to recognize.
People they could easily reject. Aum Shinrikyo, however, was different. Its membership primarily
consisted of young people fresh out of high quality universities, the kinds which society
put its faith in to continue where the prior generation would leave off. Yet the disillusionment
of an entire generation instead made these people decide to become part of a collective of monsters.
Their leader and founder, Shoko Asahara, was a man whose doctrine positioned him as the
reincarnation of both Buddha and Christ, seeking to take upon himself all of the world's sins,
and he carried out all of his crimes believing he was bringing about salvation for the world
at large. No matter the monstrousness of their actions, that kind of conviction was certainly
something a lost generation could really rally behind, and was even willing to enact whatever
terrible acts were required of them. If it wasn't obvious, this is what Light is meant to represent
as a character. Not Lucifer, but a representation of the kind of inherent bitterness and disillusionment
which would drive someone who'd be considered the future of society to become a mass murderer.
As he himself states in the finale, Light's desire to become a quote,
God, comes not from a position of arrogance or lust for power, but from his own belief that
someone had to take up the role and make the world right. What Light wanted was for people to come to
live with Kira as a new normality, a persistent reminder that evil will bring with it a divine
punishment, and thus everyone who strays from that path of good will be met with righteous fury.
This is demonstrative in the kinds of people Light targets. Not criminals in a broad sense,
but people who act in a purposeful, calculated manner to harm others and worsen society.
He would even go as far as to object to Mikami killing ex-convicts who'd atoned for their sins.
It is not a coincidence, then, that all of the characters who displayed sympathy with Kira's
actions, Misa, Matsuda, Takada, and Mikami, all belong to the same young generation Light himself
spawned from. He is what they and all of youth want, to inherit a world where a savior is truly
making things better. And of course, Light is wrong. As Nier says, in a world where objective
good and evil don't exist, all his crimes are, in the end, the work of a murderer, not a savior.
Light's refusal to understand the weight of his own humanity, his own purity that leads him to
think he can actually become such an individual and that he would make the world better, is why
he even used the Death Note to begin with. Tellingly, what causes Light's own downfall
is in Mikami, his own desire for people to understand his worldview, which only ends up
working against him as Mikami ends up ruining everything because of his eagerness to aid Kira's
world. And when pushed into a corner, Light is left with no option but to deny Mikami as a person.
And when Light himself is left begging for someone to save him, Mikami denies him right back,
his delusion shattered by the truth of who his God really turned out to be, making him then realize
that Light ruined his life. And so, in a sense, Light's true death comes not from being outwitted
or his hubris, but from his own ideology being proven as wrong. And that true defeat comes not
from L or Near, it comes from the one person to represent everything, Tauta Matsuda.
Since his introduction at the start of this series, Matsuda's role has been that of the
comic relief. Rarely does a scene with him in focus pass where he's not made the idiot,
with characters shouting, Matsuda, you idiot, becoming a running gag in the story. He's treated
as a joke, humiliated, nearly killed a number of times, and overall, in general, disregarded.
This makes it all the more shocking and important, however, when it ends up being Matsuda who puts
down Light for good, riddling him full of holes as Light barks orders at him to kill Near and the
task force. Even as Light tries to convince him to stop, Matsuda doesn't, and has to be physically
pulled away by the rest of the task force before he kills Light outright. Why this scene is so
important is simple, and yet answers everything Death Note has been about. Unlike L and Near's
teammates who staunchly agree in Kira needing to be stopped, Matsuda stands squarely in a gray area.
As the young rookie police detective who got in on family connections, he understands that Kira
is a mass murderer, but can't help but sympathize with him as someone trying to make the world a
better place. While Aizawa in Part 2 represents how an older reader might feel, consistently horrified
at the lengths Light is going to to ensure his perfect world becomes a reality, Matsuda represents
the younger reader who suffers from that same disillusionment as Light did, and even knowing it
is wrong, has a part of themselves that wants it to be right. In having Matsuda reject Light so
thoroughly, however, Oba communicates effectively what he wants us as readers to think. Just as
Aum were not a divine society which would survive Armageddon but a psychotic terrorist cult,
Light is not a god delivering humanity on the right path, but an insane serial killer enforcing
his beliefs onto others. Matsuda doesn't have an unavenged family, childhood bullying complex, or
Light's quote, manhood, but the compulsion for a better world, and Light's world is one where that
isn't the truth. Because no one understood Light, because the vague idea of Kira is what some were
frightened of, some sought to exploit, some idealized, but none truly could see. Kira is death.
Kira is god. Kira is salvation. Kira is all of those things, because it is an idea which Light
Yagami embodies, and Misa Amane, Kiyomi Takeda, and Teru Mikami worship. But that idea is a child's
understanding of those things, because Light is too idealistic to understand that murder in the
name of justice is still murder. Death Note might not be a story of two ideals fighting, but it is
a story of how an idealist's view of justice is wrong. Light dies not out of hubris, but because
he ultimately cannot understand that anyone would truly see him as wrong. The final reveal of the
series, given in the very last rule page, is that there is no such thing as the afterlife. In a world
of Shinigami enacting death upon all, the entire world itself exists in a state of mere cosmic
nihilism, where one's very soul ceases to be the moment they die. Light knew this from the start of
his journey, but when faced with the reality, he devolved into fear, his pitiful begging reinforcing
his own hollowness as he dies miserable and terrified. Light Yagami, Kira, has been defeated,
his world destroyed, his personal legacy all but erased, he exists as a cautionary tale at best,
and a cruel joke at worst. Justice doesn't exist, life doesn't exist, and a better world doesn't
exist. So the question comes, what then? The answer comes in the manga's epilogue,
notably excluded from the anime. It depicts a world one year after Light's death where,
in spite of no one outside of Nier's team and the task force knowing the truth behind Light's
crimes, the absence of Kira has seen the world revert back to the way it used to be.
Matsuda, still emotionally scarred from the climax, discusses a theory he has on it,
and the possibility of Nier being himself a far more dubious character than once believed.
As pointed out, this isn't coming from a place of logic or truth, but because he wanted to
believe that Light, regardless of his crimes, was someone he still wanted to understand and
believe in. With the world having reverted back in the wake of Kira's death, can anything of what
they did be considered right? Ide, however, tells him that he has no doubt they were right,
because it doesn't matter if Nier was any more righteous than Light was, all that matters is
that they are alive right now. There is no justice in this world, but life still exists.
So, shouldn't that be enough? While far from perfect, Death Note's imperfections in many
ways highlights just how powerful a work it really is. It is a story which, in its conclusion,
tears apart every ideal it at one point presented, expressly proving the futility in trying to
understand the conflict as no different than someone who just wanted something they wanted
inside themselves to be true. We all wish for a savior, we all wish for someone who can right
the world's ills. Our desire for that delusion is disgusting, perhaps even disturbing, and someone
who would take that role on is certainly a madman, but it is, nevertheless, human. And as life goes
on, so too does this delusion. Our prayers for a better world, one which we live in, to the very
end. Thanks for watching.