1.8K Video Views·Feb 23, 2025
🔵 Try Epoch Times now: https://ept.ms/3Uu1JA5
At the 2025 Conservative Political Action Conference, Jan Jekielek interviewed Mark Chenoweth, President and Chief Legal Officer of the New Civil Liberties Alliance, to discuss the recent amicus brief he recently filed urging the Supreme Court to affirm the President’s absolute power to fire executive branch officials.
Chenoweth: “If you go back to the Constitution, all of the Executive power is given to the President. It's vested in him by Article Two, and then the appointments power is limited. It says for a lot of these positions, you have to have advice and consent of the Senate in order to make those appointments. But the removal power is not similarly limited. Madison said this shortly after the Constitution was drafted that this was deliberate.”
“For the first time in my lifetime, and maybe the first time in living memory, the administrative state is going to shrink over the next four years, and I think that's exciting, because I don't think the founders ever really intended for the executive branch to be as large and as populated as it is. They always understood and George Washington understood this, that the President couldn't handle all the executive power by himself. That he would have to delegate it to other people, but we've come to a point where a lot of this power is being delegated in unaccountable ways, and that's what President Trump has said: No more, we're not going to have this.”
CHAPTER TITLES
0:00:04 Introduction
0:00:26 President's Removal Power
0:02:01 Precedent and Administrative Stays
0:05:35 Multi-Member Agencies and Tenure Protections
0:07:03 Distinguishing Agency Types
0:09:35 Bureaucracy and Presidential Control
0:12:11 Challenging Administrative Overreach
0:14:59 Executive Order on Federal Bureaucracy
0:19:03 National Injunctions and Judicial Overreach
0:24:45 Davidson v. SEC and Fourth Amendment Violations
0:28:34 Final Thoughts on Presidential Actions
How the US got independent agencies: “Woodrow Wilson didn't trust the American people and he wanted to insulate these independent agencies and supposedly have rule by experts. And he was very open about this. He wanted rule by experts, not rule by elected officials. And so that's how we got these independent agencies. I think President Trump has more faith in democracy, more faith in the people, and he wants to get away from this so-called rule of experts.”
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
💛 Support us 👉https://donorbox.org/american-thought-leaders
-------------------------------------------------
© All Rights Reserved.
[Music]
Mark chenowth so good to have you back
on American thought leaders good to be
with you young so just a couple of days
ago the new civil liberties Alliance
filed an amicus brief urging the Supreme
Court to affirm the president's absolute
power to fire executive branch
officials why did you do this what's
going on well what's going on if I could
take those in reverse order is that uh
the president decided to fire the head
of the office of special counsel this is
a principal officer it's uh it's an
agency that's headed by one person and
the Supreme Court had decided just a few
years ago that those sorts of agencies
cannot have heads that are protected by
layers of tenure protection and so what
that means is the President should be
able to remove that person and they
should have to leave uh the president's
removal power is absolute for these
sorts of officers and we know that
because if you go back to the
Constitution all the executive power is
given to the president it's vested in
him by Article 2 and then the
appointments power is limited it says
for a lot of these positions you have to
have advice and consent of the senate in
order to make those appointments but the
removal power is not similarly limited
so that tells us that and and Madison
said this shortly after the Constitution
was uh was uh was drafted as well that
this was deliberate and in 1789 Congress
looked at this question as to whether
they should try statutorily to limit the
president's power and they decided uh
that they shouldn't and in fact the
Constitution really didn't permit them
to uh so the power this isn't something
new that President Trump came up with in
other words this is a longstanding
presidential power to remove that Mr
Dinger the head of the office of special
counsel uh is taking issue with well and
but there's also this issue in uh the
legal world of precedent so how how much
does that play in here so president
plays in that Supreme Court looked at
this almost this exact same question a
few years ago in a case called sa of law
the cfpb the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau because the cfpb like
the office of special counsel is headed
by a single uh principal officer and one
of the objections that was made to the
cfpb was that that head was not
accountable to the president that was
that person was surrounded by too many
layers of tenure protection and so the
Supreme Court looked at that and agreed
it decided yes this this is an
unconstitutional level of protection for
the head of the cfpb that precedent s
law is directly applicable here to the
Dinger case which is why it's so
surprising that the district court
issued a temporary restraining order in
this case and tried to re reinstate Mr
delinger to his previous position but
but what was the argument then I mean
you make it sound like there's no
argument I don't think there is much of
an argument to be to be honest honest
with you Yan but the the argument is
that well first of all the judge said
well I haven't had a chance to look at
the papers I want a chance to to look at
the papers um and and put an
administrative stay in place even before
the temporary restraining order was put
in place that was an oddity on its own I
know that's that people may not be
familiar with that term it's a little
bit in the weeds but administrative
stays are what judges often will issue
against other courts so if I rule
against you but I know you're going to
appeal I might put an administrative
stay in place of my own order until you
have a chance to appeal but this
administrative uh stay purported to run
against the president against a
different branch of government that's
not a thing it doesn't it doesn't exist
uh those sorts of administrative stays
so that was the first odity from from
Judge Jackson in this case the second
one was the temporary restraining order
that she issued ran against the
president now they pretended that it
didn't run against the president but
when this got to the DC Circuit Court of
Appeals which upheld it to of the three
judges on the panel there upheld judge
Jackson's decision but judge katus
dissented and said wait a minute the
removal power belongs to the president
you may want to pretend that you're
not restraining the president but you
are because he's the only one that has
this this power so that's the other
odity here in what the district judge
did in terms of you know what what's the
what's the
controversy there there certainly have
been a number of of uh principal
officers in the past who have sued
sometimes successfully for
damages in other words their salary when
they have been improperly discharged and
that's something that Mr delinger could
have done here he could have sued to try
to get the salary for the remainder of
his five-year term I'm not saying he
would have won that case either but it's
a different question than whether or not
he can be reinstated into the position
the president has removed him from I
think the president's removal power is
absolute and the court has already
decided that so it's really
surprising that a district judge in the
DC circuit would see it differently I
don't think the Supreme Court will see
it differently help me understand this
okay um in Trump 45 you know there was
Al James Sher came up or worked on this
idea of using schedule F to dismiss
certain bureaucratic
positions um you know there's there's a
whole uh uh strategy involved right to
try to develop this but you're telling
me uh that the president
right to dismiss people is absolute so
why does there need to principal
officers principal officers so people at
the top okay of these of these agencies
and the Supreme Court hasn't spoken to
the question yet recently what happens
if you have a multi-member agency so
these independent agencies that the
president has been trying to reestablish
accountability over uh like the
Securities and Exchange Commission or
the Federal Trade Commission or there's
a bunch of these multi M the I the
consumer product safety commission where
I used to be an attorney um as another
one of these agencies there's a
precedent from the 1930s called
Humphrey's executive where the Supreme
Court upheld these tenure protections
for these multi-member agencies and has
not Revisited that question since but
that is an open question the president
has fired uh the head of or not the head
but one of the Commissioners uh at the
nlrb I believe and so that question and
I believe that's uh
Miss Willcox has sued and so that
question is being teed up as well so
what if what if it's a multi-member
agency and you have these tenure
protections does the president have
absolute removal power there as well
we'll see I think the answer is yes but
we'll see what the what the Supreme
Court says there but for Mr Dinger I
don't I think the question's already
been asked and answered and what is the
distinction what do you mean by
multi-member agency this is a bit of for
most of us a kind of a bit of jargon we
don't probably understand like like
break down how what kind of different
agencies we're talking about here and
why it matters yeah so sorry for the
Beltway jargon we have uh uh we have a
number of federal alphabet soup agencies
that are called independent agencies or
commissions and they typically not
always but they typically have five
Commissioners who are at the heads of
these agencies a lot of times it by
Statute it's two people from the
president's party two people not from
the president's party so typically two
Republicans two Democrats and then the
the the fifth person often the chairman
is appointed by the president so you
these are typically three to2
majority of the president's party
commissions but they operate a little
bit outside of the
normal report up to the White House
structure president Trump's trying to
change that some of these commissions
and Commissioners are fighting back
against that they want more Independence
uh for these agencies uh but independent
agencies weren't part of the
Constitutional design so you know I
think that if the president wants to
undo that he's going to have a lot of
success getting that done cuz like
presumably it was a thought that it
would be another check on power right
presumably I think that's the idea that
it's really Congress trying to assert uh
its way into the executive branch
because uh my experience at at the cpsc
for example was and cpsc was what the
consumer product safety so they do all
the recalls U that that folks hear about
that at least the ones that aren't food
related uh
and so when I was a cpsc I started to
say the folks there would really call
the chairman of the oversight committee
that or the Appropriations subcommittee
that was in charge of the agency that's
who they sort of felt like they reported
to Congress really likes to exert
control over these independent agencies
and the White House historically hasn't
had as much and by the way that's what
woodro Wilson wanted he he didn't trust
democracy woodro Wilson didn't trust the
American people in in or for that matter
the presidency and he wanted to insulate
these independent agencies and
supposedly have rule by experts he was
very open about this he wanted rule by
experts not rued by elected officials
and so that's how we got these
independent agencies I think president
Trump has more faith in democracy more
faith in the people and he wants to get
away from this so-called rule of experts
we could talk about whether there's
really expertise there or not but these
are political actors at the top of the
of these agencies and they're making
political decisions and they need to be
accountable to the president if they're
going to do that and then so I see so
the distinction is the multi-member
agencies there's an more of an open
question but the ones that have the
single the single lead the principle the
president has absolute power but then
this bureaucracy below that's a
different question that is a different
question it's a great question I
actually think the multi-member ones uh
is is going to get teed up first because
there are some cases it'll take a look
at this humph executive case from the
1930s to see whether or not those tenure
protections what by the way what the
Supreme Court said back in the 1930s is
interesting they didn't say these tenure
protections are okay because it's okay
for these agencies to uh exert executive
power outside of the president's control
what they said was these independent
agencies are Quasi legislative and quasi
judicial and aren't really uh using
executive power so it's okay that the
president doesn't have control over them
well whether or not that was true in the
1930s
I don't know probably not but it's
certainly not true today these agencies
definitely uh have definitely use
executive power and and are U doing
things like bringing enforcement actions
against people and so forth that's
executive power that needs to be under
the president's uh control so I think
that's why when this Humphrey executive
case gets back to the Supreme Court that
the Supreme Court will take a very close
look at that and probably reverse that
that precedent that's what most at least
most conservative legal Scholars think
is likely to
happen you know this must be an amazing
time for you right because Nu Liberties
Alliance and CLA you know your specific
focus is challenging administrative
overreach right and so it seems like a
lot of what's actually happening in the
executive branch right now with what
president Trump is precisely that you
want to speak to that a little bit sure
it is a it's a it's a challenging time
it's a fun time some of the many cases
we brought against the Biden administ
are still pending uh against the new
Administration and so we've we've seen
in some of those cases the lawyers on
the other side come in and say well
we're not going to defend that position
anymore we think that decision's wrong
and so we're the dust has yet to settle
on what's going to happen with these
cases are they going to settle uh in
some of these cases the government has
other reasons why they think that that
our case should lose anyway and so those
will continue to be fought on maybe on
different grounds uh and so but what the
thing that's been different for us is we
agree with some of the things that the
Trump Administration is doing and so
we're filing admin we're filing amikas
briefs in support of the government
which is not something we were doing
very often for the last four years but
but at the same time there's some cases
which you think this new uh Department
of Justice is uh still going to be
fighting you on they they they
definitely still are fighting us on on
some fronts some of that I think is they
don't necessarily have their top person
in uh confirmed yet and so they're maybe
in a holding pattern trying to figure
out what their strategy is going to be
in a in a particular case and so forth
and and courts are pretty lenient about
giving them extensions of 30 60 90 days
to sort of wait and see what the
official position is going to be uh of
the new
leadership bottom line right just with
agencies they're all under the executive
branch is that like almost all of them I
mean you have like the architect of the
capital and the Library of Congress and
there's a few agencies that that are in
the legislative branch uh there uh you
know there's actually we have an
interesting case right now that involves
administrative power in the Judiciary
because the federal circuit court of
appeals the judicial Council of the
federal circuit has uh done what's being
called a stealth impeachment of one of
the judges on the federal circuit that's
not something that those judges have
done with their judicial power they've
done it with their administrative power
as an agency uh and we think that's
unlawful and that's why challenging it
but this this problem of administrative
power is not limited uh to the executive
branch to answer your question kind of a
remarkable area focused for a for for a
legal group it you know it it had been
an area that no one was focused on for a
long time and our founder Philip
hamburger who's a constitutional law
professor at Columbia University uh
diagnosed the problem and started
diagnosing some solutions and thought
that the best way to get these Solutions
implemented would be uh to have a public
interest legal organization that could
bring lawsuits against the government
and so we've been doing that for for
seven years seven plus years now um we
had seven victories at the Supreme Court
this last year including two cases that
were original litigation that we brought
from the ground up so you know it's it
it's proven to be a successful effort
and we're going to keep at it I think to
your point about how interesting a time
it is right now there are so many uh
balls in play right now if you will that
folks have taken a lot of things for
granted over many decades that maybe
they shouldn't have taken for granted
and president Trump isn't going to take
those things for granted he's made that
pretty clear and so that gives us the
opportunity to help the courts think
through and reshape uh the existing law
in a way that's in Better Conformity
with the
Constitution so have you read this
recent uh executive order about I think
it's commencing the reduction of the
federal bureaucracy we had a chance to
look at that one so I'm not so there's
so many of them I don't know if we're
talking about the same one or not I tend
to read most of them once but I haven't
necessarily read all of them um yeah
it it's basically executive order that
refers to un necessary government
entities well I know there's been some
effort on the part of the administration
to to reorganize uh the government and
essentially maybe combine some offices
or or reduce some offices and so forth
and whether or not
the administration is going to be able
to do that is going to depend a little
bit on was their statutory efforts that
went into place in order to bring those
things about or were these done by
executive order originally or or were
these done by uh cabinet level decisions
originally because you can un for sure
however they were done originally you
can undo them that way it's a tougher
question if they were statutory
originally and you want to undo them can
you do that without Congress maybe not
if what Congress did is unconstitutional
maybe you can but that's going to be a a
longer tougher fight what do you expect
is going to happen or I mean we we're 30
day 31 days in I think right now and a
lot of change a lot of balls in the air
as you're describing yeah what what do
you expect is going to happen like what
what what what do you expect from the
from this administrative state that has
grown so much over the years well I
expect that for the first time in uh my
life time and maybe the first time in
living memory that the administrative
state is going to shrink over the next
four years and I think that's exciting
because I think that the I don't think
the founders ever really intended for
the executive branch to
be as large and and as populated uh as
it is they always understood that the
and George Washington understood this
that the president couldn't handle all
the executive power by himself that he
would have to delegate it to other
people but we've come to a point and
this was part of the diagnosis of
Professor hamburger we've come to a
point where a lot of this power is being
delegated in unaccountable ways and
that's what president Trump has said no
more we're not going to have this and I
you know I actually think it was good
for him to be out of power for four
years Yan because it gave him time to
reflect and think about when I was in
office the first four years what
happened what what went wrong with the
control of the executive branch what
what things were going on that I didn't
want to have happen and were happening
anyway and I think he's come in loaded
for bear uh from day one and we've seen
that determined to assert control over
the Executive Branch he's not asserting
control over the legislative branch he's
not asserting control over the judicial
branch he's not doing things outside of
the president's Lane he's doing things
in foreign policy which are under his
control he's doing things with the
administrative state which supposed to
be under his control I think what we're
going to see over this next four years
assuming that the courts don't interfere
in ways that I think they shouldn't and
and probably won't is is a return to
presidential Authority and presidential
control over the entirety of the
executive branch and I think that's a
good thing I think accountable
government is a good thing I think
self-government is a good thing people
forget that these unelected
bureaucrats prevent us from having
self-government and the Constitution was
designed to give us self-government uh
and president Trump is trying to take
that back for us and I think the
American people uh are going to be happy
with the results but we'll see we'll see
what happens s it's possible they could
go too far I haven't seen very much
evidence of that yet uh but we'll see
there's been a lot of debate about
National injunctions especially if
they're filed in a you know very very
specific local place yeah um can you
just kind of expand on that for me where
where does that come from because it
seems to the uninitiated like myself it
seems odd but there's this saying right
that the most powerful person in the
United States can be a federal judge
right because they can stop a
presidential action with one of these
National
injunctions right and it's uh it's a
problem they I like to put these in two
different buckets because I think there
are two different kinds of of
injunctions that we
see if you're talking about a rule or
regulation that has come up from one of
these administrative
agencies when it reaches the federal
district court that may be the first
time that anybody who's a constitutional
officer has looked at that rule or
regulation and that making surprising to
people but when things go in the Federal
Register as regulations the president
hasn't signed off on them the cabinet
Secretary of that agency maybe has
signed off on it maybe not it depends on
what the sort of internal rules of that
agency are maybe the general counsel of
that agency or department is signed off
on it maybe not again it depends from
Department to department and so you have
these rules that come up they reach the
federal district court because someone
sues over them and that judge may be the
first person who's ever really asked the
question uh can the government do this
is this constit
and if the answer to that is no the
government can't do this this isn't
constitutional I think what Congress has
said in the administrative procedure Act
is for that limited class of rules and
regulations that came up from
administrative agencies federal district
judges do have the power to set those
aside which means Nationwide for
everyone what we've seen in some of
these other actions is where the
president has done something not with a
rule or regulation not really from the
administrative State Side of Things or
we've seen a statute that Congress has
passed and that statute has been
challenged in court and a federal
district judge has tried to set aside
that statute well now we're in a
different place there because if you
have a statute that Congress has passed
it's already been signed off on by one
entire branch of government the
president signed it into law it's been
signed off on by a second branch of
government so you already have two of
the three branches of government saying
this is constitutional this is okay for
one single district judge to then set
that aside Congress first of all has
never empowered District judges to do
that and it's not really consistent with
our constitutional scheme that's not to
say that those things can never be set
aside but it can't be one District Judge
who sets aside an AC of Congress and so
I just want to make that distinction if
I could between acts of Congress these
sort of administrative rules and
regulations that come along and
presidential actions I think when you're
talking about these presidential actions
or these acts of Congress district
judges should tread much more carefully
if you're talking about rules and
regulations from the bureaucrats then I
think Congress has said they want
federal district judges to be able to
Reign those in when they're
unconstitutional but but we're seeing it
happen right we are seeing it happen
this judge Jackson in this case we were
started off talking about uh you may not
think of it as a nationwide injunction
but in in an Essence she has said that
deler needs to stay in as the head of
the office of special counsel that that
has Nationwide effect that's for every
every employee who's affected by that
that role well so but but you're telling
me that that's that shouldn't be allowed
so so should allowed who who decides how
do we displ the district judges who
guards the Guardians like if if if that
indeed is the and who would decide
whether that you're right you
know so it needs to be the courts of
appeals in the first instance that would
discipline the district judges that
didn't happen here the DC circuit was
stacked by Harry bird a long time ago so
you know we we've got uh we've got that
problem um but we do have the Supreme
Court in place and that's you ask me do
I think that the Supreme Court will take
the case one of the reasons that I think
they'll take the case is we do have a
district judge who has exceeded her
mandate and so I think that the court in
its disciplinary function may see a need
for it to step in and say no no no no
that's not the way we do this uh if it
would be one thing if Mr dinger had sued
for damages we could have done this on a
less con you know less uh Fast Track
that would be one thing but this
business of trying to reinstate him with
a trro no no no no no that's not that's
not how we do this and I think the
Supreme Court needs to say that to uh to
maybe just turn the temperature down a
notch with some of these District judges
if the court doesn't take the case it
will be because the Court decides that
the temporary restraining order is so
brief so short
that the harm to the executive branch
isn't significant enough for it to worry
about I think that would be the wrong
decision because I think that would then
Empower District judges to put out
multiple temporary restraining orders
and even though arguably one might not
tie things up too much a whole bunch
really could tie things up and really
even one if you you think about it Yan
if you're if you're the president you're
trying to run the whole executive branch
and you've got somebody in charge the
principal officer in charge of one
agency who you've lost confidence in
don't want there don't think they're
going to do things consistent with your
policies and
preferences that's going to take a lot
of time and attention away because
you're going to have to keep an Eagle
Eye on that person they're going to be
running interference they're not going
to be doing what you want that's really
preventing you from taking care of that
the law be Faithfully executed which is
the job that Article 2 gives to the
president in our
constitution so as we finish up is there
one particular case out there you know
that is kind of like you know the
Chevron Defence case that was taken up
by the Supreme Court and of course um
you know reduced this administrative
power U the decision reduced is there
something out there right now that you
could point to that we should be
watching yeah I'll I'll give you a I'll
give you a case to watch it's called
Davidson V SEC and it's down in Texas
it'll come up through the fifth circuit
uh what happened is the Securities and
Exchange Commission and uh and fenra got
together and created a massive database
called the Consolidated audit Trail and
it contains the stock transaction
information for every single American in
one giant database Congress never
approved this Congress never funded this
you may Wonder well how does it get
funded if Congress doesn't fund it well
fenra oversees these broker dealers and
they have charged the broker dealers who
then charge your stock account by the
way so you're paying for it just not
through taxes in a way that Congress
user fees user fees essentially but not
in a way that Congress is ever
authorized so you have this Rogue agency
engaged in Rogue taxation power and then
violating your Fourth Amendment rights
by putting all of your personal
information in a giant database you
haven't committed a crime you haven't
done anything that creates suspicion
that the government should be looking
into your stock transactions but now it
has access to every single stock
transaction you've engaged in I think
it's a huge bill bar has said that it's
a massive violation of of the Fourth
Amendment we agree with him and so
that's that's something that ncla has
been working very hard to correct I hope
that Paul Atkins the incoming chairman
of the Securities and Exchange
Commission will recognize the heir of
the agency's ways he was on the
commission back during the Bush
Administration before this thing ever
got off the ground and he remembers what
it used to be like and so he would be a
perfectly good person to say wait a
minute what are you guys doing now no no
no that's not how we do things let's go
back to the the lawful way of doing this
uh if not we're prepared to take that
case all the way up to the Supreme Court
because we think that the it's not just
the vi the violation of the Fourth
Amendment which is bad it's also this
this uh aggregation of Power by the SEC
that the amount of money they're raising
from this is more than the sec's annual
budget so they've more than doubled
their effective budget through this
mechanism you can't have agencies going
out there
and arting that much power to themselves
uh in the way that the SEC has done here
and I think the Supreme Court will knock
it down if it isn't knocked down before
it gets there well and and at a time
where all sorts of agencies are being
hacked for information it presents you
know particularly poignant issue I think
we've been told by cyber Security
Experts that this is a horrendously bad
idea and it you know it didn't exist
before before you know if you if you did
some stock trades with Fidelity you
might have some information in their
databases or you did some with Schwab
they might be over there you did some
with you know with whoever else they
might be with them but now it's all
Consolidated in one place you're just
creating a giant Target for hackers and
it's a it's a terrible idea and by the
way guess who wants liability protection
in the event that a hack occurs the
Consolidated Auto Trail folks they want
liability protection well why because
they know that eventually it's not a
matter of if it's a matter of when it's
going to be hacked because they've set
up a disastrous uh program but they
think it's easier for them
to and it probably is easier for them to
you know sort of uh look around this
database and try to find a suspicious
activity than it would be to operate the
old way where you had to have the
suspicion before you started the
investigation uh right but again major
Fourth Amendment problem but also major
structural problem finra is this sub
agency that it's been given a lot of
power by the SEC but not by Congress we
we'll be watching that a final thought
as we finish a final thought would be
that don't let the pace of action by the
president necessarily make you think
that what's happening is unored you have
to look at each one of these actions by
themselves and if each one of them
passes constitutional muster then what
he's doing is fine there's no rule
against the president being active being
uh you know doing a lot of things we saw
in the first 100 days of the Biden
Administration a whole lot of things
done but my organization was drinking
from a fire hose at that time because
most of the things that were coming out
were unlawful or unconstitutional and so
we were just like which you know it was
a which thing do we go
after the things that we've seen coming
out so far by and large from this
Administration are things where that I
think fall into three buckets either he
knows that there's a precedent against
him but he wants to test that precedent
so he's firing someone in order to test
that precedent that's okay that happens
all the time I mean that's how Rosa
Parks tested the Civil Rights brought
the Civil Rights Revolution about right
by testing a law on on buses that's
that's traditional way of testing things
so that's one bucket another bucket is
things that he knows that he's right
about and he's fighting over so the
cfpb we know that agency head can't have
protection similarly Mr Dinger at the
office of special counsel can't have
protection president Trump knows that he
fired him he's going to defend that
decision that's that's a perfectly
legitimate bucket and then the third
bucket is maybe you might call them
maybe gray area items where look can he
fire someone lower down can he um you
know can he exert some other sort of
executive power to try to Reign
something in when Congress has said
something else I think those are open
questions I think he'll probably win
some of those cases I think he'll
probably lose some of those cases but
overall the effect is going to be less
administrative power more accountability
to the president uh for the rest of the
executive branch well Mark chenowth it's
such a pleasure to have you on again
great to be with you y thank you
[Music]