SHANGHAI, LES MEILLEURS ÉLÈVES DU MONDE

EDUCATION AROUND THE WORLD
32 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Ganquan Public School, in the center of Shanghai.
As every Tuesday, a German class for its first year Chinese students,
pulled by four pins.
Here, no teacher.
It's Hantao, a 13-year-old student, who is in charge.
Please take your manual.
A role he takes very seriously.
Page 28.
The plan, the plans, one, two, three.
For 30 minutes, the student brings his classmates to the baguette.
It seems incredible.
Everyone is working seriously,
while no adult is supervising them.
It's only half an hour later
that the teacher, Mr. Lui, arrives in class.
Stop and get up.
In total, he will only speak for about 20 minutes.
This unusual teaching method in France
has become a classic in Shanghai.
Its goal?
To teach the students the main value of Chinese education,
discipline, and especially self-discipline.
Since primary school,
they have to train in all areas of discipline,
because it is very important for studies.
And if they don't respect it,
they will learn less quickly.
And it's a shame.
A method based on obedience that bears fruit.
According to the International Programme for Evaluation of Students,
the PISA,
Shanghai's students would be the best in the world today,
far from the French.
Like Antao,
his students all run towards success.
Do you like this course?
I love it, but I have to go to work.
Megalopolis of more than 23 million inhabitants,
Shanghai has become the economic capital of China
and a showcase of the country's ambitions.
Public or private,
here schools have one goal,
to become the best in the world.
In the country of Confucius,
where the sense of duty and effort are omnipresent,
what are the methods they use to achieve this?
What does the daily life of these students look like
who hope to conquer universities around the world?
A public high school in the east of Shanghai.
The environment seems idyllic,
with its alleys in the name of illustrious scholars
and its zen garden.
Yet the life of a student here is a fighter's journey.
Now it's 7.05am.
Is it going to be a long day?
Oh yes, it's going to be a long day.
Mingyang, 17, is a first-year student,
of modest origin.
This morning, the young girl and her 40 classmates
take five different classes.
The classrooms are equipped with high-tech equipment.
The rhythm is steady, without real pauses.
In more than five hours,
the only exit that will be granted to Mingyang
will bring the students' homework to one of his teachers.
I only have five minutes before the next class.
The only moment of relaxation,
the gymnastics of the eyes.
Two minutes of massage in the middle of the morning
to keep the pace.
At noon, the students can finally leave their classroom.
Can you run?
But there's no question of resting.
Why are you running?
If you want delicious dishes, you have to run.
Why? Aren't there enough?
No, they're limited.
OK, OK, let's run.
Quickly, Mingyang gets his favorite dish.
However, she won't have time to taste it.
Like her classmates,
the young girl swallows her meal in 15 minutes.
The cause, the homework.
The education system of Shanghai
is based on repetition and exercises.
Very demanding with the students,
the teachers impose a large amount of it,
at least three hours a day.
And there's still no one to supervise them.
The teenagers have to be independent.
During the weekdays,
there's absolutely no question.
You have to work.
You don't have the right object.
You have to work
from the moment you wake up
to the moment you sleep.
Since I want to go to one of the best universities,
if I don't work as much, it's impossible.
In fact, it's a competition,
a fierce competition.
5 p.m.,
class is over for Mingyang.
However, the marathon day is far from over.
The teenager has only a short moment of free time
before starting her compulsory study hours.
She takes the opportunity to go to the English Corner.
Hi, Lisa.
Hi, David.
Hi.
This place is run by David,
a professor from England.
Here, have some tea if you want.
In this place,
students can relax and talk to each other,
provided they speak English.
Thanks to him,
they all speak this language very well.
But to come here,
the students had to make a choice.
At least you always have time to come to the English Corner.
Yes, but I don't have dinner.
Me neither.
This is my dinner.
In this position for a few years,
the professor is admiring of his students.
I think they work very hard,
and I'm quite impressed with that.
And the mathematics they learn here
are of a very high level.
We had students from Spain
who came here to see how they study,
and here they learn what we learn at the university.
And when we ask him
how the Western students would react to this treatment,
his answer is clear.
I think they would go on strike,
or they would rebel.
I don't think they would do that.
I don't know.
I don't speak French,
but I don't think the Western students
would be able to stand it for very long.
Ming-Yang, she's holding out.
After 11 hours of work,
she's now going to do her 3 hours of compulsory study,
until 9pm.
Good evening.
To have the right to lead this life,
many high school students have had to make many sacrifices.
Several hundred of them
live apart from their families during the week,
and sleep in the school's boarding house.
But for the institution,
this is still not enough.
They don't hesitate to intervene in their private lives.
Love, a relationship between a boy and a girl,
is forbidden.
Forbidden?
Yes, it's forbidden.
If the relationship is announced,
the school will put an end to it.
It will stop it.
We are stuck in a cage,
like birds.
Yet, despite this lack of freedom,
high school students justify this system.
The whole country is more important than an individual.
In the future, our situation will improve.
We will have more wealth and power.
More freedom.
We will have built the country we hope for.
This is why we must make efforts now.
We support you.
Patriotism before personal happiness.
And the hope that the future will be better.
What happened?
They turned off the light.
Time is up.
Like every night at 10 p.m.,
the lights go out.
Before a new day of 14 hours of work.
From an early age,
children in Shanghai must learn to work,
not for themselves,
but especially for the motherland.
And this system owes nothing to chance.
One of the men who invented it about 30 years ago
is Mr. Wang.
Hello.
Welcome.
We haven't seen you in a long time.
Yes, it's been a long time.
In this school, he is welcomed by the principal.
For him, the education of young Chinese
is above all a way to make his country shine
and responds to a patriotic ideal.
For this, he chose to make a good contribution
to mathematics and science,
built in true cult.
Do you like science?
Yes, we like it.
Why do you like it?
Because it's fun.
Science allows you to be civilized,
to be civilized.
If you master science, you can change everything.
And don't forget that science will lead you everywhere.
In a world where new technologies reign,
Shanghai has therefore chosen to bet on science.
Education is designed as a tool of power
and economic development for the country.
We have managed to integrate science
into the minds of every child
so that the motherland becomes stronger.
Yes, I agree.
And it's like that in all public schools in the city.
But in Shanghai, there is not just one educational system.
In recent years, in the country of communism,
hundreds of private schools have opened their doors,
taking advantage of the economic boom.
They also aim for excellence, but with other values.
The personal success of children is highlighted
and also that of families,
ready to invest a lot of money to achieve it.
A music school in the city center.
Here is a promise,
to transform children into little Mozart.
Hello, hello everyone.
This morning, 3-year-old Jingxuan, Yibei and Xiaoyu
start their music lessons with the exuberant Yingying.
These children have been following these music lessons for a year.
In Shanghai, there is no school before elementary school.
Between the ages of 3 and 6,
the parents take care of their children's education.
For them, these lessons are a way to prepare them for school.
I think this course is very useful.
This teacher, in addition to teaching them music,
also teaches them things related to discipline.
And I think it is very important for the future of the school.
Ready to do everything to promote their success,
they already submit them to an intensive program,
without ever daring to admit it.
This is my daughter who wants it.
By the way, she has a full program.
She has plastic art lessons,
drawing lessons,
music lessons,
traditional painting lessons.
And recently, she also wanted to learn how to swim.
She chose all this.
Oh, it's over, what should I do?
Thank you, everyone.
Throughout their school life,
extra-school lessons have become an obligation for young Shanghainese.
From elementary school, the weekend,
three quarters of the students participate in support classes
in often tiny spaces,
barely three square meters,
where they meet with their teacher.
With all this work,
the young people still have some free time.
When was the last time you went out with your friends?
It's been years.
It was during the winter holidays.
Yes!
Have you already forgotten?
At the beginning of the holidays.
During the winter holidays,
it was supposed to be mid-February.
For me, it was yesterday.
We went to see the movie Cinderella.
And before that?
I did six hours of German before.
Shanghai manages to attract the best students,
but this performance has a cost.
It's human.
As the authorities recognized in 2014,
the suicide of students would be the first cause of death
in the next 15-24 years.
A taboo among these young people,
who are still aware of the excesses of the system.
What would you say to French students?
Above all, the French don't come to China.
And yet, in Shanghai,
there are already a lot of young French people.
More than 12,000 citizens live today in East Paris.
And with all these expatriates,
from all over the world,
the educational system is starting to evolve.
A new pedagogy emerges,
inspired by Western methods,
very far from the traditional Chinese model.
Garance, 6 years old,
is one of the students who take advantage of this new education.
His father, Olivier, has been living here for 11 years.
Entrepreneur, he settled in Shanghai
to take advantage of the opportunities of this city,
constantly changing.
For his daughter, he chose an alternative school,
Waike Pao.
Founded in 2007,
this private school claims to bring together
the best of Chinese and Anglo-Saxon education,
with a credo,
children's development.
A small revolution for China.
Relaxing spaces,
leisure time,
a pedagogy that attracts expatriates,
but also Chinese,
who represent 60% of the students.
An excellence at a high price,
1500 euros per month.
This morning, Chinese class for Garance.
The program is the same as in public schools,
but with only 20 students per class,
the teacher was able to put in place
a radically different teaching method.
At this table, they learn Chinese as a second language,
so they need more help in their Chinese learning.
But at these other tables,
Chinese is their mother tongue,
so the level is higher.
They are given different exercises,
projects to do,
but to learn the same thing.
We have an education system centered on students,
we consider their needs.
This is very important.
We don't just teach the school curriculum,
but we also change the curriculum
to satisfy the specificity of the school and the children.
And the technique works.
Garance, registered since the beginning of the year,
is already polyglot.
What language do you speak?
French, English, Chinese, Chinese and English.
This public school has become a model in Shanghai.
As a result,
Wai Kepao crumbles under the demands.
And behind its image of an open and tolerant school,
the institution is setting up a pitiless competition
to recruit its students,
as Olivier discovered.
There was a real competition.
It's incredible, but it was done in a month.
It's complicated.
Math tests, English tests, Chinese tests,
an intelligence test, oral tests,
even parent interviews.
Two parents with a school teacher
giving an interview about their commitment,
their ability to share with the community
within the school.
It's very selective.
In Shanghai,
Western education,
more respectful of the personality of the students,
begins to seduce the Chinese.
And some schools go even further.
They offer training
to allow Chinese students
to acquire the best foreign universities.
Shanghai Guanghua Private High School.
Ben, 17, is a young failure.
Queen.
I beat you again.
Since the start,
he has integrated this private high school
into a new genre.
Averaging 17,000 euros per year,
this school teaches English school programs
in place of the Chinese program.
The goal is to train students
in the Western education system
to allow them to enter and excel
in the best universities in the world,
like Harvard or Yale.
To achieve this,
the school employs Western teachers.
They make the students discover
non-existent subjects in the Chinese public system,
such as the practical work of chemistry.
A cultural shock.
I got lucky.
I got a pink result,
just like what was asked for.
You look happy.
Yes, it's the first time
I've succeeded in this experiment.
If he is committed to this method change,
it's to prepare for the future.
It's really preparing me
for my adventure in the United States.
That's what the American universities require.
You have to be independent
and have a critical view of what you read
and the knowledge you learn.
And I think that's a quality
that all students should have.
Thanks to this teaching,
Ben should be able to enter
the prestigious MIT in Boston.
He has been studying in this institution
and his dream since he was 11 years old.
There, he will be able to be part
of the elite of computer engineers.
But this is not the only reason
that pushes him to want to expatriate.
In China, some of the voices are censored
and you can't hear them.
I want to hear them
because I want to know
what the world is really like.
I know that it doesn't correspond
to what we watch on TV or on the radio here.
And I don't want to be told
what the world is like.
I want to discover it myself.
This desire to explore the world,
Ben gets it from his father,
Jianping, who studied in the United States
before coming back to Shanghai.
He and his wife have modest incomes
and yet they did not hesitate
to offer this private school,
which is very expensive,
We have to pay high school fees
and that has an influence on our lives.
For example, I don't go like my friends
or my co-workers to travel regularly,
to buy a nice car
or to buy luxury goods.
In addition, these are not the things I want.
I can eat a little less
and travel little,
but I think the most important thing
is the education of my son.
Established in 1979,
the policy of the only child
has reinforced the spirit of sacrifice
of Chinese parents.
To pursue his dream
and that of his parents,
Ben goes to an event
organized by American universities
to recruit students from the city.
But unlike other students,
he has devised a strategy
to stand out.
He does not come here to apply,
but on the contrary,
to work as a translator
for one of these universities.
When is the recruitment?
When?
It depends on the program.
Members of the integration commission
think it is very important
to have a lot of volunteer experience.
For a few years,
these events have become frequent in Shanghai.
The reputation of the students
and that of the parents,
ready for all sacrifices,
attracts these schools
at high tuition fees,
close to 40,000 euros per year.
But another reason explains their presence.
China has an important role
in business with the United States,
and therefore American students
must know the Chinese better
to better understand their culture
and so that in the future
we can do better business together.
The reputation of Shanghai students
has allowed the city to shine
all over the world.
We find them today
on the benches of the best schools,
as in France, at Polytechnique.
In the amphitheater,
the future elite of hexagonal engineers.
What do I get?
I get D2F into alpha 2T
into alpha prime 2T.
Among them, Yixin,
a Shanghainese.
Arrived in France,
she entered this great school
without difficulty after a preparatory class.
A success that did not surprise
the young girl.
When I arrived in France,
I could see that I had made a lot of progress
compared to my French friends
thanks to my secondary studies in Shanghai.
A small example
on trigonometric formulas.
We did it in high school
while we were preparing.
French students
don't know how to do it
and they found it very difficult
to find them.
It's really a mountain for them
to know all these formulas
while for us
it was really easy.
An undeniable superiority
in mathematics.
However,
she quickly realizes that the education
she received in Chinese public education
has its shortcomings.
In Shanghai,
I didn't study history at all
because
in high school,
we don't have time
to study history
so we spent all our time
working in the scientific field.
So when I arrived in France,
everyone around me
knew a lot of things
about history,
about the world,
about politics,
but I didn't know anything.
I felt like I was included
among my French friends.
Thanks to her studies
at Polytechnique,
Yixin also discovered the joys
of French student life
such as relaxing moments
with friends on campus
or associative activities.
An enriching experience
that changed her vision of the future.
I would like to stay in France
or go to another country
and not go back to China.
If I go back to China,
I will have a gap
with Chinese culture
because
in France,
I experienced so many things
that changed me so much
that I don't have the same
state of mind
as when I was in China.
Pure product of patriotic
Chinese education,
Yixin seems to have given in
to the charm of French art of living.
Evidence that despite
her flaws,
the French educational system
still has some advantages.
