Surviving The Island - Expedition Medicine House Calls - Dr Gill
In 2019 I ended up on Bear Grylls The Island, in many ways accidentally. These are some of the medical issues encountered whilst there on essentially 5 weeks protected expedition medicine
We encountered scorpions, dehydration, starvation, cellulitis, death apples, and more.
This particular video is a recording of UHCW's Grand Round, and is included here for interest
*********
All images remain copyright of their respective owners. Elements of these discussions will have been changed to preserve confidentiality and maintain flow.
hello my name's james gill i'm one of
the gps at um
warwick medical school and just recently
i was asked to do a presentation
at university hospital coverage and
warwickshire's
grand round for those of you that don't
know grant round is basically
a weekly meeting of the medical
community of a hospital
it's not compulsory and it's basically a
chance for
people to talk about their research
perhaps raise
interesting cases or talk about stories
outside necessarily the mainstream of
their work but things that may enthuse
that uh medical body
so dr andrew chaisen who heads the
ground round
recently had a space on
his calendar for want of a better phrase
and asked if i'd be willing to give
um a brief talk about the time um i
spent on the island
uh with the bear grylls channel 4 team
so i know a lot of people here have
been aware that i did that show a while
ago
and i thought that since this was
recorded on teams
in the lecture theatre it may be
interesting for some of you
who'd like to know a little bit more
behind the scenes
and maybe some of the um medical
intrigues
that we found wilma over there so i hope
this is of interest to you
and uh take care jerry
this is abby alcatra and i'm very
pleased to
welcome you to this week's um
medical grand round being held in the um
lecture theater here in the uh csb at
university hospital commentary so
without further ado i'm going to hand
over to
james who's
got a talk with a very enigmatic title
and over to you
thank you doctor rotation um so yeah so
i kind of want to highlight that here
um i'm i'm here as a shoeing so expect a
a level
slightly below that of the usual grand
round
um and i'm desperately hoping he's not
here in the lecture theater today and
i'm hoping he's not watching on teams
because you know
if prof imrae is here that's slightly
problematic for me because he's one of
the reasons that i've kind of done this
craziness you know with
his expeditions to the himalayas and
everest etc so
this is not at that level at all this is
essentially me just
telling a story and hopefully it'll be
interesting and we'll maybe
bring in a couple of bits perhaps even
some dermatology for doctor illustration
so desert island house calls um or
perhaps the
holiday from hell um
so when i say a holiday from hell i
literally mean it
here your other holiday makers if you
will are going to experience
bites burns cellulitis
immersion or paddy foot dehydration
starvation and when they get back off
the airplane
refeeding syndrome so definitely fun for
the whole family
and just in case you see an advert for
your travel agent edward grylls
don't accept his offers it's not worth
it
so with that in mind um i was bored for
want a better reason
one day and uh my medical school my
my medical school clinical partner who
i'm still very good friends with
um he said hey you're not doing anything
we've seen that bear grylls
the islands are looking for a doctor to
support them
i thought hey give it a go so i applied
and i was given the role of uh the
doctor looking after the teams
who would be on the island now i've got
to face the radio so i was very happy
to be behind camera and um on
the medical island a little way away
looking after the teams
and as part of that we were you know
very pleased to go down to london and
you know i got a week or so
intensive training on expedition
medicine
for you know a gp if you will um and
that was
really quite fascinating um and was not
what i
expected to end up doing
um you see as part of even myself
just on the medical island we all needed
a full medical so
ecg baseline blood now i know when we
teach at the medical school
we don't like baseline blood baseline
blood is not a good
line however if you're going to take a
group of people
and you're going to physically assault
them there's no other
way of describing it you need to have
where were they before we went off
and where are they when they came back
so we got the baseline bloods
some body metrics so we're talking about
how much fat we've got which i'll come
to in a moment
a dental check because realistically you
don't want a crown or a filling coming
off
when you're in the middle of nowhere a
fitness test
and a pregnancy test because we don't
want any issues with that
in remote situations um and
all this was you know run through um the
medical staff
there but they really highlighted
that most of the information that we
have about expedition medicine
is based on opinion and best practice
there's not a lot of
evidence to support it and that's really
important
when you're in a remote inaccessible
environment
that you need to be able to both think
on your feet and
react independently and that
inaccessible was particularly important
for the conversation we were having with
the doctor who is going to be in front
of camera
with the teams um because if there was a
problem
it would be a good 15 20 minutes for us
to come over
from the medical island to sort out or
help with whatever was going on
so the team on the ground needed to be
able to react
and be essentially stabilized somebody
whilst um
the cavalry was coming in and
unfortunately
um the doctor in front of camera
had a problem with their ecg and they
also failed their fitness
test and i got a very strange telephone
call
asking do i like fresh double cream
um the reason being is i was given two
weeks
to bulk up as fast as i could because i
was suddenly in front of camera
so i gone from living in a hammock scuba
diving
spear fishing and enjoying life
to having five weeks on a desert island
where i'd have to hunt for my own food
so yes i was advised consume as much
double cream as you can
over those two weeks to try and
literally put some fat on me
there's not a lot of me to disappear and
well this was me uh in my thunderbirds
outfit
uh ready to go on the island and i'm
just going to draw your attention to
these
getups that we're wearing okay these are
our
24-hour microphones that were waterproof
and those should be honest at all times
they also had a gps tracker so if we
fell down a ravine
they'd know where we were going um and
those will become a a dermatological
issue shortly
um we did survive obviously uh this is
sort of our slightly grubbiness
but uh we're going to show you how we
got from there
to here and the 14 kilos of weight are
lost in doing it
not an advised diet so
a bit of medicine for you one of the
things that we got taught
was the rule of threes and this is sort
of preparing your mind for going on an
expedition
you can do three minutes without air i
mean i don't know about you but i i
struggle to hold my breath for more than
about
two but three we're kind of making a
mnemonic thing here
three minutes without air you can do
three hours without
shelter in a harsh environment to which
i say
ha if you're in a typhoon and you're
holding a tarpaulin
over your fire because without the fire
you're not going to be able to make
fresh water the following day
you're going to keep holding for more
than three hours i think the worst we
did was six
and i was ready to quit at that point
you can do three days without water
the worst we did was two days not
fun let me tell you that three weeks
without food
unpleasant and three months without
social contact
thankfully it wasn't an issue for us but
with covert that everybody's been
experiencing
i know that some people have had worse
than that so you know we
these things come round circles so
here's the island that we had
and we were taught because we knew we
were in the panamanian region
that um the the currents would bring
sand in on the west coast of the island
and we'd be landing presumably on the
east
so we'd need to get across the island to
the beaches where it's essentially more
habitable we can find food we can fish
we would be able to live and hopefully
not have any medical problems
so because this was a tv show the guy's
gonna stack the deck against you
and what they do is they um so this this
is us i think i've
probably just gone off the boat here um
they drop you off
about 4 30 in the evening
knowing that the sun will set by about
6 30 at the equator and you've got to
swim in
with all your camera gear uh with all of
the clothes and not that you've had a
lot
i might add you've got one change of
clothes with you and only one pair of
shoes
you swim in and that very quickly
brought us to our first
medical problem so by having us land
at 4 30 sun's down at 6 30
you are going to
deplore that first night not fun
okay now it's it's one of the team
um you know we're essentially cut down a
few trees sleeping on the forest floor
it's not great
somebody screams because they've been
bitten
and they swear blind they were bitten by
a particular insect
so we're going to medical school swerve
here what is the one thing
that when we're in a finals examination
in terms of causes of pancreatitis
we do not want to hear students talking
about
this doesn't work on teams i can't get
reaction so scorpion then
absolutely if someone says that in the
finals examination scorpion venom
we're not going to take that as a very
good answer however
when you're in south america it's quite
a reasonable worry
um and there are six scorpions families
but there is only one that is toxic and
that is the
titus cirrulatus sorry i didn't do latin
and guess where that is found
south america now by luck
we'd actually ended up with a second
medic because of issues with
uh there's the timing on the team um but
she was there as a contestant
more than the the uh the medic per se
so we had a good chat now we couldn't
see whatever had been
and this particular scorpion is
relatively yellow
in coloration we knew that uh there were
things on the island there because we'd
have a briefing
um now this venomous
dangerous pancreatitis causing scorpion
will also
cause um salivation crying
really you get stunvious thought and you
cry i'm not sure that's the venom
uh runny noses there's our acute
pancreatitis
pulmonary edema as well if you leave it
long enough
mi heart failure shock
arrhythmias hypertension peptic ulcers
and hyperkalemia
so we're getting ourselves in a bit of a
tizzy at this point that we've been on
the island less than 24 hours
and somebody's in a mess thankfully
we did have an emergency radio they
weren't pleased to hear from us
uh within the first 12 hours but we got
on the blower and said
hey we've actually got someone who
swears that's been stung by a scorpion
we haven't seen it when we were told
south america type region given when you
were in panama
what's the likelihood that we need to
get her medevac all ready
thankfully thankfully we were told
that this is only in brazil and
venezuela
and that we weren't going to have an
issue with this scorpion and that it
should
only cause localized pain swelling
hyperine hyperemia parasthesia and pile
erection
ergo she'd be fine to stay on the island
we've spoken to the specialists we've
discussed if she wants a medivac because
she can't come back on if so
she opted to stay however
we weren't happy with this so we had to
change how we continued on our life for
the next five weeks
i might involve pajamas well i say
pajamas
we then elected to wear all of our
waterproof clothing when we went to bed
at night
and you can just about see the uh the
microphones
we've got waterproof tops waterproof
bottoms we've got our socks on that
we're putting on our hands
and we're also putting our boots on our
feet so we had an option of get bitten
or have a boil in the bag neither are
good
as we should come to so here's our
island we've got dumped off here
we've arrived here and we're sleeping on
forest law
we know roughly which way from the sun
we've not got watches or anything like
that we're having to work out north east
south west ourselves
we know that we need to head uh over
towards the west coast
so we're kind of just walking that way
we have no maps there is
no help we have not seen the island
beforehand now i'm not sure if we can
see here but this
this x is now a flatter bit of ground
um which you think hey that looks fine
you should be able to wander over that
it's a park
no that would be far too easy it was a
mangrove swamp
so we're traipsing through a mangrove
swamp and you see we've got
our water of boxes with
medicines in them because people have
medical problems when they went to the
island we've got
my medical kit in one bag we've got
the cameras which we will also come to
in a bit
the batteries and our own stuff and two
jerry cans
with water so we're all right at the
moment we can still drink
but we're getting through this and we
are drenched
okay you're in the woods you're in the
forest you're drenched in sweat you're
in the
uh you're in the mangrove sauce you
drench from sweat you are not getting
dry
and after about 24
20 28 hours on the island we made it
to the coast we got to the other side so
we stripped off ran
into the water it was brilliant and
first time we had a wash so
there we are having a nice wash the salt
water seems to sting
a little bit more than i expected and
you remember this thing that we had to
wear
this this little piece of evil
as i'm walking through the jungle um
after swimming from the boat so i'm in
wet boxes i'm in wet trekking trousers
i've got a
wet waterproof microphone on me um
this thing is rubbing to and fro to and
fro and it's sitting
there and we get ourselves clean you
know we're all
uh we're all you know um down to our
boxes and i go like that hands up my
backside
and round and i come away with a palms
worth of
skin that little bit of irritation that
i've gotten
was because this thing had caused a
massive ulcer there because i hadn't
been dry
for more than 24 hours now i don't know
whether or not the tv
crew thought that we were going to be a
special needs group or not however
it turned out that one of the other
people in the team in a previous life
had been a plastics nurse
i mean you cannot get much luckier than
this so
i've got this very nice lady laura
looking after my backside
when i'm supposed to be the one looking
after people and
thankfully we had a relatively
comprehensive medical care so i'm
getting
occlusive waterproof dressings changed
twice daily iodine scrubs
not fun um things did worse in a little
bit so then we're putting topical
chloramphenicol
and i'm having clarithromycin and we do
have to touch in with the production
team just to say what's going on
and they're having conversations whether
or not because of the potential scarring
here they're going to medivac
the doctor thankfully things settled
after a week
and i stayed on the island without a
major but
everything on this island is going to
try and get you
so we have to look for food and you get
to the beach
it looks beautiful i mean this is the
kind of thing people pay a lot of money
to go and
stay in a tiki hut for and along the
beach through these little apples oh and
they look so tasty don't they
are they're grills because he's very
good at pr has a name for them
a little death apple they're not very
nice these things
are uh matchanil and they tend to be
found in coastal regions
um and this little death apple because
it's one of the most toxic
trees in the world um and
the sap the flesh of the apple
and the moisture on the leaves contains
fall
and basically this stuff will take the
paint off
cars so if you've just
arrived on an island and you haven't
spent a huge amount of time paying
attention to the
floor around you and it starts to rain
and you think
i'm going to stand under a tree this
seems to be very reasonable
the sap and the will get in the water
and it'll drip on you and your friends
and it will cause
severe contact dermatitis to your skin
this island wants to harm you this is
not a pleasant place
so that's one of the things that we've
got to deal with now
let's look at the environment in which
we're going to and i use the phrase
tenuously here live okay so
on this area you have the jungle as an
option to live in you can live in the
actual uh the shoreline both of these
are good there's lots of stuff to eat
they're relatively safe however
the transition zone is bad news you're
getting the worst of all worlds
you're getting all the critters from the
forest you're getting all the critters
from the sea
you're getting all the bug and you get
all the um
infections from sea and land that's not
the place to live
now again it's a tv show so
they've stacked the deck of the people
you're going to be with
um and that means they've chosen some
people who think not necessarily are but
think they're
males um and thus democracy is kind of a
thing and it doesn't matter
logic is not going to win to emotion my
asperger's doesn't like that but i have
to deal with that
so the group duly elected to live
on the most transition point of the
transition zone you can find this is
actually one of the drone shots from
when we're there i've pulled
from channel four and you can see the
sort of remnants of the camp that had
been set up
so naturally that made our lives as
medics a little bit more difficult
and here is a good example of what
happens
if you decide that the best place to
sleep is on the floor in the transition
zone
everything from the forest decides to
eat you everything from the sand
decides to eat you and this was one of
the people that we were with
now unfortunately in the end we've done
as well as we could with
care this lady had to be medivacked out
and ended up being admitted back in the
uk for treatment when she got off the
island
can you see the theme here this place is
trying to kill you
okay so another thing that everybody had
in some way shape or form was
cellulitis cellulitis or cellulitis now
whether or not you're a new parent
or you're a lunatic like me that wants
to go off and do expedition medicine
we didn't have sepsis but the thing that
will get you out of a hole
soda can i absolutely love this stuff
and basically we were bathing into a
large degree and it helped
things tick along if you got a nasty
bite the pseudochrome was good
bear in mind we need to keep these
people ticking along
and if we're going to be giving them
sways of antibiotics and things like
that we're going to shaft their gut
flora
so it's going to be even harder for them
to exist on what we've got there
and we don't want somebody with dmv
because then we're going to have a
medivac now so a big
portion of our job though was
maintenance and this stuff
really saved our lives there's also this
one as well
now i'd normally ask what what is this
um but again for teams there's not too
many people here um
this is the the ash from the fire and
this is supposed to be miracle stuff so
you can protect yourself from
both the cellulitis from the insects by
putting this
under around your beds because the
insects on the island
won't walk over the ash this is not
pg-rated is it
bollocks i saw the insects walk through
the fire
on this stuff nevertheless we put it
down didn't seem to work very well we
still got eaten but that's the official
advice on expedition medicine
cover your bedding material with ash
prevent you from insects
rubbish okay the other thing that we
talked about dental hygiene at the start
but lots and lots of toothbrushes wash
up on the island seriously pollution is
a terrible thing over there
so we were okay with that but we don't
get toothpaste
what we do have is ash and we would
water this down with a bit of salt water
and use this to clean our teeth
and it was surprisingly effective um
so this stuff you know turns out to be
quite important from a medical
perspective
from a third reason as well now
you've seen that you know i've ended my
with my backside falling off because of
the immersion
but we've got torrential rainfalls
coming through we're traipsing through
the jungle when we're hunting for food
and we're foraging we are wet most of
the time when we're not at the beach
and emotional paddy foot was something
that affected
all of us and yeah we had plenty of
torrential rain
whilst we're over there so even when we
were on
the beach we were soaked now we were
given kit lists
and one of the things that they advised
us to buy were um
jungle boots well that sounds like you
know the kind of thing that you'd have
which oh this is a jungle boot yes you
know you can go adventuring in it
but they're actually a real technical
thing so if you look here on the side of
these
boots they've got holes on them these
aren't waterproof in any way shape or
form
because they're designed to let the
water out
so we would have to keep these clean
from sand every day to let the water
come out and hopefully
let our boots dry similarly the footbeds
are actually
um raised up off the floor of the boot
to again try and keep your feet away
from moisture where possible
didn't work so these are our most of our
feet
after about seven days on the island and
it looks unpleasant we've been in the
bath too long it's not the end of the
world
however it is breaking down our barriers
and this is my fault that's about a week
two three uh we've got ulcers we've got
shearing at the skin
these are not pleasant things and
we have to keep on going because if
you're going to sit on the beach all day
you are going to starve well actually
that's not going to be a problem if
you're going to sit on the beach all day
you're not going to be able to get water
you've only got three days without water
before
you're being medivac with a kidney
injury
so when you get immersion force or
trench foot what are you going to
experience
you're going to have paracetamol it
hurts like billy oh
there's swelling to your feet and you're
also going to end up with numbness
i actually ended up with numbness for my
feet for probably about six months
after coming back to the island now if
you look at expedition medicine
they will tell you how to prevent a
motion foot it's easy you just
air dry your feet elevate them change
your socks when wet
well if you had to make your own
accommodation and you've only got two
pairs of socks that's not going to work
very well
we could however try rubbing our feet
with the charcoal
which would draw some of the moisture
from the foot and that was effective
but most advice that we get just doesn't
work
but we did go to some of this if you
will diabetic advice every day we would
have everybody
at the end or start a day rubbing our
feet down with the charcoal
and also check to make sure that we've
got intact feet what dressings
and pseudo creme did we need to put on
did we have any evidence of infection in
which case we may actually bench
that person so they're unlikely to cause
extra damage
and as i say that was my aid memoir to
say we're rubbing the charcoal on our
feet
now there are my feet coming back on the
airplane
and what were the issues with immersion
foot and what was the fact that we were
very low on protein and things like that
i've not got my laces tied that's not
because
i'm having a nice kick or something like
that that's because my feet have swollen
so much that i can't tie them and my
feet were very painful as we got higher
and higher and higher
because the change in altitude as the
skin
on my feet was split and bleeding in
those shoes not fun
even after we left the island
now we talked about where we'd uh
decided to make our camera
we found this nice flat area
and there weren't many leaves there and
there weren't any rocks no look grand
reason being is it was a riverbed that
had dried up so when the typhoon came
again you can see everything is getting
absolutely soaked
and this is how we spent most of our
evenings the mornings were okay
and the evenings and afternoons were a
torrential rainstorm
yet in spite of all of this we still had
issues with dehydration
now i showed at the start that we had
these jerrycans
so we've got two days of water to start
off with
but the jerry camps are very important
because of how we would try and
purify the water so who criteria you get
your water from a stream something like
that and to make it
potable you filter it through somebody's
t-shirt
lots of people objected to having it
filtered through their very nice
t-shirts
um anyway i won't go into that so we
would filter the water through the
t-shirt
put it back in the jerrycans and then
get it to a rolling boil
to rolling boil it's going to have
killed 99 of all pathogens in there
and is safe to drink but
you've got to carry 20 kilos of fluid
from wherever you've found a fresh water
back and if you've not gotten any food
that day this is getting progressively
harder and harder
and then to get 20 kilos of water
to a rolling boil needs quite a lot of
fuel
so you've got to cut down trees and
bring them
to your fire so you're actually spending
a lot of energy
just to get your water which is where
the dehydration issues come in so in
terms of expedition advice they'd like
they tell you drink before
during after exercise because
first is actually in this in this
environment a poor guy to say you need
to drink
you'll be about two to three percent
dehydration impairing your tolerances
and you may not actually
feel thirsty this is a major issue that
we have
so what are the signs there that we may
have patient
people if you will who are dehydrated
dark yellow urine
passing urine less than twice a day and
the inability to spit
sounds like when i was an icu junior um
you know we all get dehydrated but over
there
we couldn't just open the tab and some
people say oh you could weigh
your uh your contestants if you will see
how things are doing with that
but that's also going to be a bad metric
because
you're on islands you've got increased
workload we've got gi upsets because
they're eating well stuff that they
found off the floor we've got decreased
appetite anyway
because we're dehydrated so don't want
to eat and unfamiliar foods
it was difficult but some of the people
there were actually refusing to eat
certain things which
i did find mentally a difficult hurdle
to get over because they were becoming
more unwell
as a result of that so nothing else
there's a nice
take-home message for if there is a
zombie apocalypse and we're having to
look after ourselves in coventry and the
taps aren't working anymore
thirsty equals dehydrated but dehydrated
does not equal thirsty drink as much as
you can
now some of the features that we were
going to get we're going to see when
you've got about
two percent water loss you get flushing
low endurance
increased heart weight rapid onset of
fatigue the kind of things that we'd see
on the ward
when we're moving to five to six we've
got sleepiness headaches nausea
parasthesia
and distress at this level people were
beginning to get quite
quite twitchy on the island and you'd
find
that people get more argumentative and
aggravated
um depending on where they were in their
fluid levels
and we were really having to force get
the fluid into you get the fluid into
you
of all the things i encountered from a
medical perspective
the thing i did not expect was having to
essentially force people
to drink water over there
now i'm i i'm not going to say i'm a
triathlete i'd like to try triathlons
and
injure myself from doing them so i quite
like sports drinks
now we were blessed on the island that
we literally had sports drinks growing
in the trees
coconuts are you know basically isotonic
and the age of the coconut will affect
um what you're getting from them broadly
though
broadly though if you've got a new fresh
green
big coconut you're going to have a lot
more water in that so you can get
away with probably having about five or
six a day before it causes any problems
but as they get older the water gets
removed from them
and this uh the electrolytes become more
and more concentrated
so one of the issues that we didn't run
into but we had to be very careful with
is hyperkalemia which again if you've
not managed to find a water source if
your fire has gone out you are down to
drinking coconuts
it's very difficult to say to somebody
no you can't drink any more
because of the electrolyte issues and we
didn't want anybody to be in
hyperkalemia
and we could see that people getting
dehydrated poor urine
etc so this was a real stressor for us
so we'd spend as much time during the
day trying to collect water from
other sources when we had the rain and
again i go back to the fact
that um there was pollution was terrible
over there so we would cut up
um jars and things and try to collect as
much water as we could
to keep things sticking over but just
getting water
did consume a huge amount of our energy
now because energy starvation um
so it's a baseline for you so our
imaginary man we know that
medicine is unfortunately sexist it's
all based on a whole idea of a man
but a sedentary 70 kilo man has about
five kilos of fat that we can use as an
emergency source
and you know we're going to need about 2
700 calories a day
to maintain that weight if we're being
active
so realistically that 15 kilos of fat if
we assume
you know that there's about 7200 kilos
at calories per kilo
you've got about 40 days worth of
calories if you just
sit under a palm tree so why not do that
why not just say thanks bear you've put
us on tropical island we're just going
to loaf it please
because we had to do the camera work as
well
um and this is the baby camera this
weighs about two and a half kilos
the big board cameras that we had as
well were a good five kilos
and bear in mind there are people who
have this as their job
so each team had four cameramen so there
were four cameramen two in each team
that we were also having to look after
and they are every day
carrying the five kilo cameras as we're
doing as well so
there's a huge amount of additional burn
being going on there
and i do want to highlight that these
guys did not get any extra support they
lived on exactly what we did
and with these weights all the while so
in terms of myself let's just look over
some of the math so this was
the clinic before we went so i've got a
weight there of 72.1
pandemic weight is slightly higher now
but my fat percentage at that
was a race-ready 10 so
here's my sedentary self um i've got 7.2
kilos of fat
that's going to get me about 51 000
calories in total
so i've got 90 days of fat stores
i was screwed and i do mean that
literally uh this was
not a pleasant experience from a energy
perspective to me
although some of it was surprisingly
tasty one of the things that we would
find is a treat
if you'd found a very old coconut you
know and it's
almost like the ones you get in tesco's
you know other supermarkets are
available
um the the black coconuts and leave them
for long enough
the water completely disappears and you
get this foam inside
it tastes really nice and if you cook
over a fire it tastes like popcorn
so we did have these little sort of
elevations to our day
but we know that there's not a huge
amount of energy in these things
now i say that some people would refuse
food um
this weird looking fruit is a stink
fruit you know it does it tastes like
the worst
rotten moldy cheese you can imagine
but one of the and doesn't taste any
better either but one of these has your
100 of your
of your vitamin c for the day so you'd
have to have
hold it eat the thing and hopefully not
vomit afterwards they really were bad
but not toxic and then we go hunting
um right so
before i go on to this i think we need
to sort of just cover that
i am a meat eater i have no problem
eating meat i quite enjoy meat
but by eating meat i know that an animal
has to go to the slaughterhouse and be
killed
ergo i have no problem eating
meat i have killed myself so that was my
mental
gymnastics in terms of uh hunting and
we knew we'd been told in the briefings
that there were wild boar on the island
um
and that there were snakes on the island
um
one of the problems with snakes um is
that they are really not clean creatures
and we didn't have any death hole to
clean them off
so the first time that we called a snake
um
everyone went to the loop um but you
know
we settled with that but snake is a
white meat
the problem with eating snake is you see
the thing
you get a y fork you catch the thing and
lock its head off
and then bring it back to camp when you
go to the supermarket and buy your
chicken or your meat or your sausage
you're not used to the chicken or the
sausage continuing to writhe in the bag
carrying a snake that does not have a
head anymore that still thinks it's
alive
that you have to eat bear in mind i
think this is the first protein we've
had in a week
is a very unpleasant experience but we
ate the thing and
it was all right um one of the other
things that you could
eat if need be is diurelite because
there is actually carbohydrate in that
and we discussed this with the medical
team and
channel 4 being channel 4 again a tv
show you do not let them have to die or
like they cannot cheat with that
i was there as the medic so as we got
further and further into
the island on week 3 and 4 i was
carrying a pack of diurelite
in my short pockets all the while just
in case anybody had
a major issue um
and i was the one that had the major
issue actually we're five days
out before coming off the island and
we've done a big trek to the far side
because we're trying to catch this pig
and we've been trying to catch this pig
for two weeks now i am actually
i've been on the group side of the group
says actually we've expended too much
energy on this
thing it's fast it's dangerous and we
are
not catching it i think we should stop
i'm good you know
three four kilometers from camp and
i can't walk as in i'm sitting there
on seashore breathing
really deep really heavily my pulse
rates
you know through the roof and it's like
what on earth is going on here
um so we would assume just with all the
bad stuff going on
my electrolytes were shafted we can
probably discuss from a medical
perspective what was actually going on
but we got some of the diora lighting to
me from a carbohydrate perspective
and after about half an hour i was
actually able to resume having
a normal conversation but that was very
unpleasant
and again um we would have called for uh
aid at that point but we've left the
walkie-talkie at camp
with the people who are using the
machetes because if you get a machete
injury
that's going to be nasty so we thought
just walking would be all right
so we did experience these issues
ourselves now to
highlight that hunger aspect the press
shots really minimize that
so this is before the island at 72 kilos
that's coming off the islands at 64. it
doesn't look too bad
the reality was quite different i looked
like a flipping prisoner of war
it was really not fun and
it affected our ability to control our
appetites
and as a gp it's given me a lot more
sympathy
when i'm dealing with patients with
weight loss so when i came back
i could eat two large domino's pizzas
back to back my stomach is swollen
distended
uncomfortable and i still wanted to eat
more
it was the weirdest thing and it took me
probably a year
to be able to have full control of my
own appetite again
knowing that i was eating bad stuff i'll
go to the supermarket and i'd just buy
everything and it was so very unpleasant
that part of it
now going back to the the title of this
uh
house falls on a desert island anybody
who's
watched these things again knows that
channel 4 is going to stack the deck
there was an argument
the group split in two so i'm actually
as the medic having to do
a half kilometer walk across the island
every day
to go and see the breakaway group who
had um
well objected and they were having
issues with dehydration
and collapse and one of the ladies there
was in acute kidney injury at that point
um we actually ended up having to take
bloods on her to decide whether or not
we were having her off the island or not
but
we fought very hard and we kept it there
in terms of coming back we needed to go
through medical quarantine
to make sure that we didn't go through
something called refeeding syndrome
so this is when you've got too much uh
you've got too much food or liquid
nutrition is consumed
after um you know coming off something
like this
because refeeding syndrome uh will
trigger synthesis of glycogen
fat and protein in the cells and
all of this goes on in the expense of
concentrations of potassium magnesium
and phosphorus
and i make the point about looking like
a powder but this happened after world
war two
the patient so the the people who were
um
survived the prisoners of war camps died
shortly afterwards
getting treatment because of this
refeeding syndrome
so when we came off the island we were
it was an old hotel that was closed
we were in there two days before two
days afterwards
with a closed menu we were told that we
were allowed to eat as much fruit as we
wish we could drink as much fluid as we
wanted
but we could not eat anything else and
all the staff there have been advised
don't sell us anything don't buy
something it was not allowed
because of this risk and we can see
how um it affected us so this is my way
to come back across the island so 663
there was where we ran into a few of the
problems so i was actually
a little less unwell with refeeding just
in terms of
fluid this is about halfway through that
first week
and then about two weeks later i'm up to
79
79 kilos just because i'd eaten too much
and i hadn't looked after myself
coming back so yeah that's
that's the the fill in if you will can
you quickly do us a quick ground ground
on uh house visits on a desert island
i don't know if how we're done on time
with that
i think that's so perfect thanks very
much james
um i think
if we have any questions they will come
up
um i don't know if we've got any
questions from our floor
one thing i could ask is
you seem to have a miserable time how
did you raise your spirits
the weirdest things you'd imagine uh the
wheels on the bus
every morning we would have a sing-song
and no one could agree what so we end up
with uh children's
children's songs so we do right before
we go off right you're going to go
hunting we're going to go collect wood
we're going to get water
right we're going to do two rounds of
wheels on the bus go round and round it
really bizarre things and our
conversations
were all about food what are you going
to have when you get and we're going to
have the banquet of this i'm going to
have that
and as that as we went on our desires
changed and in the final weeks like i
don't want to
don't care you can have all your wines i
want bread
and salty butter and strange how our
desires changed as we got worse
[Music]
i was interested to see that you had
both men and women
on the island um
we we see from other reality shows that
this
uh you know uh does lead to a
certain activity was this a a
problem amongst you guys not in any way
shape or form one of the chats came up
to us
there were several chances cannot be
traced um can i have a quick word with
you um
it doesn't work anymore you know i wake
up and there's nothing there anymore and
you know we've got some nice ladies here
but
nothing happens anymore you know we're
in starvation mode
don't worry your body doesn't want to
breed
at the moment it will come back in time
which
thankfully it did um but similarly with
the ladies uh
nobody had a period whilst we're over
there either
mention the the physical trials but the
mental trials must have been
at least as challenging was there any
particular
mental problem that any individual had
or that the group had
that that couldn't actually be very
serious or anything that you
you recognized in retrospect maybe you
should have been more prepared for them
um i would actually uh i'd suggest
actually not it was
we were very very supportive of each
other and i think that helped a lot
from from my perspective as a gp you
know you you're expecting
depression anxiety and all of those
things but actually the one thing that
did come up as it got further and
further and it was
anger um your tolerance for people
wouldn't work so one thing that happened
to me was somebody who remained nameless
i'm sitting on a log and so i personally
opened at least 250 coconuts you know
and there's a lot of work in opening
coconuts with machetes
and i'm sitting there on a log eating
piece of coconut
okay and somebody comes up and they ask
could they have some of it no i don't
want to give them some coconut i'm
hungry
but i did break off some of the coconut
and that caused a
significant issue for probably the next
couple of hours
because i probably gave them probably a
quarter of the coconut that i've gone
and got
so anger was a surprising issue
you've spoken about nutrition and
but apart from the snake and
uh um you know some stinking fruit
there must have been something else that
you had a bit more regularly
um we didn't do very well with fishing i
think we caught
we managed to catch one iguana um the
iguanas love the death apple trees
so it's like well i can see the thing
but i'm not going in there um
we yucca tasted really really nice so
sort of large plantains
and we'd go foraging for that it looks
very
unique growing out the floor so we'd
find that we'd dig it up and then we'd
have this stuff that tasted
i've not been able to cook it to get
like it since i've come home
but when we're over there it tasted like
the world's best roast potatoes
um and we did catch the pig
um now that was
difficult for a lot of people
emotionally um
particularly with how you go about
catching a pig which
i think we'll actually probably avoid um
suffice to say that well
you're catching a live animal off a lot
of girth it's it's difficult
and there's there is some violence to it
but when we caught the pig we probably
caught it
end of week four um and like wild
savages we had a massive fire on the
middle of the beach
and spit roasted the thing um without
a shadow of um exaggeration
we ate the thing from tail to nose
i think the only things that we didn't
were the intestines
um and the brain we ate the whole thing
the heart the liver the kidneys the skin
everything was gone and i remember
sitting there waking up one morning
just with a femur just stripping remains
off so we did get things but it was very
much feast or famine feast or famine all
the way through
um would you do it again would you do it
again
um i'd like to go back
i'd like to go back with extra knowledge
and the things
that we learned from it because you
your problem is when you do the island
you've got to spend
the first week using your energy to
build your shelter to set up what you're
going to do and
hopefully survive but that then burns
your energy out and we learned
subsequently in week four how we could
be upon doing things better
so i'd like to give another go to it and
see
um how we could do and perhaps do it
with
a group where the intention was success
rather than necessarily
again a stacked deck such as a tv show
with
tv crew would provide
as a dermatologist how can you protect
yourself from the sun
absolutely and i'm happy to do this in
advert we had
um life systems um spf 50
um i think swim bike and run um
cream we were given as much cream as we
wanted because they would just bring
that over in a boat
and also insect rapunt which does
absolutely squat
but that sun cream was really good
uh none of us burned um and it's still
something i'm using to this day
when i go out and do triathlons and like
so quite happy with that
so finally then
what lessons have you you know what what
lesson
how has it changed you you know perhaps
change your practice or you as a person
you know what lessons have you learned
um so
persons so uh in terms of practice um i
i feel i have a lot better relationship
with talking with people who are trying
to lose weight
because i appreciate as a doctor someone
of my thighs
it's very difficult talking to somebody
with very high bmi
trying to help them lose weight there's
a lot of well what do you know about
you've never had to struggle with weight
i haven't had to struggle with weight
but i can say i have had to struggle
with an inability to control my appetite
so i've got a bit of an insight there um
and in terms of personally two things
one apply a haste repentant leisure
say yes to every opportunity that comes
your way if you can't do it say
you can't do it once you've tried you
never know where you'll end up
as a result of doing this a year later i
ended up at everest base camp
you never know what's going to come and
personally
i'm very open that my brain is
relatively you know
has its deficiencies with asperger's etc
um
the island quite in my head because i
i think we all do this there are things
that we don't deal with there are things
that we ignore
when you are away for five weeks you
have no books
no tv no internet no ability to do
anything other than
talk and share stories with the people
that you're with
things will come to the surface that you
cannot hide
and i had to deal with an awful lot of
the things that were in my head
and i'm going to use this word where
areas where i've suffered because of my
mental health
and i genuinely look at my life as
before and after the island because i
came back a much better person
after having gone through the pain of
dealing with
some of those things that i could no
longer run away from over there
so and that perhaps is probably my
closing
point to it if you think that you
benefit from mental health as
um dr rotation said at the start your
hcw is offering was it
short short rounds schwartz rounds if
you think that you would uh benefit from
doing anything with regard to mental
health
do it again plight has repented leisure
if it hasn't worked for you fine you've
wasted a bit of time
nothing nobody loses for it but you may
benefit much more than you expect and
we're all
in the pandemic we've all struggled
we've all had different
experiences and different hardships
take the opportunity whilst these are
things that are available even if you
don't feel you need it because you may
just find something you did not expect
james thanks very much thank you for a
superb
uh interesting uh presentation
i'm very glad that i met you on tuesday
thank you very much for stepping in at
short notice all right
i'm hoping that perhaps in the future we
could invite you again
but otherwise thanks very much you're
welcome have a good everyone take care