The Real Story of Medical Cannabis: Myths Debunked - Dr. Gill
CBD Supplements and Cannabis generally are those sorts of topics where there are MANY opinions and surprisingly little fact behind the media articles
I have many patients who use cannabis and over-the-counter CBD products and when I've been asked about it, I've been relatively dismissive and advised them to avoid these products
HOWEVER - I realised that my negative opinion towards CBD and cannabidiol as an approach to helping patients was based on ignorance, rather than knowledge.
To be very clear, I had a negative opinion of cannabis generally. I knew there was an association with psychosis, but relatively little else... and I realised that I was speaking as a doctor - from a place of medical authority - from a position that I couldn't honestly say was based on science rather than opinion.
So I set out to change that. In this video, I look at the research present in the BMJ about the effects of cannabis products for patients and found some interesting results - both about benefits and harms. Let me be clear "IS CANNABIS SAFE?" is far from a black-and-white answer.
Hopefully, people will see I've approached this topic openly and honestly - these are my findings about cannabis and CBD products
If you'd like to know more about the sponsor of this video - please click this link, as it will take you their site - NatureCan
00:00 - Introduction 00:42 - Initial skepticism about CBD products 03:27 - The science behind CBD and THC components 07:10 - Hypotheses on CBD's effects on conditions like fibromyalgia 09:30 - How media affects our view on medicine 11:17 - The need for more research on CBD 13:04 - Review of scientific literature on cannabis 14:47 - The impact of cannabis on sleep quality and physical function 16:28 - Dosage considerations 17:46 - Relationship between cannabis availability and opioid-related deaths 20:30 - The risks associated with THC 22:36 - Potential of cannabis-derived medications 23:37 - Conclusion
[Music]
hello and welcome back to mine on the
channel my name is Dr James Gill and you
join me for another medical themed video
and to be looking at cannabis or
specifically CBD products
hold on how on Earth has this topic
ended up here
well I've been trying to make more
General Medical videos as well as the
clinical skills ones and seeing that the
videos on our A to Z series of the NHS
have done very well I was contacted by
Nature cam who asked if I'd be
interested in doing a sponsor video with
regard to their cannabis or CBD products
and I politely declined and I in fact
started to type a relatively vociferous
email and then just as about to hit send
I stopped
you see I've encountered and care for
many patients who've used and do still
smoke cannabis let me be 100 clear I
could not be more against smoking
cannabis if I tried
frankly my approach to inhaling anything
is best summed up by a quote given to me
from a respiratory physician several
years ago one I asked them about vaping
they said there's only two things that a
patient should put into their lungs air
and if needed the drugs for a medical
inhaler end of discussion
and honestly he looked a bit Fierce as
he said that
so smoking vaping anything is going to
have a negative impact on a patient's
health and we need to highlight that to
a patient and offer them assistance in
stopping
so we know that smoking is bad
but off the back of that there are now
lots of cannabis products that are
available over the counter that aren't
smoked or inhaled and we're talking
about sprays we're talking about pills
and none of these need a medical
prescription
and then I realized I don't actually
know anything about them and I wouldn't
be able to advise my patients if they
asked me anything about those products
and I felt a little bit ashamed actually
about my immediate negative reaction I
like to think of myself as a scientist
with an open mind
so I discussed this point with nature
can and said yes I was prepared to work
with them and do a sponsored video but I
had to do it honestly and it had to be
educational in nature not a promotional
thing other than saying that they've
sponsored the video I.E I'd approached
the hypothesis that over the count of
cannabis products should be avoided but
I'd look at the available evidence to
see whether or not that seemed to really
you know reasonable or not and I produce
a video this video following the
research that I was doing
do you know what they said yes
so here we go now
there's a bit of a heads up this isn't
going to be this house believes cannabis
products are bad
um because it just didn't feel a good
way of approaching it but my point is
I've approached this with a skeptical
eye after all
it sounds like snake oil you know
cannabis has been implicated in
affecting frankly everything in the body
so
with that in mind let's try and dig into
a little bit of the science what the
research is with regard to CBD and where
the medical science is going so let's
start off with the chemical makeup of
cannabis essentially there's two key
components in there we've got CBD
cannabidiol and THC
tetrahydrocannabinol no there's no D
there and they interact with our bodies
innate endocannabinoid system yeah until
I started researching this I didn't know
we had one either
apparently the endocannabinoid system is
thought to have a huge range of effects
across the body from the brain the gut
the bowel your immune system regulating
information affecting sex drive sleep
sufficient I heard someone describing it
as a skin encompassing all other body
systems
and honestly my when I heard that bit my
again snake all alarm belt was ringing
very very loudly I mean just think about
that for a second it sounds like utter
rubbish a magical wonder drug to cure
your every ill I mean it's almost
Victorian
and as a result of that I now need to
cry my position of media induced
ignorance
I didn't know
enough about cannabis and thus had to
cried all of it I mean I you can see
where it comes from the fact that you
might think well how could somebody be
Daft enough to think that there's a
magical plant that revolved 28 million
years ago in the Eastern Tibetan plateau
and it just happens to have this
miraculous effect on the him body I mean
it does seem rubbish
then I plug my brain in because this is
actually a very familiar story
there is another plant that will attract
every part of the body the lungs the
heart the eyes the brain the digestion
the mood and it even looks a little bit
similar
the tobacco plant
so here comes some of the science for
you and there's a disclaimer I'm a GP
I'm not a neuroscientist so if do you
think that I've got something wrong here
when I've over simple or I've
oversimplified the science please Shout
Out Below I'd love to learn and
hopefully we can make sure that
everyone's on the same page
so as scientists we've got a good
understanding of the peripheral nervous
system and its main neurotransmitter
acetylcholine and that molecule is at
the center of the main signaling
Pathways there
and I highlight this particular chemical
as there is a class of receptor to which
it binds called the nicotinic
acetylcholine receptor
have a guess as well as acetylcholine
what other chemical will activate these
receptors
yep it's nicotine
so perhaps it isn't too much of a
stretch when Research into the effects
of cannabis on the body has identified
an endocannabinoid system which not only
has naturally occurring endocannabinoids
of the body affecting it but it can also
be affected by external cannabinoids
such as CBD and THC
so we know there's a plant which
contains a chemical which is abuse for
its psychotropic effects coming from the
THC component of this plant and to be
honest that's where most of the
negativity towards it has come from I
think
and to be honest that's also where the
safety issues have come from with regard
to cannabis was which we'll discuss in a
moment but there is a growing body of
research with regard to cannabinoids
specifically the CBD component with a
strong removal of the THC which
suggested possible medical uses in
seemingly unrelated medical conditions
one hypothesis why the CBD may have
these effects is that the
endocannabinoid system
could become unbalanced in the same way
that your endocrine system could you
know your thyroid goes out of whack in
which case you may get with the
endocrine system coming out of whack
hypothyroid or diabetes with the
endocannabinoid system going out of
whack it may lead to conditions such as
fibromyalgia again this is a hypothesis
here and I want to be really clear
saying that a hypothesis is a position
that's been set forth to explain an
observation these aren't theories which
are tested propositions commonly
regarded as correct so we're far away
from that at the minute
now the reason for the hypothesis is
that cannabis products are reported by
certain patient groups I've highlighted
fibromyalgia just as having a great
Improvement in their symptoms when using
cannabis derived therapies compared to
the more conventional treatments they've
used
the hypothesis here is that that no
conventional treatments Target the
endocannabinoid system hence classically
poor outcomes when treating conditions
like fibromyalgia or me and
they're seeing improvements when we're
giving Trials of CBD medication which is
specifically targeting the
endocannabinoid system unlike our
classic medications
so with that in mind I think I need to
unpick what I'm beginning to see as an
unfortunate Prejudice because not only
does the body have an endocannabinoid
system but the body will produce its own
cannabinoids
so you know it sounds like this is part
of us but but cannabis is a drug of
abuse it's used by criminals and other
unsavory types how can this possibly be
honestly I think it's a PR problem I
think someone really screwed up when it
came to the naming convention here
I think if we called in a cannabinoid
system frankly anything else and
cannabis just happened to contain
similar chemicals I thought would be in
a very different place but again I
appreciate the nature of the discoveries
led to the name and clementia we have
but I think that's also drastically
affected research
I mean let's put it a different way
often I've got enough difficulty getting
a patient to accept a very common and
effective drug treatment plan for
example statins not because they've had
a problem with that medication in the
past but because they've heard from
somebody possibly the daily mail saying
that they could get side effects
now those same people if they have
they've heard about cannabis so widely
and we're so frankly many negative
connotations even if that person was
offered a wonder drug developed from
cannabis I think it'd be a tough sell
for those patients particularly after
the you know the newspapers had weighed
in on it
so this point of my research I was
beginning to feel a little bit
embarrassed about my negative position
Baseline as I come to realize just how
much of my rejection for engaging with
CBD discussion was based Less on
scientific knowledge but more on the
programming I'd received from the media
now before I go any further down that
line I want to be very clear I've
personally cared for many patients of
whom smoking cannabis has been a
terrible decision for them and has left
them from a mental health perspective
with significant harms many of those
long-standing
so just because we've got a bit of
knowledge about how cannabis might work
on the body doesn't mean it's going to
magically change my mind that actually
all of these claims are true
but it does recognize that I need to
open up to the idea that I really don't
know as much as I thought that I did
after all there are many drugs such as
opiates Gabapentin amitriptyline which
are incredibly useful medications
but are also dangerous drugs of abuse so
with that in mind having chastised
myself thoroughly for my possibly
unconsciously programmed bias I thought
how best to deal with this and rightly
or wrongly I thought I'd have a look at
what some of the other YouTube doctors
have had to say on this and if they
could perhaps point me in a good
direction to start with some research
studies I can get my teeth into
honestly I was dismayed that the content
studies suggest May benefit evidence
support the majority were overviews they
were useless no critical appraisal
nothing Beyond random very positive
statements which even if I'm becoming
slightly more positive on from my
neutral uh start or negative start
just someone saying yes this is
brilliant without any critical appraisal
really doesn't that work for me
now let's look at this in a different
way why I objected to that so much there
are plenty of studies suggesting that
ghosts exist but it doesn't make that
accurate or true or frankly any stronger
than someone saying my mate down the pub
said this stuff's good
that's not to decry scientific
discussion in the pub after all it's
claimed the structure of DNA was
finalized in a pub in Cambridge
but there's also people who say that
there's studies about a haunted Pub in
Derbyshire
and I think you can see what I did here
the point is I'm trying to help people
understand an area of Medical Science
and in doing so I fully appreciate this
has been dogged by controversy
and those controversial products are now
available over the counter for you to
buy
thus I think it's reasonable that we set
a slightly higher bar for talking about
these
supplements these medicines these
chemicals
so I did what else every self-respecting
doctor should have done and that was
turned to the literature what I decided
to do is I would take a journal that
most patients should have heard of the
British medical journal and I cast The
Net really wide I'd look their most
recent research Publications with the
word cannabis in the title to my
surprise I was shocked there was very
little research in the bmj by which I
mean Recent research and the the most
up-to-date systematic review was there
and I thought we'd have a look at that
I'm a big fan of systematic reviews
because they're a lovely way of looking
for signals in the noise of existing
research by getting a large number of
studies essentially putting them all all
the data that they reported from it into
a pot and seeing if they can power a
larger study to hopefully find a more
subtle result
so the study was medical cannabis or
cannabinoids for chronic non-cancer and
cancer related pain a systematic review
so I say they take all the data and
bring it in apart they took data it was
aggregated from nearly 4 000 patients
and by reanalyzing that data across
various different studies they were able
to show a moderate evidence base for
pain reduction in patients using
cannabinoids compared to their standard
treatment
I know quite a few positives from a pain
perspective here it also identified
lower pain scores and a high level of
evidence that these patients had
improved physical function which for me
surely should be the goal of all
treatments not necessarily to extend
life but to improve a patient's
functional ability and quality of life
the review also identified further high
strength evidence of improved Sleep
Quality
I'm personally depending that sleep is
one of the most significantly under
recognized areas of poor health and
anything that we can do to improve Sleep
Quality has to be a step in the right
direction
now again the systematic review so
looking for small signals that couldn't
have been detected earlier or in small
studies did show some very positive
things but it wasn't all pleasant dreams
and rainbows there was evidence of
impaired cognition drowsiness and
impaired attention in the Cannabis group
with 50 out of a thousand people
experiencing negative side effects
compared to those on the standard pain
management
now I think it's very interesting given
the lack of regulation for CBD products
in the UK the article then went on to
discuss a possible dosage regime for
patients with chronic pain which to my
mind is a tacit promotion by the authors
for use of CBD products in pain
management
they advised therapeutic trials should
start a low dose of non-inhaled
cannabidiol so going what I was saying
about not smoking not vaping and these
products should gradually have their
dose increased depending on clinical
response kind of makes sense and
tolerability they suggest perhaps
starting at five milligrams of CBD twice
daily and increasing up by 10 milligrams
every few days until a maximum of 40
milligrams and here's the crucial bit
all with a very close follow-up
now to me speaking of somebody in
medical establishment I think it's very
interesting that given that the we are
so very cautious and honestly
apprehensive about CBD treatments yet
patients can buy CBD over the counter
there's a bit of a black hole about what
to do in terms of how much so in the UK
the food standard agency has come in and
felt they've needed to give a comment
and it's similar to what was advised in
that systematic review
they say if somebody's starting CBD
products on their own without
supervision of a doctor something I'd
strongly dissuade the FSA has advised a
maximum of 70 milligrams a day so we
can't even determine where our
therapeutic ranges are and that should
be something that anybody thinking about
taking CBD products over the counter
should be very cautious about
personally I would always advise to
speak to your doctor ensure that you're
not going to get any interactions with
your other medications it's not going to
cause problems for other conditions you
might have bear in mind as the bmj
article has shown drowsiness and
impaired concentration are side effects
there could be medications that you're
on that could put your significant risk
of increasing those side effects or
perhaps side effects from other
medications
so I thought I got a good Baseline there
and I had a look at the next research
article from the bmj this is more what I
was expecting death drugs all the
classic themes
but actually again it was surprisingly
upbeat if cautious
study was looking at the association
between county level cannabis dispensary
counts and opioid related mortality
deaths I.E if you could buy cannabis
more easily
did you have more deaths from the opiate
crisis which the United States is
suffering
the article was very straightforward in
its conclusions the more medical and
recreational Cannabis dispensers there
were the lower the opiate related deaths
in fact they were reduced by 17 they
really didn't beat around the bush about
promoting this conclusion
however one thing that the article was
very clear about was to highlight that a
causal relationship could not be
determined here only that their research
suggested a positive benefit
admittedly one that is reinforced by the
early BMG bmj article they were very
clear to say we can't say that it's
definite
now it looks like I'm straying into that
annoying region of studies suggest but
let's look at what this study is saying
they did find a statistic a
statistically significant lower level of
opiate related deaths where there were
medical dispensaries for cannabis
I.E this reduction in mortality number
of deaths in opiate users were not due
to chance
however the study was not powered to be
able to show a causal link let's reframe
that so we can look at causal link good
example I always like is after World War
II the birth rate in Belgium decreased
after World War II the number of stalks
in Belgium also decreased but the birth
rate hadn't gone down because the stalks
won't bring their babies anymore
just because you've got a correlation
doesn't mean you've got causation
we can as mentioned take the information
from the previous bmj study suggesting
better control of chronic pain using
cannabis to build an empirical case for
benefit if not a statistical one
and it appears here that we've got
another study supporting cannabis use in
patients with with pain
now I'm sure someone is going to
reasonably say you know what about
cannabis psychosis that's the thing how
can I be so positive about cannabis
especially after I've said I've worked
with cannabis patients who've had ended
up having psychotic episodes
everything we've talked about so far has
been the CBD and at this stage let me
add a personal statement that all
patients should avoid anything
containing THC as this is you know the
problematic side of cannabis
and even so if you've had personal
histories family histories of mental
health disorders
absolutely avoid THC but also perhaps
not use CBD until you've discussed that
with your doctor okay so we we know that
there are problems with these drugs
so let's put a bit of science to that in
2019 one third of all new schizophrenia
cases in London were linked to high
potency that's greater than 10 THC
content containing cannabis again here's
the bmj article so let me be Crystal
Clear whilst there's been suggestions
that our understanding of THC may be
flawed from some research articles I
would currently suggest there's
insufficient evidence to support THC
being safe and there are real world
acknowledged and personally witnessed
dangers associated with the TMC so
anything that I'm saying here let me be
really clear CBD some evidence to
support benefits which we've discussed
but THC I would absolutely avoid
and obviously a whole plant cannabis
contains THC reinforcing my comment
about avoiding smoking and thus by
extension other forms of ingestion such
as eating simply don't if you're looking
at engaging in using CBD look at what
products you can buy over the counter
and how can you tell how are they saying
how are they proving that there is going
to be no THC component in their product
now I'm not going to say that these
over-the-counter products are all safe
certainly can't but I also wouldn't say
that over-the-counter codeine is safe
I've happily prescribed it or describe
it as a potentially low risk of serious
side effects though
and I think that's where we need to be
with cannabis for the moment you know
the side effects are possible but
unlikely and there is evidence to
suggest a benefit certainly in pain
now honestly I've been wrong about
flatly avoiding looking at cannabis
derived medications and feel that
actually I've got some patients I might
need to discuss this with and it's
certainly worthwhile explore for me to
explore further and to find out if I
should be discussing this with my
patients I still have a lot of
skepticism about claims made for
cannabis but as we've seen there we do
have some areas of documented
evidence-based benefit
let's flip it a different way personally
when it comes to painkillers I always
like to remind patients that paracetamol
can kill you just because you buy
something over the counter it doesn't
mean it's a benign substance and I think
that's perhaps how you should look at
CBD if you're thinking about it
it's probably a reasonable place to
bring this video to the close but I want
to add in over the research that I've
done for this I've also stumbled across
information CBD may be beneficial for
sleep medicine and also perhaps in
sporting applications both of which in
areas close to my heart so if you'd like
me to do another video as I dig further
into this topic shout out to the
comments below and we'll see what we can
come up with
similarly if there are particular areas
you think we should look at again Shout
Out Below
if you found this video useful please
consider liking the video it tells
YouTube we're here and also consider
subscribing to the channel because
you'll then be able to join us for more
magical content
once again thank you to Nature cam for
letting me actually research a topic
that I hadn't thought about before and
yeah we'll see in the next video take
care
thank you