Why Do Doctors Take So Much Blood? 150K Subscribers Q&A - Dr Gill
Thank you all so much for the 150K subscribers! The feedback from you and the community here has allowed us to reach this milestone!
This video relates explicitly to Q&A Post on the communities tab - I try to engage with subscribers on the communities section, and definitely in the comments section, so if you want to have greater involvement with the channel, please consider subscribing and hitting the bell for notifications - the more input we can, the more influential the videos can be
I set up this clinical skills channel to try and help medical students get to grips with the complexities of different clinical examinations. That will remain the main focus of the channel - there are, after all, only so many hours in the day.
I'll continue adding to the Deep Dive videos, explaining what is going on during the examinations,
00:00 Introduction 01:20 Does knowledge of pregnancy make it more terrifying? 02:34 Medical explanations of ASMR 05:00 Advice for someone considering entering the medical field 06:40 First month of marriage in one word 07:25 Will you make videos on fetal development? 08:23 Tips for studying unlikable topics 09:37 How many takes did the pregnancy video require? 10:15 Most interesting advancements being made in medicine 11:53 What's the biggest frustration when producing videos? 12:13 Biology of Adeptus Astartes 13:10 Thoughts on becoming a first-time dad 14:04 Why you shouldn't deprive yourself of sleep when studying 16:21 Are doctors the worst patients? 18:12 Are doctors aware of the most recent advancements in their field? 19:10 Favorite song 20:20 Most frustrating part of the job 21:02 In the grim dark of humanity, there is only war. 21:15 Why do doctors take so much blood? 23:00 Final Thoughts
hello and welcome back to the channel my
name is Dr James Gill and you've joined
me for 155
000 subscriber q a uh we've been a
little bit late getting this one off the
board but unfortunately things have been
rather busy at home
um as you can see I'm not in the usual
location for filming things here but uh
largely that's because as you're all
aware we've now got a baby on the way
and uh well life is being turned upside
down relatively rapidly
so we put out the uh offer for questions
for yourself and we've got quite a few
questions many of them very interesting
as far as I'm concerned anyway the thing
about these q a sessions is that I
haven't read over the questions before
um we've go through them so they're not
pre-prepared answers which makes it at
least more interesting from my site
because I get to see what you guys want
isn't it but also you guys have to put
up with me arming and eyeing as I work
my way through the answers so with that
in mind let's get on with things so
first up
um
who is a regular poster on the channel
here so so happy for both you and Beth
announcing your nose do you think that
having all that medical knowledge makes
experiencing pregnancy more terrifying I
really hope it's all going well with you
and you're both able to enjoy the Calm
before the storm
yes without a shadow of a doubt yes
um Beth doesn't get much Choice with
regard to engaging with a pregnancy
because well it's there inside her for
myself
um
I am in many ways keeping myself a
little bit more distant from the actual
bump you know I'm reading to it and
talking to it and doing all the things
that I'm supposed to but at the same
time I'm also frantically aware the
number of patients having worked in OBS
and gyne myself are the number of
patients who lose babies Advanced
pregnancy stages and things like that I
know it sounds Daft to say it
but I will be happier when we're a bit
further through the pregnancy in a bit
more of a safer space until then yes
there is definitely a burden of
knowledge and it does add to some of the
stress I think
yeah as I say we're trying to be honest
with these okay
um friend zone 75 said have you looked
into medical uh explanation studies of
ASMR do you have any interest in how it
manifest would you ever do a video to
discuss it I wouldn't I know it's not
something you always wanted to be tied
to but I feel more scientific study of
ASMR might be an interesting topic for
you in one of these videos
well actually
um Cass has just jumped here onto the
side with me hey old man hey hey okay
yes you see somebody's not been well of
late and he's a he had to go after the
vet which he did not enjoy
see tacos now
16 years old and he's got a few gray
bits on him and yeah it's it's a wee bit
worrying to me at the light but he's
really not happy about the shaved patch
on his fur
scrambach
taking this one to the vets is not a
pleasant experience
okay you're going to sit there and let
me get on
okay I've got to finish this q a video
all right
I'll take that lack of running off as
consent
so let's carry on then
um
I did a a collaboration video
um that I'll put a link
there too
um with uh one of the other uh YouTubers
one of the big cardiology consultants
and I did a little bit of research into
it
um broadly when we're talking about ASMR
there seems to be a similar connection
to friction that sort of feeling of you
know of someone walking over your grave
or the the sense that you might feel
when with a big song something like that
perhaps some people would do for their
national anthem or maybe a big song in a
religious place
um
there's not a huge amount of evidence
out there but you know depending on how
it is that people are using ASMR you
know for relaxation anxiety and things
like that there's definitely room for
further research to be done to look if
it's something that can be added into
our Arsenal with regard to CBT and
mindfulness and things like that from
a medical perspective
reeseb says what was the most difficult
part of medical school what advice would
you give to someone who's considering
entering the medical field
at this precise Moment In Time certainly
in the UK don't
um
I think the hardest part about medical
school is the lack of time so I went to
Warwick medical school so that's an
accelerated four-year course rather than
normal fives that we have and that was
the one thing I was aware of completely
whilst doing it we lacked time and I
think that's a big thing that you need
to be excellent at time management which
I'm not and you need to be very fast on
your feet in terms of being able to
absorb knowledge which I'm not
particularly and you need to be able to
manage the intense pressure that comes
with that
um I think the one thing that I would
say for such a huge decision is joining
medical school
there will be a million and one people
who will tell you reasons why you should
talk to the people who say you shouldn't
and ask them why they're saying that
particularly someone who's already in
the medical field would they do it again
I think that's probably the best way to
view such a momentous decision you know
you need to weigh the positive
opinions on going to medical school also
with the negatives and see whether or
not you feel that you'd be able to
balance those two and find what you
think is a reasonable
um
outcome for yourself
I'm sorry I'm going to mangle this name
sir savis says can you describe your
first months of marriage in one word
complete
and I think what I mean by that is
you're no longer planning a wedding
which I fully put my hands up and say
that I perhaps didn't do the Lion's
Share of that on
um but also you know you've you've gone
through that step and you get to relax
for a little bit that doesn't mean Take
Your Eye Off the Ball but it does mean
that you can enjoy each other and the
lives that you've chosen to have
together although in our situations it
appears that that enjoyment has been
relatively short-lived on our own
because there will be three before long
Justin Biddle 1288 asks will you and
Beth do any fetus development videos
throughout the pregnancy even if Beth's
not involved it would be a really neat
way to Showcase how the pregnancy would
affect the usual routines
um I'm not sure if we're necessarily
going to do any embryology side of
things because a it's a visually scary
for people
and it's quite challenging
um medically speaking it was always an
error I struggled at the medical school
we do have a couple of videos planned
and actually the next one we're going to
be doing is we're at the stage where we
can actually detect the fetal heartbeat
now so we're going to be doing a video
on that certainly
but a lot of it will depend on as with
all things how much time we've got
because well the pregnancy doesn't slow
down depending on how bad my work
schedule is so we'll see what's
appropriate for the stages as we are
So Daniel Lag
7 to 790 asks do you have any tips study
tips especially when you have to
approach a difficult not likable Topic
at medical school if that makes sense
um they say the best way to understand
the subject is to teach it so um I
always find it's effective to work in
revision groups and you each take a
topic that you do not want to do or you
find difficult and it's your job to do a
five ten minute presentation to the
group on the basics of it how to
understand it and you know perhaps
include a case study with that as well
it's very easy for us to sit in our
comfort zones when we're revising
particularly at medical school and avoid
the topics that you don't like I've just
highlighted them not a fan of embryology
but if you force yourself to revise it
because you're giving that knowledge to
somebody else it changes your impetus to
do it and well makes you
makes you force your way into that
subject
that was something that we did quite a
lot of explaining topics to each other
in
jaytaylor4510 asks how many takes did it
do for you and your wife to film the
baby announcement pregnancy checkup
video honestly I was quite surprised it
when you took us two attempts to get it
and as far as bloopers are concerned
um honestly there aren't really any
the problem being I've only got so much
space on my hard drive and because I'm
filming in 4k most videos coming in
about 50 to 18 gigabytes so I don't
really have the ability to cut out the
outtakes and save them for you know
years later using later on but maybe one
day if I get some extra hard drive space
rat Lord Ally asks what do you think of
some of the most interesting exciting
advancements being made in medicine
honestly there's the so much work being
done on the gut microbiome at the moment
and you know generalized gut health and
so for example there's two things that I
find particularly interesting there's
information with regard to the
prebiotics the things that are gut
bacteria feed on and our probiotics the
supplementation of microbes that we can
have to try and improve people's gut
microbiome and for example there is
research being done on sourdoughs where
people have found to have an increased
level of prebiotics on their hands and
things for making the sourdoughs and
that might translate to positive health
benefits note I'm talking about the food
that our own bacteria consume rather
than the bacteria themselves because
those probiotics are still going to be
killed in the cooking process
one of the other things that I think is
particularly interesting about gut
microbiome medicine is I firmly believe
in maybe 10 15 years rather than giving
medications for depression and anxiety
to specific mental health things I'm not
meaning broadly I think it's possible
that we may be looking at alternate
diets and because the pharmaceutical
companies will want to continue making
money possibly giving prescriptions of
probiotics to try and increase serotonin
production the bowel and things from
that side of things so a very
interesting field that will probably be
affecting us all before too long
juvental asks so for editing your own
videos what's your biggest frustration
you have with the editing honestly
because I'm colorblind I kind of get
that wrong quite often so that's one
area that I struggle with but
um I think things are gradually
improving I'm not perfect but we are
getting there
Jared Dunham six four four sevens asks
would you ever do a deep dive video on
the biology of an adeptus startis or
their enhancement
well actually it's on the job list to do
I was contacted by another YouTuber
asking if um you know I'd like to work
with them to do that and when I was at
University I was at Nottingham so I was
very lucky that games workshops
headquarters was actually my local store
um and I still have friends who actually
work for GW today so yes I think that in
the fullness of time there may be a trip
to Games Workshop with some cameras if
we can get their permission because
apparently they're very specific about
taking cameras in there and then yes we
might be able to do something fun on
that side of things looking at you know
Space Marines and their fictional
biology certainly
the Fleming family at 22 asked what's
your thoughts on becoming a first-time
dad
I'm not even remotely ready or mature
enough
um I presume that everybody has feelings
such as that but uh
yeah
we're going to see but it's something
I'm honestly anxious very very anxious
about
um
and part of that is you know things from
my own history that I don't want to
repeat on a child which I think
everybody will say similar things like
that but
yeah
um I'm sure we'll be filming things to
do with the pregnancy and perhaps
um childhood
um yeah what's this face there's lots of
medical stuff to do with Pediatrics and
uh yeah finally I'll have a
small creature to perhaps utilize for
teaching with so we'll see
Avid 5055 said hey I'm starting medical
school next four and was wondering how
much I'm going to be able to rely on
coffee to study through sleepless nights
before exams or will I need stronger
stuff
now bear in mind my medical degree seem
to be sponsored by Red Bull
um
I am aware of the hypocritical side of
this when I say that do not do the
sleepless nights and do not rely on
caffeine
uh why on Earth am I saying something
like that well
ultimately passing your exams and
knowledge retention is about getting
information in your brain
and that requires REM Cycles in your
sleep in order to get better restoration
and memory formation
um caffeine will interfere with
adenosine stopping you going to sleep in
the first place and Will significantly
impact on the number of REM Cycles
you'll get so let's say you stay at
three four hours later
revising with the use of caffeine you're
probably going to do more than three
four hours worth of damage to the memory
that you're trying to the memories are
trying to form from that revision period
Then actually if you concentrate on
getting that seven hours a night's sleep
um
now yes whilst I'm through medical
school I still have to do teaching
teaching the medical school now I still
have to do my own prep and frequently
there will be a new subject that I'm
having to cover with regard to a lecture
or a new medicine stuff comes out that
perhaps I've had to research before
consultation
in those situations I have actively
changed my revision process and I'm
trying incredibly hard not to work late
Into the Night
when I need to utilize my memory yes I'm
not very good at switching off
particularly when it comes to getting
work done but if it's in terms of
getting it into my head then I do try
very firmly to switch off and make sure
I'm getting my seven to eight hours
sleep a night so really try not to do
the caffeine and cram because actually
it won't work very well in the long term
for you
Chuck
o'neill2023 says um
are doctors really the worst patients
I I'm not sure the doctors are
necessarily the worst patients per se I
think in my experience dealing with
other doctors the problem is that when
I'm asking a patient who is not from a
medical background questions I get
answers in the order that I am asking
them so how I have my internal workings
however when you're dealing with a
patient who is also a medic obviously we
want to be helpful so we give
information that we know or feel is
relevant but as the person receiving
that information it can be out of the
order I normally thinking so on that
side of things it sometimes means that
Medics can be a little bit more of a
challenge
but there is also the issue of
um imposter syndrome I remember when I
saw one of my colleagues who had trained
me
um you know in anesthetics when I was at
Warwick hospital now as far as I'm
concerned anesthetics like the best of
the best at medicine you know they know
everything you know this person came in
with their child you know and I
basically sort of my brain screamed and
ran out of the door I said look what do
you want I will do it you know I'm
terribly sorry you know I'm not worthy
her and he looked at me said
I'm a gas man my child's broke and I
don't know what's wrong fix it so
sometimes we can cause ourselves
problems when it comes to treating
Medics as well and that goes back to the
the constant Mantra it's vitally
important that we treat all patients
equally and as the patient first and
foremost
ogallo says do General Practitioners
Specialists or medical doctors who work
with patients read research papers as
part of their usual activities yes so
bmj comes through the door very
regularly and it's basically a way of
overviewing what's going on with
research and then often they do specific
research articles in there that you know
might be outside your field that might
still be interesting but yes it's
vitally important that we keep up to
date because well the world is changing
medicine is changing science is changing
I believe this there's a statistic that
by the time you leave Medical School 25
of what you were taught there is
actually out of date by the time you
finish your training 50 of what you were
taught at medical school is out of date
so it's vitally important that we do
keeping engage with research and the
changes in our Fields all about helping
the patient at the end of the day
uh Josh Marshall
1054 asks do you have a favorite song
just curious what you jam out to on a
usual day honestly it depends on what
I'm doing if I'm cycling and I'm doing a
heavy workout
I actually quite like listening to I've
forgotten who's done it now but there's
a dance version of dying of the light
and I think it's actually narrated by
Michael Kane and it's a really good one
to knuckle down and get that power out
conversely if I'm just relaxing I tend
to you know actually like Bare Naked
Ladies they're they're a group who just
sound happy and on that same note
um Scouting For Girls no one sounds like
a younger version the other again it's a
a band who sound like they know they've
won the lottery and they're enjoying
doing what they do
but if I'm working I can't have music
with words in it because it like
distracts me so often listening to theme
tunes and things like that so Gladiator
um Lord of the Rings Jurassic Park you
know
basically you know the the big film
scores that that's my working music
certainly
uh CMW asks hi Dr Gill what's the most
frustrating part of her job
I don't have enough time and I don't
have enough brain it's simply I wish
that I knew more
um and I wish that I had more time to do
more with the little bit of knowledge
that I've got to help the patients and
it's one of the reasons why I've um you
know doing the sports medicine clinic
um
but
on the on the private side so I can give
that extra time that's needed to work
through those really complex things I
wish I could be doing this on the NHS
but it's not something that we can
um afford in the UK nationally so it's
something that I'm doing myself that way
William Winder 5011 has just put in the
Grim dark of humanities far future there
is only War I'm not sure that's a
question but it perhaps might be rather
predictive
okay final one uh friendly o why do
anesthetists need so many blood tests
before an operation what are they for
I'm going for surgery not major soon and
on Monday I'm having my sixth sample of
blood
actually this is a really good question
because it's a question that patients
often ask me why am I asking for extra
blood tests
having blood taken is like going to the
supermarket if somebody didn't ask you
to pick up milk then you won't have
brought the milk back with you and it's
the same thing with a blood test if
someone hasn't needed to ask for a um a
calcium level at that point but then
there's a change to medications which
can affect calcium then suddenly you
need to get that blood test and it won't
have been done before bear in mind you
can't just test for everything because
tests cost money
and I've been astonished when doing sort
of the background work
how much blood tests cost so an hba1c a
test I do all the while costs like 50
Quid you know this is not you know cheap
things and I I personally think it will
be a really good idea for patients to
have the price written beside both the
tests that we're requesting and the
prescriptions that they're getting not
so we get them to pay it not at all but
so they understand the value that we're
getting from the NHS so six blood tests
because
you know they need to know different
things and different blood tests may
open different questions
similarly some blood tests are only
valid for a short period of time
particularly with regard to anesthetics
where we need to have the most
up-to-date information in order to keep
the patient as healthy as possible
whilst that surgery might be going on
well that's been a reasonable q a
session for you
um if there's any other bits that you
you're interested stick them in the
comments below particularly with any
ideas on further videos that we might be
able to do
one of the things that I'd be very
interested from your perspective is I am
aware that I have literally run out of
time my entire week is packed and some
days I'm doing seven days
I am thinking about setting up a patreon
here in order to be able to do more
YouTube videos because
actually I I think that I'm probably
helping more people than I do in a day
in clinic some days
now in terms of doing that a what do you
guys think about doing that the only
reason why I say I'm thinking about
setting up a patreon is I will need to
stop a days or half a day's work
somewhere else in order to do more
filming so that's one of the reasons for
that but what would you guys get out of
that in terms of patreon well I like and
often fail to do four videos a month so
ideally a clinical examination video a
deep dive video something a little bit
like this a talking video but then I was
thinking of the fourth video of the
month would be something that a the
patreon users would be able to decide
upon and when you know people have
suggested four or five different topics
those topics could be voted on by the
patreon so that you're actually having a
direct impact on what topics we're doing
um that might allow us to do topics that
perhaps aren't as
friendly to the YouTube algorithm so for
example we've had people have asked you
know very good video topics things like
chronic regional pain syndrome and you
know it's small
topics in terms of YouTube but hugely
important for people
at the end of the day this is you know I
need I am beholden to the YouTube
algorithm to some degree so those
slightly more esoteric videos I've not
been able to do but with support from
patreon it may actually be that we can
ignore the algorithm and do at least
more of the videos that you guys want
and similarly you guys would vote for
um if there's any other things that you
think would make patreon a reasonable
consideration for yourselves I'd be
really grateful for you to put that down
in the comments below I'm not I haven't
decided that's what we're going to do
but ultimately I need to try and find
more time in order to be able to do this
so that's perhaps the only option we've
got at the moment
with that in mind thank you for watching
this far please consider liking the
video and subscribing we've got a really
good little Community here and I'm proud
of the positivity that you guys show at
times
um you know and have a look at some of
the comments genuinely that they're
wonderful people coming back after years
to check how somebody else is doing
after they put a comment that on a
medical thing that they're experiencing
so yeah this is a wonderful place and
thank you for my ability to be part of
that with you
take care and we'll see you next one
cheerio