Cleveland’s NEVER ENDING Cycle of Heartbreak Continues After Trading Another Fan Favorite

Baseball Channel
134 followers
There's a lot of painful experiences in this world to have. Getting kicked in the balls,
getting cheated on, hemorrhoids, childbirth, rooting for Cleveland sports. Life is rough,
man. And yeah, especially that last one. The Cleveland Guardians, formerly Indians,
it seems like that city and team can't have anything good. But what makes it even worse,
honestly, is the teases that they get. Like, sometimes I think it'd be better to just suck
all the time rather than what teams like Cleveland go through. They're not historically an awful
franchise, at least not in the last 20 years. They've actually been very competitive and
advanced in building good teams. They were ahead of the game in the analytics department,
the origins of Moneyball started there. But what sucks is no matter how close they get
to the promised land, not only do they just lose in the end, but it feels inevitable.
Every time, no matter how good or magical any recent Indians or Guardians teams have felt,
no matter how much fight they seem to have, you know there's just no way they finish on top.
And they never do. And on top of that, they don't spend a lot of money. And because they
don't spend much money, they have no issue trading anybody. And that's where we get to
the newest reason why Cleveland sports is a sad existence. Really quick, as always,
if you're part of the 59% of viewers not subscribed yet, go ahead and hit that button
if you enjoy the videos as it really is wild when you look at this franchise and how gross it gets
when it comes to keeping their beloved players. Obviously, you cannot keep everyone and that goes
for every single team, even the richest of the rich. But think about it this way. The only star
player Cleveland has been able to keep is Jose Ramirez. And that is the anomaly of anomalies.
Despite being one of the best players in baseball for his entire career, J-Ram took the biggest
discount imaginable. He could have easily gotten at least $250 million with another team. I mean,
Francisco Lindor got over $300 million from the Mets and Ramirez, I think, is a better player.
But he decided to settle for a $141 million contract over 7 years. I mean, the team straight
up told Ramirez that they cannot afford what he's worth. Like, I think they admitted that.
And he told them he didn't care. He was comfortable in Cleveland, saying whether he has $150 million
or $200 million, his life is going to be the same. So the one time the Guardians kept a star,
it's because the player decided to be way too extremely nice. They are beyond lucky to still
have him. But again, that's an anomaly. So anyone else who's good will eventually be traded away,
and Josh Naylor is the newest example of that. Josh Naylor has been one of the most
electric players in baseball since he became a full-time player in 2022.
Before that, he was the 12th overall draft pick by the Marlins in 2015,
got traded a year later to San Diego, where he played with the Padres in 2019 and 2020,
and then the Indians in 2020 and 2021 after getting traded there, but had his 2021 season
ended early because of a nasty collision that broke and dislocated his ankle.
But since coming back in 2022, Naylor's been awesome. He's one of those guys that has that
24-7 look of, I'm going to rip your throat out if you try me. And then when he does the damn thing,
he goes absolutely berserk like an animal, like he's always bottling in that craziness,
and then it unleashes. It's insane. He's insane, but it's part of his game,
and what makes Josh Naylor, Josh Naylor. It's easy to see why he'd be a fan favorite,
other than how good he is from a talent standpoint. And he's only really gotten
better as the years have gone on. He had over 300 in 2023, had his batting average drop a lot for
2024, but then had his power go up. Hitting a career high 31 home runs, he got named an all-star
for the first time, drove in over a hundred RBIs, and his intensity level stayed exactly the same.
He really is and has been a great player and person, I think, to have for this Guardians team.
He's an important bat to a Cleveland team that wasn't very strong offensively, even with him.
So to trade him away isn't very ideal, but with Naylor being just a year away from free agency,
meaning a year from having to pay him more money and United States currency,
and considering Cleveland would rather have Superman destroy progressive field than pay
a player what he's worth, Josh Naylor has been traded to Arizona to join an already
strong Diamondbacks lineup, while an already weak Guardians lineup gets weaker.
There were rumblings about a Josh Naylor trade leading up to this, so it's not the biggest shock
ever, especially when you notice what I just said about how he has only one year left before free
agency. Seattle made the most sense for a landing spot, since they need any type of hitting they can
get, but no, I guess they just don't want it bad enough, and so Naylor becomes a snake.
The Guardians immediately followed this trade with the signing of 39-year-old Carlos Santana
to slot in at first base and replace Naylor, and it will be Santana's third stint in Cleveland.
He's already played there and left two other separate times over his 15-year career.
I like Carlos Santana. He's put up a nice overall career, he really has,
but like I said, he's also almost 40, not as good as he used to be, and
yeah, it sucks, man, to lose yet another fan favorite and impact player while getting pitcher
Slade Ciccone in a competitive balance round B draft pick in return. Ciccone's done nothing
but stink it up so far in his two years of experience in the big leagues. His ERA last
year in 77 innings was over 6.5, but knowing how good Cleveland is at developing pitching,
I wouldn't be surprised to see them unlock something in him, but
Cleveland already has good pitching and a really good bullpen. What they don't have is a good
offense, and then they traded away one of their best hitters. Let me know your thoughts and thank
you for watching.
