The Best Underdog Story of 2025

Baseball Channel
134 followers
This is a story about the platonic ideal of a grinder.
Let me just give you the rundown real quick.
This is the 30 second summary.
If you only have 30 seconds, watch this part
and then watch the rest of the video later
if you're still interested.
He is five foot five.
This isn't about me, to be clear.
He received zero D1 offers.
Again, still not about me.
He went undrafted.
Again, I know all these things
technically match my description as well,
but he was playing Indie Ball less than a year ago
and now this player is knocking on the door
to the big leagues.
If we're rating how much of a grinder he is
on the 20 to 80 scale, he's a 100.
So here is this player's senior year stats
from 2018 at Allatoona High School in Ackworth, Georgia,
where my grandparents used to live.
5.26 average, 5.73 on base, 6.91 slug.
Also stole 17 bases in 39 games.
Despite this, despite a very impressive senior year
of high school, zero D1 offers.
That player's name, by the way, is Peyton Eels
and I believe he is a name worth knowing for 2025.
So with no D1 offer in hand, Peyton Eels goes
to Division II Cedarville to play ball
for the Yellow Jackets.
He is a four-year starter, a shortstop,
and as you can see, continues to perform
at a very high level.
He has a career .382 batting average, .469 on base,
and .505 slugging in his career with Cedarville.
Despite this, he's still not considered
one of the absolute top-of-the-line players
in Division II baseball.
You can see he fails to make the All-American team
his senior year, first, second, or third team
for all of Division II.
He also fails to make one of the regional teams
in the Midwest.
This is the first team for the Midwest in 2022,
second team as well.
He is nowhere to be found.
But thankfully, he is second-team all-conference
for the great Midwest Athletic Conference.
You can see him there at shortstop,
Peyton Eels, Cedarville University.
In terms of the spectrum, this puts him
as better than Israel Espinoza of Lake Erie College,
but worse than Aiden Brewer of Hillsdale College.
So that's the whole story, really good high school player,
really good D2 player, but after four years of college,
he's done, right?
Wrong, because 2020 was, of course,
a COVID-shortened season.
Players got an extra year of eligibility,
meaning he could be a fifth-year super senior and transfer.
And transfer he did.
In 2023, he played out his COVID super senior year
at Division I Coastal Carolina in the Sun Belt,
aka the Fun Belt.
As a Chanticleer, he was arguably more impressive
than he was as a Cedarville Yellow Jacket.
For instance, he was averaging
about 25 walks per season with Cedarville.
He walked 45 times his one year with Coastal Carolina.
That gave him a 500 on base percentage.
He also stole more bases, 25 steals on average
with Cedarville, 42 stolen bases to only six caught
in his year with Coastal Carolina.
Coastal's baseball program's a pretty big deal,
and that's sort of indicated by the talent
that Peyton Eels was surrounded by.
He was most notably out OPSed by Kayden Bodine,
who is likely going to be a first-round draft pick
this summer in 2025, as well as Derek Bender,
who was a sixth-rounder for the Minnesota Twins
last summer in 2024.
But with regards to Peyton Eels,
the draft we're concerned with is the 2023 draft,
which followed the summer after his COVID super senior year
with Coastal Carolina.
The first name called that day was Paul Skeens.
He, of course, signed for a record-breaking signing bonus
with the Pirates, and after the 614th name was called,
20 rounds later, Peyton Eels went undrafted.
I mean, even DJ Ungelele, who is a college quarterback
and did not play college baseball at all,
was selected by the Dodgers in the 20th round,
but no Peyton Eels, and why is that?
One thing to keep in mind is that in MLB draft terms,
Peyton Eels is old.
He's gonna turn 24 a few months after his draft year.
That makes him two or three years older
than the college juniors
that are getting drafted ahead of him.
That means basically the gap between him
and some of these college juniors is similar to the gap
between the college juniors and the high school seniors.
So he's just older than the typical draftee,
and that would be one reason beyond the height,
beyond just sort of the profile,
why he could be looked over.
So that's the story, right?
Exceptional high school player, exceptional D2 player,
proves he can be an exceptional D1 player,
but now it's time to enter the real world.
Now it's time to learn LinkedIn, buddy.
We all have a digital footprint.
Mine is probably a lot bigger than it should be,
but Peyton Eels is no exception.
Maybe Peyton Eels, after five years of college baseball,
it is time for you to put that
bachelor's in civil engineering to work.
I know you're a smart guy.
I know you won a bunch of scholar-athlete-type awards
throughout your baseball career.
Maybe it's time for you to continue to work
as a substitute slash parapro
for the Cobb County School District.
Or maybe not.
Maybe it's time to hop on board
with the Chicago Dogs of the American Association.
That's indie ball, folks.
And because he joined right after college,
he becomes one of the youngest hitters in the league
and also one of the best.
He finishes 17th overall in terms of batting average,
and he ends up with a higher OPS
than some players who have played in the big leagues,
like Delano DeShields Jr. and Oduble Herrera.
Not just guys who cameoed in the big leagues,
like guys who had actual big league careers.
He is out hitting them straight out of Coastal Carolina.
And does the opportunity come for him now?
Does he get the chance now to play affiliated ball
in a major league team's minor league system?
No!
And around this time, he's turning not to LinkedIn,
but rather to YouTube to post his highlight videos
to try to advertise his services.
And I appreciate him for that
because a lot of these clips you're seeing of him
come from there.
So check out Peyton Neal's on YouTube.
Like and subscribe.
So in February 2024, less than a year ago,
he joins the Atlantic League's Southern Maryland Blue Crabs.
And you know what he does next?
He has a power outburst.
This is, of course, a classic scrappy,
hit for average steel bases type of player.
Four home runs in 47 games his last year at Cedarville.
Four home runs in 63 games
his last year at Coastal Carolina.
Three home runs in 39 games
with the Chicago Dogs of the American Association.
And with the Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
in the Atlantic League, he has three home runs in six games.
And then finally, early in the 2024 season,
thanks to his great performance in the Atlantic League,
the Minnesota Twins come a knocking.
And as detailed in this excellent Baseball America article
from author Phil Miller,
it is the Twins' farm director, Drew McPhail,
who remembers signing him for $500.
A $500 signing bonus for Peyton Neal's.
So does the five foot five, 180 pound Peyton Neal's
make it to minor league baseball and say,
huh, it's nice to be here.
Maybe I can just stick around a little bit
and prove that I belong.
No, he rakes.
He rakes.
He destroys everybody in A ball.
He has a 331 average, 448 on base and 517 slug.
Promoted to high A five weeks later in high A.
He's walking 20% of the time, striking out 6% of the time.
That's a 473 on base percentage.
Twins have some injury issues at AAA.
They move him up to AAA.
He never comes back down in AAA.
He has a 299 average, 419 on base, 500 slug in 64 games.
He steals 20 bases at that level.
That means across the entire 2024 season,
he plays 111 games.
His OPS is above 900.
He steals 41 bases and he's doing this
the majority of his playing time at AAA.
He doesn't just make it to minor league baseball.
He excels in minor league baseball.
Among Twins minor leaguers
with at least 300 played appearances on the season,
he leads the minor league system in average,
on base percentage and slugging.
So with Peyton Eels finishing strong
at the AAA level in 2024,
there is opportunity for him in 2025
at the big league level with the Minnesota Twins.
I'm looking at the second base position here in particular.
Brooks Lee, Eddie Julian, Austin Martin even,
all three of these guys were not particularly great
at the big league level in 2024.
There's opportunity here for Peyton Eels.
He could become the ultimate underdog story
and make his big league debut in 2025.
And it's not just second base.
There is serious utility here coming off the bench
potentially at the big league level.
We're talking about a guy who played second base,
third base, shortstop, left field, center field,
and right field in the minor leagues last year.
And thanks to the power of Stat Head, Code Foolish 20,
we now know he would become just the 11th player
listed height five foot five or shorter
to debut in the big league since the integration era.
And only the second player to meet that criteria
in the last 50 years alongside Esteban Quiroz.
Keep in mind the obvious comparison,
Jose Altuve is listed five foot six
even though he's probably five foot four.
And of course, Peyton Eels has taken notice
when it comes to his height.
He has said, there's a lot of guys at the big league level
I saw performing at my size.
Guys like Jose Altuve, Dustin Pedroia, and Nick Madrigal.
Some of those guys showed me, hey, this is possible.
And deep inside myself, I knew I could do it
if I really wanted to.
If Peyton Eels makes the big leagues for one day in 2025,
he will make approximately eight times his signing bonus.
Until then, to save some money,
I think he should use SeatGeekCodeFoolish
for $20 off his first purchase.
Not just baseball, guys.
Here's some basketball tickets for this year.
Looking at the Hawks game,
this is rated a 10 out of 10 on the deal score, $46 each.
That is including fees.
This could be your view, guys, SeatGeekCodeFoolish.
