In this exclusive expose, we'll explore: 🚀 How Bernard Arnault climbed to a staggering net worth of $200 billion and became the second richest man in the world. 👜 The colossal LVMH conglomerate that owns Louis Vuitton, Fendi, Celine, Bvlgari, Hennessy, and over 70 other brands. 💼 Arnault's shrewd and, at times, ruthless strategies that earned him the nickname “Wolf in Cashmere”. 💸 How this master of financial engineering acquired almost HALF the shares of a HALF TRILLION DOLLAR company. All materials in these videos are used for educational purposes and fall within the guidelines of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. If you are or represent the copyright owner of materials used in this video and have a problem with the use of said material, please send me an email, wallstreetmillennial.com, and we can sort it out.
With a net worth of $200 billion, the French businessman Bernard Arnault is the richest
man in Europe, and the second richest man in the world, although the position on the
top spot changes every few weeks based on the erratic moves of Tesla's share price.
Arnault is the CEO, chairman, and controlling shareholder of LVMH, the massive luxury conglomerate
behind Louis Vuitton, Fendi, Celine, Bvlgari, Hennessy, and 70 other brands.
With such a powerful portfolio of iconic brands, it's unsurprising that LVMH has attained
a half-trillion-dollar market cap, and with Arnault owning about 40% of the shares, he
has become one of the richest people in the world.
But you might be surprised to hear that Arnault is not the founder of LVMH.
In fact, he hasn't founded a single fashion company in his life.
So how is it possible for him to acquire almost half the shares of a half-trillion-dollar
company?
Arnault amassed his position of wealth and power through a multi-decade-long scheme of
financial engineering, anti-competitive business strategies, backstabbing, and exploitation.
Join us as we peel back the layers of the onion and see how Bernard Arnault earned the
moniker Wolf in Kashmir.
Bernard was born into a wealthy family in France, with his father owning a successful
real estate company.
After graduating from an elite French university, he started working in the family business,
becoming president after his dad retired.
In the early 1980s, Bernard moved to New York, hoping to expand the family real estate business
into the US.
This was during the Reagan era of deregulation, and Wall Street was becoming increasingly
sophisticated with its financial engineering.
One of the most significant developments of this era was the rise of private equity firms,
or corporate raiders as they were called at the time.
They would identify publicly traded companies which they viewed as being mismanaged, then
proceed to borrow a bunch of money and take the company private via a hostile takeover.
They would then replace the entire management team, lay off workers, and liquidate some
or all of the business.
When done right, this can be extremely lucrative, because the investment returns are multiplied
by leverage.
Arnault was captivated by the obscene amounts of money that America's corporate raiders
were making in such a short period of time.
It was anathema to the conservative culture of family-run businesses in Europe, where
wealth is slowly accumulated over generations.
Arnault took his learnings from New York and went back to France.
He was dead set on disrupting the sleepy luxury fashion industry.
Upon returning to France, Bernard Arnault set his sights on Boussac Saint-Ferrez, a
beleaguered conglomerate with operations in clothing manufacturing and retail.
The company had recently declared bankruptcy, but nobody wanted to buy it out of bankruptcy
court because it was seen as a failed business.
With investor interest so low, Arnault was able to buy it for just $60 million.
He used $15 million from his family fortune and secured a loan for the remaining $45 million.
So why was Arnault willing to buy this failed business that nobody else in France wanted?
Armed with what he learned in America, Arnault was able to view Boussac differently from
his French peers.
Amidst the struggling segments of Boussac's portfolio, there was one sparkling gem.
Dior, a prosperous luxury fashion house steeped in rich history.
As a standalone company, Dior would be extremely valuable, worth far more than $60 million,
but it was being dragged down by the rest of the group.
Upon taking control of Boussac, Arnault swiftly implemented his private equity playbook, laying
off 9,000 employees and liquidating most of Boussac's assets, except for Dior.
With these actions, he turned a bloated, unprofitable conglomerate into a much smaller, but profitable
company.
With the successful acquisition of Dior, Arnault had already established his net worth in the
hundreds of millions of dollars, but this was just the beginning of his ambitions.
Louis Vuitton was and still is one of the most prestigious luxury brands in France.
It was founded by a woodworker named Louis Vuitton in 1854, who made wooden trunks for
horse-drawn carriages.
Eventually they expanded to leather handbags and clothing items, which is what it is best
known for today.
Control of Louis Vuitton was passed down through the generations, and in the 1980s it was run
by Henri Racamier, who married into the Vuitton family.
One of Racamier's biggest fears was that an outside investor would make a hostile bid
to buy out the company.
While most shareholders would love to receive a buyout offer at a premium to the current
share price, family-run businesses often take a completely different view.
They don't care about the financial gain alone, they want to maintain control of their business
empire so they can pass it down to future generations.
As a standalone company with a relatively small market cap, Louis Vuitton would be a
bite-sized target for larger European conglomerates.
Racamier came to the conclusion that it was eat or be eaten.
The only way he could prevent a larger competitor from acquiring Louis Vuitton was to make Louis
Vuitton too big to acquire.
He accomplished this by merging with the luxury alcohol company Moet Hennessy to form the
combined company LVMH.
Moet Hennessy is a premium alcohol brand producing expensive champagne and cognac.
It was structured as an all-stock merger.
The Vuitton, Hennessy, and Moet families would collectively own 51% of the combined company.
If they all stuck together, a hostile takeover would be mathematically impossible.
Everything appeared to be going smoothly.
The combined LVMH company would be too big for an outside company to acquire, allowing
control to stay within the Vuitton family.
While Racamier thought he was building walls to defend Louis Vuitton from corporate invaders,
he had inadvertently let the enemy in through the front door.
Before the merger, Moet Hennessy was run by a man named Alan Chevalier.
Chevalier and Racamier agreed to a power-sharing arrangement where Racamier would run the fashion
side of the business while Chevalier would run the alcohol side.
This was an untenable way to run the combined company because the two men almost immediately
had disagreements about the strategic direction of the company.
Specifically, Racamier thought that Louis Vuitton was given a back seat compared to
the larger alcohol business.
Around this time, Racamier gained the acquaintance of Bernard Arnault, who would become a rising
star in the luxury industry following his successful takeover of Dior.
Given Arnault's success in the fashion industry, Racamier believed he would be a much more
suitable business partner than the Hennessy and Moet families.
Racamier offered a proposal to Arnault.
Using his existing wealth as leverage, Arnault would purchase 25% of LVMH's stock on the
open market.
Arnault had already amassed a personal fortune of hundreds of millions of dollars as a result
of his masterful Dior acquisition.
Plus, he had good relations with investment banks who could lend him money as well, so
he would have the financial wherewithal to buy 25% of LVMH's shares.
With this, the Vuitton family and Arnault combined would own a controlling stake in
LVMH.
They could then push out the Hennessy and Moet families, allowing the Vuitton and Arnault
families to run LVMH together as equals.
But Arnault had much bigger ambitions.
Instead of sharing power with Racamier, he wanted the whole company to himself, and the
infighting between Racamier and Chevalier gave him an opening.
Arnault teamed up with the Irish alcohol giant Guinness, and together they bought 24% of
Guinness was interested in LVMH because they wanted to form a strategic partnership with
Moet and Hennessy.
Guinness could leverage their existing distribution network in the UK and North America to greatly
increase sales of these alcohol brands.
Arnault promised Guinness that they could get this strategic partnership, so long as
they supported him becoming chairman and CEO of LVMH.
In addition to the 24% he bought together with Guinness, Bernard bought an additional
$1 billion worth of shares on his own, bringing his ownership stake to 43.5%.
This made Arnault the single largest shareholder in LVMH, although he didn't quite own a
controlling stake.
He convinced the Moet and Hennessy families, who collectively owned 18% of the shares,
to support him.
Having secured more than 50% of the shares to vote in his favor, Arnault was able to
kick out Racamier and install himself as chairman and CEO.
When Arnault took control of LVMH in 1989, it had a market cap of just $5 billion.
Today, that value has increased 100-fold to almost $500 billion.
So how were they able to achieve such an extraordinary growth rate?
Since Arnault took over, the company has been on a non-stop acquisition spree, doing a major
acquisition almost every single year.
These include the cosmetics retailer Sephora, the watchmaker Tag Heuer, the fur and leather
clothing maker Fendi, the jewelry producer Tiffany, and many others.
These acquisitions are largely responsible for driving LVMH's revenue and share price
growth.
The cumulative cost of these acquisitions adds up to almost $50 billion, the vast majority
of which was paid in cash.
So where did they get this money?
They borrowed it.
LVMH's debt has been increasing substantially, from about 5 billion euros in 2008 to almost
20 billion euros today.
Despite the large amount of leverage, the company has maintained a pristine credit rating,
allowing them to issue bonds at very low interest rates.
As they acquire rival fashion brands, this increases the group's operating profit.
The higher operating profit means they have a greater ability to service debt, so lenders
are willing to lend them even more money.
They use this to do even more acquisitions and repeat the cycle.
Of course, this strategy only works if LVMH can increase the operating profit of the brands
they acquire.
For example, in 2020 they acquired the American jewelry company Tiffany.
Within two years of LVMH's ownership, profits doubled.
While Tiffany is perhaps an extreme example, they have consistently been able to increase
the profits of brands they acquire.
There are a few ways they have done this.
Firstly, the luxury goods industry as a whole has been growing at a compound annual rate
of 6% per year over the past decade.
This far exceeds GDP growth, with the majority of the growth coming from China.
As the Chinese economy grew, more and more people could afford luxury items, resulting
in sales growth across the industry.
But this is only part of the story.
By acquiring so many brands, LVMH has amassed the tremendous power to set prices and crush
their competitors.
While China is the most important market for luxury goods today, up until the mid-2000s,
the top spot was occupied by Japan.
At the time, Japan was the world's second largest economy, and they had a massive upper
American and European fashion brands alike were expanding aggressively into the country,
and competition was fierce.
One of the brands attempting to make inroads in Japan was the leather purse maker, Coach.
According to Coach, LVMH representatives contacted Japanese department stores, and threatened
to stop selling them LVMH products if they also sold Coach products.
They could either sell LVMH or Coach, but not both.
Given the massive number of brands under the LVMH umbrella, most of the department stores
chose the French conglomerate.
If these allegations were true, this behavior would be blatantly anti-competitive and illegal.
In 2005, Coach made an official complaint to the Japan Fair Trade Commission.
The commission ultimately ruled in favor of LVMH, as they did not find sufficient evidence
of anti-competitive behavior.
According to Coach, LVMH stopped its anti-competitive behavior only after they filed the lawsuit.
So by the time the commission made its ruling, the offending activity had already been stopped.
As an outside observer, it's difficult to tell what actually happened.
It's possible that Coach was over-exaggerating their claims against LVMH, but what is indisputable
is that LVMH's consolidation of the industry had given them a tremendous amount of market
power, and we can see this in the numbers.
One of Louis Vuitton's most popular products is their Speedy bag.
They've been selling this bag since 1930, so we can use it as a proxy for how Louis
Vuitton has increased its prices over time.
According to an analysis by Luxfront, the price of the Speedy 25 bag in the US has increased
from $350 in 1998 to $1350 in 2022.
Adjusted for inflation, the 1998 price is equivalent to about $600 today.
In real terms, the price of the bag has more than doubled over the past 20 years.
In fact, this actually understates the price increases.
In 2011, they launched the Speedy B, which is the exact same thing but with a shoulder
strap added.
This shoulder strap will cost you an additional $300.
Only a company with significant market power can do something as ridiculous as charging
an extra $300 for a strap.
The price increases are not the result of the bag becoming more advanced or increasing
in quality.
The only difference is that the industry is more consolidated today than it was 20 years
ago.
Many of Louis Vuitton's competitors are owned by LVMH, allowing the company to strategically
limit the quantity produced to achieve higher prices.
The benefits of LVMH's market dominance can be seen in their ability to raise prices faster
than their competitors.
According to an analysis by Deloitte, Louis Vuitton increased its prices in China by 11%
in 2020, despite the pandemic.
This increase was far higher than competing luxury brands.
Now we can start to see the rationale behind all of their acquisitions.
By gaining more and more control, LVMH has achieved near-monopoly status, allowing them
to raise prices, increase profits, and acquire even more of their competitors.
Of course, generating revenue is only half the battle.
Your profits are also determined by how much it costs you to generate that revenue.
When people shell out $2,000 for a jacket, they expect the quality to be very high, and
producing high-quality products costs a lot of money.
For Louis Vuitton and most of LVMH's other premium brands, they manufacture the products
in France or Italy.
This is a major selling point for consumers.
If a bag is handmade in Italy by highly skilled artisans, it reasons to believe its quality
will be far higher than mass-produced bags you would find at Walmart.
Louis Vuitton posted this video on their official YouTube channel, showing the inner workings
of one of their factories in France.
It has over 13 million views.
This is the side of the supply chain that they want you to see.
According to European Union regulations, when a product is made in more than one country,
the country of origin is the one where the item underwent the last, substantial, economically
justified processing.
It appears that LVMH's lawyers spent tremendous efforts finding the bare minimum amount of
processing they can do in Italy, and still put on a made-in-Italy label.
In 2017, The Guardian investigated a contract manufacturer in Romania that made shoes for
Louis Vuitton.
They would complete everything except for the sole, which was then sent to a factory
in Italy to attach the sole.
This way, they could put a made-in-Italy label even though the majority of the work was done
in Romania.
The factory building also had no visible logos on the outside, and its managers took great
pains to conceal the fact that they were supplying Louis Vuitton.
Romania is a far poorer country than Italy, and workers at the factory are paid the equivalent
of $300 per month, a fraction of what equivalent Italian workers would make.
When confronted with this information, Bernard Arnault denied that Louis Vuitton makes its
shoes in Romania.
But eventually, The Guardian gained access to insiders at the Romanian contract manufacturing
facility, and confirmed that they are in fact suppliers to Louis Vuitton.
One of the most difficult types of clothing to make are hand-embroidered lace dresses
such as the one sold by Dior, an LVMH company.
For some complex designs, it can take hundreds of hours of labor to produce one dress.
Even if you sell the dress for thousands of dollars, this can be prohibitively expensive.
According to an investigation by the New York Times, Dior uses contractors based in India
who pay their workers the equivalent of a few dollars per day, and offer unsafe working
conditions.
Now we can see how Bernard Arnault became the world's second richest man.
He conducts leveraged buyouts of his competitors, gaining market power and raising prices.
He then ships the manufacturing overseas to minimize the costs and thus maximize profits.
Higher profits allows him to borrow even more money, rent in repeat.
If you look at LVMH's portfolio of 75 brands, most of them are what you would expect.
Premium alcohol, leather goods, perfumes, watches, and cosmetics retailers.
But the last category seems off.
The conglomerate owns a collection of some of France's most popular newspapers.
Specifically, they own Les Echos, Investeur, and Le Parisien, which collectively have millions
of regular readers in France.
These newspapers contribute a miniscule amount of revenue, little more than a rounding error
compared to the luxury brands.
Not only that, but they are also burning cash.
In 2022, the parent company had to inject more money into Le Parisien to offset its
losses.
Why would Bernard Arnault, one of the world's most savvy businessmen, acquire these newspapers
which lose money and have nothing to do with the core business?
I first thought they might be trying to influence editorial decisions to promote their luxury
brands.
But this doesn't make any sense.
The newspapers that they own are normal newspapers that cover topics about the economy, politics,
financial markets, national and world events, etc.
They're not fashion magazines, they're just normal newspapers.
Also, they only publish in the French language, giving them substantially zero readership
abroad.
With only 6% of the group's sales coming from France, this wouldn't be enough to move the
needle anyway.
The rationale for buying these newspapers is not to advertise their fashion brands,
it's far more sinister.
On November 25th, 2019, LVMH entered into a definitive agreement to acquire the American
Large acquisitions like this one always take at least a few months to close, as they require
shareholder votes and regulatory approval.
Within a few months after the deal was announced, the pandemic began, which greatly reduced
international tourism, a key source of Tiffany's sales.
This caused same-store sales to decline a whopping 44%.
LVMH's own sales were declining for the same reason.
Arnault was worried about the financial health of the company.
Paying $16 billion in cash would stretch their balance sheet thin, at the worst possible
time.
He wanted to pull out of the deal, but because he had already signed a definitive agreement,
he was legally obligated to follow through.
At the same time, it just so happened that the US and France were in the middle of a
trade spat.
France had recently proposed a tax on internet companies that would affect US tech giants
like Google and Facebook.
The US responded by threatening tariffs on French imports, specifically luxury goods.
On August 31st, 2020, the French Foreign Minister, Jean-Yves Le Drian, sent a letter to Bernard
Arnault, saying, quote,
The American government has decided to implement an additional customs duty on the import of
certain French goods, in particular goods in the luxury sector.
France considers these measures legally objectionable.
Proposed investments by French companies in sectors that could be subject to such sanctions
must be reevaluated in light of this new context.
In order to support the steps taken vis-à-vis the American government, you should defer
the closing of the pending Tiffany transaction until January 6th, 2021.
I am sure that you will understand the need to take part in our country's efforts to defend
its national interests."
Unquote.
LVMH put out a press release saying that the French Foreign Affairs Minister sent them
a letter directing them to defer their acquisition until after January 6th, 2021.
Because the acquisition agreement had an expiration date of December 31st, 2020, it would not
be possible to complete it.
LVMH claimed the situation was out of their control.
The French government was forcing them to abandon the merger because of an unrelated
trade dispute.
The fact that LVMH itself wanted to pull out of the deal anyway was just a lucky coincidence.
Analysts were immediately suspicious of the letter.
During a press conference, LVMH's CFO was asked point-blank whether the company had
sought help from the government to block the deal.
He replied, quote,
"...you must be joking.
Are you seriously suggesting that we procured the letter?
I don't even want to answer that question."
Unquote.
However, this story quickly fell apart.
Responding to questions by French lawmakers, Foreign Minister Drian revealed that he wrote
the letter in response to a query the ministry received from LVMH.
This contradicted the conglomerate's claim that the letter was unsolicited.
Shortly thereafter, Bloomberg reported that Arnaud himself contacted the foreign ministry,
asking them to help him pull out of the deal.
With LVMH having been exposed, they finally agreed to follow through.
Although not before Tiffany agreed to a $400 million price cut, representing 2.5% of the
purchase price.
The Tiffany controversy exposes a troublingly close relationship between Arnaud and the
French government, with Arnaud having been a public supporter of President Emmanuel Macron.
Arnaud successfully established LVMH as a strategically important company for France,
putting him in a position where he can call up high-ranking government officials to help
with his legal battles.
The fact that he owns three of the country's most-read newspapers possibly gives him influence
over politicians and greater access to government officials.
Arnaud's control over the news media also has other consequences.
In 2016, a left-wing activist and filmmaker named François Ruffin produced a documentary
film called Merci Patron, which translates to Thanks, Boss.
The documentary interviewed former employees of Boussac Saint-Ferrez, who were laid off
after Arnaud took the company over back in the 1980s.
Needless to say, it is highly critical of Mr. Arnaud and LVMH.
Bernard Arnaud was not amused.
In fact, he was so angry that he banned any of the three newspapers that LVMH owned from
even mentioning the film.
Alright guys, that wraps it up for this video.
What do you think about Bernard Arnaud?
Let us know in the comments section below.
As always, thank you so much for watching and we'll see you in the next one.
Wall Street Millennial, signing out.