Comparing The Brynje Mesh Base Layer to My Old Thru-hiking Base Layers

AROUND THE WORLD
406 followers
#trevel #longwalk #adventure #backpacking
00:00 Hey Y'all
01:20 My Initial Thoughts
02:11 Taking Them Out In The Snow
05:02 Some Info On The Polypropylene Mesh Fiber
06:29 Wet Tests
07:37 How Much Extra Weight of Moisture Held
07:53 Comfort While Wet
08:23 Drying Times
09:10 Benefit of Mesh of Solid Knit
09:44 Prices
10:41 Durability
11:26 Closing Thoughts
Places to buy (no affiliate links):
https://www.brynjeusa.com
Homemade Wanderlust Merch: https://homemadewanderlust.com/shop/
Hey y'all, Dixie here. It's doing something very rare in my hometown. It is snowing. Of course the
whole town and most of the state for that matter are completely shut down because we don't have
the equipment to deal with the roads, but it made it a perfect day to test out a new base layer that
I've been wanting to try for a while, which is a base layer made by Brynja in Norway. I've been
wanting to get one of these base layers to try out for a while, but I was pregnant, so I didn't
want to have like a pregnant size and then a normal size, so I was just waiting until I had my baby
so that I could just have one size. Then I saw in the fall that Garage Grown Gear started selling
them on their website, so I went ahead and bought one because I was hoping to try it out and sneak
out a video before the larger American YouTube backpacking channels inevitably started putting
out information about them, but unfortunately my son has been extremely colicky pretty much
since like two weeks after birth, but I finally got this golden opportunity to at least circle
around the block and test out this base layer compared to a couple of my old trustees. So anyway,
better late than never, but fair warning, Garage Grown Gear's more popular sizes have already sold
out. But anyway, now I want to go into my thoughts on this new base layer. So the crazy thing to me
about this base layer when I first saw it is that it's holy, not in the way that you'd wear it to
church, but in the way that it's like mesh. I was not aware until recently, but apparently
mesh as a base layer has been a thing in the outdoor world for quite a while, including the
first ascent of Mount Everest back in 1953. I ended up purchasing the women's base layer that
has the modesty panel and in hindsight I honestly wish that I hadn't done that because I would only
be hiding my sports bra. So to compare this mesh base layer to a couple of the ones that I've used
for several years now, one of those is a Wool-X base layer and the other one is an Arc'teryx
zip base layer. So first I wanted to just see how these base layers felt while walking outside
in the cold. The first shirt I decided to try is the Arc'teryx shirt. I just figured I'd go in order
from what I would naturally feel like is the warmest option. It's heavier, so like the weight of
the shirt weighs more than the other options. Also it feels the thickest and it's like fuzzy on the
inside. So naturally I would feel like this one would keep me the warmest. So I thought I'd start
with it and then go down to what I would think would be the coldest and see if I do indeed kind
of feel colder as I go. So I'd say when I first started out from my warm house of course my
upper body felt pretty warm. I am starting to cool off a little bit now with the Arc'teryx shirt
and I'm just getting back home now. So I'm gonna thaw out a little bit when I get in and
change and then see how I feel about the other two. Alright, shirt number two is a Wool-X shirt that I
got from Amazon several years ago. This Wool-X shirt is definitely more lightweight than the
Arc'teryx, almost by half. And I was gonna say that right out of the house I can't really tell a big
difference, but I don't know. I feel like I'm already starting to get a little more chilly
on my body. While wool I know is a good option because it still has insulating properties even
when it gets wet, I would have needed probably a heavier weight wool than the one that I have on,
which it's pretty lightweight. I am going to wet these shirts and do like a drying test just to see
how long it takes all of them to dry. Alright, so now I've got on the mesh shirt. This one
obviously I would naturally think would not be as warm because it's got a bunch of holes in it.
This mesh top is just slightly heavier than my Wool-X shirt by 0.2 ounces. So I feel like it's
pretty compatible as far as that goes. But right out the gate I would say that this shirt feels
at least as warm as the Wool-X did starting out. I don't think it feels quite as warm as the
Arc'teryx shirt did. Again, that one's a lot more heavyweight. I do like when I put on the shirt that
it's actually long. For my torso, shirts usually are just kind of too short or, you know, aren't
super long so I can't tuck them in if I want to. For this, I haven't tucked in any of them. And this
specific fabric is called, I assume it's pronounced poly-colon. It has one of the lowest surface
tensions of all synthetic functional fibers. So it's not supposed to retain moisture and it's
supposed to stay dry. Another cool thing that I saw on their website is it is supposed to be
resistant to high heats, which is important if you're trying to like wash and dry at high heat.
And that's pretty convenient as far as being a through hiker goes because with wool, which is
one of the go-to base layers for through hikers, you have to watch putting it in the dryer on high
heat because it will shrink things up. And so you don't typically on a through hike have a lot of
time to like air dry things or allow things to take a long time to dry. So having something that
you could wash and dry at high heat would be convenient in that way. But if you're a wool fan,
Brinia does offer this in a wool option also. So I am arriving back at the house and I would say
I can't tell a huge difference between this base layer and the Wool-X base layer.
Maybe it's slightly warmer, but for sure the Arcteryx takes the cake as far as how warm my
body has felt just circling the block. But you really can't determine what is the best base
layer obviously from just what keeps you the warmest in a singular moment, you know, walking
around in cold temperatures. There are other things to consider like what happens if you get sweaty or
if you get rained on. And yes, even if it's cold outside when you're backpacking, you can definitely
sweat. Climbing a hill, exerting yourself, you know, before you know it you can work up some heat
and get sweaty. And then you slow down, you cool off quickly, and you can become hypothermic. So I
felt like another good comparison would be how these things seem to do with being wet. To try to
make sure they had equal wetness, I ran them on a quick wash cycle, didn't add any detergent or
anything like that, but I wanted them to get all equally wet and then all equally spun out or at
least as close as possible. So one thing to note is how much moisture these garments will actually
hold. So I had the weight before when they were dry and then of course once they were wet. The
Arcteryx shirt held 4.5 ounces of water, the Wool-X shirt held 3.75 ounces of water, and the
Mesh shirt held 2.35 ounces of water. So the Mesh had the least water retention, then the Wool,
then the Arcteryx shirt. I also tried all three on while wet just to see the comfort level of being
soaked in these different base layers. I would say if I had to be out in the freezing cold snow
with one of these shirts wet, the most comfortable would be the Mesh shirt. Then the next was the
Arcteryx shirt and then the Wool-X shirt. This one's worse.
So of course drying time of these base layers matters as well, so I hung all three of them up
and timed their drying times. The Mesh shirt dried the most quickly. The Mesh part was dry
around two hours, then about two and a half hours for the modesty panel and like the sleeve cuffs
and things like that to be completely dry. The Wool shirt was dry at the three-hour mark,
and then the Arcteryx coming in last at the four-hour mark. But another thing to consider
with the wetness and drying of these shirts is the idea behind the Mesh shirt is you will have
more ventilation, so you're not supposed to get super sweaty and wet, so it may not ever even
reach saturation level. And something else interesting to note about fabrics in general,
there was a study done back in 1990. It's in the European Journal of Applied Physiology and
Occupational Physiology titled, Thermoregulatory Responses to Intermittent Exercise Are Influenced
by Knit Structure of Underwear. And that talks about the structure of the fabric itself being
maybe more important than even what the fabric itself is, especially in regard to
the fishnet structure. So moving along, we've talked about weight, so now obviously price is
something that folks want to know about when they're picking out backpacking gear. The Arcteryx
shirt I bought years ago, I'm pretty sure I ordered it on Amazon at the time. I don't recall how much
it cost and I couldn't find where I had purchased it, but the comparable products out there right
now by Arcteryx cost about $140. And if I remember correctly, it was over $100 back then. When I
bought the Wool-X shirt from Amazon, I only paid $55 for it. You can't even get Wool-X on Amazon
right now, but on their website, they're like $130, so they got real proud of their stuff.
But comparable stuff on Amazon right now is probably going to run you anywhere from $70
to $100. And this mesh shirt from Garage Grown Gear cost me $65. Now just a word on the durability
of these garments. The Arcteryx shirt and the Wool-X shirt I have had for years. I mainly use
them for sleeping while on a thru-hike. They've taken the occasional trip to a cold destination
and have been used as a base layer. So they've held up very well over the years. With that said,
I have a small hole on my Wool shirt, but I don't think it's affected the functionality of it at
all. I can't speak specifically to the durability of the mesh shirt, but from what Brynja claims,
the polypropylene is extremely durable. It's got a very high strength to weight ratio,
so they say it should be able to withstand years of extreme use. I'm really interested to see how
well this new backpacking fad, if you will, really kind of sticks. At least here in the U.S.,
as I mentioned before, while I'm on thru-hikes, I generally just sleep in base layers. It's like
my night-night clothes. I don't typically hike in them, and I feel like that's pretty much the same.
Most thru-hikers aren't using base layers to actually hike in. Now, that is obviously different
at maybe the ends of the thru-hike. If you start off early in the spring and then you're finishing
late in the fall in snow and rough conditions, then there might be some base layer use for
actually hiking at those points. But I think that this is really going to be up to the folks who
enjoy going winter backpacking to kind of keep this thing going as far as mesh base layers.
But hopefully at some point I can actually put this thing into action on a colder backpacking
trip and see how it holds up to the things that I'm used to using, you know, in the field when
I'm getting sweaty and exerting myself. But these are just my initial findings and thoughts. If any
of y'all have experience with the Bernia base layers, whether it's the polypropylene one or
the wool, I'm really curious to see what your thoughts are on how they perform while you're
backpacking or, you know, doing outdoor sports. But on that note, I hear my son screaming downstairs,
so I'm gonna wrap this up. Thank y'all so much for watching and we will see y'all next time.
