Dana Gold remarks: Rights, Recourses, and Resources for DOJ Employees Targeted by Trump

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Feb 3, 2025
Dana Gold, Senior Director of Advocacy & Strategy and the Director of the Democracy Protection Initiative, Government Accountability Project delivers an opening statement at the Democratic briefing, titled "Rights, Recourses, and Resources for DOJ Employees Targeted by Trump."
my name is Dana gold I serve as senior
director of advoc strategy and director
of the Democracy protection initiative
of the government accountability project
a nonprofit nonpartisan public interest
whistleblower protection and advocacy
organization that for nearly 50 years
has sought to promote government and
corporate accountability by protecting
whistleblowers and ensuring their
disclosures make a difference government
accountability project has LED or been
on the front lines of campaigns to enact
or defend nearly all modern
whistleblower laws passed by by Congress
including the Whistleblower protection
act of 1989 as well as the 1994 and 2012
amendments to this legislation um this
is the primary law that empowers federal
employees to report violations of laws
rules or regulations grossness
management gross waste of funds abuses
of authority and substantial and
specific dangers to the public health
and safety free from retaliation and The
Whistleblower protection act is embedded
in the civil service reform Act of 1978
which is the Cornerstone legislation
that protects the Merit system that has
been in place since 1883 to ensure that
federal civil servants are loyal to the
Constitution and the rule of law rather
than to a president Administration or
party and are protected from
inappropriate political interference in
their hiring firing and the execution of
their work fulfilling the mission of
their agencies that serve the Public's
interests they have due process rights
protected in the Merit System including
but not limited to their rights to
report wrongdoing to refuse to obey
illegal orders and not and to not be
gagged from exercising their speech
rights these rights encourage expertise
continuity and commitment to government
service rather than political patronage
but more importantly they recognize that
employees committed to compliance with
and in the doj's case enforcement of the
Constitution and laws passed by Congress
are the best mechanism for
accountability because they are in the
best positions to discover prevent or
mitigate serious illegality abuses of
power and dangers to public health and
safety not only do we just need part
nonpartisan civil servants to execute
the functions of government that touch
on every aspect of Our Lives we need
them to be able to warn against
misconduct that undermines those very
functions such as protecting against
unsafe meat poultry or baby food nuclear
weapons explosions Health Care fraud and
Railroad and airplane disasters like the
tragic one that occurred earlier this
week the Relentless battery of attacks
on the Cil servants across the
government and particularly at the doj
it's a blatant effort to literally
remove or drive out the federal
employees who are the guardrails of
accountability and indeed these efforts
consistently executed without compliance
with employees due process rights and in
many cases amounting to prohibited
Personnel practices have the additional
effect of chilling employees from
exercising their rights to blow the
whistle or defy a legal orders for fear
of suffering retaliation with impunity
further undermining enforcement and
account ility mechanisms by suppressing
reports of evidence of misconduct the
fears of retaliation and futility which
are the two primary reasons employees
stay silent in the face of wrongdoing
could not be more real in an age of
political violence and profound
challenges in the Integrity
functionality or sometimes both of the
three branches of government my
colleagues today have here have talked
about challenges to many of the actions
targeted at wide swaths of employees
working on matters undesirable to the
current
Administration such as Dei initiatives
the fork and the road memo and others um
um but we are already starting to see
speech-based resistance to the policy's
implementation both the consequences of
these executive orders and memos that
have been coming down for the past two
weeks and the manner of their execution
today employees still have rights and
avenues for recourse even if weak and
under threat they also have resources
for rights doj employees and almost all
federal employees have rights to report
wrongdoing um to uh refuse to obey legal
orders like Nicholas gotlib of usaid did
yesterday and to not be gagged from
exercising any of their speech rights
via legal non-disclosure orders or
directives there are key elements of the
whistle protection act embedded in the
Cs employers may not take or fail to
take or threaten to take or fail to take
a Personnel action with respect to an
employee because they disclose
information they reasonably believe
evidences of VI violation of law rule or
regulation gross mismanagement gross
waste of funds abuse of authority a
substantial and specific danger to
public health and safety and also
scientific censorship that would result
in any of these forms of
misconduct this is not just illegality
this is like a wide swath of issues that
are protected because we recognize that
employees are the best defense against
wrongdoing the standard is reasonable
belief so it's verified information what
we used to call truth and the range of
issues that are protected are not Li are
are WI because we recognize that
employees are the best mechanisms for
compliance risk management and
protecting the public interest they do
not have to go through a chain of
command to report problems their
disclosures can be formal or informal
they can be made to the osc which
receives and investigates disclosures
but also to the IG to Congress agency
officials law enforcement entities and
the Press they are all protected
recipients of information and that
information catalyzes the mechanisms of
accountability including this body's
role in condu oversight they also have
the right to refuse to obey orders that
would require the individual to violate
a law rule or regulation while the
burden is on an employee to prove the
illegality of the order it is not a
reasonable belief standard so it's
riskier to the employee but they can
stand firm against illegal
orders
um finally um they have recourse they
can um the special C office of special
counsel can order a stay of an adverse
Personnel action rooted in whistleblower
um
whistleblower reprisal they may also
appeal in some cases a prohibited
Personnel action directly to the mspb
union collective bargaining um
agreements may be the one remaining
reism depending on the um attack on the
existing Federal whistleblower rights
but Union cbas may be one of the
remaining mechanisms for enforcement of
whistleblower rights because
whistleblower rights and adverse actions
are recognized as unfair labor practices
by Union arbitration of course as unions
are under attack this becomes a new in
threat to the rights of employees speech
um currently federal employees do have
to choose between filing a grievance or
pursuing the osc so there is a uh there
is a choice of venue problem um problem
there but it is a really powerful
enforcement mechanism there are grave
threats to these whistleblower rights of
federal employees as I've said in terms
of scheduled PC that would reclassify
employees and strip them of the
independent review of their
whistleblower rights by the osc and mspb
and put it with the agency on which the
Whistleblower is reporting wrongdoing
and alleging reprisal so it would be the
fox guarding the hen housee of whether
or not those rights are um actually
enforced um so if that is gutted or
politicized we are going to have a
problem on our hands um with a greater
chilling effect there are resources as
so many of my colleagues have talked
about we have provided whistle um
resources um for years on our website at
www.wi.rr.com
federal employees contractors and
grantees which will be updated soon a
book we have published with our friends
at project on government oversight and
public employees for environmental
responsibility called C CAU between
conscience and career expose abuse
without exposing your identity we are
working and conducting trainings with
our partners at partnership for public
service with afg with civil society
organizations who often receive
whistleblower informations to make sure
they know how to provide protection and
work with a whistleblower safely and
effectively the house office of The
Whistleblower UDS has amazing resources
available to whistleblowers and
employees thinking about exercising
their rights as do our friends at Civil
Service strong.org where all of this
information has been curated finally we
are creating an army of pro bono
attorneys we have already trained them
to do rapid response intakes and provide
support to whistleblowers so we can
quickly file retaliation complaints um
as well as disclosures to ensure that
they receive protection and legal report
employees are already
vulnerable I what might be good is the
fear may be turning into anger the more
employees can exercise their rights to
speak up about wrongdoing or to refuse
to oby to obey illegal orders the more
they will inspire others to do the same
and we have seen for decades the power
of one individual to make a difference
when they exercise their rights and
their Duty having taken an oath to
uphold the Constitution to speak truth
about illegality and abuses of power
they don't catalyze accountability alone
they need expert legal support
protection by Congress protected
independent oversight mechanisms support
from Civil Society bringing lawsuits on
whistleblowers underlying disclosures
and other advocacy reporting by a free
press and their rights not only
protected but strengthened civil
servants are the only major sector of
America's labor force without Court
access to defend their free speech
rights whistleblowers have been vital to
accountability no matter which
Administration or a party holds power
nothing could be more true now thank you
so much for your concern and support for
our federal employees and this unique
and Powerful mechanism um of protection
that they deserve
