To much of the outside world, Singapore is a capitalist utopia of low taxes and prosperity for all. In reality, the city-state is starting to have serious doubts about its widely admired model.
In the first two parts, we mentioned concerns such as kiasu culture, meritocracy in education system, the immigration dilemma, burnout culture, aging population pushing the government to re-examine some of the policies that have made it one of the wealthiest nations in the world.
Today, let's continue to explore the remaining challenges and problems that the island nation is trying to solve with My Wonder channel!!! Don't forget to hit the Subscribe and Like button to continue watching other interesting videos of My Wonder channel in the near future!
Content: 6. Income Inequality 7. A High Risk Country for Money Laundering
To much of the outside world, Singapore is a capitalist utopia of low taxes and prosperity
for all.
In reality, the city-state is starting to have serious doubts about its widely admired
model.
In the first two parts, we mentioned concerns such as complacency, kiasu culture, meritocracy
in the educational system, the immigration dilemma, and the aging population pushing
the government to re-examine some of the policies that have made it one of the wealthiest nations
in the world.
Today, let's continue to explore the remaining challenges and problems that the island nation
is trying to solve with My Wonder Channel.
Don't forget to hit the subscribe and like button to continue watching other interesting
videos of My Wonder Channel in the near future.
6.
Income, Inequality
A study published in 2017 by the Institute of Policy Studies, a local think tank, suggested
that Singapore's sharpest social divisions were defined by class rather than race or
religion.
The following year, research commissioned by OnePeople.sg, the national body promoting
harmony, also identified class as the nation's most divisive fault line.
Human nature, jealousy, anonymousness, and the story of winning and losing can quickly
poison society and further widen the divide between rich and poor.
Worse, there is no minimum wage in Singapore, and the influx of foreign workers has caused
local wages to plummet.
Singapore's Deputy Prime Minister, Wang Chuntai, said the country's authorities have made progress
in their ongoing efforts to help low-wage workers.
Measures taken by the Singapore government include child allowances and expanded economic
relief programs.
However, the harsh reality is that no assurance is ever enough in the time of economic uncertainty,
short of never-ending handouts from the public coffers, which may also exacerbate the economic
situation, said Eugene Tan, Associate Professor of Law, Singapore Management University.
Because for Singaporeans, economic issues are the primary issue, said Bilvir Singh,
Associate Professor of Political Science at the Singapore National University.
A growing fear among locals that social mobility has slowed.
Workers from overseas were among the first to get caught in the crosshairs.
Hiring criteria got tighter after competition for jobs became a theme of the 2020 election,
with the ruling People's Action Party suffering the worst parliamentary results since taking
office in 1965.
Now the rich be next in line.
Income inequality is rising, but wealth inequality is probably more glaring, largely because
asset values have increased over time, said Ho Kwan Ping, a local tycoon and former journalist
who is regarded as one of Singapore's public intellectuals.
Meritocracy in Singapore is clearly not a slogan which the power elites only pay lip
service to, but social mobility is less than before, he said.
The government realises that we need to improve the system.
Singapore's considerable wealth has been built on its status as a stable, open, technologically
advanced economy with low taxes.
Inheritance, dividends, investment income and capital gains are all untaxed.
That's made it a hub for the world's richest, from Facebook Inc. and co-founder Eduardo
Saverin to gaming billionaire Forrest Lee.
It's also spawned a local boom in private banking, family offices and asset management.
Signs of luxury are everywhere.
Sales of high-end bungalows, the city's equivalent of mansions, tripled in 2021, according
to Knight Frank Singapore.
Golf memberships have jumped 40% from pre-pandemic rates, costing as much as $350,000, $262,000
for locals and more for expats.
With its good infrastructure, stable security and low taxes, Singapore attracts many rich
people in the world.
Currently, Singapore has a higher rate of millionaires per capita than any other country.
The average income per capita is also among the highest, over $51,000 USD, surpassing
developed countries such as Germany or even the US in some aspects.
But Singapore's wealth gap is the second highest among developed Asian economies, after
Hong Kong.
It's clear that poorer Singaporeans will struggle to afford basic necessities.
The city-state has no minimum wage or poverty line, and no social assistance like many developed
European economies.
The problem has become so acute that anti-poverty campaigners have issued a challenge.
Can you afford to live on $5 a day?
And while the wealthiest amass multiple properties, the poorest residents are often crammed into
tiny public housing units.
But in 2020, Singapore's overall median household income fell for the first time in
a decade, with the poorest tenth of the population hardest hit.
Real incomes declined 6.1% to a median $5.60 a month, although those incomes rebounded
by 4.7% in 2021.
Those who are more affluent should pay their fair share of taxes, Finance Minister Lawrence
Wong said in October, adding that the government was studying wealth tax options.
Central Bank Chief Ravi Menon has suggested the country shift away from taxing income
and towards taxing wealth, highlighting property and inheritance as potential avenues.
Even among the city's wealthiest residents, there are some who are in favor.
Wealth taxes globally are very necessary because it's not income, but wealth inequality, which
is the most glaring divide between the super-rich and the rest of the world, said Tycoon Ho,
whose banyan tree holdings Lanaud runs luxury hotels and resorts in 28 countries.
The problem is that our economic policy is based partly on attracting the super-wealthy,
he added.
The challenge is how to extract more from them without scaring them away.
Prime Minister Lee has also pointed out that wealth is harder to track than income.
It's amorphous.
You can squeeze it here and it pops up in different forms elsewhere, he said at the
Bloomberg New Economy Forum in November.
We need to find a system of taxation which is progressive and which people will accept
as fair, Lee said.
Fair means everybody needs to pay some.
But if you're able to pay more, well, you should bear a larger burden.
7.
A high-risk country for money laundering In 2023, August, the $3 billion money laundering
case shocked Singapore and the world, making it the largest in Singapore's history.
About $1 billion, you $736 million in assets, including properties, vehicles, luxury goods
and gold bars, have been seized or frozen in one of Singapore's largest police probes
into money laundering and forgery offences.
They laundered proceeds from online gambling, passed through at least 16 financial institutions
in Singapore.
10 foreign nationals from countries including China, Turkey and Cambodia were charged in
court over their suspected involvement in offences including forgery, money laundering
and resisting arrest.
These foreign nationals, aged between 31 and 44, were arrested following an island-wide
raid by more than 400 officers.
Besides, 12 others are assisting with investigations, while 8 more are wanted by the police.
Through extensive investigations, including the analysis of suspicious transaction reports,
the police identified a group of foreigners suspected to be involved in laundering proceeds
from their organized crime activities overseas.
These activities include scams and online gambling.
The first judgment was handed down in early April 2024.
Regarding the case, the FATF president said,
Granting citizenship and residency to wealthy investors through golden passport and visa
programs can potentially lead to economic growth, but they can and are being exploited
by criminals and the corrupt who want to launder their money, hide their identity and assets
or carry out further crimes.
These persons are believed to have connections among themselves.
All the persons involved are neither Singapore citizens nor permanent residents, said Singapore
police force.
For decades, Singapore took steps to attract the super-rich, building a finance industry
that's made it one of the wealthiest countries on earth.
Generous tax incentives and pathways to long-term residency have prompted billionaires and many
more to set up family offices.
Assets overseen by the money management sector have almost doubled in 7 years to $3.65 trillion,
with about three-quarters of that coming from abroad.
More recently, a wave of Chinese investors has arrived, fleeing strenuous pandemic restrictions
and crackdowns that hit industries from technology to real estate.
Singapore is a natural choice for them, as ethnic Chinese make up about three-quarters
of the population and Mandarin is widely spoken.
Since 2019, direct investment from mainland China and Hong Kong has risen 79% to $19.3
billion.
Private wine bars and country clubs have benefited from the surge in spending.
The surprise sting operation is now prompting a rethink of all this amid signs dirty money
is joining legitimate businesses in the rush to Singapore, with cash winding up at global
lenders from Credit Suisse to Citigroup Inc.
In all, the 10 accused have at least five family offices among them, according to documents
reviewed by reporters and people familiar with the matter.
Many of the accused also invested in existing companies or set up their own businesses to
establish ties.
Wang Dehai, for example, whose employment pass is valid through June 2024, according
to Manpower Ministry records, invested in Delibol PT, a Chinese restaurant chain, records
show.
Su Haijin, 40, another of the accused, became a director at listed restaurant firm No Signboard
Holdings Lendalid in 2021, after investing $6.5 million through an entity controlled
by Chief Executive Officer Lim Yong Sim.
Su also holds or has had shares in seven other firms, according to documents.
Su, who fractured both feet and injured his wrist jumping from the balcony of his rented
mansion after his son alerted him that police had arrived, now faces charges linked to laundering
money in Singapore using profit from illegal gambling operations.
Su was arrested with $171 million in assets tied to him and his wife in Singapore.
Singapore has acknowledged the challenges in trying to stop money launderers who get
these work passes.
Some of them may pretend to be employed by companies that are dormant or operate active
companies that mask the movement of ill-gotten gains, Manpower Minister Tan See Leng told
Parliament in October.
Some individuals may abuse the work pass framework to enter Singapore to commit illicit activities,
such as the present case of money laundering, Tan said.
Criminals will constantly find new ways to circumvent our laws and regulations and update
their methods over time.
The 10 arrested were granted various visas to stay or work, in part because none of them
was on the Interpol Red Notice List, despite being wanted in China, according to authorities.
Chen Qingyuan, Su Wenqiang and Su Jianfeng were wanted in China, and were charged after
the raids in Singapore.
Singapore is also looking into the effects of a little-known loophole that helped many
of the accused start businesses.
According to Singapore law, foreigners must hire a citizen or permanent resident as an
authorised representative to set up a company.
To meet this demand, some locals have become serial directors, representing hundreds of
firms at the same time.
Wang Junjie is a prime example.
The Singaporean is director, shareholder or secretary of more than 200 companies, and
has held roles in at least nine firms related to three of the arrested, most of which he
left recently, according to corporate filings.
One of the firms linked to Zhang Ruijin, another of the accused, has two corporate secretaries
from a firm called Venture Haven, which claims it can deliver business registrations in under
24 hours, according to its website.
Those two secretaries alone, Koh Teng Teng and Safra Binte Saad, each hold more than
3,500 positions at various firms.
For the booming financial hub, it's all a delicate balancing act.
Singapore wants to keep borders open to attract the super-rich, while having enough controls
in place to detect tainted funds.
Singapore's ability to attract funds from across the region and beyond means it has
an added responsibility to ensure its anti-money laundering controls are effective, said John
Cusack, the London-based chairperson of the Global Coalition to Fight Financial Crime.
The purpose of such controls are to follow the money and deprive criminals of these funds.
This appears to be a likely successful example of delivering on that purpose.
For his part, Lee, the premier, said the money laundering case isn't a scandal, and that
the system is clean.
He said in an interview at the Bloomberg New Economy Forum last month,
Singapore is far from perfect.
It has outdated laws, issues with personal freedoms, and basically no opposition.
But in my opinion, it is a shining example to many other emerging countries of what can
be achieved with vision and hard work.