Parrying Daggers - Size and Design

Ancient Swords
6 followers
2 Video ViewsยทFeb 3, 2025
A short examination of typical designs of parrying dagger used in Italian rapier & dagger fencing styles.
Hello everyone it's Greg from Edinburgh Renaissance Fencing Academy here.
Before we start today's video I'd just like to take this opportunity to say a big welcome and
thank you to all the new viewers to the channel. We have recently surpassed the 700 subscribers mark
which is a big milestone for a small channel like this one so thank you everyone. Now on with the
So today's topic is parrying daggers and in particular I'm going to discuss the design
and size of those daggers commonly used in Italian rapier fencing styles of the late 16th
and early 17th centuries. Now in this period of European history we should remember that Italian
fencing theory was quite influential in other countries as well so the sort of rapier fencing
that was being practiced in places like France, England, Germany was very much Italianate in its
style or at least based on Italianate principles. So what I'm going to say has relevance outside of
as well as for Italy and the swordsmanship of Italy itself. So my motivation for producing
this video is really twofold. On the one hand I personally really enjoy rapier and dagger fencing.
I find it to be both challenging and fun and however the second factor is that I feel like
there are quite a few misconceptions about parrying daggers out there in the wider
HEMA and historical fencing community. So I wanted to tackle some of those ideas in today's video.
Okay so in this first part of the video I want to analyze a few real historical examples of
the type of daggers that we're talking about. Before we do that though a quick note about
nomenclature. Now in the modern HEMA world and historical fencing world it's common to refer to
these weapons as parrying daggers because that's how we use them in rapier and dagger fencing.
You also sometimes hear people use terms like left hand dagger and particularly man gauche
which is the French term for simply left hand. However according to the Italian fencing treatises
they're just daggers. They use the Italian word dagga. There's no specific name for this type of
dagger. So it's just a dagger which you use in combination with the sword. Okay so moving on
let's have a look at a few examples. Now most of these are taken from this nice little book I have
by Eric Valentine. It's called Rapiers and Their Companions.
So yeah without further ado. So this first picture here shows two nice examples and this is
really a picture that's worth remembering as we continue our discussion. So the larger dagger
here has a blade of around 38 centimetres and the smaller one has a blade length of approximately 27
centimetres. And you can see they've got modestly sized quillings and the cross guard and small
side rings which would sit on the outside of the hands to protect the top of the hands.
So these are as I say really the classic two models of dagger which were in use in Italian
fencing schools. So we could consider this to be a large version and a medium sized version.
Okay next picture here we've got again a slightly larger one a blade length of around 30 centimetres
this time and the other one again around 27 centimetres and very modestly sized cross guards.
This next example is the smallest one it has a blade length of only around 24 centimetres
and quite small quillings and the side ring. I should also note this dagger is very similar to
one that I'm quite familiar with which is held in the National Museum of Scotland here in Edinburgh
and so that's an interesting point as well. And then our final picture here so this is a
matched weapon set this is held in the Wallace Collection in London and so the dagger here
has a blade length of again 25 centimetres and clearly designed to match the rapier next to it
which I believe has a blade length of 115 centimetres or something like that.
So there you go these daggers are relatively simple in design and not overly large shall we
say. I don't have specific weight data for these weapons but I'm confident that they are not
particularly heavy either and they're probably 500 grams or a little bit less in most cases.
Okay so next I'd like to refer to my favourite period source for fencing which is the treatise
of Giacomo di Grassi from 1570. So I'm going to read out a short quotation to you from the text
to give you di Grassi's idea and advice about firing daggers. So he says as for the form that
daggers should have there is this much to be said that in order to withstand blows from a sword
they have to be strong to encounter the sword easily they have to be long and in order to be
drawn quickly from the sheath they should be short accordingly those of medium size are praised.
So basically he's saying that a medium-sized dagger in other words a dagger with a medium-sized
blade which is of strong construction is the optimal weapon for this and that's his guidance.
So if we think about the examples we saw earlier particularly that first picture
if the longer one of these is a large dagger and the other one is a medium-sized dagger
and di Grassi was probably intending for the smaller of these two weapons to be the standard
for his way of fencing. Now let's expand the picture a little bit and take a look at some
diagrams from period fencing treatises. So let's start off with di Grassi's treatise itself.
So if we take a look here you can see the daggers are pretty much as he described. So the blades
are of modest length and the weapons are fairly simple in construction. Simple not too big
a cross guard and in fact there are no side rings shown here. That may be an artistic device,
maybe the the artist didn't want to confuse the picture by drawing in extra bits to the guard
or this may be an accurate representation of the weapons. It's hard to be sure but let's
move on to another treatise. So this is Camillo Agrippa from the 1550s. Pretty much the same
thing. A modestly sized dagger with a simple not too large cross guard and again no side rings.
And then a final example from Rodolfo Carpoferro's famous work of 1610 over here.
Same thing again, medium blades at best, relatively simple cross guard,
not too big and once again no side rings shown interestingly. So basically the treatise
diagrams, the actual fencing diagrams, back up what di Grassi was saying. So simple daggers with
simple guards seem to be the norm as far as this evidence is concerned for what was going on in
Italian fencing schools. So the next piece of evidence to examine is a little bit of portrait
evidence. So if we remember di Grassi's quote, so he said that the dagger needed to be of modest
length so it was easy to draw from the sheet. And what does that mean? Well let's look at di Grassi's
portrait. So if you look at his right hip you can see the handle of his dagger projecting just
beyond the right hip. So the idea is that's easy to draw with the right hand or with the left hand
to draw across your body, assuming you already have a sword in your right hand.
So this was a convenient place to have such a weapon out of reach of the opponent, a little bit
hidden. You can draw it with your dominant hand as a primary weapon or with your off hand as a
companion weapon to support the action of your sword. So you can imagine if you've got a large
heavy complex dagger weapon then it would not in any way be convenient to to wear it in the
small of the back like this and it would become difficult to draw. So if we take a look at another
portrait, so this is Robert Dudley the Earl of Leicester. So I've chosen this one just because
it's a very typical portrait of the late 16th century and if you look carefully at his waist
he's wearing his dagger in exactly the same way as di Grassi was. And if you look at other portraits
of noblemen from around Western Europe from the same period you can find the same thing. And it's
notable as much as we can judge this from just being able to see the handle that these weapons
seem to be of relatively small size. Okay so let's bring this video to a finish by forming a
kind of conclusion. So hopefully from everything you've seen so far in today's presentation you
now have a pretty good idea of the typical daggers that were being used as companion weapons in the
Italian fencing schools of the late 16th and early 17th centuries. So they were kind of
moderately sized and relatively simple weapons. The thing is that in the modern HEMA and historical
fencing scene most practitioners seem to prefer weapons which are longer with more complex hilts
and which are heavier they've got more mass overall than these historical examples.
Because practitioners tend to prefer those weapons it means that's mostly what suppliers
provide. So just as an aside it is much more difficult ironically to to get these simple
weapon designs for the practice of historical fencing than it is to get the more complex ones.
It's not impossible it's just more difficult and this is something that slightly irritates me to
be perfectly honest. However the wider point is as always when we're trying to recreate a specific
historical martial art if we want to do it properly and accurately then we need training weapons which
accurately simulate the original period armaments. So if you are using a weapon which has a longer
reach greater mass and more hand protection it's inevitably going to change the techniques that you
perform with weapon in hand. So the fact that people like di Grassi and Capo Ferro to give
two famous examples are using simple open hilted weapons tells us something about the way they were
using these daggers. So they were obviously parrying in a way which meant that even though
their hand was exposed it wasn't at a huge risk of injury. Now I'm going to make a follow-up video
to this one in the near future where we're going to examine the approaches of di Grassi and Capo
Ferro. So please check back in a week or a couple of weeks from the publication date of this video
and you should find the follow-up there. However for now it is worth noting that there were larger
daggers more complex daggers so these designs which you find sold by HEMA suppliers are in some
ways authentic but they're just not the weapons which are shown in the treatises that I have
described today. So if you want to accurately recreate a style like di Grassi or Capo Ferro or
Agrippa or Saviolo or any of those people from that period Fabris is another big name
I really advise you to try to get an appropriate dagger for use as a parrying weapon.
My personal belief that people use these big heavy complex daggers are either looking for
competitive advantage in some kind of tournament situation or they are overly worried about injury
to their hand and the correct way to minimize the chance of injury to your hand is to use correct
historical technique and not to rely on these over-engineered examples of daggers which let's
not forget you would be unlikely to wear with your everyday civilian clothing back in the 1500s and
1600s and they were just too bulky and inconvenient. So yeah that's really the thought I want to leave you
with today. I'll be back as I said in the near future at some point with a follow-up video where
we're going to talk about techniques with the parrying dagger but this video is long enough
for today so I'll leave it there but as always try to look at primary sources and original
examples of weapons if you want to accurately recreate historical fencing techniques. That's
it for today. Take care everyone. I'll see you again soon. Bye.
