The Significance of the Dead Sea Scrolls | Professor Bart Ehrman

Prophecies Revealed
9 followers
1 Video View·Jan 31, 2025
In this fascinating video, Professor Bart Ehrman delves into the profound historical and religious significance of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Unearthed in the mid-20th century, these ancient manuscripts have provided invaluable insights into the Jewish world during the time of the Second Temple and the early Christian period. Professor Ehrman explains how the scrolls illuminate the development of biblical texts, the diversity of religious beliefs in antiquity, and their impact on our understanding of early Christianity. Don't miss this engaging discussion on one of the most significant archaeological discoveries in modern history.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Just moving on, if I may change the subject slightly, the significance of the Dead Sea
Scrolls. Now, I'm often told, I often hear from Christians who say the Dead Sea Scrolls,
they really took us much further back in time. We've now got much earlier manuscripts
and it confirms the Old Testament we always had. It's the same books, the same content.
Isaiah is just the same. Jeremiah is just the same. Is this true or not? I mean,
what's really going on here? Or is it more complicated than that?
Yeah, no, it's a very important, it's a very important thing. The Dead Sea Scrolls are huge,
hugely important for all sorts of reasons. Not just the copies of the Bible, by the way,
but also they tell us a lot about this group of Jews who were in these kind of monastic-like
communities, the Essenes. But some of the Dead Sea Scrolls are biblical manuscripts and they
are a huge find. The reason is because the Hebrew Bible that we use today, the people who use the
Hebrew Bible actually in Hebrew and that are translating the Hebrew Bible are basing their
translations on a manuscript that was written around the year 1000 of the Common Era. Around
1000 of the Common Era. It came from Leningrad and so it's called Codex Leningradensis.
Jewish scribes in the Middle Ages, when they copied a manuscript, they would destroy it
because now they had a perfect copy of it and they made sure the copy was perfect.
They had ways of doing that through the Middle Ages. The problem is what were scribes doing
before the Middle Ages, before they had these rules? Well, we had to guess they were getting
it right. And so the Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in 1947 and they have, they include
portions of every book of the Hebrew Bible except for the book of Esther. Esther? Yeah.
Because, yeah, it turns out God is not named in Esther and so that for some reason that book's
not among the Dead Sea Scrolls. Most of the scrolls we have are not complete scrolls.
The Isaiah Scroll is a virtually complete scroll and it is very, very close in wording
to the Codex Leningradensis. Right. So that confirms the Bible we have today was historically
accurate. No, it's got nothing to do with it. And so I need to explain several things here
because there's several points that some people like overlook, which is the first one people
overlook. That's true of the Isaiah Scroll, but it's not true of other Dead Sea Scrolls.
There are other Dead Sea Scrolls. The Scroll of Jeremiah that we have has differences from
our Jeremiah and the differences from our Jeremiah are like the differences that come to us from the
Greek translation of Jeremiah in the Septuagint, in the Greek Bible. That version of Jeremiah
is 15% shorter than the Leningradensis. 15%! So that's not very accurate.
And so it's not that everything is like the Isaiah Scroll. The Isaiah Scroll is like the
Isaiah Scroll, but it doesn't prove— That's why it's always mentioned,
it's always showcased. Oh, look at Isaiah. Isaiah is exactly the same. Look at the perfection of
transmission and the reliability. So that's my first point. This manuscript of Isaiah was
written 1,000 years before the Leningradensis. It's accurate, but the others are not the same.
Second point, Isaiah the prophet was writing— Isaiah of Jerusalem was living in the 8th century
BCE. So that means we don't have any manuscripts for the first over 700 years. So the fact that
you have a manuscript that from, say, the year 1 to the year 1,000, you can show that Isaiah
was copied accurately, but our question is, what about between the year 700 BCE and 1?
So there's 700 years. We have no evidence in Hebrew, no Hebrew text. So you can't say this
is exactly what Isaiah wrote. How would you know how much it got changed between 700 and the
Dead Sea Scroll copy? There's no way to know. There are ways, not good ways to know. So that's
second. Third thing, even if we had everything that was accurate in either any book of the New
Testament or the New Testament or Old Testament, even if we had a manuscript, even if we had the
original, suppose we had the original of Mark, or suppose we have the original of Joshua,
we have the original. That would have no bearing on the question of whether it's accurate or not.
It would only have a bearing on whether we know what the author wrote.
So the way I usually illustrate this is, we have millions of copies of Mein Kampf,
and they are accurate. They might not be accurate with what Hitler actually wrote,
but they don't have any differences. We know what the first printed copy looked like.
Does that mean that it's accurate? No! It doesn't mean that it's right.
It just means you know what he wrote. The fact you know what somebody wrote doesn't
mean that what they wrote is right. And that's a different thing. So those are three really big
points that shows that this argument just doesn't hold. And any one of those three shows that they
didn't hold. Three together, forget it. Yeah, is it not worse than that? Because we give the
example of Isaiah, it's now commonly accepted that, yeah, maybe the first 39 chapters of Isaiah
were written by this prophet in Isaiah from downtown Jerusalem. But it was added to by maybe
a second scribe, or maybe a third scribe or scribes. So we don't even need to dig up the
book of Isaiah that we have it today from 500 years ago, 600 years ago. It doesn't mean we
have the prophet Isaiah's own words, which many scholars were added to anyway. Yeah,
yeah, no, it's very common to think that Isaiah, and there's a really good reason for this,
Isaiah of Jerusalem wrote most of chapter 1 to 39, and then someone 150 years later wrote 40 to
55. And so, you know, it's a compilation, no matter what. But even if you have Isaiah's words,
again, it doesn't mean that he's right. He might be right. But that's a different,
it's a different question. The fact you have an accurate manuscript is not evidence that what the
person said is accurate. Okay, that's fair enough. Let's move on to the last part, then.
Christianity after the New Testament, or Christianities after the New Testament. You've
written a superb book here, After the New Testament, a reader in early Christianity,
published by Oxford University Press, which is a wonderful anthology of texts from the early
centuries of the Church, or the Church is, I suppose.
To just clarify a few things, the traditional picture, when we get from the Church historian
Eusebius, for example, is that Jesus founded the Church. The disciples were the pillars of the
Church. They went out, preached the message with Paul. And, you know, yeah, the Church encountered
heretics and problem groups and so on, what you might call the Ebionites, or the Marcionites,
or the Gnostics, or whatever you want to call them. But basically, Christ founded the Church,
and it went through time, through history, right up to the present day. But do we not now know that
we see Jewish Christianity, we've got churches founded by Paul, we've got the Ebionites,
we've got Marcion in the second century. And these are quite a wide spectrum of different
Christian groups, all identifying as Christian, you know, that these are people who believe what
they believe is true. Firstly, this is astonishing, isn't it, when you really get the sense of the
diversity, the big differences between these Christian groups. And my second question connected
to that, which of these early movements most closely resembles, do you think, the faith of
Jesus' own disciples, if it's possible to make that connection? Yeah, so again, it's a very
complicated issue. So Eusebius, as many of you here will know, is known as the Father of Church
History. He's the first one to write a sketch of the history of Christianity from the time of Jesus
up to his own day, around the year 300, so the first 300 years of Christianity. And he has a lot
of motifs driving his work, as he describes a lot of earlier authors and a lot of earlier views. He
talks about persecutions and martyrdoms and heresies, and he gives the history of the church,
church leaders. His view of the relationship of heresy and orthodoxy, so orthodoxy for him would
mean the correct belief, the true faith that people in his day had. And heresy would be a
false teaching of some kind. His view was that Jesus taught orthodoxy to his disciples, taught
basically what we would think of as the Nicene Creed or the Apostles' Creed. He taught the
truth to his disciples, who passed it down to their successors, who passed it down to their
successors. And there's always been this main body of truth that has been the mainstream the whole
time. It's always been the majority opinion. And every now and then you get some heretic coming
along who is willful, or mean-spirited, or inspired by a devil, who is motivated by bad
intentions. They're never good guys who've just got a different idea. They're always
malicious individuals, I've noticed. They're malicious and demon-inspired. And they come up
with something like, they'll say, oh, actually, there are two gods. There's not one God. Or there
are 36 gods. Or salvation isn't by Christ's death. Jesus didn't even die. And these are all offshoots.
They're secondary offshoots from the mainstream that's always been there in Eusebius' presentation.
That view of Eusebius held all the way up to the beginning of the 20th century. This is just
what church historians said. So if you read a church historian from the 19th century,
this is how they'll paint what happened in early Christianity. It all changed in the 1930s
with the publication by a German scholar named Walter Bauer, who wrote a book that his English
translation is called, Orthodoxy and Heresy in Earliest Christianity. Bauer argued that if you
actually look at the surviving evidence, region by region, so you look, you go to Egypt, and you look
at our oldest records of what Christianity was like in Egypt, or you go to Antioch up in Syria,
or you go to Asia Minor, you go to these places where we actually have records, the earliest
records in almost every place is something that later was called a heresy. Bauer argued that in
fact it wasn't that there was like this mainstream of Orthodoxy with heretics coming off everywhere,
that in fact there were lots of different groups of Christians as far back as we have records,
and they were fighting for converts. And eventually one of the groups ended up winning
out, and it got more converts, and it wiped out the opposition, and then it rewrote the history.
And you see this as a rewritten version of what actually was the truth,
which is that there was a wide diversity. So Bauer, so that's Bauer's, that's Bauer's view.
He came out with this in 1934. Unfortunately it wasn't translated into English into the late 1970s,
so a lot of English and American scholars didn't pay enough attention to it, but it has, it has
become very much the critical opinion of the critical historians today. And it's interesting
that archaeological discoveries have in almost every instance verified what he had to say before.
So, I mean, for example, the discovery of the Nag Hammadi Library in 1945, just a year and a half
before the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls. The Nag Hammadi Library, or the Gnostic Gospels,
as they're sometimes called, which, you know, every time there's some kind of gospel that shows up,
it's always something that is not orthodox. You know, more recently, for example, the Gospel
of Judas. And so it looks like in early Christianity there were these various views of
things, and you can trace the diversity actually back into the New Testament. Just as you were
talking earlier about Matthew and Paul having different views of the law, that's a pretty
significant difference. And everywhere, you know, almost every time Paul writes a letter, he's got
these Christian enemies. He has more enemies than friends, and that's in his day. We don't have the
writings of his enemies. We wish we did. So the idea is it's very diverse all the way back.
