Psychology of Influence - The Lure-Technique (1/2)

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
1 Video View·Jan 29, 2025
The lure-technique is a very effective psychological influence tactic. Why does it work?
Author: Eskil Burck (degreed psychologist)
Imagine you are sitting on a bench in a public park. Maybe it's just your break
from work or maybe you are just reading a book when all of a sudden somebody
comes over and he says hi I'm an undergraduate student and in the
framework of a research program aimed at studying students concentration during
the day we have to carry out some experiments. All you have to do is watch
a short video and answer a short questionnaire. It only takes 15 minutes
and you will be paid six euros. Are you interested? Well six euros for 15
minutes of watching a video and answering some questions that's a quite
well-paid job so probably you say yeah okay let's do it yeah okay why not but
when you follow the experimenter to the lab all of a sudden he seems to get a
message on his mobile phone and unfortunately the message is not good at
all because the experimenter turns around and has to tell you oh I'm so
sorry my colleague just called me and we already have the number of persons
needed for the video. We only needed a few more people you know so it's no
longer possible. However I just remembered I don't know if you would be
interested that we are conducting another experiment which also deals with
students concentration. All you have to do is to copy a number of symbols as
fast as you can. This experiment lasts 15 minutes but you won't get paid for it.
Are you interested? So what do we have here? First of all there was the lure
which was the offer of a well-paid and interesting sounding low-effort
experiment and there you said yes and now you're offered to participate in a
less interesting rather boring experiment in which you have to copy
some symbols and you won't even get paid for it. How do you react? Are you a little
bit angry? Are you a little bit pissed? Because no that's definitely not the
deal we had. Sorry I won't follow you on this. Well the truth is in all the
experiments with over 1,000 participants they conducted on the lure technique
the complete opposite turned out. In comparison to a control condition in
which participants were asked directly whether they were willing to take part
in the boring experiment the compliance rate when using the lure technique on
average doubled. And in a number of experiments which I want to present to
you now scientists tried to figure out why the technique is so successful. And
first of all one could speculate that as soon as we follow the other person to
the laboratory as soon as we are halfway we already invested quite a lot. So we
talked to the other person and we already walked with the experimenter for
at least some meters. So maybe it's our investment in this project that we don't
want to waste. And if that's the case the lure technique should be even more
successful when we invested even more. When we are for example already sitting
in the laboratory. And this is exactly what they tested in another study with
150 students. When they made the students come to the laboratory they had them
sit down and only in the last moment the participants were told oh sorry
we can't conduct this video experiment but maybe you are interested in another
experiment. And even though one could suspect that this should have made the
participants even more angry this tactic was even more successful. About 92% of
the participants said yeah okay let's do the other experiment. So the more the
other person invests the more effective the lure technique seems to be. But as
they also found a quite strong effect when the revelation if you want to call
it like this took place very early the investment hypothesis seems to be only
half the story. Another explanation for the efficacy of the lure technique might
be impression management. We all have the tendency that we want to be
perceived in a special way and usually we want to be perceived as good, stable,
strong, helpful and all the other good attributes. So if we agree on taking part
in the first well-paid video experiment but we then say when we hear well sorry
we can't conduct this experiment but there's still the second experiment and
when we then say well no sorry I won't participate in this one. Come on I don't
get paid for it and it's boring. Well this is not such a good impression
management because then we would look as not stable as not helpful and therefore
to make a good impression it might be better to say well okay I will
participate in this second in this rather boring study. But how can we test
whether this impression management explanation is really right? Well what if
we exchange the experimenter to which we said well of course I will participate
in the video experiment by a second experimenter to which we never presented
ourselves as helpful or interested in science. So towards this person we
shouldn't feel obliged to present us in this special way. So if there are two
experimenters well then the effect should be much smaller. Marie Marchand
and colleagues tested this in an experiment published in 2015 by using
quite the same procedure as in the previous studies. Participants were told
well are you interested to participate in a 15-minute last-in-video experiment
you will be paid six euros and then most participants said yeah why not. They came
to the lab and when they sat down there they were told by the experimenter oh
I'm so sorry we can't conduct the experiment huh I'm really sorry. Then she
left for a minute and a second experimenter entered the room and told
the participant hi I'm sorry to bother you I'm a student in neurology and I
have to do an experiment on students concentration. All you have to do is to
correctly copy the maximum amount of symbols. So it was again exactly the same
boring experiment but this time proposed by a second by a different experimenter
and it turned out maybe a little bit surprising the compliance rate to
participate in this boring experiment was still quite high in this condition
with the two different experimenters. The exact compliance rate was about 64%
whereas when they used only one experimenter the compliance rate
was 76% which is only a little bit higher and in fact not significantly
higher so there was no significant effect. But both conditions again were
much more successful than a control condition in which the participants were
directly asked whether they would participate in the boring experiment. So
these results do not speak for the impression management explanation
because otherwise the effect for the condition with the two different
experimenters should have been much lower.
