Whether in advertising, in politics or in everyday conversation with acquaintances or friends: Persuasion is omnipresent. Especially in advertising persuasion attempts are rarely based on substantial arguments. Instead, marketers often introduce (supposed) experts, celebrities or seducing background music. Quite often even beautiful models are photoshopped and speaker voices are made even more enjoyable by sound designers. But are we really fooled by these superficial characteristics? And if so - under what circumstances? The Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM) by Petty & Cacioppo yields reliable predictions.
Keywords: Persuasion - Influence - Manipulation - Psychology - nonverbal communication - Speaker - Voice - body language - mind - brain - music - social psychology - psychology of advertising - consumer psychology - mind control - marketing - ELM
Author: Eskil Burck
Hello and welcome back to the world of psychology.
The psychology of persuasion or the elaboration likelihood model.
Day by day we are exposed to numerous persuasion attempts.
We switch on the telly and there's a politician who wants to convince us of his policy
and wants us to vote for him and his party.
If we switch to another channel we see an ad for a toothpaste
and if we try to escape from that we switch the channel again
and we now see an ad for a new car.
So persuasion attempts are omnipresent
and what psychologists have been very interested in for a very long time
is how recipients process these persuasive messages and information.
How much do we think about all this information, all these advertisements?
Do we elaborate all the information and think about the pros and cons
or are we convinced by superficial aspects like the voice, the speaking rate,
the popularity or attractiveness of the communicator,
the nonverbal behavior?
Is he or she avoiding eye contact or speaking with confidence?
How influential are these aspects and especially under which circumstances
do these aspects which are regarded as factors of the peripheral route of persuasion
whereas the quality of arguments which is in fact what should really matter
is regarded as the central route of persuasion?
Well, the elaboration likelihood model tries to predict under which circumstances
peripheral and the central route of persuasion are used.
And one predictive factor seems to be motivation.
If we are really motivated, if we are involved and the decision is really relevant to us,
the elaboration likelihood model predicts we choose the central route
which means we really think it through, we reflect about it.
And that this really seems to be the case,
Petty, Cacioppo and Goldman were able to show in their study
personal involvement as a determinant of argument-based persuasion,
a study which was published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
In their study, 145 students were told a cover story.
They were told that the new university president was considering a policy change.
He was thinking about implementing a new comprehensive axiom
for all students in their major area.
Therefore, the chancellor had already asked several individuals and groups
to prepare policy statements.
And all the participants had to do was to listen to one of these policy statements
because they were thinking about broadcasting it in the campus radio.
And as they wanted to know about the effectiveness of these statements,
they had invited the participants to rate these statements.
For the next step, they had some variations.
For example, half of the students were told
that the reforms would take place in about 10 years.
So imagine you are one of these students and you are told,
well, we are thinking about implementing such a comprehensive exam,
but only in 10 years.
So this is not really relevant to you.
And your motivation to think about all the arguments might be not that high
because you are not really involved.
The other half of students were told,
well, we are thinking about implementing it next year.
So this is really relevant to you
because you will probably have to take this exam
if they decide to implement it.
Another variable that was manipulated was the expertise of the source.
So some students were told,
well, the statements you are going to hear have been discussed at a high school
and you will hear the results of their discussion.
So the source were just normal pupils.
The other half of students were told,
well, you are going to listen to the statements of a Princeton professor,
a Princeton professor for education,
which is obviously a very good expert.
The third and last variable that was manipulated
was the quality of the arguments.
So some students were given weak arguments.
Like for example, a friend of mine was at a university
and he had to take such comprehensive exams
and today he has a really, really good job.
Well, this kind of argumentation is quite similar to
a friend of mine was smoking all his life
and now he has no cancer.
So smoking cannot be bad for you.
Not really persuasive.
Other students were given strong arguments.
For example, statistics.
Statistics that seems to prove when there are comprehensive exams,
it's better for your job chances.
So these variables were manipulated.
First, the relevance,
how motivated the participants were.
Second, the expertise of the source
and third, the quality of the arguments.
What were the results?
Well, it was very interesting to see
that when the participants were really motivated
because they were told that these comprehensive exams
might be implemented already next year,
their attitude towards comprehensive exams
was not influenced by the fact
whether the source was an expert,
a professor from Princeton
or just pupils from a high school.
So they really thought it through.
They thought about all the arguments
and it didn't matter who was the author of the arguments.
It was only of importance how good these arguments were.
Quite different results occurred
when the involvement was low,
when the participants were told,
well, this will take place in 10 years.
Under these circumstances,
the participants gave much more attention to the source
and even if the arguments were really weak,
yeah, I have a friend who blah, blah, blah,
even when the arguments were really weak,
the statement of the Princeton professor,
of the expert was really persuasive.
So obviously, when we are not that motivated,
we are more willing to pay attention to peripheral aspects
because we are not really willing to think it all through.
And under these circumstances,
peripheral aspects can have an impact.