Psychology: Physical Exercise for Depression - Running Away from Depression? - Part1

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
Jan 29, 2025
http://www.learningpsychology.net
Almost everyone knows the satisfying feeling that sets in after a physical exertion: Your body awareness intensifies and you get the feeling that you made it.
But is physical exercise also an effective means against major depressive disorder?
In recent times there is increasing evidence that physical exercise can have positive effects for people with MDD.
For example, Blumenthal et al. (1999, 2007) observed no significant differences between an antidepressant (sertraline) and an aerobic exercise training.
It seems that exercise is one of the few antidepressants with
positive side effects ...
Hello and welcome back to the world of psychology. Exercise for depression or
running away from bad mood. I just recently talked to one of my best
friends who just broke up with his girlfriend and therefore felt very down
a little bit depressed and I told him well because it's written in our
psychology textbook one first aid intervention could be to do some aerobic
exercise to to go running for example but he was not really convinced he said
well I don't think this will work is there any evidence for example how big
are the effects if you compare it for example to antidepressants so give me
some evidence and I'll give it a try well I said give me three days and I
present to you all the data that we have today and here we are three years later
yeah it wasn't it was not possible to make it in three days so it took me
about three weeks to get a good overview but I think it was worth the
effort because up to date there are really some very interesting studies
that I want to present to you the first study I want to present to you was
published in 2009 it was a really huge study with 17,264
participants from all in all 21 countries participants were coming from
Belgium England France Germany Greece Iceland Ireland Italy the Netherlands
Portugal Spain USA Bulgaria Hungary Poland Romania Slovakia Japan Korea
Taiwan and Thailand and in this study published by Grant and colleagues the
researchers were interested in and that's also the title of the study the
relationship between life satisfaction and health behavior a cross-cultural
analysis of young adults so all participants in this study all 17,264
subjects were asked and now I quote all things considered how satisfied are you
with your life as a whole quite an important question and of course they
did not only ask this question they also asked for example about physical
activity did you engage in any leisure time physical activity in the past two
weeks think about it any physical activity in the past two weeks that's
really not much activity and therefore you might expect that almost everyone
meets these criteria but this was definitely not the case of those
participants who said they are dissatisfied not satisfied at all with
their lives they don't like their life of those participants only 61% said they
engaged in any leisure time physical activity in the past two weeks in
comparison those participants who said they are very satisfied with their life
they they are happy with their life 77% of those participants said that they
were physically active in the past two weeks the only other variable that showed
similar results as physical activity I mean other variables were for example
smoking drinking the use of sunmilk the only other variable that showed similar
dose respondent effects was fruit intake so only 36% of the people who were
dissatisfied with their lives said that they were eating fruits at least once
per day and whereas those people who were very satisfied with their lives of
those 49% said that they ate at least one apple banana cherry strawberry
whatever per day
so this is first evidence but weak evidence because it's just correlational
and it's not telling us anything about the causal relations from a psychologist
point of view the next study is much more interesting published by Goodwin in
2003 the and that's the title of the study the association between physical
activity and mental disorders among adults in the United States was observed
so this time it's not about your overall life satisfaction but this time it's
about the correlation between physical activity and mental disorders like
depression phobias panic attacks schizophrenia etc again they had a really
huge sample size they had 5,877 US citizens aged 15 to 54 years physical
activity was assessed by the question and now I quote from the study how often
do you get physical exercise either on your job or in a recreational activity
participants could answer with regularly occasionally rarely or never in the
analysis the category of regularly was compared with the other three categories
so they compared those participants who said yeah I'm regularly physical active
with those participants who were never to occasionally physical active the
results were quite impressive because it turned out that those participants who
were regularly physical active had a probability of only 8% to be depressive
whereas those participants who were never rarely or occasionally physical
active had a probability of about 13% to be depressed but all this evidence we've
been talking about up to now is not really strong evidence it's just
correlational it doesn't tell us anything about the causal relation so
for example it's no wonder that those participants who are depressed are not
that often engaged in physical activity because it's very hard for them to
motivate themselves for leaving the house and go running so maybe all this
evidence is not at all speaking for a positive effect of exercise for
depression but maybe all this evidence is just speaking for a negative effect
of depression on physical exercise so we need a better methodological approach
and already in the study by Rene Goodwin there is a better approach because they
also assessed potential confounding variables like age, gender, race, family
relations, education, income, physical diseases I mean especially this is
obviously a possible confounding variable because if you for example lost
a leg in a car accident it's quite logical that you don't go out running
every day and and it's quite logical as well that you could be depressed for
quite a long time so it's important to assess these variables as well and it
turned out when you control for all these variables if you adjust for all
these variables regular physical activity still reduces your probability
for example for a major depressive disorder for about 25% even bigger
reduced probabilities of about 35% were observed for social phobia if you are
afraid of what other people might think about you and agoraphobia if you are
afraid of for example places with many people for example afraid of for example
a supermarket scenario so this statistical analysis is already much
better but it's still not perfect because maybe there are other variables
that push the correlation between exercise and feeling better so what we
really need are experiments we need an experimental design with randomized
distribution of participants to one group being physical active exercising
and another group a weightless control group or even better a placebo group one
of the first well-done and very influential experiments was conducted
by McCann and Holmes and was published in 1984 in the journal of personality
and social psychology the title of the study influence of aerobic exercise on
depression 43 participants and this is obviously one weakness of the study but
later on we will get to know studies with much more participants 43
participants with major depressive disorder were randomly assigned to three
experimental groups the first group was the exercise group who engaged in so
called rhythmical aerobics so two times per week for one hour they met to go
running jogging or dancing besides that they were also told to take extra
activity outside of class the second group was a relaxation placebo group they
were told just like the aerobic exercise group was told well there's
evidence that exercise might improve depressive symptoms this group was told
well there's evidence that relaxation might improve depressive symptoms and
therefore they met for four times per week for 15 to 20 minutes and they
practiced progressive muscle relaxation PMR I guess you've heard of it you you
make your muscle very tense then you let it relax and this has a relaxing effect
on your body the third group was another control group this was a no treatment
group they were just answering the question about their depression at the
beginning of the study and at the end after 10 weeks of running jogging and
dancing a really huge effect could be observed for the aerobic exercise group
on average people in this group felt much less depressed in comparison there
was only a little numeric effect for the relaxation group and there was no effect
at all for the group that receives no treatment at all so from a historical
point of view a very important study because after this study even though
they had only a small number of participants because after this study
much bigger and better studies for example comparing antidepressants and
physical activity were conducted and we will take a look at these studies in a
