Pioneers: Women in British Art - Joan Carlile, 'Portrait of a Lady', 1640s

Antique Masterpieces
23 followers
This acutely observed, delicate portrait of an unknown woman suggest that artist and sitter were well acquainted. The name of the painter, Joan Carlile (c.1606-1679), is a sadly unfamiliar one today, though she was much admired in her lifetime and for many years after her death. In this film, Lawrence Hendra, Head of Research, and Emma Rutherford, Portrait Miniatures Consultant, delve into the life and work of this prolific portrait painter.
This work is currently on display at Philip Mould & Company as part of our exhibition, 'Pioneers: 500 Years of Women in British Art'. #AntiqueMasterpieces
I'm particularly pleased that for this exhibition we've managed to find a work by Joan Carlard
who, as you know, was a painter at the court of Charles I, who later moved to Richmond
at the outbreak of the Civil War. But interestingly, there appears to be some similarities with
what portrait miniature artists were doing at this date too.
So this is painted oil on copper and I think I'm right in saying it's one of the only works
known by her using copper as a support. And because it's therefore on this much smaller
scale it clearly relates to portrait miniatures. And I would say in particular the composition
with this dark background behind the sitter and then this landscape with this sort of
foggy ancestral home in the background really reminds me of works by John Hoskins and his
nephew, Samuel Cooper, who I'm sure Carlisle would have known.
Because she presumably met Cooper and Hoskins after she moved to, or she would have been
familiar with them, but of course she would have worked alongside them more or less in
Covent Garden where she moved to.
Yeah, so we know that she actually had a studio in Covent Garden, so like a professional artist
she actually hired rooms and had a studio there. And Cooper lived and worked in quite
grand premises in Covent Garden and it was a very mixed but highly artistic community
of which presumably she would have been accepted as a professional painter. But I don't think
this work was painted in Covent Garden.
No, so we think this one was painted a bit earlier, in the 1640s, so it's presumably
after Carlisle had moved out of London and to Richmond. And it's one of a number of works
by Carlisle that have come to light in recent years. In fact, the Argonne Gallery handled
one a few years ago, that's now in the Government Art Collection. And in fact the Tate bought
one a few years ago for their permanent collection.
Really I think the most defining characteristic of her portraits is the way that she painted
the flesh tones, they've always painted in this very sort of silvery manner. That's one
of the key characteristics. But also the very confident way that she paints her sitters'
costumes. And you can just see here on the sleeves it's painted with sort of very quick
brush strokes, quite thickly applied paint as well. And of course, because this work
has survived in such good condition, you can really see those features in a way that isn't
sadly possible in some of her other works.
So it's painted on this incredibly intimate scale, but we don't know who the sitter was,
but I think we can assume probably a close acquaintance, because she hasn't commissioned
a large painting for her home, something much, much smaller, but presumably no clues to the
sitter.
No, no, she has in the past been incorrectly identified as the Duchess of Cleveland, but
of course it isn't her, the dates wouldn't work at all if the Duchess of Cleveland, it
would be about ten when this work was painted. So we know it's not her, but no, we don't
know who she is. But of course, this was painted during a time of great austerity
in the 1640s, the Civil War was raging, so this would have been a relatively inexpensive
commission by comparison to one of Carlyle's larger, small full-length portraits, which
she otherwise would later specialise in.
She's still put on her very expensive lace, the collar and bonnet, and then her nice pearls
as well, so she's still wearing her finery despite it becoming a Puritan world in which
she's living. There's something really intimate about not just the scale, but the way she's
observed the face incredibly carefully, and even the hairline with this very wispy hair,
and the way the lace is turning. She's picked up some of the imperfections of the sitter
as well as her beautiful gown, and she's described that silk so well. She's a really
incredibly good artist, isn't she?
Yes, she is, and that's why I think it's such an exciting addition for our exhibition.
