Exclusive
How I Used Analytics and Metrics to Build a Successful University | Jim Doti

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
929 Video Views·Jan 28, 2025
Chapman University experienced remarkable growth over 25 years, expanding from 1,600 to 10,000 students and establishing itself as one of the premier schools in Southern California. Siyamak sits down with Jim Doti, who served as Chapman University's president during this transformative era.
"The most important attribute of a leader is not being on top of the data, not being persuasive, and not using data analytics to drive transformational change," says Doti. "The most important thing is to treat people with respect and dignity. You can't be a good leader unless you treat people well—with respect and dignity."
*Views expressed in this video/article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The California Insider.
Chapman University grew from 1,600 students to 10,000 students in over 25 years, and it became
one of the best schools in Southern California. My guest today is Dr. Jim Doughty, who's the
president of Chapman University during this growth phase. He's responsible for this growth,
and he tells us today what he went through in the process of this growth, and what lessons he
learned, what challenges he faced, and how he was able to make this happen. The most important
attribute of a leader, and that is not even being on top of the data, not being persuasive,
not using data analytics to drive transformational change. The most important thing, to treat people
with respect and dignity. You can't be a good leader unless you treat people well
with respect and dignity. I'm Siamak Rameh. Welcome to California Insider.
Jim, it's great to have you back on. Welcome back. Thanks, great to be back on. We want to
talk to you about your experience of building one of the most successful schools in California.
You started when this university had 1,600 students, and now it has 10,000, and it's one of
the biggest in the community, with some programs that are top 10 in the country. Can you tell us
how you started? Well, interesting that you should ask, because I just completed a book
that deals with that, delves into that very subject. The name of the book is
Using Data Analytics to Drive Transformational Change. It will be published by Roman and
Littlefield under the arm of the American Council of Education Series on Higher Education. What it
tries to do in the book is to explain the various strategies we used during the 25 years
I served as president to transform our university. So, can you tell us the story,
how you started with the university? You started as a professor, right? Yeah, I started as an
assistant professor of economics in 1974. This is my 50th year at Chapman. I'm still teaching.
I'm no longer president, but I started as an assistant professor, founded our Center for
Economic Research, the A. Gary Anderson Center for Economic Research at Chapman around 1970,
started our first economic forecast conference in 1978. Last December, we just had our 47th
annual economic forecast. I became dean of our business school, and then in 1987, I was serving
as acting president of the university. Our president came back. He retired. I became acting
president again, was a candidate for the position. The board didn't select me. I went to another
person, but that president stayed only about a year and a half, and then I became president in 1991
for 25 years, 1991 to 2016. So, tell us how you became a dean. Was it easy to become a dean?
That's a very interesting question, because in many respects, that led ultimately to my becoming
president. When I became a professor at Chapman, I had no interest in administration. I was very
happy teaching. I loved my students. I loved economics, and I loved teaching it, but our
president at the time, Buck Smith, was very persistent. He kept saying, I need you as a dean.
I kept resisting. Finally, I relented, because I finally got tenure, and I figured, well,
if I don't like it, I could always go back. Anyway, I became dean, but I learned a very
important lesson as dean. Actually, something else happened that was very important.
The person that was very much behind our business school was George Argyris.
So, as dean, I worked very closely with George Argyris, who loved the business school.
He's a big fan.
He was chairman of the board of trustees, very, very successful entrepreneur, a leader of our
community in many respects. He was serving as our board chair, and he loved our business school,
so he wanted to work very closely with me in building the business school.
So, I learned a great deal from George about leadership and what's necessary to drive an
institution. What are the basic elements? Things I didn't know, but the best way to learn is to
watch real leaders in action and then picking up their characteristics.
So, what did he teach you in that?
I think the most important thing he taught me was, I observed very closely
how he handled his own business. He had a very successful apartment business,
one of the largest in Southern California, thousands of apartments.
Others do as well, but his business always did a lot better than the competition.
Why is that?
I also saw him in action. We were on a committee together at Chapman.
I as dean and Mr. Argyris as a member of the board of trustees,
and I could see how he worked the committee and his leadership attributes.
Those attributes, I think most important was the fact that whatever he did,
he had a primary overriding goal that he was very passionate about.
In terms of his apartment buildings, he would walk those apartments.
He'd go out during the day and walk the apartments, make sure that everything was pristine,
clean, because in his inner being, what gave him the most satisfaction was not making a lot of
money, which he did. That was secondary to something that was far more satisfying,
and that is creating a residential community that he was proud of.
So, he really cared about the mission and what he's doing?
In spades. I mean, he really focused on that goal.
How do I make my apartment communities better? How do I improve the lifestyle so that
our residents are proud to be a part of an Arnell apartment?
Now, for you, were you able to take some of that and apply to it as a dean?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, because then I realized as dean...
Because in academia, there's a lot of things that are not...
I realized that the most important thing now, watching George Argyris in action,
I realized the most important thing is to have something you are passionate about,
something that will drive a transformational change.
When I say transformational change, I'm talking about big change,
something that's fundamental, something that changes the fabric of that institution.
In that case as dean, I was responsible for wanting to do that to our business school
that ultimately became the Argyris College of Business and Economics.
And I felt that the most important thing we could do was for us to become, our school,
to become accredited by the American Assembly Collegiate Schools of Business.
The acronym is AACSB. And this is the highest level of accreditation.
And only a few schools have that accreditation.
Most business schools in colleges and universities are not accredited.
At that time, you guys were small too, right?
We were small and no school of our size was nationally accredited.
That was the goal. I figured as dean, if we could achieve that,
we would be the smallest institution, smallest college
with a business school that is nationally accredited in Southern California.
Larger schools are, USC, the Cal State schools, UCLA, the UC schools, they're accredited.
But most private schools were not, independent schools were not.
So that was my focus. That was my vision.
And that's what I was passionate about.
Ironically, I couldn't do it.
And the reason I couldn't do it is because the higher ups at Chapman at the time
felt that our doing so would make it impossible for us to continue teaching courses
off campus, which we were doing at the time, not online courses,
but we had courses at military bases throughout the state.
And most of them were taught by adjunct or part-time faculty.
AACSB wouldn't allow that.
So if we were to become accredited, we would put that program in danger.
So the administration said no.
And I just fell back and said, it's not going to happen.
And I resigned as dean.
So I failed.
You resigned as dean?
I failed, yeah.
And then what happened?
You can't ultimately succeed at anything unless you go through some failures along the way.
So you resign as dean and you go to teaching.
I go back to teaching, exactly.
And then our president, Buck Smith, decided to go on sabbatical.
And he reaches down to me, rather than selecting one of his vice presidents,
and asks me to serve as acting president while he was on sabbatical, which I did.
I thought that would be an interesting experience for me to be his president,
but just acting president first semester.
I couldn't do anything transformational,
but it gave me an opportunity to see things from the top, if you will,
and see financial challenges at the top, but also board relations at the top.
So that gave me a lot of experience.
He came back, and then he resigned.
I became acting president again.
And I made another big mistake.
I wanted to move our Division III program,
during the time I was acting president, Division II athletic program to Division III.
That would allow us to save on athletic scholarships
and transform our athletic scholarships to academic-based scholarships.
I thought I had everyone in agreement, and that was going to happen.
The board would approve.
I go into the board meeting.
The board, at the last minute, decided not to,
because the athletic head at the time convinced the board not to do that.
It did an end-run to round May, and as a result, it failed.
So you thought you...
I thought it was happening.
But he was going behind you and...
Behind me, and it convinced George Argyris and other board members not to do it,
and it didn't happen.
And I realized it wasn't the athletic director's fault.
It was my fault.
I didn't do my homework.
I learned an important lesson, and that's why, in leadership,
there was something one of our board members, Harry Rinker, taught me.
When I explained the story, when I told him the story, he said,
you know, Jim, it wasn't a mistake.
You learned something from that.
As long as you learn...
If you make a mistake and you learn something, it's no longer a mistake.
So what did you learn from that?
Well, I learned that I had to do my homework.
I should have, if I had met with more trustees,
if I had a more solid base of supporters,
rather than just relying on one or two who the athletic director was able to sway,
because there was only one or two supporters,
if I had developed a stronger core of support for what I wanted to do,
I believe I would have been able to maintain and get that change that I was seeking.
But I didn't do it.
I didn't do my homework.
And my lesson was, in the future, if I want to propose something, make something happen,
I have to convince a larger group of people.
I have to be persuasive.
I have to do my homework.
I have to get my data and use data to present a compelling case
for whatever it is I want to achieve.
And what happened next?
Did you have to resign again?
So then, during that period I was president,
the board was looking for a new president.
I was a candidate.
But the board wanted someone more experienced as president than I was.
I had no experience.
So a candidate was selected who was 11 years as president at another institution.
He came.
He became president.
It only lasted about a year and a half.
Very qualified guy, but didn't really understand the culture of Chapman.
And it just didn't work out.
And he resigned.
And then the board came back.
And the third time, I became, this time, president, not acting president.
And you know one of the first things I did?
I went back and got the board to approve the change from Division 2 to Division 3.
That's amazing.
But I did it the right way.
You convinced everyone.
Now, at that time, how many people did you guys have?
How many students?
Students?
We had about 1,700 students.
So it was the beginning of the growth.
That was the beginning.
And that was both graduate and undergraduate students, 1,700.
Small school in Orange.
We weren't accredited by anyone.
We were considered a small college in Orange, a local kind of college.
Didn't really have any national reputation.
We did good work.
People like George Argyris graduated from Chapman.
Dale Fowler, another ultimately very successful entrepreneur, graduated from Chapman.
But we weren't on the map nationally.
And the major problem that I identified by looking at the data again.
I'm a data guy.
Remember, I'm an econometrician.
I love data.
And I use data to inform the decisions that we were making at Chapman.
And one of the things I found out early on is that a student would come to Chapman.
And if that student succeeded and was a good student, that student would leave after two
years and go to UCLA, USC, or some other school.
Transfer.
We were like a community college.
Other students that we brought in that were weaker students, many of them just couldn't
handle the course load and just dropped out.
So we were only a student that started Chapman as a freshman.
Only 38% of those students ultimately graduated from Chapman.
The norm is something around 65%, the average.
And we only had about 38%.
No one really knew that.
No one really.
The board was incognizant of that fact.
So I was able to bring that information to bear and let them know we're not doing something
right.
We have to change what we're doing to bring our graduation rate from 38% to something
more reasonable and ultimately something that would be stellar.
Something that would lead the pack.
How did you learn to do that?
To go and look at that specific data?
A lot of it I learned.
I know statistics.
I know econometrics.
I think it's just part of my core being to look at numbers.
So that happened even before I became president, even before I had my PhD.
So you were always analyzing?
When I was a student in graduate school, I was learning econometrics.
At the time, it was a new subject.
You needed computers.
And computers were just coming into being at the time.
I was a graduate student.
The big ones.
We used key punch cards.
Young people don't even know about it now.
So it was just at the formative stages of technology.
I had a part-time job and I learned how to do a regression equation to forecast the company
sales, which I was doing as a paper for a class.
Brock's Candy Company, who I was working for in Chicago at the time, was so impressed with
because my forecasts were more accurate than a sales forecasting team.
They gave me a promotion, my own office.
I was finally treated with some respect.
So I was getting more and more into data.
But probably the fact that I was interested in numbers was kind of a natural thing.
I remember in the 50s growing up, I knew the batting average of every baseball player in
the National and American League.
I could calculate the batting averages in my head when I would see Nellie Fox hit another
single up the middle at Comiskey Park.
So I liked numbers.
And it's natural then that I used numbers to help support and determine the kinds of
strategies we put into place.
We are honored to be sponsored by Shen Yun.
I've been attending Shen Yun performances every year as they change the choreography
and music.
Shen Yun takes you back in time to the magical world of ancient China with unique blend of
brilliant dancing, beautiful costumes, and legends coming to life.
Overall, it's a very meaningful performance with a lot more than just entertainment to
offer.
Make sure to go see it this year.
Go to Shenyun.com and book your tickets today.
I highly recommend it.
People nowadays go to the doctors, the psychiatrists for pills, for antidepressants.
This, this is the antidepressant, the best.
I knew it was going to be good.
It's a billion times better than I even thought it would be.
I heard people say, you don't want to miss this.
And I would fully agree.
I'm going to tell everyone to come see it.
You have to.
Definitely going to come back next year.
Totally inspirational.
You have to go see this.
It's a once in a lifetime must see that will change their lives forever.
And now you brought this decision to the board.
You have 1700 people.
You're the president of the school.
What happened next?
So, and this is the very important thing, Seamook, that, that I decided early on.
And it's something I learned during the time as a faculty member and a dean and as director
of our Center for Economic Research.
Periodically, the president would bring in a strategic planning expert to lead a strategic
planning program for the university.
The plan would be conducted.
There'd be a big volume that to do all of these things.
And then I would see that nothing happened.
The plan would go on a shelf and never be used.
It was.
And I thought it was just not only a waste of money, but a waste of people time.
People's time.
Because the consultants will talk.
It was so big.
What it was, was at the end, a wish list.
You know, everybody was well meeting.
So people with the strategic plan would come to the department heads, the deans and ask,
what do you need?
So they'd spot out everything they needed.
The plan would include all of these needs in this big volume, but too many more needs
than what resources were available to make them happen.
So nothing happened.
So what I learned from that is rather than a lot of different things to go forward to
change, select the most important thing.
Focus on that.
Okay.
So early on, we wanted to transform Chapman and make it the kind of institution with an
academic environment that students wanted to stay there, not transfer to another school.
Also, the kind of school that would be strong enough and have the kind of reputation to
attract better prepared students than what we were formerly able to recruit.
And more of those students would stay on.
So we decided the first thing, the first five years, we would focus on student selectivity.
How do we attract better students?
The deans and the schools in the department, they did other things.
That was fine.
My focus was attracting better students.
So every major thing we did as an institution for those five years.
Five years of doing one thing.
1991 to 1996 was the focus on that.
We did other things, but our focus, my focus was driving student quality.
And that's not an easy, you might say, you're kind of suggesting, gee, only one thing in
five years.
That's easy.
It's not.
Some things are so difficult and require a multi-pronged strategy that that's, it takes
five years to get that done.
So what are some of the things we had to do?
How do you attract better students?
One thing is you offer them more financial aid that required going from division two
to division three athletics.
I didn't do it the first time.
The second time I was successful, that helped us move $2 million in athletic scholarships
to academic.
So to throw money to recruit better prepared students.
That was just one strategy among many that to bring better students to Chapman.
The other was changing our fundraising to somehow, some way, make it possible to attract
donors that were interested in providing scholarships to attract these better students.
The other thing we did was change our pricing.
People don't realize that schools are like businesses.
Pricing strategy, price elasticity, all of the things you learn in economics are very
much a part of tailor-making and targeting a particular kind of student.
So we changed our pricing strategy, actually increased our price, and then discounted from
there.
By increasing the price, it gave us more of an opportunity to discount, when I say discount,
provide academic scholarships to recruit better students.
See, this wasn't easy.
It took time.
I'm telling you-
Because it was hard, probably, because all the students would get upset, right?
Yeah, well, you have a faculty out there.
You have many on the board that were really happy with the kind of school we were.
I had to try to convince them, showing data, that, okay, many, many faculty members, many,
many trustees were very supportive of the kind of school we were, which was, let anyone
in.
If you didn't have the grades, that's okay.
We'll transform you and give you a college education.
Give you a chance.
Give you the chance that other schools won't give you.
It's a noble goal.
It's tough to change that, because the trustees felt-
They came here to do that, right?
That's probably-
Yeah, that these are schools that were able to trans-
But it was data that allowed me to show, it's nice to have that as a goal, but it wasn't
working.
We weren't succeeding at that.
Because people were leaving, or people were not making it, right?
Now, how did you stay motivated?
Because it seems like you were doing your own thing, and you had this board of trustees,
some of them.
How did you manage to get yourself motivated?
Leadership and changing, moving, transformational change is an exciting business.
To be part of that is very rewarding.
There's a lot of rewards that come from seeing changes that all fit in and are part of a
fabric that ultimately moves an institution forward.
So when I was beginning to see better students, students being attracted to Chapman, that
I knew that those students were making our classroom experiences more exciting, more
vibrant, more vital, a campus more electric with ideas, that's very rewarding, and that's
self-motivating.
And what about, because universities are a unique place, because you have a lot of academia,
and academia, I know they have a lot of opinion.
They usually have very strong opinions, and they're very intellectual.
So managing that must be very difficult, because you're dealing with a lot of intellectual-
Very difficult, and you can't do it alone.
I can't go in as president and dictate things.
I don't think any leader can.
Even in the corporate world and the non-profit world, you can't do it on your own.
You have to have a team of people that make change.
And that means you have to bring, everybody has to be part of the bandwagon.
So you have to, just like my failure the first time around at trying to change our athletic
division, was because I didn't bring enough people along.
So you have to convince them, you have to get them as excited as you are about where
are you going, and you have to define that point.
That is where we're going.
Most schools are, and institutions, many of them, maybe not most, but many of them are
rudderless.
They're just churning, they're going around in circles, because they don't know where
and who they want to be.
If you have that, and if you can convince people, this is where we're heading, join
me, this is exciting.
This is going to make this place more exciting, vibrant.
We're going to bring in students that will make our fundamental thing, learning, a more
exciting experience.
People join the bandwagon.
They want to be part of an exciting place like that.
Takes time, but it can be done.
As long as you can make sure all of your strategies, all of the things that you're doing are
serving that purpose.
If you start getting distracted, getting involved in little wars or battles that don't
get you anywhere, you lose direction.
And that's what happens, I think, at most schools.
I noticed presence, my colleagues, peers in higher education, when I would talk with them,
I found that most of them were in petty battles with their faculty, and even their board,
over insignificant issues.
If you're going to have a battle, make sure it's an important issue, because then if you
win, you make a giant leap forward.
And it's worth it.
But if you get into a battle and you win, but it's to no purpose, all you're doing is
creating enemies and not moving the wheel.
Now, after you spent five years on bringing these students, so what happened next?
OK, so then the next thing, that's the next five years.
The next five years is, OK, our SAT scores are improving.
We're bringing in better students.
But now the question is, how many?
And we were bringing in more students.
You put focus on that and you already worked.
You were getting better.
In my book, I provide a lot of data.
And what we were doing was we were not only looking at the progress we were making, we
were evaluating Chapman's progress against the competition.
We set up three different levels of competition we were looking at, national, local, regional,
and seeing our progress compared, relative progress.
Relative progress means how much progress we're making compared to everyone else.
So we were doing that, but we realized we were growing.
Not only were we bringing in better students, more students.
So the next question is, how big do we want to be?
How big did you get?
So, well, ultimately, we went from the 1,700 to 10,000 students.
But at five over at the end of those five years, we went from around 1,700 to 2,200
students.
May not sound like much, but percentage terms, that's a big, that's like a 20% increase in
five years.
So the question is, how big should we be?
Again, data came to the core in terms of helping determine our decision.
We looked at all schools.
I looked at schools throughout the nation.
And I looked at the size of schools and their costs.
And I found that there's something in economics that relates to the average cost curve.
That is, economies of scale.
That as you become bigger, your costs per student actually drop.
And you could actually increase your quality, but costs would be lower.
Let's take as an example, you know, a library that, I'll just pull out a number.
Let's say a library, you want to make a $5 million investment by expanding your library.
And that costs, I don't know, $10 million.
But that expansion of the library allows you to bring in, I don't know, 5,000 more students.
That 5 million divided by the increased number of students actually will bring your per student
cost down.
So we looked very carefully at what areas were there economies of scale.
We found that we should move Chapman.
We decided we had to move Chapman from a small liberal arts college to a medium-sized institution.
We had to move from around 2,000 students to more like 4,000 to 5,000 students.
We had to more than double.
So we went from 1,700 to 2,200 at the end of 1996.
But we decided by 2011, we had to be moving to 4,000.
So we would be competing not against Whittier or Redlands or Occidental,
but against schools like Pepperdine, University of San Diego, the private school,
Santa Clara, Loyola Marymount University, medium-sized university.
That's a big stretch, but that's what we were going to do the next five years.
But you see, now we had from 1996 to 2001 now to focus on that.
And how did that go?
It went very well.
We achieved our goals, and we did that by a couple of things.
First of all, we decided how do we radically increase the number of students?
We were increasing it, but from 1,700 to 2,200.
How do we get to 4,000, 5,000?
You want to double.
Yeah.
So we did that first.
I went back to the board and now got the board to approve the AACSB for our business school.
I'm kind of tenacious about that.
I went back just like we did on the athletic.
Here's something interesting.
When I wanted to move our business school when I was dean to AACSB accredited,
the first time I was dean, I did get it because we were to be jeopardizing our off-campus programs.
It didn't fit into anything.
So it didn't fit into an all-encompassing strategy.
But when I was president, we decided here's the school we want to be.
All of a sudden, AACSB accreditation made sense.
It was no longer an anomaly, but consistent.
It was aligned with what you wanted.
All of these other schools that we wanted to be like, LMU, Pepperdine, University of San Diego,
these middle-sized schools, they were all AACSB accredited.
Well, if we want to be a school like that, all of a sudden, strategically, it makes sense to do that.
And now all of a sudden, the board can say, yeah, we should have done this a long time ago.
But now we knew where we wanted to go.
So that was one thing.
The other very important thing is we started a film school,
which was now our film school is ranked fourth best in the nation.
Small Chapman, we had the fourth best film school.
Why did you start this film school?
Easy.
It's something economists call comparative advantage.
What program could we do at Chapman that would have an advantage over other schools?
Film.
We were, you know, our location to Hollywood.
How many schools are located near the motion picture capital of the world?
Not many, but we were one.
So we figured we would have an advantage over other schools because we could attract
professorial talent, directors, screenwriters,
cinematographers from Hollywood to teach at Chapman.
We had an incredible dean by the way.
Actually, at that time, a department head by the name of Bob Bassett,
who had a very exciting vision about using
digital photography instead of the old print.
No other school was doing that.
And he had a focus on storytelling for our school.
So we had all of the elements in place to move our business school,
to move our film program forward.
Thankfully, we had people like Marianne Knott.
We had CeCe Presley and other people.
Ultimately, Christina and Larry Dodge ultimately became the Dodge College of Film.
People that gravitated to our film school provided the funding that allowed us to build
our film school from a small department to now what is considered the fourth best in the country.
Jim, did you have a hard time attracting people to come to your university to teach
and work with you guys?
Well, you were a small...
Initially, yes.
Because...
You were small.
Chapman.
Who's Chapman?
What's Chapman?
And we didn't have the funding in place to pay the kind of salaries to attract the best
and the brightest faculty.
So yeah, initially it was difficult.
But if you do things in stages, things work out.
So the first five years, better students.
We have better students faculty like to go to places that have better prepared students.
Secondly, in our next five years, we built certain programs like a film school that was
increasingly giving us national visibility, an AACSB approved law school.
And thirdly, we established a law school.
Why a law school?
All of these other schools, LMU, Pepperdine, University of San Diego, Gonzaga...
They all have law schools.
If we want to be in playing that game, we have to have a law school.
So we had a law school that established more of a national identity and reputation.
And as our reputation grew, more and more people knew who we were, where we were going
when they would visit the campus and realize that, hey, we had an exciting vision that
everyone seemed to be pushing and moving towards.
They come to Chapman rather than they're visiting a school that they're looking at
and everybody's fighting about who we are and what we want to be.
We knew what we wanted to be.
So that was the third element was establishing not only these new academic programs, but
ultimately then developing a campus.
That was our fourth five year plan was to build the kinds of facilities that would drive
academic quality.
And was it always in the area it was or you guys decided to move there or the campus?
No, it was always in Orange.
But we only had about 40 acres.
But since we knew we wanted to be bigger, we did two things.
First, we kept buying land, ultimately acquiring about 100 acres, more than doubling the size
of the campus.
The other thing we did ultimately was to acquire land in Irvine for our graduate health science
programs, what we now call the Rinker Health Science.
So a lot of different things were going on, but they were all driven by a strategy of
quality.
I'll give you an example.
You asked the question earlier, how do you attract the best and brightest faculty?
And I said, well, I pointed out, well, our reputation was growing, but we needed to do
something else.
Two things we identified.
It was a five-year period where we focused on attracting better faculty and even faculty
stars like Nobel laureates, national science winners.
How do we do that?
Two things.
Number one, we began focusing our attention on the salary survey put out by the AAUP,
the American Association of University Professors.
It gives you the average salary in different ranks.
We're at the bottom of the barrel.
Even though our campus was in Orange County where housing prices were higher than the
nation.
So what we did was, how are we going to attract the resources to pay higher salaries?
I found in the balance sheet, actually in the income statement, the P&L, that there's
a ratio of academic spending on faculty to total spending.
What was our ratio?
Nobody looks at that.
We did.
And we compared ourselves to other schools.
We were spending about 52% of our budget on academic spending.
Faculty, research, things like that.
It was about the average of all other schools.
So we weren't behind the wagon, but we were low given the fact that costs in Orange County
were so high.
So what we decided to do was to increase that ratio from 52% to 65%.
We did that by increasing that percentage 2% a year over a five-year period.
So it went from 52% to 65%.
Actually outpaced our ultimate goal.
That allowed us to increase our salaries.
So we were at the 95th percent of salaries for instructors, assistant, associate, and
full professors.
The other thing we did was we increased the number of endowed chairs.
To your audience, an endowed chair is one of the most important things a faculty member
can strive for.
Even more important than the salary is to hold an endowed chair because it's a recognition
of the kind of impact one is making in the profession.
We had one endowed chair when I became president.
When I left, we had 65 endowed chairs and professorship.
Generally, an endowed chair now requires a donation of around $2 million.
I was very fortunate to hold the Donald Bren chair in economics, and that meant more to
me than my title as president or my title as a full professor because of the recognition
that comes from having an endowed chair.
So when I recognized that, we increased salaries, but we also increased the number of endowed
chairs.
That allowed us to recruit not only a Nobel laureate like Vernon Smith and his team of
researchers that we were able to bring from George Mason University, but people like physicists
like Yakir Oranov, who was a National Medal of Science winner, and others as well that
we brought to Chapman.
And those faculty stars, even people like Elie Wiesel, we were able to bring on an annual
basis over a two-week period another Nobel laureate.
This helped create not only to bring these stars to campus, enriching the academic life
of the university, but it enhanced our national visibility and reputation.
That allowed us to bring more people to campus.
Now, you mentioned endowed chair.
Does that require raising a bunch of money?
Yeah.
And how did you do that?
Yeah.
So, you know, most donors aren't even aware of what, they're not cognizant of an endowed
chair.
So when we as a strategy realized we needed more of them, I had to work closely with our
advancement team.
Advancement team, those are the people that work on trying to get gifts to the university.
And I had to say, we have to give higher priority to getting endowed chairs.
What does that mean, higher priority?
It means, first of all, to teaching donors, letting them know the importance, the significance,
the value of an endowed chair.
Unlike a building, let's say a donor wants to create a building.
Because people put their names on these buildings.
Yeah, they put a name on the building.
You see a name on a building.
There's a lot of recognition and rewards that come from that.
Not so much in an endowed chair, other than the endowed chair holder and maybe a few faculty
and students knowing about it.
It's not well known.
So one of the things we did, it happened as a result of a, I talk about, I write about
this in the book.
I was training for a marathon, my first marathon in Chicago.
And I was in Rome.
And I had to do the, there's a required 20 mile run you do two weeks before the marathon.
And so I go to the concierge of our hotel and, where can I run?
I'm not going to run out in the streets, smog ridden hot.
And I said, what can I run?
And he recommended the Burghese Gardens.
Where's that, told me, and Burghese Gardens, beautiful area of Rome.
Kind of high, so it's above the fog and smog.
And I was running there and I ran through, beautiful place, did my 20 miler, successfully
did my marathon in Chicago a few weeks later.
But as I was running the marathon, I was running on this one promenade where there were these
pedestals and statues of famous world luminaries, artists, writers, the Greek and Roman scholars,
the Renaissance intellectuals and scholars and artists.
And I thought, wouldn't that be something to do that at Chapman?
Have these busts of these famous people.
But even better, when someone gives a chair, my wife and I, Lynn and I, we gave a chair.
Here's what happened.
We were thinking, do we want to endow a chair as part of our, endow a scholarship as part
of our giving back to our university that we love so much?
Or do we want to create a chair?
We knew if we created a chair, I could designate that the person that would be symbolic of
that chair is Milton Friedman, my teacher at University of Chicago.
So when you endow a chair, you could select someone to symbolize what that chair represents.
Dick Bortea, another great donor at Chapman, he gave a chair in music.
He loved Ella Fitzgerald.
So we had a bust of Ella Fitzgerald.
We had the incredible husband and wife team of Paul and Mary Bell Musco.
They loved Giacomo Puccini, the great opera composer of La Boheme, Tosca, Madame Butterfly.
And so they did a chair and we did a cast of Giacomo Puccini.
So now if you come to campus, you're going to find a slew of statues.
And we have a little quotation of that personage, whoever it is.
And when you go to come to campus, you can't help but stop.
Who is that?
Look at the person's name.
You see a quote from that person.
And then underneath that quote, it says, this pedestal and statue of whomever honors the
creation and establishment of the blank endowed chair.
Don Kennedy, wonderful one, really the leader that really brought first American financial
as making one of the leading title companies in the nation right here in Orange County.
His hero is mine, Abraham Lincoln.
He selected Abraham Lincoln.
So when you come on campus, you'll see a quotation of Abraham Lincoln.
And it will say, this this this statue of Abraham Lincoln honors the establishment
of the Donald Kennedy chair in law.
And then there will be a quote from from Lincoln.
From Lincoln.
You seem to have a very strong vision of where things were going.
And in an organization like a university, it's probably very difficult to do that because
there's different people.
They have different different visions and they're on boards and they're probably powerful
people.
And then you have your professors and deans and everybody has their ideas.
How did you guys manage to have a unified vision?
You work with the various constituencies.
That's what, in fact, the fact that there are so many different so-called owners of
the university, you have the faculty, you have trustees, you have administrators, you
have students, you have alumni, you have the church community, all.
They are pulling you to a different.
They all own part of the university.
You have to bring out all of those along.
So various ways you do it.
Power of persuasion.
But mostly it's it's creating rational arguments backed up by data that convince people, hey,
yeah, that makes sense.
I'm supportive.
And so you do that.
Maybe as president, I'll do that with the trustees because I'm the main conduit between
the board and the institution is the president.
I serve at the behest of the board of trustees.
They can hire they hire me and they can fire me and they also reappoint me.
So that's my constituency.
I have a senior staff.
I work with the provost, the various vice presidents, the vice president for advancement,
for administration, build a strong team, the senior staff, and they work with their constituents
to bring our message to them.
The provost works with the faculty and everything we do, we do together.
So if there's an idea, we we we bring those ideas to everyone so they're all supportive
and understand how it fits into the overall puzzle.
So they can.
Yeah, it makes sense.
I'm supportive.
Now, Jim, the board of trustees that over the years, I assume it changed, but did did
were they surprised with what you did?
Because they didn't hire you in the first round.
They said you didn't have enough experience.
I think I was the only one out there after their appointment.
Didn't work out when I was a candidate.
They felt we got to do something.
We can't do a search again.
So Jim is our guy.
I'm not sure the expectations were very high.
But when they began to see, and I'm not sure they were even all that comfortable with some
of the things that we were doing at first, they went along.
I brought the data.
So they went along maybe grudgingly at first.
But when they began to see our SATs increasing, our move in the U.S. News and World Report
rankings going from the bottom of the barrel to higher and higher and higher, they became
more proud to be part of Chapman because they could see that the school was gaining national
visibility and was doing a better job at what it's supposed to be doing, and that is to
create an exciting academic environment.
They were more proud to be part of that school, as were our faculty, as were our students.
Now, for you, what did you go through when you got appointed and then got back to teaching
and then you got appointed again and then they didn't want to have you lead?
What was it like?
Well, yeah, I felt like I was being whipsawed.
When I didn't get the job as president, I was very disappointed.
But I'll never forget something.
When that decision was made, George Ardrous, who was chairman of the board, he actually
came to, drove from his office to my office to tell me, Jim, we didn't select you, we
appointed.
He could have called me, could have had somebody else.
He knew his news that was disappointing to me, but he had the courage and the respect
that he gave me to do that.
And, you know, my reaction was, I'm disappointed.
As Adlai Stevenson said when he lost a second time to Dwight Eisenhower's president back
in the 1950s, he said, it hurts too much to laugh, but I'm too old to cry.
And that's kind of how I felt.
But the good thing was, listen, I could go back to the faculty.
I have a book to write.
I could do my research again.
I love teaching.
So I'm still doing something I really enjoy.
And that's what I did.
And what you mentioned, the fact that he came to you and he gave you that message, what's
the difference?
It showed to me the importance of probably the most important attribute of a leader.
And that is not even being on top of the data, not being persuasive, not using data analytics
to drive transformational change.
The most important thing is to have to treat people with respect and dignity.
George showed me with that visit that that's what he was all about.
And that's what that's what a good leader is all about as well.
You can't be a good leader unless you treat people well with respect and dignity.
He came and met with you and for a couple of minutes, right?
More like an hour.
So he came and met with you for an hour.
And what did that mean to you?
Well, that I was I was impressed.
He taught me a lesson about what what respect, treating people with respect, what it means.
It's more than just talking the talk.
It's living the talk.
And he did that.
A very busy man to take the time to do that.
It showed to me that as successful as he is, I could see how important people are to him
and treating people well.
George Argers, a graduate of Chapman, comes from humble circumstances.
The fact that he's a Horatio Alger recipient of the Horatio Alger Award is an indication
of that.
That's an award given to people who've made a great success, but from very modest circumstances.
His his parents were Greek immigrants.
And he came as a young man.
He worked very, very hard when he was going to school at Chapman.
He was working at the local grocery store as a manager.
And, you know, it was a bootstrap kind of thing.
But he ultimately became very successful.
But it wasn't easy.
It wasn't on a silver platter.
He did it on his own.
But there are certain in there are certain fundamental characteristics that lead to success.
It's not just working hard.
It's not just having a grand vision.
But it's also, as I say, treating people the way you want to be treated.
So, Jim, how was the last five years?
So you kind of you got you got to your you're building this university with data.
You change the culture.
Remember, 25 years as president of five five year plans.
Students, what size?
We grew the campus.
Buildings was another.
Faculty fourth, fifth.
What do we do now?
And it was at that time looking at the landscape of Orange County.
Many people don't realize this.
At Chapman, in a combined research effort with UCI's Chapman, UCI advanced industry list,
we rank the advanced industry, high tech, highly scientific, higher paying jobs.
People don't realize that Orange County out of 50 different
metropolitan statistical areas, the top 50.
We are number one in medical products, manufacturing.
And people didn't know that.
Most people don't know that.
We're number one.
But told me that we should be Chapman should be
graduating more students with a specialty in that area.
We had the acumen in that area, which meant that we needed engineers.
We needed more natural scientists.
We had a science program.
We did not have an engineering program.
So the next five years was to create an engineering school,
build the foundation for that school.
And secondly, to build our science program,
build a new science center, which cost 125 million dollars,
which I have to pay my respects to the Keck Foundation
that made that made the gift possible for us to do that.
And build a campus in Irvine because we didn't really have
the kind of space we needed in Orange,
which we wanted to focus on our undergraduate program.
But to build out our health science program in pharmacy,
in physician assistantship, in physical therapy,
in our brain institute and other areas in the future,
medical school, veterinary medicine, dentistry.
That's in the future.
But to do that, we needed a larger campus.
So we began buying land in Irvine.
It's now part of our Rinker campus.
That's what we were doing in those five years
to lay the foundation for a stronger program
in the natural sciences, engineering and the health sciences.
And you guys attracted a lot of donors by then, right?
You had a lot of support from the community.
What was it like for you during that phase?
People could see the need.
People could see the need for that kind of graduate in Orange County.
People could see that if Orange County is going to be a vibrant community,
we need to have more education,
another private school able to produce graduates in engineering and science.
So when the community is supported, when they see the need,
they naturally want to be part of it.
People have often, you know, the word is out there that,
oh, Jim Doty is a really terrific fundraiser.
We've heard that, by the way.
There's the old joke that if I enter a bar or a restaurant,
everybody runs out because they're afraid I'm going to ask them for money.
Causes a mass exodus.
The thing is, you know, if one is a good fundraiser, you don't have to ask for it.
People recognize the need and they come to you and they say,
I want to be a part of this.
It was like Marionette when she decided that,
hey, it was a good idea to build a film school.
She came to me and said,
Jim, can I be part of this?
We need a film school.
C.C. Presley, who's the granddaughter of Cecil B. DeMille,
she came, we need this in Orange County.
I didn't come to her, she came to me.
You know, interesting story about C.C. Presley.
I was at an event, I didn't know C.C. Presley.
I didn't know most of the people at this event,
but I'm there hobnobbing, it was a cocktail event of some sort.
And I started a conversation with her.
We started talking about movies.
I love movies.
I could see she knew more than I did.
So we talked like an hour.
And finally she said, by the way, who are you?
I said, I'm Jim Dodd.
I'm president Chapman.
You're president?
And I said, who are you?
How do you know so much about film?
Well, our family has been involved a little bit in film.
I said, well, my grandfather was a director.
Director, who is it?
Cecil B. DeMille.
Anyway, they come to you because they want to be part of something
that's improving our community, enhancing our community,
enriching the lives of young people.
They want that.
They want to be part of that.
Now, Jim, when is the book coming out?
The book will be out mid 2025.
I'm very happy.
I have a wonderful publisher, Roman and Littlefield,
which is part of the Bloomsbury Publishing Group.
But what I'm really excited about is it's being published
under the rubric of the American Council of Education,
the acronym ACE.
And they have a series in higher education
where they select important books in higher education.
And as a result of that, it gives me an entree
to boards of trustees, administrators, presidents and provosts.
We're all part of ACE.
That's an organization that produces programming,
enriching educational programming for these groups.
So if you're a trustee and you want to know more about higher education,
you will attend a session that ACE sponsors.
Well, when ACE sponsors these, they'll be inviting the likes of me
and other authors of their series to present some of the ideas
that I'm sharing with you today.
Dr. Jim Dodi, president emeritus of Chapman University,
it was great to have you on California Center.
Thinking, how do we go through a whole show without talking about economics
and the Orange County economy?
Maybe we'll save that for the next show.
