How does one go about dating an artefact that was found in a field in England by a metal detectorist? And by dating we’re not talking dinner and a movie with your favourite curb chain…
As part of the Treasure process in the UK, artefacts found by metal detectorists that happen to be of a high percentage precious metal, need to go through a process of identification and classification. Join curator, Rachel King as she investigates the clues found on this spectacular gold pendant to shed some light on when it was made, by whom and for whom.
Chapters 00:00 Introduction 02:00 A Quick Aside – Terminus dates 02:45 Investigating the clues on the front 03:48 The clues on the back 04:39 Dating the materials 05:00 The Gold Standard 06:06 Enamel decoration 07:47 The Tudor Curb chain 09:55 Johann Froben 11:46 Jousting at Greenwich 13:20 Who could afford such an artefact? #AntiqueJewellery
Today we're going to be looking at this Tudortastic piece of bling.
It was found completely unexpectedly at the end of 2019 in a field.
One of the parts of my job here at the museum is to answer questions about how an object like this
was made, when and for whom. My name is Rachel King, I'm curator of Renaissance Europe and
the Waddesdon Bequest here at the British Museum and welcome to my corner.
Today we've got the exceptional opportunity to look at this sensational object. You might have
heard about it through the press. It's a really recent find which has come to us through the
Portable Antiquities Scheme. It weighs just under 350 grams. It's a pendant in the shape of a heart
with a chain of 75 links. It was found in December 2019 by a gentleman named Charlie Clark,
a metal detectorist working in Warwickshire. He was working over the field when he heard the
sound on his machine that indicated there would be something special in the ground below him
and as he began to dig he saw the shine of gold. He says he had to reach in up to his elbow
and then he pulled this out. Can you imagine the feeling that that must have given him?
In the museum as well we were pretty surprised to see something of this type. Charlie did the
right thing according to the treasure process and he took it to his local finds liaison officer.
The finds liaison officer investigated the object initially for him and then it came to London to
the British Museum. The British Museum was absolutely the right place for something like
this to come because we have a range of expertise here in house that allowed us to investigate the
piece and to think more carefully about when this could have been made, for whom and why.
A quick aside. Before we carry on we need to introduce you all to a concept that archaeologists
use to work out the date of an object. It involves identifying something we call terminus dates or if
you know your Latin a terminus posquem, the earliest possible date an object could have been made
and a terminus antiquem, the latest possible date an object could have been made. Rachel's job is to
use each element of the pendant to reduce the gap between the two terminus dates until she's left
with the smallest plausible period of time that the pendant could have been made in. For now our
terminus antiquem is pretty easy to work out. The pendant was found in December 2019 and so must
have been made before this date. Everything else is still unknown. Back to you Rachel.
So let's take a look at some of the clues that this object gives us about itself. Let's begin with
the heart pendant at the base. You can see a domed heart around that a border of twisted ribbon.
In the centre we have a motif which is a red and white rose superimposed entwined with a pomegranate
and then we have a banner stretching across the bottom with a text toujours. Now some of these
motifs mean something. In particular you might already know the red and white rose. That's the
symbol of the Tudor dynasty and is used by them after 1485. The pomegranate here is a symbol used
by Catherine of Aragon and they're entwined. Things like this tend to be a reference to a union.
In this case the union between the Tudor dynasty and the dynasty of Aragon, more specifically
the marriage of Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon. If I turn the object over on the back
there's a very specific clue. You might have already asked why am I saying Henry? Because
Catherine was married to Henry's older brother first. But of course here we have the H, Henry
and the K of Catherine and they're knitted together by a white ribbon which ends in these
natty little tassels that have the effect of being like thistle heads and again down at the bottom
here the banner which says toujours. That's the first slew of clues that we want to investigate.
I've implied that those related to Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon but essentially I could make a
heart today if I were skilled enough like this and I could decorate it with all of these motifs.
Motifs are one thing but they don't get you down to that very specific moment in time and in the
museum here we have scientific laboratories and our colleagues working there are able to apply
a number of different techniques to an object like this. It's they who can test the surface
purity of the metal, they can identify the metal, in this case as I've already said it's gold
and we know it's between 23 and 24 carats so a very high purity. There were certain expectations
of goldsmiths working under the reign of Henry VIII. They had to produce objects of a certain
gold quality. So although we can't tell where the gold came from to make this object or when
it was mined, we can look at the purity of the object and see whether that's consistent with
what we would expect a goldsmith to be making from that period. By and large it's generally
accepted that an object from this period should be of high quality gold. Conveniently this object is
of high quality gold. However, when the object came into the museum we realised there wasn't
very much data out there so we did a wholesale survey of English made objects from around this
period that are already in the British Museum's collection and we happened to find out that almost
no object conforms to what the Leal standards were. So the subject's somewhat of an outlier
in that circumstance. We can also test the colourful decoration on the object. We call this
enamelling. It's a glass-based decoration and you can see white and red and amber colour
and on the back there's a little bit of black. We look at the recipes that were used to make them
both in books and manuscripts that survived from the period but also through analysis. For an object
that would be from the time of Henry VIII we have certain expectations of what those recipes
should contain and in this case the scientists here were able to demonstrate that the contents
of the enamels here are consistent with what we would think about for this period but more
specifically particularly when it came to the black enamels a specialist in the museum here
was able to demonstrate that those black enamels would very likely have been made before 1530.
Now that's very good for this object because Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon were married between
1509 and their marriage was annulled in 1533. What's particularly interesting about this object
though some of it's made in a very high quality way and other parts of it are made in the rather
slapdash cobbled together manner. In fact one of the questions we had was is this a whole object
or are these two pieces which have been brought together and there seems to be a significant
difference in quality of workmanship between the pendant and the chain. Now which one do you think
is better than the other? In fact it's the chain which is significantly better than the heart.
This chain is made of 75 individual links. Each link is fed through four other links.
It allows the chain to lie flat at all times. It stops it becoming tangled. Each link is
individually soldered into place. You might know this form of chain already. It's what we call in
modern English a curb chain. It's the type of chain that you often have for a handbag or you
might also see it on the bearskins if you see the changing of the guard at Buckingham Palace.
This type of chain means that there's a lot of gold used in a very very small space and in fact
of the 350 grams that this object makes up about 300 grams are in the chain and only 50 grams
in the heart. How do we know that the chain and the heart are made at the same time? Well
again that comes back down to consistency. The enamels which are used on the heart and the
enamels which are used on the hand are not only consistent with the period we expect
but they're also consistent with one another. So it's either the case that whoever enamelled
the heart enamelled the hand or that the people who enamelled heart and hand were working from
the same recipe or they might even have been working in the same workshop. Whatever is the
case they shared some type of knowledge. We wanted to look at other ways of dating the object
and as I've already said for the heart motifs are one important way to do that. So let's say
something about the hand as a motif. It took us a long time to identify a source for this hand
but we're happy to say that we found an image that we believe might have inspired the craftsperson.
In the middle of the 1510s a book printer and publisher working in Basel, his name is Johann
Froben, develops the symbol for his printing press and Froben's symbol was a hand with cuff emerging
from a cloud. The hand is in a fist shape. When Froben is publishing his books this symbol is
being spread all across Europe. Books were very important and expensive things at this time of
course but if you were a scholar you would have been acquainted with the works of Erasmus of
Rotterdam or someone like Thomas Moore and Froben was their publisher. How did the goldsmith come to
know the motif? Well we don't know the answer for that. It could be because whoever asked
the goldsmith to make this piece supplied the types of motifs they wanted to have. It could be
because the goldsmith themselves perhaps came from Europe and many goldsmiths also worked with
publishers and printers to engrave for them so that their books could be illustrated. It could
be that the goldsmith was fairly learned and had access to books of this type anyway. There are a
number of avenues still to explore but whatever is the case we can certainly date this hand as a
motif to somewhere around 1515, 1516, 17 and available in England around that time as well.
We started to look at manuscript sources, archival sources, accounts of Henry's court. There's a lot
about how Henry spent his money. His father had been very frugal and Henry inherited huge sums.
He liked to splash the cash, he liked to have a party and there were many celebrations throughout
the year. We found in 1521 an account of the tilt yard which is like a jousting place at Greenwich,
one of the king's palaces. They're tidying up after a joust which had happened at Shrovetide
that year and one of the things that they're starting to wonder about whether to keep or to
get rid of are a series of horse's bards and these horse's bards are decorated with a hand
emerging from a cloud and the hand emerging from a cloud is holding
entwined boughs of roses and pomegranates and letters H and K interlaced together.
So with that in hand we think we've narrowed it down further and we'd like to suggest that this
object might have been made in the context of one of these entertainments because the motifs
on this object are so similar to the motifs which are recorded as being on the horse decoration.
We've been through all of the inventories and other surviving documentation for Henry VIII
and his wife Catherine of Aragon and it's fair to say in comparison with the type of objects that
Henry had and Catherine for that matter too, this object much as it weighs nearly 350 grams
is pretty puny in comparison. It's likely that somebody who belonged to the upper nobility
or who was a high-ranking courtier could have afforded an object such as this.
They were in the pay of Henry so in this effect Henry is the paymaster for everything
but we haven't been able to demonstrate that Henry himself directly had this made
or that Henry and Catherine were the wearers of something like this. It was an expensive object
in its time and if you were for example master of the mint, which would be something of the
equivalent of the Chancellor of the Exchequer today, an object like this might have cost you
half your annual salary. These are all ideas and we're feeling our way towards understanding this
object still. It was found three years ago in 2019 and it came into the museum in 2020.
We're in 2023 now. It's very likely it'll take us just as long again, if not longer,
to really understand this and hopefully with time we'll also begin to understand how and why
this came to be in Warwickshire in a field. If you think this is over the top then wait until
you see some of the other things I've got the privilege of looking after here at the museum.
You can see some of my other videos here.