The recent fires in Los Angeles tested the city's emergency response, raising important questions about preparedness and coordination. In this episode, we sit down with former Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva, who shares insights on the obstacles responders faced, the impact on communities, and what steps can be taken to improve future responses.
"If you look at the press conferences, you see all these people standing behind the microphone. Everyone's crowding in, and then, when they get on the microphone, they say, 'Oh, I want to thank this person. I want to thank that person.' People don't want to hear that. They want to hear what's coming next and how you're going to make their lives better—because, right now, they've lost everything. That's what they want to hear," says Villanueva.
There are a lot of discussions and rumors online about how LA handled the fires.
My guest today is Alex Villanueva, former Los Angeles Sheriff, who has been an insider in
dealing with such emergencies in the past. He's here to tell us what went well and what didn't
go well and what the city should do to improve responding to these type of emergencies.
If you look at the press conferences, you see all these people standing behind
the microphone. Everyone's crowding in and then when they get on the microphone,
oh, I want to thank this person, I want to thank that person, I want to thank that.
People don't want to hear that. They want to hear what's coming next and how are you
going to make my life better because right now I've lost everything. That's what they want to hear.
I'm Siamak Ghorami. Welcome to California Insider.
Alex, it's great to have you back home. Welcome back.
Oh, thank you, Siamak. Appreciate that.
You know, we are seeing the fires in Los Angeles and there's a lot going on. You're somebody that
has been in the system that knows what's going on behind the scenes. We want to hear from you.
What happened? What went wrong? What went well?
Well, I can start with what went well, and that is the firefighters on the ground,
the law enforcement on the ground working, either battling the flames or trying to get people
evacuated, trying to prevent looting. That effort is ongoing. National Guard coming in and assisting
as well. All of that is working great. Everything that is not that, not so great. And this is about
planning the events that led up to when the fires first started.
Can you tell us step by step what did you see and what did you hear? Because you have people
from on the ground that are telling you what's going on.
Well, you got to recognize that these fires in 2025 are five years or four and a half years after
the summer of love of 2020, when the big craze of defunding law enforcement and basically
dismantling the public safety network to shift all the monies and the resources to social justice
programs, soft things. They have nothing to do with public safety. And now fast forward to 2025,
a huge demand for firefighters, huge demand for law enforcement, and the bodies are just not there
to provide it. So that's part of the shortcoming. But the planning part is a troublesome because
I think January 2nd or so, 1st or 2nd, the National Weather Service issued a PDS,
particularly dangerous situation. And they were predicting and forecasting hurricane force winds,
you know, sustained winds of 60 to 80 miles per hour with gusts up to 100 miles per hour,
which is unheard of. And that was for the areas that had been through two years of record rainfall,
followed by eight months of no rain whatsoever, and record heat, which meant you had a huge amount
of buildup of fuel. And now you're going to blow 100 mile per hour wind through that. That should
have been a massive red flag that says this is an unusual event, we have to prepare for it.
The city fire started pre-positioning some assets, but they didn't do all the assets,
put them in the right positions in the Palisades, for example, Topanga Canyon, that's county fire.
So same thing with the Eaton Canyon, where the two big fires broke out, the city and the county
weren't ready for the magnitude of what happened afterwards. And that is concerning. Now that they
got their feet wet the hard way, now we have a new fire today, a huge fire in Castaic. Now they're
doing better about early evacuations, they're being more aggressive early on, which is good.
So they're learning from the mistake, but you can't unring the bell from what happened two weeks ago.
You mentioned the police role in this. What role did the police have to play?
Well, they have two primary roles. There's what's called a unified command. So you have fire
assets, you have law enforcement assets, you'll have public works, for example. All these people
are going to come together in the incident command system, and they form a unified command.
So there's leaders of each group, they meet together to decide how they're going to address this.
Before there is a fire, right?
Unfortunately, this started when the fire started. It should have been spun up
days prior, with the warnings, so they would have everything in place. For example, in Pacific
Palisades and Topanga Canyon, that area, their mountainous roads are very narrow. You can't get
fire engines through when everyone's parked on the shoulders of the road. That's always been a problem.
So they have to issue parking restrictions because of the threat, so that clears out the road.
You have to do early evacuations and get everybody out in a timely, orderly fashion,
because every once you evacuate at once, is exactly what happened. Everyone jumped on the
road and no one could move at all. I talked to someone who was stuck in a car in the Palisades,
and they ended up walking away from their car because they couldn't go anywhere.
And of course, the car burned down, their house burned down. That shouldn't have happened. And this
is where the Highway Patrol is involved as well, because when you clear out all the traffic to let
people out, that means you got to clear it out all the way to the freeways. You make everything
one direction only. If there's two-lane roads, they become one direction, both lanes, and you
got to get people moving out. So the law enforcement had to do that, right? They do the evacuations
while the fire department, they do the firefighting. And that's the way it's supposed
to work. Because law enforcement has a lot more bodies than fire does, about five times as many.
But the fire people are devoted to putting out the fires, and they can do containment,
they do their lines of defense, all those things they do, the aerial assault with the tankers and
all that, they do that. Law enforcement does evacuations, then they got to do the traffic
control, make sure people don't go back into the area, prevent the looting, for example,
that happened a lot afterwards. So there's a lot of activities that have to happen,
and it requires leadership at the top to make sure you have the right people in the right
place at the right time. So you don't think the law enforcement was deployed at the right time?
Well, problem is, there's not enough law enforcement. This is where the summer of
the defunding movement hurt law enforcement. Between the LAPD and the sheriffs, there were
over 3,000 personnel short. They're not there. 3,000 people short? 3,000, yes. Between the two,
3,000. So you have right now skeleton crews working patrol stations, and from there,
they're supposed to pull bodies to then go to the fires, which means now the patrol stations don't
have people. So when you call 911, there's no one to send to the emergency area. So you can see
how thin they spread. In LA County, the Sheriff's Department is probably the most understaffed
law enforcement agency in the entire nation. They have less than 0.9 deputies per 1,000
residents. LAPD, they have less than, they have about 2.0 per 1,000 residents. The national
average is 2.5. Metropolitan average across the entire nation is 3.8. So you're dealing with a
huge metropolitan area of LA, you realize 0.9 and 2.0 is tragically small. Those are under normal
circumstances. Now we have a massive event like this, you just don't have the manpool
to provide personnel to keep the stations up and running and have personnel boots on the ground
to address the fires. So the National Guard got to call them up right away because they know
they're short. They waited four days. And did they have to get trained? We heard that they had to do
some training as well. National Guard, you can deploy them to traffic control points, to the
perimeter, to maintain the security, the perimeter, ingress and egress, and that frees up law
enforcement to then go chase the looters and do all the police activities. And National Guard
serves that purpose very well. And they can also do other things as well. But why they waited four
days, I don't know. It was obvious even before it started, order them up because you know you
don't have the personnel to initiate it to begin with. So this is the planning part. This is the
politicians at the top. But when the people are activated, they did a wonderful job, everyone. I
mean they've been working. Some people unfortunately were left in their posts for 24 hours straight
with no relief. Imagine that. No break, no relief. Nothing. They're there for 24 hours. And we heard
the horror stories. And I talked to a young lady. Then they were in 12-hour shifts. So I talked to
her four hours after the end of her 12-hour shift. She was still there. I talked to her sergeant
an hour later. She was still there. That's now, do the math, that's now 17 hours.
That person hasn't budged from that position. And they still have to go back to the command post.
From the command post, she had to drive back to Compton Station to return her vehicle, go home
the other direction. I think she lived in Glendale. At six in the morning, she had to be back
at Compton to then go back there. Which meant, when was she gonna sleep? Two hours at the most?
She had a lot of people out there like zombies. They're just bone tired. And that's lack of
personnel. Our sponsor today is Shen Yun. There's been some negative press on Shen Yun recently.
Shen Yun's mission is to revive ancient and traditional Chinese culture. Shen Yun performance
started by a group of Falun Gong practitioners in New York. Falun Gong is a spiritual and religious
group which believes in living by truth, compassion and tolerance, putting others first. The Chinese
Communist Party, CCP, has been persecuting it since July of 1999 in China. Since Shen Yun started,
CCP has been targeting it in the U.S. and across the globe by playing different kinds of schemes
to cancel the shows or impact the performance. The current negative reporting originated from
some Chinese social media accounts. And we know that CCP is given a new directive to go after
Shen Yun and Falun Gong in the U.S. by turning the public opinion against them. If you hear something
negative on Shen Yun, make sure to do your own research and your own due diligence. Despite all
of CCP's campaigns against Shen Yun, the show has managed to grow significantly across the world.
I highly recommend you go see it. I've been going to it for the last 14 years as they change the
performances every year. They're coming back to California. Make sure you go see it.
And what about the preparation for the fire? So we heard that one of the reservoirs was empty.
The Santa Ynez Reservoir was taken offline in January of last year. The LA Times has a huge
article about it. And it was a decision to take it offline. And then ideally by April or May,
they were going to have it back online and up and running. But they go through the very
cumbersome city bidding process. And it's a very lengthy process. And this is where the
bureaucracy gets in the way of common sense. You have to have it up and running before the
summer starts and the heat and the potential for fires. So whatever your bidding process is,
you have to have an exception for emergencies or a sole source vendor. Like the county has that.
If it's a sole source vendor or it's emergency, you can bypass all that and just get it done
because of the need. And the city didn't treat that as an emergency. They should have.
Because now when they went to the fire hydrants, lost pressure very quickly and all of a sudden
they had no water. And that's 117 million gallon reservoir that would have supplied water for the
fire hydrants and for the helicopter dropping early on. It wasn't there. Now what about the
evacuations on the Altadena site? We heard that some people didn't get the notice.
The fire started right a little bit after 630 in the evening on the east end of Altadena,
Eaton Canyon. And then everything was blown west. But there was mysteriously no order to evacuate.
And 17 people ended up dying, at least the number might go up. And all of them were centered around
Lake Avenue and west of Lake Avenue. So if the fire was two or three miles to the east
and it's going that way, why on earth did they wait six hours to two in the morning before they
started door knocking and using the bullhorns or the PA system? That's too late, especially when
you have senior citizens in nursing homes. That was a lot of tragedies. There are people that died
that didn't need to. But kudos to two Pasadena bus drivers from their municipal bus line
they went, they took their commandeer, their buses, they went into the fire zone. On their
own? On their own. And they got people, loaded them up, wheelchairs and all, or screw the
wheelchair, get on the bus and they drove through the fire to safety. And God bless them. See that
type of thing, you admire it, but at the same time, was it necessary? Could it have been avoided? Yes.
So it seems like everybody probably got surprised by the magnitude of the fires. Do you think
realistically there could have been a much better response? I think the fire was going to happen,
remember, two years of rain, eight months of no rain, record heat, and then 100 mile wind.
If a fire started, it was going to be big and it was going to be devastating. I don't think that
you can change that equation much. But had the city and the county prepared for it,
they could have minimized the size of the destruction and there shouldn't have been a
single life lost. One guy was found dead with a hose in his hand, trying to keep his house, you
know, from burning up. And that shouldn't be, I mean, the order of the day when you're in a warning
or you evacuate, take the things, everything that starts with a P, people, pets, prescriptions,
important papers, photographs, you know, things that you can't replace. Everything else you can
replace. You can replace the house, you can replace your clothes, your furniture, your
appliances, all that. Who cares? It's that stuff that you can't replace. Have it packed, have it
ready to go. And it looks like it's coming. Go. Don't wait for it's too late and the embers are
flying because by that point you're part of the problem. Now, in a situation like this,
so what should have been happening? You don't think that command center was there?
And the decision makers at the top didn't activate the command center in a timely manner.
The department operations center, I don't think they opened it up and had it up and running until
late Monday into Tuesday then. But that should have happened like Friday, you know, Friday or
Saturday at the latest. And they should have had everything mapped out what they were going to do.
And they should have had a plan for evacuating. They should have been able to identify
everyone in need of evacuation because some of these nursing homes, the senior citizen
assisted living facilities, they were tucked in the foothills up in Altadena
and they burned to the ground. That should have been known ahead of time how many of these type
of places are and what is the resource we have to evacuate them in the case we have to.
That discussion never occurred. They had to figure it out on the fly as it happened.
It's kind of like in Katrina. Remember the big Hurricane Katrina? I think it was 2005.
They had a bunch of people that were abandoned in assisted living facilities.
And the bus drivers ran away northbound on the freeway out of New Orleans and the buses stayed
behind and the people ended up dying in the nursing homes. And the people were supposed to
drive them away, just abandon them there. That was foreseeable because hurricane doesn't show
up one day. They track it, you know it, you know who your vulnerable populations are,
you got to have a plan. How do we move people that can be impacted?
Well there's other things that are, these are policy decisions and economics is driving it
because we keep expanding the urban footprint of LA County. We push deeper and deeper into the
wildlands. So the interface between the wildlands and suburbia, it keeps getting more and more
precarious because the areas that they're building into, all these canyon residents
and all these very steep terrain and all that, prone to fire, prone to burn, prone to mudslides
in the wintertime. All these things happen at once, and not at once, but they're predictable.
And the more we build into that area, we're increasing the risk and we're not mitigating
that risk. So now that Palisades doesn't exist anymore, for example, most of Altadena is gone,
at least half of it. Do we rebuild? Do we repeat the same mistake? Or do we have to tighten the
building codes? For example, like there are people still with wood shingled roofs somewhere,
heaven forbid. I bet you there probably were. I've been through Altadena, I've seen a lot of
the homes, there are a lot of wood homes there. Everything is wood and that's just a source of
fuel. In fact, this fire was the first one that showed that a suburban residential track can be
a source of fuel. It's always thought that the source of fuel ended where the brush ended in
the woods. No, now it's actually the houses themselves become a source of fuel. They're
unproof. They're going to set everything on fire and it's a domino effect going down.
And it's the actual houses. And that's kind of a new development. And Altadena is a unique place
for LA, right? Very unique. It's one of the first communities that did not develop with redlining.
So people of all colors and creeds were able to settle there, buy a home, build a home with
their dreams. And they worked in the middle class jobs in LA when they were those middle class jobs
in the aerospace industry, for example. And they'd settle in Altadena.
So you're mentioning that the leadership, some falls on the city of LA and some falls on the
county, right? Altadena is part of the county, right? Yes. And the leadership model is weird
because this is at the top at the political level. For example, the LA city fire chief,
LA county fire chief answers to the board of supervisors. LA city fire chief answers to the
mayor. The sheriff answers to the people. But at the start of all this, who was the director of
emergency management? It's like a mystery because there was no one person. It was kind of like
management by committee, which in an emergency is the worst type of management model possible
because you can't make quick decisions. Can you give us some thoughts or examples for us that may
not know what is management by committee mean? Management by committee means that everyone gets
together to decide what to do. And you're already behind the curveball because if there's one person
in charge in an emergency, that person can say, hey, I need this, this, this, this, and happen.
And you do that, you do that and get going. And everyone is on the run. But what is management
by committee? You got department head and department head. Everyone is chiming in. Everyone
is putting their two cents in and the decision-making gets, it becomes very elaborate,
very lengthy. And everyone brings their politics to the table. They want to defend their bureaucratic
turf. And it's not very clean when it's by committee and it can work for some things. You
know, you can achieve consensus as a group, but when you need fast decision-making, because the
fire is literally coming, someone has to take charge and say, let's go. You mentioned there's
all these different jurisdictions. There's the county, there's the city. Who should be in charge?
How does it, how should it work? There's a thing called mutual aid, and that's a process where
different jurisdictions assist each other in times of need. And fire and law enforcement
uses mutual aid all the time. And the sheriff is responsible as a mutual aid coordinator for
the region that includes LA and Orange County. The entire state is divided into seven regions.
And the region, I think is region one, is LA and Orange County. And when you're the mutual aid
coordinator, the unified command is formed for these big events. And then if a need is addressed,
hey, we need to have national guard troops. Well, the mutual aid coordinator, in this case,
the sheriff, calls the California office of emergency services, Cal OES, to say, hey, we need
500 national guard troops here right now. Takes them about four hours to get spun up and
start rolling to respond to a big event, the national guard. And that is kind of how it works.
Same thing, fire chief might say, hey, we need, you know, a fleet of tankers to do airdrops.
And who's available? And then they call Cal Fire, and they're part of the California office of
emergency services. They have their fire branch, and they have all the assets, the air assets.
Because the city has helicopters that can drop. The county has helicopters that can drop.
They might have some fixed wing, but most of the big aerial assault comes from Cal Fire. So
the mutual aid coordinator, the sheriff in this case, serves as that point
of getting information requests and working with the state Cal OES. Hey, we need this,
we need that. And then they distribute it as they get it. That's how it's supposed to work.
And it's effective because we're down to a few people. But when the board decided to
eliminate the sheriff as a director of emergency management, now it became by committee,
not by one person. So the CEO was designated, but the CEO designated the responsibility
or the authority to the director of the office of emergency management, the county level OEM.
But that's just an appointed director. The big dogs in the fight, which is the fire department,
the sheriff's department, may not pay attention to a director of the office of emergency management.
So you have this mismatch of authorities.
Some people having titles that are higher, and you need to listen to somebody that's...
Exactly. You get all the internal conflict going on. In reality, you can delegate authority.
But you can never delegate responsibility. So say I'm your boss. Hey, I want you to do this,
go get this done. Okay, I gave you the authority because I'm your boss. But if it doesn't get done,
falls on me. Because my responsibility was to ensure that it happened.
So that's kind of the principle of you can't delegate responsibility. But politicians
like to do that because they'll put a bunch of barriers between them and the problem.
They'll create blue ribbon commissions. That's always a fair one. Let's create a blue ribbon
commission to study what happened. No, they were responsible. They screwed it up. But they're going
to put up a big front, you know, and you'll have a press conference. And they have all these
appointed people who are buddies with them. And you'll never get to the point, well,
okay, who screwed up? That's the whole idea. What was it like for you? You're not the sheriff
anymore. You're kind of sitting aside and watching. What was it like for you to see what's going on?
Well, I'm saddened by the loss of life, the loss of property. I mean, people,
you know, I have friends, I have wealthy friends. They say, you know, it's just property.
We'll rebuild. But I have other friends that that was their entire
livelihood. You know, their entire net worth was based on their property. So it's different
depending on where you, you know, what your means are impacted. But the loss of life,
regrettable, the loss of livelihood, how many jobs disappeared? Not just homes and people that
died or homes, but how many jobs were employed in all these different places. They're out of work.
You got gardeners, you got home care workers, you've got assisted living people. You have how
many restaurants and how much retail places depended on people that lived in all those
I mean, it's a it's a huge, you know, echoing effect in terms of the misery that this thing
created. And and then going back to my cup of tea, which is in the law enforcement arena,
just to see the deputies struggling because they don't have the resources, there's not enough of
them. And they're working so many hours. It's unreal that, you know, that could create another
set of tragedies. There was a point where everybody got a message to evacuate. Well,
there's a thing on on phones that is used, the phones used called WEA, which is a wireless
emergency alert system. And the sheriff's department has the ability to activate that
the Office of Emergency Management has ability to activate that. And apparently an operator who
is poorly trained, sent out alerts and sent out multiple times to the entire county when
they only wanted to affect a little small area of the county. And then the director of the OEM
said, oh, it's a technical issue. And that is just it was a mistake. And you could say that's
lack of training, lack of supervision. That's not a technical issue. That's a human issue.
And so I think every county department is better served when people are just forthright.
Hey, you know, we didn't have the resources, we didn't give them the proper training or,
you know, whatever the case may be. But saying what isn't doesn't instill more confidence
in in public entities. That's one of the things that that's happening now. There's a lot of rumors
around the fires. People I've I've heard a lot of conspiracy theories and some of them sound really
crazy. Is it because people are not coming forward in these positions of power to explain
what's really going on? Well, I think the messaging hasn't been very good. If you look at the press
conferences, you see all these people standing behind the microphone, everyone's crowding in.
And then when they get on the microphone, I want to thank this person. I want to thank that person.
I want to thank that people don't want to hear that. They want to hear what's coming next and
how are you going to make my life better? Because right now I've lost everything. That's what they
want to hear. And if there's time, you know, could have this been prevented? Because they're already
the last lawsuits have already been filed, both in Altadena and the Palisades now. Against who?
Against Southern California Edison for the Altadena fire and against against the city
and the DWP for the Palisades because the reservoir wasn't full of water. And Hollywood
finally spoke up and said enough is enough. I think Bill Maher said it best on his show
Friday. He said, I pay 13% of my taxes goes to the state of California.
I expect at a minimum that there's water in the fire hydrants.
Kind of hard to argue against that. Yeah. People expect some basic things from government.
If we exist solely for the purpose of providing public safety, that's the number one responsibility
of government. You better provide it. If you're not, why are you there? You know,
get someone else that can get the job done. Alex, you mentioned that the city and county of LA short
3000 officers. And part of the reason the evacuations was not as organized is probably
because they're short staff, right? Yes. The lack of staffing contributed to inability to
effectuate a good evacuation, orderly evacuation, and to prevent the looting that happened
afterwards. There was no one around. The crooks figured it out. And the main reason both agencies
are suffering. And this goes all the way back to 2020 when the politically popular thing to do was
defund law enforcement. Yes. Let's reimagine public safety. So they froze hiring from the
sheriff's department. They cut funding from the LAPD. They restored it. But the people that apply
to be law enforcement are already suspicious of both the LAPD and the sheriff's because of
leadership. They don't trust the leadership. So people don't volunteer. Hey, I'm going to work for
that organization whose leadership is not trustworthy. Employees are the number one
source of recruitment for both agencies. It comes from within. But if your own employees are not
recruiting, you don't fill the academy classes. They run empty. So as people retire, your total
population starts dropping and dropping and dropping. And that's been happening since 2022.
And we took a big drop in 2020 with the hiring freeze. Then the vaccine mandate.
Cops don't want to be told what to do or what to put in their body. Neither do firemen.
LA City Fire lost a lot of firemen behind the vaccine mandate.
I blocked the imposing a vaccine mandate on the sheriff's department, but I lost some deputies
that I'm not going to wait around for this. I'm going to go to another county where I don't have
hassles from the board of supervisors. So that it proved very harmful to the staffing levels.
But people didn't pay attention to it until now. Fast forward to 2025, you got a firestorm
and boots on the ground. There's not enough. So you recently wrote a book. You were in the
middle of the defunding. Can you tell us why you wrote this book? Well, I picked a lousy time to
be sheriff. It was between the defunding, the riots, civil unrest, the pandemic. I mean, I had so much
drama going on. But I ended up going through four years of lawfare. Lawfare was a term that didn't
really exist when I was elected sheriff in 2018. But behind what Trump experienced, for example,
at the national level, that was going on here at the local level with the board of supervisors.
They weaponized every resource they had to convince the public that I was wrong or somehow I
was either corrupt or I was a gang member. I mean, you name it. I was called everything
while I was just doing my job. So when I was done, I left the office,
lost the re-election. I thought, you know, I got a story to say. I want people to see who I am from
the very beginning. So I set out to write it. It took me about two months to write it.
It wasn't hard to write. The only part that was hard to write was the beginning because I don't
like talking about myself. But since I had to kind of give the story from the beginning,
I had to make it kind of autobiographical at the beginning. So that was OK. OK. You know,
once upon a time I was born here, blah, blah, blah, you know that. And that's like the first
third of the book. Once I get into the career and lieutenant and then running for office and then
the four years in office. It lays out what the county did and they were so desperate to regain
control of the sheriff's office and not because it wasn't being run right. It was being run right.
But they did not want an honest sheriff in office. So I was I was declared unwanted early on.
What are you trying to say with the book? I titled it Holding the Thin Blue Line in a Deep Blue State.
OK. And, you know, you always hear about the thin blue line in law enforcement.
But here in L.A. County, in California, it's a deep blue state. So how do you negotiate that?
It wasn't easy, but we had a lot of successes in office. They were pretty much ignored because
it didn't matter to the establishment or to the media. My first year on the job, 2019,
I hired eleven hundred deputies. No one's come close to doing that. How do we do it? Because
we did it the right way. We convinced people you can recruit your sons and daughters. You can trust
us with their career. We're going to hold them accountable, maintain a high standard, and we're
going to support them. That worked. Oh, my God, did it work. And people came in droves. The line to sign
up to take the test in Monterey Park used to wrap around the building. We had no shortage of people
wanting to be deputy sheriffs for the right reason. We hired locally. I don't want to have
people coming from other states to be L.A. County deputies. I want the kids that are born and raised
in L.A. County to be L.A. County deputies. It worked. We were able to do that. We raised the
standard from high school to associate's degree. First time ever that's done. It worked right up
until the point they cut my hiring ability and then my numbers crashed. Then we had to abandon
that. But everyone says they want to raise standards in law enforcement. I raised the
standard. So these things were successful. When the riots came, L.A. didn't burn down.
No. The few places there was a little bit of trouble was caused by politicians telling their
law enforcement not to do anything so you don't offend the rioters or the looters. I said screw
that. Ain't going to happen in L.A. County. So we made sure it didn't happen in L.A. County.
That was successful. Throughout the pandemic, in the congregate living facilities, people were
dying left and right from COVID-19. Not the L.A. County jail. In fact, we got an award from the
for innovation in jail management because we lost a record low number of inmates to COVID-19. Even
though we had the nation's largest jail system, it was safer to be in the jail system as an inmate
than it was to be a resident outside the jail. Twice as safe. That's how we kept the place clear.
That was a successful thing, but it didn't matter because they were all about, oh my God,
the sheriff this. Oh my God, the sheriff that. Yeah. When I had a public corruption unit addressing
public corruption, that's literally part of the job. You enforce the law. How dare he?
What do you mean? Supervisors are above the law? County employees are not. You can't enforce the
law. Who said that? But that was never the conversation, how it was spun up.
Deputies with tattoos. There are gang members. Okay. What are they doing? They got a tattoo.
Okay. And? Half the population has a tattoo. That doesn't make them gang members. What are
they doing? Well, we know they're gang members. Who? It was just hysterical. When you look at it
now, in hindsight, you realize it was all political theater, had nothing to do with
public safety at all. Now today, now you see the tragic results of it. You have a department in
shambles and people need to be held accountable. So I had a good motivation in writing this book
because I wanted to set the record straight and I do. And it's interesting how history has been
very kind to the things that we did because they were the right things to do at the right time.
Do you think LA will change after these fires? Do you think there will be a shift in the way
they look at law enforcement? Because law enforcement hasn't come up in a lot of these
discussions. And that's really, it's only come up tangentially about the looting.
And now maybe about the evacuation, they're starting to figure, hey, wait a minute,
what happened? Now people are starting to think more carefully, but I think nationally,
because the elections in November, I think the whole country kind of shifted back to the middle.
So the pendulum swung. I think it's swinging for law enforcement as well. And now here in LA,
because of the firestorm, now you have Hollywood figures wanting to know what happened. How come
there's no firemen? How come there's no law enforcement? Why is there still looting? So I
think there's a newfound appreciation for first responders that wasn't there before. And people
are realizing, oh, wait a minute, that is the number one obligation of government is to bribe
for the welfare of the community. And they were all, oh, let's do DEI initiatives and we'll create
a justice care and opportunities department. This is the county, but there's no water in a
fire hydrant. That's how irrational government had become. They're worried about who can check
which boxes so we look better, not can they do the job? It's real simple. You mentioned this
law enforcement is short staffed by 3000 people. And you mentioned they worked 17 hour, 20 hour
shifts. One guy was a trainee in patrol, allegedly 34 hours nonstop, which is insane.
And they also are seeing this amount of destruction. What do you think is the impact
of that on this force? Oh, it's devastating. I mean, you're seeing death, you're seeing destruction
at a level that few people have seen, unless you've been a deputy for a long time,
then they're driving two hours to get home for a couple hours, then to go back to that again.
And then what about what happens in their home? We had firefighters and cops who were on the front
line and they lost their home in the fires. And they were working the fires that happened in Eaton.
I don't know if it happened in Palisades, but I know it happened in the Eaton fire.
And it's a big emotional toll. And now you have contaminants. So now you have to do decontamination
of your personal gear, your boots and stuff like that. So you're not tracking that home
to your loved ones. So there's going to be problems and respiratory issues that
a lot of people are now starting to suffer. We saw it with the 911, the first responders of 911.
That was a huge mess that's gone two decades now, where they're still dealing with people that
suffered, you know, life altering conditions, breathing conditions because of the toxic
substances that were in the air. We're seeing, you know, that type of issue is going to develop here
now, locally in the city and county, everyone who was stuck out there. Olympics are coming up,
World Cup is coming up in LA. And what are your thoughts on that? Do you think LA is prepared to
do that? Oh, no, they weren't prepared without the fire. Now with the fire, there's twice as not
prepared. And I'll give you my concern because in the 84 Olympics, the four years preceding the 84
Olympics, both the city and the county went on a hiring spree, hiring as many officers as possible,
deputies as possible. So they were fully staffed for when the Olympics came, they came, they were
fully staffed, went without a hitch. Now, the Olympics are in 28, eight years prior, they were
trying to get rid of cops as much as they could, which is insane. So they went the opposite direction.
And now they dug themselves in a huge hole. It's going to take a lot of work to get back to full
staffing. I think the mayor's office says that they'd like to get up to 9,500, but they're still
sitting around 8,800. And they're barely keeping up with attrition. So if you have a class of 60
recruits, that graduates once every three months, but every, every three months, you have, you know,
70 or 80 that retire, well, now you actually lost 20 net. Sheriff's Department, the number is even
worse. They're under, probably at this point, they're under 8,200. They're supposed to be 10,300.
And they're graduating classes with 25, 30 recruits every four or five months, supposed to be 85
recruits every month and a half. See, the numbers are not there. That number has to turn around
to have the sufficient personnel for 28, 26, the World Cup. I think the college football
championship coming up, there's so many big events that are lined up. It's going to take a lot of,
a lot of staff on the ground. Some people are blaming the politicians and it's tragic. People
have lost their homes. But there is also certain rumors online that so-and-so, it feels like some
people think some of this has been done on purpose. Some of this, some people directly blame
the politicians. What are your thoughts on that? The fact that the fire occurred, I think there's
the big reasons are out of control of humans. That's mother nature. Again, record rains,
record drought, high temperatures, high wind. It's a recipe from hell. I don't think anybody
could change that on the ground. And trying to attribute to global warming is, is not being very
dishonest. Because if it were global warming, that's a fact for the entire globe. And here
locally, we're not going to change anything if we can starve ourselves or for ourselves to adopt
all these green emission, you know, mandates from the state. But if China and India do whatever the
hell they want, it means nothing. In fact, this fire, the environmental impact of this fire,
I think it set us back, what, 20, 30 years. I've heard the output in one incident.
And they haven't really studied it, but this is huge.
Yeah. I mean, so in other words, all that work, it took one incident and it's gone. Plus,
we're not even factoring what other people are doing. So we can self-flagellate ourselves all
we want in terms of, you know, environmental purity. But if no one else is doing it,
it doesn't move the needle globally in terms of, you know, man-made causes of,
you know, climate change. So that, however mitigating, it is a political issue.
In other words, people dying, that's because of bad planning, prior planning. Not having water
in a reservoir, for example, that's, those are human mistakes. That's not mother nature. So
we got to be able to separate the two. Alex Villanueva, former sheriff of Los Angeles
County. It was great to have you on California Insider. Oh, well, thanks for having me.