California’s Disaster Response Has a Major Gap—Can It Be Fixed? | Jay Coggan

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
153 Video Views·Jan 21, 2025
California’s fire response depends on the National Guard, but what if there was a faster solution? Former State Guard Commanding General Jay Coggan explains how bureaucracy slows emergency efforts, why California disbanded a force that could have acted immediately, and what it would take to bring it back.
*Views expressed in this video/article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of California Insider.
LA fires highlight a big gap in California state emergency response.
My guest today is Jay Cogan who's the former commanding general for California State Guard.
Today he is here to tell us what is the difference between National Guard and State Guard
and how the State Guard could have been deployed to help with Los Angeles fires
and they could have gotten there much faster helping with the fires and commanding with the
I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
We apologize for the quality of the audio in this recording.
There are parts that may be choppy or hard to hear.
Jay, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. It's good to be here. Appreciate it.
You know, Jay, we have had the fires that have been devastating in LA
and we have had to tap into the National Guard.
Can you tell us what's the process to tap into the National Guard?
Because it probably took them some time to get involved, right?
Well, the basic premise is if the National Guard is needed,
whatever agency needs them, whether it's LA, the county, the city,
makes the request to the California Office of Emergency Services,
governor's office approves it, and then orders go down to the military department
saying they need whatever assets they want, whether it's personnel,
helicopters, planes, whatever it might be.
And then it's the military department's job to effectuate that.
The military department of California is a state agency,
and it is responsible for running and managing both the National Guard and the State Guard.
So the first request goes to OAS, Office of Emergency Services.
They then, if approved, will issue orders and requests to the National Guard,
to the military department, whose job it is to respond.
They do not say, I want National Guard, I want State Guard.
They simply say to the military department, I need ASCAS, personnel and equipment.
That's all that happens.
And does it take a long time for them to get involved in an emergency like this,
when we have fire?
It depends what the emergency might be.
Certainly for fire, absolutely.
Say the National Guard is trained for its federal mission, warfighting.
Many people don't realize that approximately 40%
of all soldiers deployed to the Middle East during the wars we've recently had,
were all National Guard.
There just aren't enough active duty soldiers.
So the way that is managed is federal funding is utilized to train the National Guard.
They are in state command and control,
they're less federalized, but they're trained with federal money for the warfighting mission.
They are not paid to train for a state mission.
As a result of that, you have all these personnel.
But you have infantry brigade, you have artillery units,
you have all sorts of units that would not really be used during a disaster,
in California or anywhere.
So what happens is, if it's a specialized issue such as firefighting,
you have lots of human beings, the warm bodies, but they're untrained.
They simply do not train during the year to respond to a fire.
So the result is, let's say there's been a request and an approval
for the National Guard to send in personnel for wildland firefighting.
Problem is, where do you get them from?
You get them from various units within the National Guard,
but they don't know how to put a fire out.
And the last thing you want to do are send personnel into a dangerous zone
that haven't been trained to do the job.
It's a risk of itself.
So they're generally sent to Camp Roberts.
The entire process is about five days of both transit and training by CAL FIRE
on how to do wildland firefighting.
So if you think about it, from the day the governor approves OAS issues orders,
and the department says, I'll get your people,
you're really looking at at least five days before they're boots on the ground.
And during those five days, you could lose a lot of property.
You lose lives.
They're just not there.
They're coming, but they're not readily trained and ready to do the mission.
Same thing like we've had in LA during this fire,
the need for personnel, new traffic control points
to ensure that there's also not looting in the areas,
all the problems that have happened.
And of course, the police are just stretched to the F degree.
I mean, LA is a large area.
They've got regular crime to police.
You can't just take every police officer,
they send their fire zone and it would be total havoc.
So what's happened is they've actually mobilized this particular fire,
the infantry battalion, our brigade.
Problem is, they're not trained for this.
They're trained for warfighting.
So the net result is you've taken people from the National Guard MP Brigade,
off mission, to train the infantry brigade in the middle of this
to do this kind of security work during the fire.
So I guess, kind of based the question,
when you have all these people on your rail,
why is it you don't train them until after they're needed?
They should be trained before they're needed,
so they're ready to be utilized.
I hope that answers your question.
Now, are you saying that it took five days for us to tap into the National Guard
during this fire?
Not necessarily.
What I'm saying is it took five days from the decision
to provide service members for the firefighting,
for them to be trained and back down to LA to be able to respond to the fire.
That's it.
And from the security perspective,
it's whatever time it took to bring them up from their units
and get them trained on how to do the security work they've been asked to do.
I don't know whether that's five days or not,
but it's certainly not in ready time before the event.
So it's at least a few days or some time of training
because people need to get trained how to fight fires.
Absolutely.
I mean, you don't want to send untrained people.
I mean, I'm sure you've seen the pictures of what it looks like.
You do not want to send people that have not had at least basic training
and assurances they're capable of doing the work out onto a fire line.
That would be dangerous to them,
dangerous to the entire command structure and everybody else working around them.
Now, is this normal to call the National Guard
or is there another force that we could have that deal with this kind of emergencies?
It could be the State Guard.
I mean, the newer door, National Guard is a national organization.
It's got a national mission.
State Guard is really a state mission.
The California State Guard has existed certainly before World War II,
but during World War II, there are 73,000 men and women in California that were part of it
because the National Guard went to war.
Somebody had to take care of California while they were gone, say during Korea.
Big difference during Vietnam because the National Guard did not go and they're on,
but we have had a State Guard in California, but it had sort of waned in utilization
and it becomes solely, I like to call it the reserve of the reserve.
All it did was support the National Guard, an important mission, don't misunderstand you.
The State Guard currently trains the National Guard in small arms training.
You improve their shooting capabilities when they go to war.
They train them in truck driving.
Their lawyers do all the wills, powers of attorneys for the National Guard before they deploy.
They do a lot of the logistics, office work, backup,
but as an operational force, it had basically gone away.
And I said, why are we being utilized?
Because many members of the State Guard are currently serving law enforcement officers,
police, some police chiefs, many retired law enforcement, retired police chiefs.
And I said, why don't we do that?
And then years shortly thereafter, we had another fire.
And the question was asked of me or of someone else,
why do every summer or every fire season do we have to reinvent the wheel?
We know there's going to be fires.
Why do we have to spend five days every time there's a fire
training the people to do the job when they could be pre-trained?
Now, the reality is, is the State Guard does not have a federal mission.
So it doesn't have to drill or train to go to war.
Its job is solely to protect California's people.
It's effectively the governor's army.
The governor mandates and controls and is the commander-in-chief
of the California State Guard, not the president.
And these people are volunteers.
They train for free.
There's a group of people, many of them are young,
who don't want to join the National Guard and deploy or the regular army and deploy,
but they want to serve.
They want to be in uniform.
They want that camaraderie that comes from working with other members in the military,
because the State Guard is military by law.
We have those that have retired from the National Guard or the army or the Marines or the Navy,
all of them, but miss serving, miss being back in uniform.
And so they joined the State Guard.
We have those that are a little older, maybe 50s, 60s even,
that did not join years ago as they raised families and didn't want to deploy.
But now their kids are grown and they want to serve again.
So we've got a lot of very talented people that want to do this and don't need to get paid.
Now they are paid when they're called up to actually fight the fire,
just like everybody else is.
Effectively doesn't even cost California money on this,
because the federal government is reimbursing California 100%.
But the point is, where else are you going to get a fully trained force?
Every month, all they do is practice putting out fires,
practice doing security work, practice doing flood response, search and rescue.
Whatever the disaster might be in California,
that's what they train for and it costs the state effectively nothing.
I'd also like to thank California, unfortunately,
from a disaster perspective, for a season.
The first season is rain.
What happens after rain?
A lot of growth, which everybody is now blaming on why the fire just did that,
because following rain, too often we have drought.
When we have drought, all that new growth just sits there as tinder.
Then it's drought season, it's our second season.
Then we go into new.
Why?
Because we have all the tinder.
If something happens, comes in, something sparks it,
there's an arsonist, who knows what, it burns.
What happens then for the fourth season, in my opinion,
is let's assume the winter after a fire disaster like this,
we have massive rain, we no longer have ground cover.
All the hills take a month's life.
That's why Malibu runs, goes into the ocean.
Why roads get closed down all the time.
Why there needs to be rescues.
The seasons, to me, are really disaster-related, and how do you respond?
The State Guard's purpose was to be prepared to do all of that.
And right now, that's not happening, right?
No, no, it's not.
When I first decided to do this, we started going on social media
to recruit young men and women to be firefighters.
We needed them a little more healthy, because last thing you want is someone
passing out from a smoke inhalation on the fire line,
or having a heart attack, or someone with asthma.
Unfortunately, this is a very dangerous job.
These firefighters are unique human beings.
And we recruited, within a very short time, 125 immediately.
They were vetted medically by medical personnel, and they were trained.
And then the California Office of Emergency Services
gave us five wildland firefighting engines,
capable of bringing personnel into a fire line,
having water, tools, all the necessary stuff.
They then trained up on those, how to operate them.
And they did go out to fires.
Two years ago, there was a change in leadership at the military department.
Let's just say that the new leadership, the new Adjutant General, General Beavers,
his policy was he did not want the State Guard.
He did everything possible to pretty much ignore them and take them down.
And the firefighting unit was disbanded.
Some of the people got jobs in what's called Task Force Rattlesnake,
which is fire abatement.
But all the other people that are trained went nowhere.
The security forces were merging to somebody else.
They weren't doing anything.
Swiftwater Rescue disappeared.
And he literally gave back the five fire engines to HODFs.
I can only imagine how valuable they would have been right now
in those very narrow and winding roads in the Hollywood Hills.
These are smaller trucks.
I think I may have sent you some pictures.
If not, I will.
They would have fit on these roads really well with some water,
could have pulled a water buffalo behind them.
They could have actually physically carried firefighting personnel up these roads
and made it a lot easier to get them there than a big pumper truck
and had to push cars out of the way and save property and people.
They're all gone.
That's a policy decision, which I cannot understand.
Why would you take down a ready force and not replace it with better things?
If that had happened, you wouldn't have needed five days to take it.
They would have trained all year long and requests would have been available.
That's really a shame, quite frankly, and dangerous.
Dangerous to the people of California.
Now, Jay, do you recommend to bring this force back?
Oh, absolutely.
In fact, there's no reason not to have it.
More states are activating their state defense forces
to respond to these disasters like the California State Guard.
They're growing.
We're retrenching.
California sent their people, excuse me,
taxis have sent their people to work on the border.
There are people, Florida just stood it up,
spent $100 million organizing their state guard.
We got no money.
In fact, our people were trained with private firms.
We started-
So it doesn't cost the state anything to have this force?
No, no, it really doesn't.
When they're utilized to fight a fire, there's a cost,
but that's a cost you'd pay anybody anyway.
National Guard, private people, it's irrelevant,
but they train for free.
That's the key.
Where else are you going to get a ready, willing,
and fully trained, vetted operational force
that are going to do all that work for you
for nothing more than make sure they have their equipment
and a sandwich for lunch?
That's about it, and a bus ride to where they train.
That's the effect of it.
And when we didn't have money from the state,
we started a foundation.
It was very bicameral.
We had the elected district attorney
of San Luis Obispo County,
the chairman board supervisor of San Bernardino County,
people who needed this kind of resource.
We had the vice president of UPS, of government affairs.
We had a vice president of MGM Television,
the former treasurer of California, John Chong.
And we raised hundreds of thousands of dollars,
bought boats, bought masks for firefighting,
bought shovels, bought radio equipment,
bought everything so these people could train.
And then, again, as a matter of policy,
the new leadership in the department decided,
we don't want people to protect California.
We'd rather just ignore them because we don't like them.
And it really came down to, we don't like them.
And as a result of that,
we actually disbanded the foundation
with hundreds of thousands of dollars left
that we're going to use to further train new people.
Now, how many people were in this state guard force?
When I was the commander, it was about 1,600 people total,
doing various jobs throughout the force.
But remember, this is a non-supported force.
We built it up pretty much from whole cloth,
for want of a better phrase.
If the state ever got behind this, which they should,
I mean, we were doing our own social media.
If the state got behind this and provided the resources
for recruiting, for marketing, and for training,
I mean, not the dollars for the personnel,
but the equipment and the resources
to feed them and transport them,
I could get you a couple of thousand people
in a heartbeat, ready, stationed throughout California,
ready to respond to whether it's fire, flooding,
search and rescue, any kind of disaster, period.
It would take months to do it, but it could be done.
Readily available and trained personnel,
all qualified and certified.
Nobody goes out on the line, whether it's security,
armed up, or there was firefighting,
without being qualified and certified
to do the job they're doing.
We don't just want warm bodies.
Now, does this force include other resources
like doctors and potential?
Oh, sure, sure.
I was a lawyer in civilian life.
I'm a Vietnam veteran, but I then became a lawyer,
practiced law in Century City for many, many years,
and then decided to join the State Guard
because as a lawyer, I wanted to provide services
and help for service members, and we did.
We helped so many service members that had deployed.
In fact, the California State Guard,
because they work for the governor
and they're not federal, were accordingly authorized
to go to court in uniform to represent soldiers
coming back from the war zone
that were being foreclosed on, repossessed, being fired.
For all the wrong reasons, and we started going to court
for free for the soldiers, and the net result is
nobody lost their homes, nobody got repossessed,
everybody got the help they needed
at no cost whatsoever because these lawyers
wanted to volunteer.
Right now, these lawyers would be available
to be in LA County working at resource centers,
helping people understand how to fill forms out,
how to get help, how to get aid.
Doctors, a lot of doctors.
These are people that want to serve,
but earlier in their careers didn't want to join
active military for personal reasons.
They wanted to raise their families, whatever.
They've joined.
In fact, one of my doctors who was at Stanford at the time,
at the request of the CDC, we sent him to Washington, D.C.,
and for one year, wearing a uniform every day,
wearing California on his uniform,
he ran a billion-dollar program
for the federal government during COVID.
Yet nobody knows about that
because the same individual that doesn't like us
never even called the governor.
I'm sure if the governor had known it,
he would have broadcast it all over the place.
In fact, the California Military Department
won the annual LAMP award
issued by the American Bar Association
for legal assistance for the Army
to the California Military Department.
That means not the regular Army,
not the Reserve Army,
not any National Guard in the country,
but the California Military Department
got it for legal assistance
because of the programs we developed.
That's very proudful for California.
I don't think the governor knows it.
I'm being honest with you.
I don't think he was ever told.
Why wouldn't you brag about that?
The whole country, all the regular Army,
all the Reserve Army, all the National Guards,
California's Military Department
got the American Bar Association award
for legal assistance
because of what the state guard was doing.
These are examples.
You have doctors, lawyers.
If you name it, we got it.
We have people that teach drug driving.
People teach small arms shooting.
If you need it, we got it.
And by the way, my whole attitude was this.
We don't have it.
We can recruit to it.
Because think about it.
Whatever skill set is in California,
I guarantee you there are people that do it,
would love to put that uniform on,
be very prideful,
standing with the National Guard
because they're co-equal.
The National Guard and state guard,
when you command and control the governor,
there's no difference.
California, a state guard officer
can command National Guard and vice versa.
We stand co-equal
because there's no federal nexus force at that point.
So they want to assure,
you name a skill set that California needs,
I'll find you people through recruiting.
They'll just jump at the chance
to volunteer to do this.
You got 40 million people.
We can't find a few thousand
that want to help in a uniform?
Give me a break.
Easy.
And what would be the impact
of having this force ready?
The impact would be
that California,
because we're going to get a lot more disasters.
We know that.
It's not going away.
And anybody who thinks it is, is delusional.
The truth is it would mean that you had,
I like to call them like a hot shop,
but they're not in the same term,
but they're ready to go.
No matter what the problem
or disaster California has,
you've got people ready to go out the door immediately.
Where else?
And also think about it during seriously tough crises
like this going on in LA right now.
Our normal first responders are exhausted.
They're exhausted.
Our guys can relieve them
on a midnight shift, a day shift,
whatever it might be.
The result would be,
is you'd have a lot of better morale
even amongst the existing first responders,
more arrested first responders,
because we could act,
even if we weren't out the door first,
we'd be a great relief valve for all of them.
And they need it.
Trust me, they're working their butts off
to say the least.
These are amazing first responders.
The fire and police and medical people
that are out there.
I tip my hat if I have one on.
Now, Jay, you really have this belief
in the state guard.
Yes.
What did you see on the ground
that makes you have this certainty
about this community of people
that are volunteering?
Every time we sent them out,
whether it was fires or securities,
without any embarrassment, any negativity,
I remember the first weekend,
a very strange story.
But the first Saturday,
I put our very first fire team out.
They weren't as a team.
They were mixed in five people each
in each force package.
Force package is 20 people.
So we were mixed in with National Guard.
About three, four hours
after they went out on the first fire,
I got a call from another general who said,
I'm sorry to tell you, sir,
but one of your soldiers had a stroke.
I felt terrible for the soldier,
but then I hung up.
I'm saying to myself,
how do I mess this up now?
I've spent so much time saying
we're capable of doing this.
This is bad.
Except he called me an hour later,
said, I apologize, sir.
It wasn't one of your soldiers.
It was a 25-year-old National Guardsman
who had a stroke,
and your guy saved his life.
So the bottom line is
the State Guard has produced.
If they've never failed
and always produce,
we were doing joint exercises
with the Coast Guard
for tsunami response and flooding.
State Guard, not National Guard.
We were doing,
I have films of joint exercises
off Morro Bay.
We would go out with the big boats,
small boats,
presuming that there was a problem on shore.
We were sending our small boats
in to rescue the people,
get them into the small boats,
bring them out to the bigger boats
where the doctors were,
and manage it as if it was an instant response.
The Coast Guard thought we were amazing.
They kept doing it with us.
And in fact, during Fleet Week,
the last two years in San Francisco,
we got specific requests
for our people to run picket fences,
to run security for the Navy fleet
and the overflight at Little Angels in the Bay.
Obviously, we're doing something right
if people want us.
And during COVID,
we were running the food banks.
And we had four of the 500 people
of the State Guard
running food banks
throughout the state during COVID.
And they wanted us,
not even the National Guard.
And I'll tell you one reason why.
Not everyone in the National Guard
wants to do this.
That's not what they thought
they were going to do.
A lot of them are burned out
because they're training,
they're going to war,
they're doing all the other things.
When someone joins the State Guard,
they join to do this.
They want to get called up.
They want to go fight the fire.
They want to respond to disaster.
They're not joining up
to get the federal retirement,
to be part of the National Guard,
to whatever else that might get
the skills that we'll learn there.
They're joining to volunteer, to respond.
Their desires are region.
You can't pay for that desire.
That's why you have to volunteer.
I think they're way better
than anybody getting a dollar for it.
That's my opinion.
Now, Jay, you have a long career
of service yourself.
How did you get into it and why?
From the very beginning,
I was the lousy student
at the University of Connecticut.
I started in 1966.
I'm an old guy.
And after one year,
I dropped out and joined the service.
The Vietnam War was on.
I was 1A.
I was gone.
And I ended up becoming
a combat air crewman
on what's known as the PTV Neptune.
We were flying out
of Naval Air Facility,
Cam Ranh Bay, Vietnam.
In Vietnam, we were doing
all over reconnaissance,
looking for weapons
coming in from the north.
I got out of the,
left the military at 71,
finished college now in Connecticut,
then came back to LA to go to law school
and started practicing along 79.
And then later I said,
you know, I still want to help.
I'm too old now to go back
into the active component.
I'll join the state guard.
And that became my calling.
Hopefully that this force
will come back
and will help us
in the time of disasters
in California.
Major General Jay Cogan,
it was great to have you
on California Insider.
Thank you so much.
And good luck.
And if anything,
I believe in your operation there.
And I believe it will be viewed
by the appropriate people
that might simply ask the question
of the legislature, the governor.
What a great idea.
Want to start looking into this?
Get it organized
because it's coming back again.
So I'm hoping this gets that resolved.
Thank you very much.
Have a great night.
