Why is There "Something" Rather than "Nothing"?

Why We EXIST?
14 followers
12 Video Views·Jan 19, 2025
Forget science. Forget God. This is the ultimate question: What if Everything had Forever been Nothing? Not just emptiness, not just blankness, but not even the existence of emptiness, not even the meaning of blankness, and no Forever. If you don't get dizzy, you really don't get it. Featuring interviews with John Leslie, Peter van Inwagen, Bede Rundle, Quentin Smith, Richard Swinburne, and Steven Weinberg.
When I was 12, the summer between 7th and 8th grades,
a sudden realization struck such fright
that I strove desperately to blot it out.
Why not nothing?
What if everything had forever been nothing?
Not just emptiness,
not just blindness,
but not even the existence of emptiness,
not even the meaning of blindness,
and no forever.
Lump together everything that exists and might exist,
physical, mental, platonic, spiritual, God, everything.
Call it all something.
Why is there something rather than nothing?
My whole life, I've been haunted.
Why does anything exist at all?
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn,
and Closer to Truth is my journey to finally find out.
Maybe.
I start on Mount Wilson, high above Los Angeles,
where humanity's vision of the vastness of existence
expanded enormously.
I talk with John Leslie,
one of my favorite living philosophers.
His passion is explaining existence.
John, the question,
why is there something rather than nothing,
is this a legitimate question that we ask?
I think it's legitimate because it can have answers.
Even if you think the answer is,
there just happens to be something,
there might instead have been nothing,
that's an answer.
You could argue that all your views
about the nature of the universe
will in the end depend on whether
the universe which you believe exists
could have a reason behind its existence.
I don't like the theory that the universe
just happens to exist and just happens
to have the characteristics which it does.
Now, it would seem that nothing is simpler
and should have been there rather than something.
I think that's correct, but bear in mind
that even in a blank there would be all sorts of facts.
So if you try to imagine out of existence
all actual things and say that's nothing,
in a sense that's right,
but also you've overlooked the fact
that there's an infinite richness
of truths about possibilities
which is bound to exist
even if no actual things exist.
If there were a blank, it would still be true
in this blank that if there were ever to exist
two sets of two apples,
then they would make four apples.
And even if there was no possibility
of them ever occurring?
Even if there was no real possibility
of their occurring,
there would be no contradiction
in their occurring.
Their occurring would not be like
the occurrence of a married bachelor.
And therefore do you say
that it is impossible
for there to be a nothing
without possibilities?
I think that's so and I think
you can go further and say that
there's an infinite number of possibilities
and an infinite number of facts about them
and they would be there
even if there were no actual things
forever and ever.
But at the end of the day we are still faced
with this fundamental reality
of dealing with this rich nothing
versus our very specific something
that we have to explain.
Yes, I think there is this problem
why we have an actual world
instead of just a set of possibilities.
To John, why is there something
rather than nothing
is the single most fundamental question.
It cannot be addressed by science,
but it can be analyzed,
if not answered, by philosophy.
This is the domain of metaphysics.
Peter van Inwagen,
a philosopher in Notre Dame,
specializes in metaphysics.
He has thought long and hard
about this seemingly impossible question.
His claim is that progress is possible.
Peter, the question why is there something
rather than nothing
is perhaps the most fundamental, deepest,
most difficult question
that I can conceive of.
It seems like there is no progress
we can make on such a question.
What can we say about that?
Well, let's think about it.
Now, one sort of answer that you might give
would be
that it was
impossible for there to be nothing.
There have been two attempts
at this in the history
of philosophy.
One is summed up under the name
the ontological argument,
and the other under the name
the cosmological argument.
The ontological argument
is generally seen as a proof
for the existence of God.
But it also answers our question
because, of course, if God exists,
then it's false that nothing exists.
If God has to exist,
then
it's
true that it's impossible
for there to be nothing.
The cosmological argument
is also seen
as an argument for the existence
of God. It tries to show this.
If there is a world around us
that looks as this world does,
then in the background there mustn't be a being
who couldn't fail to exist.
But since we see that there is
a world around us like this,
then we can see that there is in the background
a being who couldn't fail to exist.
So, in a sense, that argument shows
that if there is something, then it's impossible
for there to be nothing.
I don't find either of them
convincing
myself.
Another way of answering
the question, however,
you think of all the possible ways
that the world might be.
And we mean
a total possibility for the world,
not every detail.
All these seem to be equally
probable.
And the probability
of all of them seems to be zero.
And yet, one of them
happened.
Well, what could differentiate
one way
for there to be nothing
from another way for there to be nothing?
There's only one way for there to be nothing,
and it's a total state of affairs.
That is, it settles everything.
Every proposition has its truth value
settled, true or false,
usually false, by there being
nothing.
So, if we're right that it's one way
for the reality to be,
and always total ways for reality to be
are equally probable and it's all zero,
then the probability of there being nothing
is zero.
Some people would answer this question
very glibly and say,
God,
that there is something
because God created it.
Well, either God is a necessary being
or he's not a necessary being.
If he's a necessary being, then there isn't
any possibility of there being nothing.
If God is a contingent being,
then we still have the question,
why is there something rather than nothing?
Because one of the possible ways
for there to be is there's nothing,
not even God.
If God is a contingent being,
that's just to say, answer the question
why there's a physical world or something like that,
not why is there something rather than nothing.
So, at the end of the day,
what do you feel
in your guts
to the answer to that question?
I think God exists
and that God is a necessary being
and therefore it's not possible
for there to be nothing.
Peter argues that
because there are an infinite number
of potential worlds,
each specific world
would have a zero probability of existing.
And because nothing
is only one of these potential worlds,
there is only one kind
of nothing,
therefore the probability
of nothing is zero.
But the prior
probability of nothing
may not be the same
as other possible ways
the world might have been.
Isn't nothing
different, simpler?
In that all
other worlds would require
something more.
As for God
being the answer,
I need to go to Oxford
to meet
Bede Rundle,
an atheistic philosopher
who wrote a book that turns my question
into a statement.
Why there is
something rather than nothing.
Why indeed?
Bede, when I was
12 years old, I was lying
in bed one night and
suddenly I had this thought
what if there were nothing?
And it so
panicked me, I forced
myself to put it out of my mind,
it frightened me so much.
It's a fascinating one because it seems
impossible at first
blush to give any sort of
coherent answer.
As you no doubt know,
it's had a longish history,
started off with Leibniz
and
many major philosophers
have tried their hand at giving
an answer. Perhaps the
major worked
out answer is to be
found in someone like St Thomas Aquinas.
So his answer
to the question, why is there something
rather than nothing, was well
there is God and
God has to exist,
he exists of necessity.
But perhaps a prior
question is, clearly if someone says
why is there something rather than nothing,
they think that there being nothing
is a genuine alternative.
And the question's got to explain why we have
one alternative realised rather than
the other. I'm inclined to agree
with the general position that there has to be
something or other, but
the theistic solution
seems to me to have its difficulties.
Many of the difficulties centre
around this slippery term nothing.
Suppose I say to you
there's nothing between these two bodies.
Now you might take that in two
ways. You might say well in that case they must
be touching. Or
you might say, and perhaps this is a more natural
one, there's just empty space.
Okay. Now which one are we
interested in? I
think it's the first one. That's the literal
sense of there being nothing
because space is not nothing.
You can travel through space,
you speak of the depths of space
and so forth. You can
measure a space. So now
we've got to consider whether
there could be nothing in the literal
sense. Take this
idea, there being nothing
and then the universe coming
into being or beginning to exist.
Now does that
make sense? Could there be a preceding
state of affairs of there being
nothing which gives way
to a state of affairs where there's something?
Well,
what are the conditions in which
you can speak of something as beginning to exist?
Isn't it that there has to
be a time when it doesn't exist
followed by a time when it does exist?
But if you don't have anything
at all, then you don't have time
so it doesn't make sense to think of an
antecedent state of affairs of nothing
being followed by something.
So perhaps we just have to confront
it as a brute fact that there is
something. You can't get beyond that.
There's no explaining it
and that's that.
But that's just incredibly
not satisfying.
I mean, is it just a defect
of a human mind or
my own incapacity
or immaturity? To say
brute fact, it just seems
that that's not
enough. Well, if it's
a conceptual truth
that there is
something, if there has to be something
then that's an
end to your agonizing, surely.
And if you could
refute all the arguments that
say, well, we can make sense of a state of affairs
in which there's nothing at all,
then of course the problem is still
with you.
Beebe believes that there
must be something or other.
There cannot be
nothing.
Nothing is an impossible
state of affairs.
Is this progress
or word games?
I can't decide.
Nothing
still shadows me.
God
could close off debate.
But I'm not ready
for God.
I am ready for Quentin
Smith, a painter
and a poet and an atheistic
philosopher who is consumed
by the riddle of existence.
Quentin, if there is
any question that has haunted me
my entire life, it is
why not nothing? Why is there something
rather than nothing?
Is it even possible to make progress
in answering
this question? I think so.
The first thing is to recognize
that when people have tried
to answer it, they
have defined nothing
as this very thin sort
of something, like empty space,
quantum vacuum,
someone
called it the null set.
But this is really nothing.
Absolutely
nothing forever.
Not even the concept of nothing.
Okay, and I think I've got a way to describe
it as not something.
So the question is,
why is it the case
that
it is false
that there is not something?
Well said.
Okay, now there is
an answer to that, but it's very
trite and trivial.
The answer would be this. Right now,
this is a state of the universe. It is something.
So why does
this something exist?
Well, it was caused to exist by
the previous state of the universe,
which is also something. And that was caused
by a previous state, which in turn
is something. And if you ask
why there
is something at all,
I can just confine myself to one
example. This state of the universe.
Then the answer is
a previous state. The universe caused it to exist.
But
there's no reason why
this whole package, this
sequence of states
had to exist rather than not
this. It would seem to be more
simple,
more logical, and less to explain
if there really were
nothing, not something.
I'm not sure
simple and less
to explain makes sense. You're talking
about not something. What
makes the answer
difficult is that the answer
is so obvious and trivial
and we're so used to expecting
it to be a
grand answer.
I don't mean this to be insulting, but your
answer is not very satisfying.
Well, I found that insulting.
But
do you find your own answer satisfying?
Yes. You do?
Yes, although... You look pretty content.
Well, it took me a while
to recover from the disappointment
after I first realized
that's the answer. I spent
all my life wondering why there's nothing or nothing
and this is the answer.
I love
Quentin's passion.
He contends that
while no thing existing
might have been the case,
some things existing
is the case.
And the reason
is trivial.
Each and every thing
was caused by a
prior thing.
That can't be the answer.
But might it?
I want to scream.
Why not
nothing?
Every time I return to it,
it drives me nuts.
To conclude,
I consider God
and then know God.
In each case,
why not
nothing?
For the theistic view,
I go to Richard Swinburne,
a leading theistic philosopher.
Richard is
the author of
The Existence of God,
perhaps the most influential
modern book suggesting
that God's existence
is more likely than not.
Richard,
when we think of
why there is anything,
it is a natural human
inclination, if you really think deeply about it,
to think there is nothing
more astonishing, nothing,
than there is something,
that nothing would have
been the most logical possibility.
I share that intuition.
It is extremely puzzling.
Where do we go from here?
Well, all explanation
consists in trying to find
something simple and
ultimate on which
everything else depends.
I think that that simple and ultimate,
which we can get to by rational inference,
is God.
It is not logically necessary
that there should be a God.
The supposition, there is no God,
contains no contradiction.
Nor is it the case that
there is a God because
it's good there should be a God,
and the good necessarily comes into existence.
This principle of explaining
the existence of something
because it's good, not because
some good person designed it,
but because it's good in itself,
is a principle which we do not
recognize in other fields as a
kind of explanation at all.
We explain things in scientific
way, by laws and initial
conditions, or by the actions
of persons in virtue of their purposes.
So,
there is no explanation
of why there is a God, and it would
be theologically
problematic, as it were, if you
were to say, well, as a matter of fact,
it's logically necessary that there's a God
because that would mean that the
existence of God depended on some
principle of logic which was somehow
superior to God.
If God explains
everything else, then
he wouldn't be God
if there was an explanation of
his existence, and
he is the ultimate truth
which we,
that's how it is, we can't go
further than that.
For the atheistic view,
I go to Stephen Weinberg,
a Nobel laureate
and leading atheistic
scientist.
Steve's insights into the
nature of reality should
be known by everyone
on earth.
Steve, why is there
something, anything,
rather than nothing?
That is just the kind of
question that we
will be stuck with when we have
a final theory, because
whatever our theory is, no matter
how mathematically consistent
and logically consistent
the theory is, there will always be the
alternative that,
well, perhaps
there's nothing at all. In
modern physics,
you can say the idea of empty
space without anything
at all is
inconsistent with the principles of quantum mechanics,
that the uncertainty principle
doesn't allow a situation
of empty space where the fields are zero
and they're not changing, they're always zero.
But the question gets down to
why do you have quantum mechanics?
That doesn't answer the question. Why
do we live in a world governed by
those laws? And
we will never have an answer to that.
Does that bother you?
Yes, I would like to have an answer to everything,
but I've gotten used to it.
I do think that as we learn more
and more about the universe,
we see that there's no point
in the laws of nature
that refers specifically
to human beings. There's nothing that gives
us guidance. But if we don't
find a point in nature, we
can at least make a point for
ourselves. We can love
each other and find beauty in things.
I think the position of human
beings
is eternally
rather tragic,
that we have no
guidance, we have
no script, we're not
acting out a part in a cosmic drama.
Facing
this essential
tragedy, we can leaven it
with a certain
sense of humor
about our condition and
get some, even
some pleasure out of being able to
face the tragedy
of our position without
actually whining about it.
Why the universe?
Does God
exist?
Both questions
forget.
Why
anything at all?
That's
the ultimate question.
Wouldn't it have been simpler
if there had always
been nothing rather than
always something?
I've come
to only two kinds of answers.
The first
is that there is
no answer.
Existence is a
brute fact without
explanation.
The second is at
the primordial beginning
something
was self-existing.
The essence
of this something
was its existence,
such that
non-existence to it
would have been as
inherently impossible
as physical
immortality to us
is factually
impossible.
Candidates for
self-existence include
matter-energy
and space-time.
Natural laws of physics
or higher order laws that
generate quantum mechanics
and perhaps multiple universes.
Forms
of consciousness,
cosmic or otherwise.
A creator
god or an ultimate
cause beyond the physical.
Some
overarching principle
or value like Plato's
The Good.
Why is there something
rather than nothing?
If you
don't get dizzy,
you really don't get it.
This is
Closer to Truth.
For complete interviews
and for further information
please visit
www.closertotruth.com
