BMW RATES MY 'NEW' X5 V8!

Ex Used Car
15 followers
I've just bought myself a new car and it's this, a Mark 1 BMW X5 V8 from 2002. I recently drove
one of these for a Car Wow video, liked it so much, thought I'd buy my own. Trouble is they
can be a bit unreliable and rather expensive to fix, so in this video I'm going to take this car
to one of the leading BMW specialists in the UK. They're going to assess it, take it for a test
drive and give me a bill for how much everything will cost to fix on it. This video could be very
scary. I've come to BMW Park Lane Service Centre in Park Royal to get my X5 assessed by Mitch
Costely. Now Mitch, what's your role here? I'm a master technician. A master technician. Do you
have much experience with the E53 X5? I have. These things were out when my apprenticeship
started, so I cut my teeth working on these things. And what I'm going to get you to do today, right,
I want you to basically grade this car out of 10. I think I've bought a good one, but I'm not sure.
It might be absolutely dreadful in your eyes, so I want you to walk around the exterior, grade the
exterior. Then what we'll do, we'll go inside it, have a look at the quality of the inside, see what
works and what doesn't work and then we'll go underneath it, get on the ramp, might be some
things leaking and then we'll go for a drive and overall you'll grade it out of 10. Not a problem.
So BMW Park Lane is owned by BMW UK, isn't it? Yep, that's correct. We have the sales department
on Park Lane. We have two service departments, one at Park Royal and another one south of the river
in Battersea. Okay, so this is basically their flagship service centre and as you can hear,
there's lots of work going on, so let's get to work ourselves now and go around this car and
judge it. And let's start here at the front then. So you've got a little bit of discolouration in
your headlights, a few dense stone chips in the bottom. I mean this is a 20 year old car, right,
so that's all fine. Yeah, to be honest, it's actually pretty good for the age. What about the
headlights themselves? They are xenons, aren't they? They are xenons, yep, factory xenons. Your
front wing on this side is starting a bit of paint peeling, a bit of fading in the paint,
a little dent there. What is causing this peeling? Do you know what, I'm going to film it with this
camera here so you can see what Mitch and I can see. Here we go, let's have a look at this. So
what's going on there? Probably just a little bit of age, it may have had some work done previously
and it's not been painted the best, but considering the age of it, something you'd potentially expect.
How about the wheels? Look at the wheels. A little bit of corrosion and paint peeling on this rim,
no big curbing or anything like that, so nothing of major concern. Tires on the outside look all
right, there's no bulge or impact damage there. What's the quality of the tires like? Do I need
new tires? I was thinking of getting some. Maybe a little bit of feathering here, that's something
we'll look at better when we've got the car in the air. We can rotate the tire around and look at it
fully, but from the outside it looks okay for now. Down the side. The paint looks a little bit dull,
I was worried that it might be like full of filler. Does it look like it is? Have you got any
way of testing it? You can use the old school technique of a magnet. You've got a magnet!
And it sticks. It sticks? Sticking is good. I wouldn't say there's anything of major concern
there, there's no ripples down the side of it and if you look at it down here,
maybe a little issue with the gap there which would probably point towards maybe this being
off before. Oh yeah look, it wouldn't have come out of factory like that would it? No. So you think the
door might have come off and someone's refitted it? The door or the wing might have had a little bit
of work there, but again if it has, it hasn't been the worst repair in the world. This rear wheel is
worse than the front wheel, look at that, it's a real mess, look at that. That's been repainted before I
think, you've got a bunch of corrosion and all in there. And what's going on here? It's like it's got
the pox or something, it's got monkey pox. It looks like the bumper's been off before,
this trimmed like a black plastic but this has been painted. Yeah that is, look you can see the
black paint on there and why are they doing that? Isn't that over spray from that or I don't know?
It looks underneath like it has been possibly filled or primed, so you can see down here like
it's got a little bit of the primer and stuff so it looks like whoever did it may have done it
deliberately but I can't explain why. I can't understand why either, but this is all like just
general like you know day-to-day living, it's a 20 year old car, the odd knock and bang, you know?
That's the beauty of having an old car like this, I'm not so worried about it, not so precious.
Rear bumper's definitely been off again, you can see the paint here. What is going on here?
That looks like someone's used a house roller. Like you do like your wall at home? Or a rattle
can but it's not. Is that Australian for spray paint, a rattle can? That's something I picked up
over here. Really? Yeah. Oh okay, I'll shut up. But I would say that's either been done at home or a poor
body shop. Okay so I've seen a lot of old X5s, these E53s with cloudy light areas here. Yeah when they
get water and stuff in and the seals tend to leak but you've got a little bit of darkness in there.
This side doesn't look too bad, that side actually looks quite good. This one, yeah you've got a
little bit around the edge there but. That darkness there? Yeah I think it's a little bit, maybe a bit of
water's got in there and then. Yeah let's move on from that, let's go around this side. As you can see
if you compare it to the other side, this side's actually still the plastic. Oh yeah that looks
better doesn't it? And all these panels are metal as well, there's no filler in there you don't think?
Not from the old magnet tests but it's a very scientific way of doing things. Yeah you can use a
paint depth gauge to be more accurate but we just want to do this quickly and you can't tell just by
the naked eye, your trained eye Mitch, you can't see anything that looks untoward. No not particularly.
You've got a mirror that's taped on. Oh I didn't notice that, I really didn't notice that at all.
So I believe you've got folding mirrors so that one's not going to work. I haven't tried the
folding mirrors, we should try the folding mirrors when we get inside. Both rims on this side, pretty
much similar to the other side. I think just peeling paint, I wouldn't be surprised if that's
Yeah you can see a bit of feathering and cracking on the outer edges. Yeah these are quite old these.
So I'll tell you what, as we're going around you're picking up bits and pieces, at the end of it as
well as getting a grade for the car, we'll find out how much it's going to cost to actually make this
perfect for the age. Just notice that. Yep. What's happened to the badge? They've changed the logo,
it's not the blue propeller anymore, it's more the silver and like partially white propeller. That is
either a genuine badge that's been aged or the fact it's kind of half lifted up makes me suspect
it's had one put on. Really, so someone might have stolen a badge and then they put a new one on
the cheap. Possibly come from eBay. So then overall despite the badge, what do you grade the exterior
of this car out of 10 considering it's a 20 year old car? To be honest I'd have to give it a 7.
It's pretty good, doesn't look like it's full of filler, there's no big dense, no scratches,
it's actually a really really nice car. I'll take that and let's see if that thing continues on the
inside. Before Mitch has a look at the inside of this car, I thought I'd tell you that obviously
before I bought this thing, I did a vehicle history check with my friends at CarVertical
and here's the report for this X5. So look, I think coming back on mileage, theft, accidents,
finance, so it was all clean so I was happy to buy it. Scan down I could like check various like
MOT reports as well. A couple of things here and there, maybe Mitch will pick one later like
problems with the suspension bushing. Will he notice those? We'll find out. Anyhow I was very
happy to see the mileage vouchers as well. So it's got 129 000 miles on the clock,
the last MOT said it had 126.6 000 miles on the clock. It's always worth doing this because you
never know what you're going to get. So here's a report from CarVertical from a similar X5 and
E53. It's actually the facelift version and this one, it's got a warning for accident damage. Now
CarVertical will actually show if it's been stolen or whether there's outstanding finance
on it but this one had accident damage and if I scan down, sometimes with CarVertical you get
photos showing the accident damage itself. Now this is really handy because sometimes people
repair the cars, put them back on the road and you don't know that they've ever been damaged before
but if you've got some photos like this you can see for yourself. So that would definitely put
you off buying that particular car. Thankfully mine had none of those issues so I'm very pleased
about that. If you're thinking about buying a used car and you want to check its history,
check out my friends at CarVertical and use the discount code WATSON10 for 10% off. There
is a link in the description and the pinned comment for this video. Right then Mitch,
welcome to the inside of my beautiful X5. What do you think of it? First impression's pretty good.
Dashboard's all in pretty good nick. Perfect actually for the age of it. On both sides you
see the fabric starting to peel up. Yeah it's like wrinkled stockings isn't it? Yeah got it
on both sides. That side, your passenger side is actually a little bit worse. Yeah I really
notice that when I'm looking over there. It really does my head in. Can I stretch that out
quite easy or is it a nightmare? You can. The trims will have to come off and you can stretch it out
and then... It sounds like a nightmare. Let's move on. There's a little bit of goo around your cup
holders in here. Yeah it's not me. Hand sanitizer. Whenever you buy a used car you don't know who's
been in it. Always have some hand sanitizer. Not that I've got OCD after COVID or anything like
that. Everything else, everything seems to work. You've still got your cigarette lighter. Yeah
essential for a non-smoker like me. Yep essential for everybody. It's just a surprise that a car at
this age still has it there. Does it work though? Let's have a look. That's looking very much like
a no. No not at the moment. Consumption 18.3 miles to the gallon. All the pixels are still there.
Normally on these. Everything works. Are they starting to fail these little? They have always
been temperamental. They fail and go blank. What is that noise? It does this noise. Has someone
fitted some kind of like bluetooth system? When I turn it on after about like 30 seconds it goes
beep like that. It looks like something non-genuine because you've got your little microphone up there.
Don't believe that is BMW standard equipment. No it doesn't look it. Especially the one over
there for the passenger. And do not believe it made those noises. No it's a bit shocking.
Your display works. It sort of does work. It's got some spots. The fact it works and it's genuine.
Pretty good. It's got a telly. The telly doesn't work because the old signal has been cancelled for
digital. Yeah that's what you get. A load of like fuzz. It's one of those magic eye kind of images.
So if you stare at it long enough you will see a dolphin. It works. Works perfect. Both sides.
Should be able to get it everywhere. Heated seats. They work. I can attest to that. So then you're
quite liking the front. Let's check out the back seats before you give a verdict on the interior.
Right then Mitch. Welcome to the back seats of my X5. What do you think? Again pretty good nick for
the age of the car. Leathers in good condition. It's a bit wrinkly but not too bad. Be expected.
Don't have any wear marks around your edges. They tend to get wear there from people getting in and
out and all that sort of stuff. Especially with kids jumping in and out. This is actually really
good. I mean it's almost as new. Really really good. Pockets which is a nice option in the back of the seat.
Got some goodies in this one. Covers for your ISOFIX. Yeah look ISOFIX. I really like that. I
think it's quite an early vehicle to have ISOFIX. Really handy. What else you got in here?
Oh what's that? Remote control for a TV or something. So is it the original one for the TV?
Did it come with a remote? I don't believe so. Not for the front one. You do have this trim here with
your in and out and TV buttons. It's something I would have to look into to see whether it's genuine.
Look it's a bit wobbly. It is a bit wobbly which again raises a little bit of suspicion as to
if it is genuine or not. But something you have to find out. But again you've got a cigarette lighter.
This one works. Oh look it's working. That's good so if I need to smoke I need to hop into the back.
Yeah yeah it's good for the kids. I just noticed this actually. Ah a bit of history about the car.
So it looks like it was auctioned off in June. Maybe June this year. We'll actually come to the
service manual and stuff a bit later on because yeah I think that must have been June. And is
the disc for the CD? For the navigation CD or something? It's Finding Nemo. I would say that's
better. It's probably more accurate. I can also see where that big beeping awful noise is from now
that I'm in the back seats. Right what is it? You have a massive big speaker screwed into the side
under your glove box on the passenger front. So that's where that's coming from. Aftermarket
Bluetooth isn't it? Right one last thing to show you it's the boot. What really annoys me about this
car. Ah your button doesn't work. Button doesn't work. I have to do it on the key or either button
inside yeah. Is this a common fault? Yeah it's relatively well known. Is it easy to fix? Um
or hideously expensive? Probably a combination of both. This part operates though. I love this bit
they've folded down the tail they get you bits. And all the trims are intact nothing torn or worn.
Spare wheel full size. Well relatively full size which you don't see very often.
You've got your spare wheel like that. Oh wow that stays there and then you can lift your wheel out
easily. You were like what it's 20 years ago since you worked on these so even remember that it did
this is good. I'll drive out here and forget that it even does this. Let's put it back.
I'll let you do that. That is a really clever feature.
Sometimes takes a little bit of wiggling and jiggling to get back in properly.
Okay so you've seen around the outside of the car a couple of bits and pieces like that not
working. Overall what do you think of the interior of this car? You gave it 7 out of 10 for the
exterior. How about the interior? Do you know what? For the age of it again it's really good. You've
got no tears. Leather's all intact. I think you're probably at a good seven and a half to be honest.
Should we just like bump it up to an eight? Always round up. The Germans round up you see.
Every decimal point they round up and that's why the 6.2 litre AMG engine.
I'm sorry. I was going around corners.
Anyway so eight for the interior, seven for the exterior but now there's a moment of truth.
We've got to look underneath. Right Mitch we've got the car up on a ramp. You're taking some
covers off. What can you see up in here? Anything to be worried about? You have a power steering
leak starters. Is that what that is? You can see that. You can see someone's had a go. That's not
genuine. That's not an official repair from BMW. Okay that looks like it's had a split and someone's
put something over the top of it. You've got an alternator belt. Your AC belt is pretty badly
cracked. Oh gosh look at all the cracks in that. I'll be looking at replacing that. The air
conditioning does work though for now. Yeah until that belt snaps. Fair enough. Can't see any coolant
leaks but you do have an oil leak which we can spot a little bit. Oil leak sounds very bad. Let's
have a look. Oh god yeah. Oh my gosh look at this. This is yeah. Is it broken? I wouldn't use that
word so much but. I'm starting to panic right now. It's coming from the top and leaks down the side
so before you go panicking about anything down below, place the top. Clean it off. Is a leak
from the bottom worse than a leak from the top? Only with the amount of work required to fix them.
So the top's easier to get to basically? Yeah because once you start looking at the bottom
you've got all this front axle suspension bracing and all that sort of stuff that tends to have to
come down. It is pretty standard on these to have rocker cover leaks. So it's a normal feature of
the E53. It's standard fit. This engine type it is a pretty common. Really? Yeah. So not to worry about
it just keep an eye on the oil level. Yeah if that's been like that for a decade and no one's
done anything it's going to look like that. Well it's kind of like um rust proofing. You can look
at it that way. So that's nothing to worry about but I will still get you to price up putting the
new gasket on because it's the gasket around the rocker cover yeah? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. So we'll price
that up. Let's move on to the suspension and the steering. Just a bit of corrosion around here. Not
much to worry about in the age of the car. It's all still pretty solid. It's just your front bushes
here. Yeah okay I can see those. They've started to crack. I know that the tracking rod here on the right
hand side is seized because of the tracking done on the car. They could change the left but they
couldn't do anything about this because it's just solid. Yeah to get that adjusted we'll have to put
the new one on. How about the rest of the suspension and the bushings throughout the car and at the
back as well? There's a few issues with the back bushings. Let's have a quick look. Good news is
someone's already been in and had a go at these ones. Look like they've been replaced and these
rear bushings are starting to wear off. Without driving you'd have to see the very back. So these
appear a little bit kind of cracked. Oh I can see that's cracked that is. Yeah it's cracked. So that can
cause a bit of play. Make it drive a bit loosely. Once they go you'll have a knock. I don't think
any knocks but you'll find out when you drive it in a moment. You also got one of your drop links
for your rear stabilizer split and leaking grease. Oh yeah I can see yeah. Someone has also
had some repairs done to the diff. Oh they don't come out of the factory like that? No no that is
definitely not. That is not to German standards. All right so suspension it's okay yeah it's kind
of is it what you expect for this age? Yeah well it's got air suspension on the back as well
and it works. That is a good sign for a 20 year old car. Because that could be expensive to replace.
Very very expensive. So if we're looking at eventually one day doing the bushings should
I do the shock absorbers as well just as good practice? 130,000 miles or would you just you
know leave it and accept that it's a 2,700 pound car? On a car this age this price range
if it ain't broke don't fix it. One last thing the brakes. I'm gonna be toying with this car hopefully
so I just want to make sure the brakes are okay. What have you found? You've looked over the brakes
yeah I've looked over front and rear. Rears are fine everything measures out perfect. The front
ones your front discs are a bit low. You've got plenty of meat left on your pads. Next time around
you'll definitely need to get your disc replaced. The underside of this car what you've seen of it
and what you'd expect for a 20 year old E53. What do you rate out of 10? I think I'd have to
match it with the interior to be honest. An 8? I'll give it an 8. The oil leaks for example
are common. Like I said I've done my apprenticeship on these almost 20 years ago and I was fixing them
back then. It's a pretty standard thing on that engine. But the engine itself is quite solid yeah?
Yeah yeah. Well you've given an 8 for underneath what really matters is how it drives right?
Do you want to drive it? Yeah let's go. Before we go for a drive we thought it was wise to plug the
car into the OBD reader to see if there's any fault codes and we do have a few here don't we?
Got a few. I don't think there's too much to be worried about. Ah okay. So we'll clear them down
go for a drive and see if anything comes back. I like the sound of that just clear them off forget
about them and if they pop up again we know we've got an issue that's recurring whereas these could
just be like they could be historic. Okay let's hope they're historical because this car has
actually been well maintained so here's a service history book and it's it's pretty much full isn't
it? Pretty much on time should be every every two years. It's BMW official like? Been to a BMW dealer
the whole time. 119,000 miles so it's about 10,000 miles to go 119,000 miles. That was the last
service at a BMW dealership. That's pretty impressive. So it should drive well? Should.
All those vital fluids are in there. Because if you break it you buy it and it's now five grand
because it's been vouched as being an 8 out of 10 by a BMW master tech. That's right we'll speak to
the boss. Let's drive it now. Right Mitch in the driver's seat take care of it and go easy on your
right foot because the economy's not great. Let's see what you think of it driving. Oh look straight
away there's a nicer one than mine. It's a facelift as well. It's the IS isn't it? 4.8 IS yeah.
Shall we see if we can just ditch this one and get into that one? I'd prefer the engine in this one.
Really? The older generation I think they're a bit better. For the BMW geeks this has an
N62 engine. Yes. The one in that is an N62. This one is seen to be more reliable? Yeah.
Not really quick though it's like something like 270 odd horsepower. It's a big car though.
For 270 horsepower well I toyed a GR Yaris it's got three cylinders 1.6 litres and that's almost
the same power output as this big 4.4 litre V8. Come a long way the last 20 years. Now one thing
I noticed when I started driving this for the first time the steering seems heavy and seeing
that leak for the power steering fluid is is it related or is just the way they are sir? Yeah
your power steering fluid level's fine. I did check that under the bonnet but this is what
they've always felt like. They are a bit heavier this generation of car around this time like E46s
E53s E39 5 Series it's just the feel of the hydraulic steering that's that is the way they
are. Because this is E39 5 Series generation isn't it? Yeah it's actually very there's a lot of things
in common electrically as well with that E39. Despite the tracking rod it is driving nice and
straight like sitting in an old sofa especially even with the steering. And the electric seats
do work like they do fully work and the electrical steering column. I tell you what not many rattles.
No nice and quiet. To be honest a good trade of these cars they didn't rattle that much.
Where's it like BMW going like this is our first SUV let's make sure it's solid as hell.
And a bit of an accelerate going up to 40. What does it feel like? Feels the way it should it's
got a nice little pull to it. And it oh that sounded nice higher up and it's got the old
style BMW trait where it pulls higher up in the rev range you don't get that so much in modern
cars because they're all torquey and turbo. Right we're coming to a stop here try the brakes.
Have you got that clunky sound or is it fine? It's there a little bit really but it's not too
bad because when it gets really bad you feel it. So that's the bushings in the front? That's the
bushings in the front. Being a little bit loose that when you brake you can feel a little bit.
Yeah it feels like the front axle's like moving a little bit but you can hear it a little bit
feel it a bit but when they get really bad you can really feel it in through the steering and
stuff as well. Is it worth me doing that really? I don't want to spend any money on it. Not at the
That's what you want to hear when you've got a £2,700 car because it can soon become
a £5,700 car can't it? And that's why these things are so cheap right because if you start
doing repairs on them and we'll find out if we do everything that I'd like to do that you've
suggested on this how much it could come to. So how was it moving then? So the kick down on the
gearbox fine? That's nice and then it sounds good it revs nice it's nice and smooth so it brings
back memories. Being a main dealer we don't see good ones of these very often and this one is
a good one for the age. At a ten for the drive what are you going to give it? Bearing in mind
you've given it seven for the exterior, eight for the interior and eight for the underside and the
mechanics. Of course it's a V8 I'm going to give it a nine. Nine! It's a nine for the drive I'm so
pleased. So you think for £2,700 this has been a good buy? Definitely if you bought a diesel
it wouldn't be higher than an eight. Fair enough. So Mitch has driven the car he's assessed it and
you've established that it's a very good car considering it's 20 years old. Yes. But if I
wanted to make it light new make it perfect there are a few things that you picked out
and you've priced all those up now and you're going to tell me how much it would cost me
to make this car the dream X5 yeah? I'll give you the paperwork and let you have a quick feed
through. Okay so there's on the last page there at the bottom right hand corner you can see the
price. Okay three pages so this is parts and labour okay right so um let me run through some of these
things before I tell you the price. We've got the mounts £177 to £190. Then we've got the
gaskets and stuff for the rocker covers. Is this with fitting as well? Yeah. £341. I thought it'd
be more than that to be fair but still quite a lot of money. So that's the front pads and discs yeah?
Yes. That's £440 all in for the front pads and discs so I'll wait till they start grinding.
Steering hose £266. The thermostat because actually the fault codes didn't come back
apart from one. The thermostat fault. Could be quite important that. That's £205
fitted yeah? Yeah and you've got your coolant on top of that actually so. Oh so £100 for coolant
okay. Cleaning and refilling all the coolant. The biggest single item here is like £1014
for swing arms. I didn't remember you saying anything about swing arms. Yeah that's your
rear control arms for those bushes in the rear. They come as a whole arm you can't buy those
bushes separate. You can't buy the little rubber bit separate you have to buy the whole. You have
to get the whole arm for those inside ones. Let's move on. The door mirror. Yeah that's a lot. It's
like £472. And wait these numbers that I'm quoting don't include 20% VAT either. And that brings me
onto the the total bill. Parts and labour with the AT £4,972. It doesn't need doing though does
it necessarily to make it perfect? That is to make it as good a car as it could possibly be
but it's a pretty good car. It's a pretty good car and it costs £2,700. That would turn it into a
£7,700 car which I could then sell the next day for £2,700 again. We won't do
that. There is one thing we might do. The bonnet badge. £60. We can do that. What you mean you'll
do that for free? I think we'll be able to sort something out. I'll go and change it then if it's
free otherwise it was staying faded. I hope you'll enjoyed the video. If you did give it a like. Let
me know what you think of my car in the comments all right. If you want to watch some other videos
click on the windows and don't forget to click on my face to subscribe to this channel. Oh there
we go. Thank you very much for that Mitch. No problem. Nice new badge there and I should point
out it's £40 for the badge but that bit of labour that Mitch just did that was £20.
