Come and join us as we take a ride on the new lunar terrain vehicles that will be used for the Artemis Missions. You will learn about the different capabilities these new rovers will have which will allow us to explore further and enable more scientific discoveries for humanity.
We’re launching STEM Engagement to new heights with learning resources that connect teachers, students, parents and caregivers to the inspiring work at NASA. Join us as we apply science, technology, engineering and mathematics to explore space, improve aeronautics, examine Earth and strive to land the first woman and first person of color on the Moon with the Artemis program.
Follow us on social media. Facebook: / nasastemengagement X: https://x.com/NASASTEM Pinterest: / nasa-stem
Welcome to the NASA series, Exploring the Moon,
where we take a behind-the-scenes look
at the preparations for humanity's return to the Moon.
The lighting conditions are going to be very different
between Apollo and Artemis.
We're taking the ability to transport crew and tools
and these Mars rovers that can operate independent of the crew,
and we're putting them together.
The South Pole is really hard to drive in.
It's going to be quite an adventure
and be able to get some good science out of it.
That is the whole reason we're going.
We're going for the science.
I think it's pretty cool.
Hi, I'm Stephanie Cifala,
and in this episode, we are honored to have Nathan Howard,
who is an expert on Moon rovers.
Hi, Nathan. It's good to have you here today.
Hi, Stephanie. It's really good to be here.
So, Nathan, I wanted to start our discussion today
with the idea of humans returning to the Moon
as part of the Artemis campaign.
We have these rovers that we designed for Apollo.
They were single-use rovers.
They're still sitting on the surface of the Moon.
Tell me what's going to be the difference
between the Apollo rovers and the new rovers
that we need for Artemis.
Okay, so the Apollo rovers, as I said,
they were single-use vehicles,
and so they were designed for one purpose,
and that was to carry the crew
and the equipment they needed during the mission,
and then they were done.
For the Artemis campaign, we are going,
and we are going to learn how to live on Mars in the future,
and so we're designing a vehicle that can last longer,
and so if you want to compare the Apollo rover
to, say, the amazing Mars rovers that are out there,
we're taking the ability to transport crew and tools
and these Mars rovers that can operate
independent of the crew, and we're putting them together.
The lighting conditions are going to be very different
between Apollo and Artemis.
During Apollo, because they landed equatorial,
they wanted to land either in the morning or in the afternoon,
and the reason for that is in the morning,
you're able to get shadows,
and you're able to give yourself some depth perception
or depth cues.
If you were to land during the middle of the day,
you get very harsh light straight overhead,
and it's very difficult.
We're going to run into a different problem
on the South Pole.
In the South Pole, the sun never gets more
than a few degrees off the horizon,
which creates very difficult lighting conditions
from the standpoint of sometimes you're going to be
driving directly into the sun,
and it's going to make it hard to see what's going on.
The other part of that is it creates long shadows,
and so you could end up being in the shadow
from a mountain that is kilometers away
because the sun is at such a low angle.
It's casting these long shadows.
It's like taking a flashlight and holding it
real close to a table and seeing how long
the shadows can make from just little bitty things.
It sounds like you're describing driving at sunrise
or driving at sunset, perhaps directly into the sun.
Oh, yes.
For those of us in Houston,
there are certain times of the year
where I'm coming into work or I'm leaving work,
and the sun is right on the horizon,
and it makes it very difficult.
Makes you wonder if the rover is going to have
some sort of special windshield
to protect from the low sun angle.
That's one of the things that will be part
of the design challenges.
What are we going to have within the system,
and the system being both the rovers and the landers
and the suits to help the astronauts perform the best?
The suits might even have sunshades.
I know they have sunshades for ISS operations.
It becomes an integrated problem to solve.
You have lots of tools that you can aid the astronauts with.
You have lots of tools you can give to the astronauts
to make their job a little bit easier.
That's true. That's true.
So I have this great video here
of what the sun conditions look like at the South Pole.
Can you explain to us what we're looking at?
The moon is traveling around the Earth,
but we always see the same face,
which means that the sun is always
coming across the moon at different angles
as the moon orbits the Earth.
And so what we're looking at here
is how those shadows change
over the course of days and a year.
And what you'll see is that
kind of in the middle of the screen,
there's a crater, and that's where the South Pole is.
And then you'll see these shadows that pass across,
and some of those shadows are from a mountain,
Malpert Massif, that is more than 100 kilometers away.
But that shadow, because the sun is such at a low angle,
is actually still putting the area in darkness.
Nice. Thank you.
I have a really great image coming up next
that shows the same craters
and the same part of the lunar South Pole.
The star in the middle, I believe,
is the actual South Pole marker.
And then the graphic also has red areas and blue areas.
What do those indicate for us?
So, Stephanie, you're right.
The star marks where the South Pole is.
And you'll see that the South Pole
is actually right on the rim
of what's called Shackleton Crater.
The red areas represent the highest elevation.
And so if you think about it,
red is high and then blue is low.
And so in the upper right-hand corner,
you see Shoemaker Crater.
That one is the lowest area in this image
because it's deep.
And so those areas stay dark for a very long period of time.
The high areas, they get the most sun.
And what scientists have found is that the connecting ridge,
which is actually just a local high area
between Shackleton Crater and Degrelash Crater,
is an area of the moon
that receives light most of the year.
So let's turn all of this lunar environment knowledge
into a rover.
How does the light environment
and the sun environment you're describing,
how does that affect the design
and the capabilities needed from a rover?
So the rover is going to have to be able to survive
both light and dark conditions
and take advantage of the light when it has it
and be able to survive the dark.
And so we have found that there's areas of the moon
that stay lit most of the time around the South Pole.
Once you get away from the South Pole,
most of the moon has 14 days of light and 14 days of dark.
So if you're going to operate in the South Pole,
you need to figure out how much dark do you have to survive.
And so we figured out that there are areas in the moon
where we can minimize that period of darkness.
And so the idea would be to stay in the sun
as long as you can, charge up your batteries,
and then go to those locations
that stay light most of the time.
And whenever a shadow does come,
you kind of do like a bear.
You go and hibernate.
Go to sleep for a little bit,
and then when the sun comes back out,
you wake back up and you continue exploring.
It's a combination of planning your day
and planning your excursions
on top of designing a vehicle
to handle these lighting conditions.
That is absolutely right.
You have to think about it as an integrated problem,
both the vehicle design and the mission design.
Because some of the things that we want to be able to do
is we want to be able to travel
between these column hibernation points.
We want to be able to travel between these points
because there may be additional science we want to explore.
And traveling between those parts, those points,
is going to take a lot of planning and vehicle design.
You shared with us another graphic
that I'd like to pull up right now.
And in this video,
we can see two dots moving across red lines.
The image on the right, I clearly understand.
That is us floating above the surface of the moon
looking down,
and the red track is the track that the rover takes
and the green dot is the rover.
Help me understand what's happening in the left graphic.
So you're absolutely right.
The green dot is the rover
as it travels along the red path.
And so what we're looking at here is
how would the rover travel
between some of these high points and stay in the sun?
And so, well, in this case, think about the shadows,
the big black bars on here as the shadows.
And those shadows, if you get stuck in those,
those are probably going to be long enough
that your vehicle can't survive.
So you have to plan out when you're going to go forward,
when you're going to stop,
and when you're going to go forward again.
And so if you notice between the two graphics,
there are periods of time where the rover looks like
it could drive forward and keep going,
but it's sitting there stopped, and you wonder why.
Well, the reason is that you don't have enough time
to get to the next stop point before a shadow comes.
And so you actually have to stop
and wait for the shadows to move around you
before you can move on to the next point.
This is really complicated.
I always assumed building a rover for the moon
would be pretty easy.
Well, that's kind of interesting
because during the Apollo era,
they thought the exact same thing.
They thought, okay, it's a simple rover.
We'll go put it on the moon.
Well, once they got into it,
they realized that they had a lot of mass constraints.
They knew that they had mass constraints.
They had volume constraints.
They had complexity that was just phenomenal.
And we are understanding the same thing as well,
is that the rover is a very complex piece
of a very complex system.
Not only is it how do you get from one point to the other,
how are you able to support the science?
How are you able to do simple things like phone home?
Because just getting communication there
is more difficult.
During Apollo, it was a lot easier
because they were equatorial.
The moon's tidal locked.
If they wanted to know where the Earth was,
all they had to do was look up.
It was always right there in the sky.
Because we're at the South Pole,
we have to pay attention to where is the Earth
relative to where we're at,
and because the terrain is referred to
as highland-type terrain,
we could very easily dip below a hill
and not be able to see Earth.
How do we train ourselves and our astronauts
to drive in these difficult conditions?
We can train the astronauts using simulators,
and we have used data collected
from the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter
and its instruments to create topographic maps.
And then we take those topographic maps
and we put them in a simulation environment.
And some folks might be interested to know
that it's the same sort of simulation environment
that they use to create a lot of the video games.
They put the terrain in there,
they put the rover in there,
you put the sun in there,
and then you get the same lighting conditions
that you would expect at the South Pole.
So you're able to train the astronauts
in an environment that they would expect
when they get there.
You know, Stephanie, the other day,
I had the opportunity to show astronaut Tracy Dyson
how to drive a moon rover in one of our simulations.
I'd love to see that video.
Well, welcome to the Systems Engineering Simulator,
a simulation of the Lunar South Pole environment.
I'm excited about this.
Some of the fun things that you're going to find out
is that the South Pole is really hard to drive in
because of the lighting.
Okay.
So to get started,
what you would do is you'd release the parking brake.
Okay.
Okay, so let's turn that.
There you go. You see the wheels?
I do. I see the wheels are ready.
A little bit.
All right.
Okay.
And so if you want to drive forward,
you just push forward.
What's the top speed on this guy?
It's 15 kilometers per hour.
Oh.
And so one of the things that's interesting
about the South Pole is because the sun is so low,
you see all these craters and these rocks.
The craters don't get much sun down in them,
and so you can't tell how deep they are.
Oh, wow.
Or how big they are,
so you're going to want to try to avoid some of those.
The rocks, you can see that they're kind of small,
but they're cast in these long shadows.
That's one of the things about the South Pole
that's going to be fun to navigate.
And so you push forward.
Okay.
So don't worry, we can reset the simulation
if you get stuck on anything.
And there you go.
That's great.
Handle that little rock there.
And you can see all the different craters
that we're expecting.
And right now, we're up on Connecting Ridge.
Connect, that's the name of it?
Connecting Ridge is what everybody calls it,
and it actually connects Shackleton Crater
to Degrelosh Crater.
So it's a local high area right on the South Pole.
So now, if I try to go between these craters...
Well, go ahead and do it.
And you start to see here
that this one might be a little deeper.
Go ahead and drive through,
and the vehicle will react.
Leaning over to one side,
as you drop down in the crater.
All right.
All right, I'm going to open it up a little bit.
Yeah, open it up.
I feel like I'm...
And that's one of the reasons why we're doing this
is so that the astronauts,
when they're getting ready to go to the South Pole,
they can get an idea of what it's like to drive
before they actually get there.
And then you can see all these little rocks.
They popped into view as you got closer.
Yeah.
Oh, I see what you're saying.
Those little...
The little rocks.
The little guys.
And they can tell you where the sun is coming.
Give you an idea of where the sun's coming from.
Now, this is in reality going to be all open, right?
So I'll have windows all around me, basically?
This is the unpressurized rover.
So this is very similar to the lunar roving vehicle from Apollo.
So you'll be in your suit.
I got you.
And able to...
Your view will be as big as your helmet.
So now you can see starting to go downhill,
and you've got an inclinometer there on your display.
Oh, I do.
A little bubble right here.
Okay.
You can see you're kind of tipped over to the right a little bit.
And then if you point it more downhill,
you'll see the bubble move around.
So it's downhill, open.
Go ahead, open it up.
All right.
We're going.
If you turn to your right and start looking towards the sun,
you'll see what it's like driving.
Wait, toward the sun, you said?
Towards the sun, yeah.
Okay.
If you turn, you'll see how difficult it might be to start driving facing the sun.
See there?
You can see that crater.
Oh, man.
You don't really...
You don't know what's on the other side.
No, you don't.
You don't know at all.
Here you can see headed back towards the hab.
So that...
You had driven off over this way, and now you're coming back around.
So this was the local low area that you drove around.
Wow.
I'm just in awe at the moment.
So the goal here is to work with the planet,
the data that we've been able to collect from the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter
with all the elevation maps and everything, create the topography,
and then come in, and then the scientists, the planetary scientists,
come in and tell us, you know, should these be big rocks, little rocks?
How big are the little craters?
So, like, if you try to drive over that rock, are you going to go over it?
And then you get stuck.
Oh, I get stuck.
I'm not going to break an axle in there.
So what if this happened to me in real life?
What would I do?
Well...
Do we have, like, a...
Yeah, in the Apollo era,
they actually could just pick up the vehicle and move it.
Oh, they'd just get up and get out?
They could just pick up and move it.
This vehicle is going to be different.
It's going to have a lot more capability.
I just did it.
Well, I didn't do it.
There you go.
I did it.
All right.
We got out.
There you go.
Now you can see your tracks.
Oh, this is so cool.
Okay.
So, as you can see, if you look right here in this area,
you can see a depression area right there.
And so you can go and you can try to drive down from there.
No kidding.
All right.
Going.
Going into the crater.
Yeah, but see?
You can't see what's down there.
Oh, no, I don't want to go there.
I'll get stuck, huh?
Because you can pull me out, right?
You might get...
Yeah, we can get you out.
Oh, God.
Go explore down in there and see what it's like when it gets dark.
This is crazy.
It looks like a really steep wall on the other side.
It does.
Don't try this at home.
All right.
I'm going in.
Going in.
Oh, look at that.
So, there you go.
You can see now you're tipping off to the side.
I feel like I'm in a dune buggy.
There you go.
Yeah.
Look at that.
So, there you go.
In and out.
We did it.
You probably had no doubt.
You're like, this vehicle can handle it.
That's right.
Oh, my.
So, that's a shadow then.
That's a shadow of a mountain that's behind you.
Oh, wow.
So, that's one of the things about this area, about the South Pole,
is even though it's illuminated most of the time...
It's got some wicked...
It's got some wicked shadows.
So, like right here, you have no idea what's down in there.
Almost like driving in fog where...
Yeah, you can't see what's...
You can't see in front of you except like two feet.
You're already on top of it.
Wow.
So, now you're seeing where the sun is just barely clipping the top of it.
Is that the mountain that was behind me or the mountain that I was headed for?
That's the mountain you were headed for right there.
So, you're down in the shadow and you can see where the light was coming through
and it's cast this long shadow.
So, if you continue up that, you'll get up out of the...
You'll eventually come up out of the shadow.
Oh, wow. I bet it's pretty cold down here too.
That's right.
So, the other thing about the South Pole is it's got these cold traps in it
that are part of the reason we're going there
because we're looking at the possibility of having water trapped in those areas.
Okay, so it looks like you're getting pretty close to the edge of the shadow now.
Okay. Should we like slow down and make it dramatic?
There you go.
Yeah.
So, you can see how sharp that shadow line is
because you don't get any of the light scatter that you get from the atmosphere here.
There you go.
Wow, and there you are.
Back in the light.
Oh, my gosh.
That was super crazy.
There you go.
Let me...
Look at that.
That's what you were.
And so, I started on the other side of that shadow.
You started on the other side of that shadow.
You went all the way down through there and came right back out.
So, now that you've had a chance to drive the simulator, what are your thoughts?
My thoughts are that this takes some practice,
but it reminds me a lot of riding motorcycles out in the deserts of Southern California
where you have flat terrain but all these features,
and there's potholes that could come up,
and you have to think quick before you react to them,
before you can get out of the way.
But I also think that it's fascinating just the fact you're on the moon's surface
and how you were describing the sun and the shadows on the terrain
and how they change and how shadows are...
They appear to be like these sheer drop-offs,
but they're actually...
Some of them are just inclines, and our job is going to be to go explore these areas.
Absolutely.
So, I think just having, first of all, this vision to go and do this is pretty exciting.
The fact that we can take all of the data that we had from our Apollo days
and put it to use like this is also pretty exciting.
Absolutely.
This is going to be a fun tool.
It's absolutely going to be fun,
and it's hopefully going to make all your lives easier in the years to come.
I was going to say that any little bit helps
because this is going to be quite an adventure to go for the long haul
and sustain a presence there and be able to get some good science out of it.
Yep.
That is the whole reason we're going.
We're going for the science.
I think it's pretty cool, and I appreciate it.
No problem. We're happy to have you.
Awesome.
Welcome back anytime.
Thank you.
So, just like driving around your neighborhood,
you drive it enough times, you know where everything is.
I bet that makes everybody feel a lot more comfortable.
I know it would make me feel comfortable.
And what about the simulators?
Do we use them for anything besides astronaut training?
Yes, we use the simulators for other things as well.
We can use them to help plan out science missions as well as train the astronauts.
Nathan, how do the science requirements for the Artemis campaign influence the rover design?
Science has influenced the design of the lunar rover.
We are designing it in such a way that it can accommodate different payloads across its mission
where we can change out what we want to carry from one mission to the next.
How many lunar terrain vehicles will there be in the Artemis campaign?
Well, right now, we don't know how many rovers there will be.
We are asking industry to go out and help us understand
what's the most efficient way to explore the moon for 10 years.
It's not just how much does something cost,
but also from the standpoint of how much crew time would it take to maintain a vehicle over 10 years.
The rover that you shared with NASA astronaut Tracy Dyson earlier this week, what is it used for?
Why does NASA have it?
Yes, we are putting together a reference design
and we are also in the process of building a ground test unit.
We call it the GTU.
And so the reference design is what Tracy was able to drive in the simulator.
And so that's a design that really helps us understand operations in the lunar environment,
looking at the lighting, looking at just getting from point A to point B.
And there are things that we have learned over the last year and a half to two years
that we didn't even know we didn't know when we started this.
The ground test unit is kind of the other side of the coin
where we need something that our astronauts
and our trainers and our engineers can interact with physically
to understand how do you physically interact with this thing?
What do we need its capabilities to be?
How are we going to use it within the larger architecture?
Not just on paper, but how are we actually physically going to interact with this thing?
So we're putting that together and then we're planning to use it
to help us better understand the vendor designs when those come out.
Has the rover ground test unit been tested in different analog conditions?
Not yet. The ground test unit, we are still in the process of developing it.
Will the ground test unit allow us to practice changing wheels
and other types of rover maintenance that we might need?
Yes, the ground test unit could be used for a variety of different use cases.
So one of the things could be how do you perform maintenance on the vehicle?
We know that across 10 years, the vehicle is going to need maintenance.
And so even though we don't know the design of the final vehicle yet,
we do know that there are likely things that we will have to do.
And so we can look at changing a wheel.
We could look at changing other pieces of equipment.
The other thing that we can look at is simple things like where do you put the steering wheel?
Do we even have a steering wheel?
Do we have computer screens? What else do we have?
So we can use this to help us better understand how we could use the vehicle
and how we would interact with it in the future.
Nathan, thank you so much for joining us today
and sharing with us an inside look of the Moon rovers.
Thank you, Stephanie. It has been a pleasure to be here.