"Why the Holy Roman Empire Ruled So Long "

Sculpted Rome
10 followers
The Holy Roman Empire lasted over 800 years and it looked like this.
So how did such a fractured political entity last so long?
It has to do with a concept called subsidiarity and it holds the key to implementing responsible
government today. Voltaire famously derided the Holy Roman Empire as neither holy nor Roman
nor an empire. But what couldn't be denied was its longevity. Existing from 962 to 1806,
it was birthed before William the Conqueror invaded England and continued on after the
American Revolution. It's considered one of the longest lasting empires in history,
a feat of particular intrigue when one considers its central geographical location
So what was its secret? Why did the HRE last so long, surviving massive political turmoil
and even wars within its borders, while other nations came and went?
To answer this question, we first need to understand the concept of subsidiarity.
Subsidiarity is a Catholic principle of governance developed by Pope Leo XIII
in his 1891 encyclical Rerum Novarum, or Revolutionary Change, as an attempt to bridge
the gap between capitalism and socialism. Later Pope Pius XI defined it,
A fundamental principle of social philosophy, that one should not withdraw from individuals
and commit to the community what they can accomplish by their own enterprise and industry.
Essentially it means that matters should be handled by the lowest or least centralized
competent authority. Political decisions should be made locally. A decentralized government ensures
that those closest to the problem have the most control. Decentralization and thus subsidiarity
has an inherently stabilizing effect as government has many checks and balances
and can't be undermined by a few poor decisions from leadership.
In the spirit of philosopher Nassim Taleb, a decentralized system is anti-fragile.
And the HRE was exactly this. Let's explore how its structure implemented subsidiarity.
The HRE, like many medieval states, was feudal. This meant that society was structured around
lords, vassals, and fiefs, or lands. There were various forms of feudalism within the empire,
but we'll stick to the basic model. A lord was a noble who owned lands. A vassal was someone the
lord granted possession of land in exchange for service to the lord. Vassals would get
land in protection, while the lord would get a vassal he could call upon for military service.
This was the feudal relationship. The system is best envisioned as a pyramid with a king,
who is the ultimate lord, at the top, and a series of vassalages cascading down to the peasantry.
Lower classes granted upper classes resources or military service,
while upper classes granted lower classes protection and land. The HRE was sometimes
called a patchwork carpet due to its multiplicity of small, somewhat autonomous
principalities. At its peak, there were more than 300 Kleinstädten, or little states,
in the empire, some covering no more than a few square miles. This patchwork structure was akin
to a federation, where some principalities were controlled either by church authorities,
prince-bishops, or the emperor himself, while most were held by local princes who pledged fealty to
the emperor. A 1232 document explicitly calls German dukes Domine Terre, or owners of their
lands, making it clear that a level of independence existed apart from the emperor, and this meant
authority was very localized. The emperor had little involvement at the local level.
Each principality was managed by its prince or bishop, creating a decentralized system
where vassals looked to their lords for support or grievances, rather than a far-off ruler.
The emperor's role was primarily to maintain peace by 1. defending the borders from external threats
and 2. settling inter-principality disputes through his court. The princes were largely
free to run their fiefs as they saw fit, as long as the emperor's interests were respected.
Another decentralized aspect of the empire was the selection of its ruler. Unlike other medieval
monarchs, the Holy Roman Emperor was not hereditary, but elected. A small body of the most powerful
princes first elected the candidate and bestowed him the title, King of the Romans. According to
the Golden Bull of 1356, seven prince-electors cast their votes. The Archbishop of Mainz,
the Archbishop of Trier, the Archbishop of Cologne, the King of Bohemia, the Count Palatine of the
Rhine, the Duke of Saxony, and the Margrave of Brandenburg. Imperial candidates often
negotiated with electors in a process called electoral capitulation. Starting with Charles V
in 1519, candidates swore to respect the terms set by the electors, placing limits on the emperor's
authority. A sort of early checks and balances. To be formally named emperor, though, the
candidate needed to be crowned by the pope. It often took years in between being elected king
and officially becoming emperor. Ferdinand I, for example, waited a whopping 25 years before his
coronation in 1556. The HRE is perhaps the best example of subsidiarity implemented on a wide
scale. Its implementation, even if unintended, was a huge factor in the empire's longevity by
creating a system of small, autonomous states held together by a common emperor. Other political
entities came and went, either succumbing to external threats or internal revolution.
But the HRE remained a continuous empire for over 800 years, surviving dynastic shifts and
political changes. Today, subsidiarity remains an important principle when evaluating governmental
policies and programs. A good litmus test for any new policy should be, does it follow the principle
of subsidiarity? Thanks for watching this video. Please like, comment, and subscribe if you'd like
more. Also, please check out our xAccount for daily content like this and consider becoming a member
of our channel to support our work. Catch you next time!
