Buddhist Cosmology (8): Mara

BUDDHISM • Beliefs • Life
6 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 14, 2025
Part 8 in a continuing series on Buddhist Cosmology. In dialogue: Ajahn Sona and Ajahn Punnadhammo.
Mara, one of the most famous characters in Buddhist cosmology, a major function in the
Buddhist universe, an opposing force to Dhamma, and keeps reappearing famously throughout the suttas.
So we decided we would explore the function and nature of Mara today.
Of course, perhaps the most famous episode is the beginning episode on the night of the Buddha's
awakening. Yes, and this has come down to us in various versions, and later times
received many literary treatments from everybody, from Joseph Campbell to Thich Nhat Hanh.
The version that's found in the commentaries to the Pali suttas is an early version, very well
fleshed out, is that the Buddha was sitting on the Bodhi seat, the Bodhimanda, which is an
important spot. Cosmologically, all the Buddhas become enlightened on the same spot.
And devas from 10,000 world systems had assembled, and this is a moment of great expectation.
And then Mara, realizing that his dominion was about to be threatened,
appeared with his army, a great host of lesser deities. Sometimes they use the plural Maras,
Mara's company, assuming various ferocious demonic forms. And Mara threw all kinds of
attacks against the Buddha, like showers of hot coals that turned into lotus petals and fell
harmlessly around him, one thing after another. And one detail that's important is that the devas
fled. They ran away, including Mahabrahma. The lesser devas, including Saka, they ran headlong
to the edge of the world system. Mahabrahma went up to the peak of Mount Sinai and planted his
parasol before he left. So he still ran away, but not quite as headlong.
I think this is significant because the devas are not fleeing so much out of cowardice, but
because they recognize the superior position of Mara as overlord of the whole sensuality realm,
and they're subject to the realm of sensuality. Mahabrahma still has some concern with Mara.
He's not completely beyond Mara's power, but it's attenuated. So he's able to make a gesture
of defiance before he runs away. So the Buddha was left alone facing this horde of demonic beings.
Mara realized that no matter what they did, he was unable to shake the Buddha. So he challenged
them and said, you have no right to be here. This earth is mine. This realm is mine.
And the Buddha said, I have earned the right to be here by my perfection of the paramis.
And in my last human birth, the vasantara birth, I perfected the parami of generosity.
And Mara said, so have I. And I call this host to witness. And all his lackeys and minions are,
yes, yes, we have seen it, we have seen it. And the Buddha said, I have no living witness,
because it was done long ago. But I shall call an unconscious witness. And he put his hand on
the earth. And this is a famous motif in art. You see many Buddhist statues with this mudra where
his right hand is touching the ground and his fingertips. This is the earth touching Buddha.
And the earth cried out in a loud voice like thunder. I have seen it. And this was the end
of Mara and Mara's assault. His host dissolved. They ran away in panic and fled in all directions,
dropping their weapons. And the Buddha was left entirely alone. He attained to full awakening.
Well, we should talk about where Mara resides as well. We've discussed this in other
cosmology videos, but the position of Mara is not in hell as Satan is. Talk about the
realm that Mara lives in. Mara is a very high level deity of the dewa, of the sensual desire
realm. He resides in the highest of the sensual heavens, Hari Nimitta Vasavata.
Hari Nimitta Vasavata. So just translate that. The realm of those who delight in the creation
of others. The lord of that realm is Vasavati. And Mara is said to not recognize his authority
and rules as an independent rebel prince in one quarter of that realm. So there's a division at
the very peak of the sensual desire realm. But Mara must, the being who became Mara,
must have made considerable good karma to be reborn in such a high station.
Yes, this is the interesting thing. This is an interesting detail.
We should also point out that like Saka or Vasavati or any of these other
high level devas, the name Mara is really more of an office than a proper name. Because there's
always a Mara. But because nothing is permanent in the Buddhist cosmos, he has a beginning and
an end. He will cease from that realm. But then some other being will become Mara.
Yes, it's really interesting that in order to be there, you've got to have a good stockpile of
merit, have done many good deeds. At the same time, be in opposition to, you just have to be
jealous of your realm and your power, you know, in opposition to the Buddha who is dismissing the
value really of Mara's realms. Yes, yeah. Well, it shows both the power
and the limitation of meritorious karma alone. He is a being who has made sufficient meritorious
karma to be born as a high level deva, but he does not have any impulse to renunciation or to
seeking anything higher than the sensual desire realm.
Yeah. So Mara is functioning in various people's lives who are
aspiring to the spiritual path as well. So the Buddha is not the only opponent or victim of Mara.
And one would, the spiritual practitioner would encounter Mara in certain ways. Mara,
are there various forms of Mara? Yes. Well, he can, like any of the higher
devas, he has the power to change shape and appearance, and he'll come and appear to beings
in various forms. There's a whole series of suttas in the Samyutta where he encounters
bhikkhunis practicing in the Andhawana, the blind man's grove, some spooky forest.
And in several of them, he takes the form of a handsome youth and tries to seduce them.
And it always ends the same way where the bhikkhuni rejects the Mara and says,
I know you, Mara, in this formula. Once Mara is known, his trickery is punctured,
then he has no power. So this is always the formula that, you know, when he fails in his
attempt, the person says, I know you, Mara. He also appears in some cases as an old brahman
to give bad advice, like he shows up amongst the bhikkhunis and he tells them,
you're all still young and black of hair. When you're old like me, you'll regret having wasted
your life not seeking pleasures. Yes, Mara is still around, isn't he?
Yes. He's speaking all the time.
Yeah, yeah. I mean, all these kind of blandishments of Mara we can recognize
in our own cases in modern times.
Mara is sometimes said to be like the five khandas is when the body itself is a
attempt to prevent you from moving forward and its demand for catering to its needs.
Yes. The body itself.
Yeah. The name Mara means death.
Aha. So it's identical with death. Very interesting.
So, of course, the body is subject to death. So the whole sensual desire realm is
impermanent and subject to death. This is Mara as leading beings to their destruction.
Yeah. So let's talk some of the encounters of monks and lay people with Mara.
One of the famous encounters is with Mughalana, one of the two chief disciples,
and foremost in psychic powers, and in Arhat. He has an encounter with Mara.
Yes. That's a very fascinating account. The first indication that Mughalana had
that Mara was around was he had a bellyache, and he said,
why does my belly feel like this? It feels like it's full of beans.
And then he uses his psychic power to investigate, and Mara is sitting inside his stomach.
So he admonishes Mara, you're making bad karma for yourself, plaguing the Arhats.
And Mara leaves and stands in the doorway, invisible, but Mughalana is still able to
see him. He says, I know you're there, Mara. I know you're still there. And he says,
you should be careful, because I know, because in a previous age, I was the Mara.
During the reign of the time of Kakosanna Buddha, you know, eons ago, Mughalana had been
the Mara Dusi, was his given name. And it's a curious detail. It said that he had a sister
named Kali, and that the current Mara was Kali's son at that time. So he was his nephew,
was Dusi's nephew. So I don't know for sure if there's any connection with the Kali as she
appeared in later Hindu mythology. Kali as the destroyer, isn't it? Like this Kali Yuga.
Yes, yeah, this very dangerous black goddess, people would do human sacrifices to.
It's not clear whether there's a connection, but it's quite likely that there was.
In any case, when he was, when Mughalana was Mara Dusi, he plagued the bhikkhus of
Kakosanna's dispensation. And he entered the minds of the villagers when they went,
when the bhikkhus went in for alms round. And he had them scold and revile and curse the bhikkhus
as they came into the town, you know, abuse them. Kakosanna taught his bhikkhus to practice
loving kindness meditation, so that this had no effect on them. So Mara was frustrated. So the
next time he tried something different, he again occupied the minds of the villagers and he had
them lavish praise, excessive praise and homage on the bhikkhus to try and turn their minds to
self-aggrandizement. And Kakosanna had the bhikkhus practice meditation on the repulsiveness
of the body. Again, it didn't work. And his final encounter was as Buddha Kakosanna was leaving the
village, followed by his chief disciple Vidura, the Mara Dusi, taking the form of a village boy,
threw a stone that hit the elder disciple in the back of the head and caused him to bleed.
And the Buddha turned around and said, now, Mara, you have gone too far. And at that instant,
because of that very bad kamma, he died instantly. The Mara died instantly and reappeared in the Raya
hell. And as Moggallana is recounting this to the current Mara, he says, I spent a very long time in
that hell realm. I had the body with the head of a fish, and the demons thrust spears into my body,
and they told me, when the spears meet in the middle of your body, you'll know a thousand
years have passed. So he said, you should be careful, Mara.
Yeah, that's an interesting power tactic, actually, is that whatever attempts to impede
the spiritual path, also there's risks involved in that. And one doesn't say that one is not always
the helpless prey of temptation and Mara and fear, but also those agencies which
attempt to impede practice also have resultants. So one can say, Mara, bad karma.
Nice details of that story. And I think that it's refreshing also for
people who are practicing to realize that Moggallana was Mara. No matter what you've done
over time, this is the vast time frame of the Dhamma and Buddhism. We tend to be in the West
in narrow, short time frames. But we realize that somewhere in the universe, we've been there,
done that, and all kinds of things. So not to despair, thinking that some event in this life
is kind of an impediment to enlightenment. You may have done great harm and great good
in the past, you just can't remember. But you should not think of these things as
great impediments to the progress on the path. The time frame is very, very opening for
the West. Often in the Sri Lankan community, a layperson, especially giving a bit of a talk,
will start with, in our long journey in samsara, in our long journey, it's kind of
spacious and open. It's a long journey sometimes. And I think it's actually very important to think
in those terms, to think in terms of multiple lifetimes. To narrow your view down to a single
lifetime, then it puts a wrong perspective on things. Looking back over a person's life,
when they're looking back from 50 or 60 years old, and thinking how panicked and
obsessed with time they were when they were 21, something didn't get done in a week,
it was the end of the world, and so forth. And if they could go back and give advice to that
20-year-old, they would say, just chill, just relax. There's lots of time and lots of space,
and it's a different atmosphere. So in the Buddhist view, it's even more expanded.
So are there any other pertinent areas for the exploration of Mara?
Well, another of his repertoire of weapons is inducing false view.
There's one story where there's a lay follower of the Buddha named Sarambhata,
who, after hearing a discourse from the Buddha, he went back to his home, and Mara thought,
this fellow's getting a little bit too close for comfort to escaping my snares, so he tried to
trick him. He assumed the form of the Buddha and knocked on the fellow's door. And when the
fellow answered the door, he said, I had to come and see you because I'm sorry I made a mistake.
I taught you that all the five aggregates are impermanent, but actually one of them is stable
and lasting. As frequently professed in some religious views, yes.
So Sarambhata was not fooled by this. He thought to himself, this cannot be the Buddha. Buddhas
are always confident in their teachings. They don't make such mistakes. He said, I know you,
Mara. He disarmed Mara. The attack was over. So I noticed in the story of the villagers
that Mara possessed their mind in some way, that seems to be able to take over
their volition in some ways. Yes, although it's not a total loss of
self to Mara, because it's added in that story that the villagers who reviled the bhikkhus
were reborn in hell, and the villagers who praised the bhikkhus were reborn in heaven.
So karma can only be made by oneself. It takes volition. So it's not a total possession. It's
more like an influence. And there's also an incident towards the end of the Buddha's life,
when Ananda failed to ask the Buddha to prolong his life. And it said that Mara possessed his
mind. And then the commentary discusses this, because Ananda was already a sotapanna, that
Mara can only influence someone like Ananda, a sotapanna, at the level of perception,
but not at the level of view. An unenlightened person, a patujana, can be possessed at the level
of view. So he can twist their understanding. But what the commentary says he did to Ananda was to
cause his mind to conjure up a frightful vision, so he became confused and didn't properly
understand what the Buddha was saying. So he was more or less distracted at the time.
Yes, distracted him. Yeah. And failed to
ask the pertinent question to live on for the body. Yeah, the age. Yes.
So, yeah, this is very interesting that, you know, the core teaching of the Buddha is that
evil is done by oneself, also the good. No one else purifies the mind.
And so, but at the same time, there's obvious influence. So this is kind of like,
in many cases, well, even in the Second World War, this idea that you're only following orders.
Yes. Does not get you off the moral hook.
Right. The fact that you follow the orders is
yes, there were strong persuasions, but others refused to follow the orders.
Yes. So we're constantly in this, in life, sometimes we're, we seem to be pulled by
circumstances. This happens in riots and big public events to the power of the crowd, you know.
Yeah. And, of course,
in elections and so forth, it's an attempt to appeal to that element of the mind,
but you're still responsible for your decisions and who you vote for, etc.
It's a very useful teachings and puts the responsibility squarely back on the individual.
Another set of characters that's interesting is Mara's daughters.
He has three daughters, Tadha, Raga, and Arati. Passion, desire, and discontent.
And after the Buddha's awakening, Mara followed him around for a period of time.
And it's a little bit obscure. There's kind of different ways of interpreting it,
but it's either for one year or for six years. He followed the Buddha around after his enlightenment,
looking for a flaw and not finding anything. And he gave up for the time being, and it says he was
sitting dejected by the side of the road, drawing lines in the dust with a stick. So, you know,
this great powerful Deva reduced to this sort of pathetic figure. And his daughters come along
and say, what's the matter, Tadha? Like, Daddy, what's the matter, Daddy? He says,
I can't find a single flaw in this Gautama. He's just beyond my power. And the daughters say,
leave it to us. No man can resist our charms. So, they appear before the Buddha and they said,
beauty is beyond human comprehension. No man could resist. And they offered to be his handmaidens,
and he didn't even raise his eyes. So, they assumed all kinds of various forms. They said,
well, some men like really young girls, some like women of middling age, some like older women.
They assumed always different forms. Nothing could tempt the Buddha. So, they too gave up
in despair. And they went back to Mara, and Mara berated them. You foolish, foolish girls. What
did you think you did? It's like trying to topple Mount Sinuru with your fingernails.
It's like trying to cleave an iron pillar with your breasts. So, they had to give up as well.
What's interesting is that after the Buddha's enlightenment, he is free of all delusion.
Mara seems to appear to him, I think it's 16 times or something like that. You get the
interaction of Mara with the Buddha. And so, the idea that Mara is exclusively a psychological
aspect, that Mara is really your own internal desires and so forth, doesn't seem to
make sense. If the Buddha is free, not only of the temporary hindrances, but also of the very
roots of these things, how would he be encountering elements of his own mind as temptation and so
forth. In all of these, he's shown to be quite immune from any of these things. But he's still
meeting Mara from time to time. And the Arahants are also meeting Mara. So, it really
means that they did not think that we're just telling, psychologizing a story. There's some
function in reality, externally to the mind, that plays this role. And this is so that we don't go
too far with the psychologizing. We still have this encounter from enlightened beings. Now,
some would say, well, they must have little things left over. But it's very clear that they're not
supposed to have anything left over. The commentary is quite aware of this issue
and distinguishes between different forms of Mara, different usages of the word, you should say.
There's Mara as defilement, there's Mara as Khandas, and there's Mara as Dewaputa,
meaning the being. And the encounters of the Buddha and the Arahants with Mara was with an
entity, with a separate being. Yes.
But you can use it almost metaphorically, just for defilements arising in your mind,
you can consider them to be Mara. Yes. And the body is Mara as well.
Yes. The mind can be Mara. There are aspects of the mind that are playing tricks on itself.
The body itself has an element of problematic element to it. In fact, the discourse is
destined for death as well. But there is this either external element, which I like people
from the West who are understanding these things as stories and psychologies. To understand, yes,
they are stories and psychologies, but there is another element to this. It's uncanny. I think
most monks have encountered Mara in certain ways that it's not simply a projection of the mind.
The situation, it's uncanny, the elements of these things.
And as you say, the Buddha is perfected so that there's no trace of these defilements left.
And Mara keeps attempting this fruitless task. He keeps coming back and trying again and again.
At one point, the Buddha says to him, you're like a fly buzzing around a bowl of hot porridge.
You can't possibly land on it. And it gets to be what, at the very end of the Buddha's life,
Mara's last temptation to the Buddha is, okay, now you've done everything you need to do. Why
don't you just enter Parinibbana and leave this earthly realm? The Buddha says, enough, Mara,
enough. When I finish my last teachings at the end of this rains retreat, I shall enter Parinibbana.
And you get a sense in these last encounters that the Buddha and Mara are almost at this
point like old buddies. They've known each other so long. The Buddha's given them, okay,
I was going to enter Parinibbana at the end of the rains. That'll make you happy.
It is, of course, parallel in the Christian encounter of Christ and Lucifer or Satan,
this kind of temptation.
In the desert.
Even in the desert and then at crucifixion and all these things. So either it's a universal
experience or there was some sort of influence in the stories of Christ's temptations that
possibly Buddhist stories have drifted across. They had 500 years to drift through the pilgrimage
trails, the merchant trails, and with the Greek influence as well.
There's an interesting parallel with Christ's temptations in the desert with Satan.
And he says, get thee behind me, Satan.
Yes.
No, it's like, I know you, Mara.
Yeah.
And the three temptations correspond to the three forms of tanha, three forms of craving.
First, he uses sensual desire because Christ is fasting in the desert.
So he says he creates bread out of rocks and says you can eat your fill.
Then the second temptation is like the desire for becoming.
He says, if you follow me, I shall make you king of the world.
You can rule the whole world.
The third temptation is not being, the temptation of unbecoming.
He tempts Christ to make an end of it and throw himself off the cliff.
Yes.
You seem to know all the stories, don't you?
I had vague memories of this thing, but you seem to be able to put your finger on all these.
So when you were reading these, you know, reading about Mara and researching Mara,
did these associations come up or did you go back and sort of compare or what?
No, because I don't think in general that Satan is a good parallel from Mara because
Satan has fallen from a high realm and he's in hell and he's intrinsically evil.
Mara is not so much evil as just full of self-aggrandizement and
afraid that beings are going to escape from his
snares, which is the sense-desire realm.
He imagines himself as the overlord of the whole realm of sensuality.
It terrifies him to see someone escaping that.
Yeah, and I often think of him as a Madison Avenue advertising executive
or some sort of corporate boardroom kind of thing that wants to keep customers
and will pretty well do anything to do that.
They don't perhaps even know.
Quite often people who are in those fields are asked,
why are you so strongly motivated?
And they don't know, but there's a certain identity investment in keeping people who
either appreciate them or admire them or refer to them with gratitude or something like that.
There's a final story that comes from a late source, the Asoka Wadana Sanskrit
account of the life of King Asoka.
That could be considered to be the end of the Mara of the Buddhist time.
The great Arahant monk of the day was Upagupta, and Mara wanted to disrupt his teachings.
So when Upagupta gave a speech in public before a large assembly,
Mara showered the crowd with pearls.
So everyone started scrambling to get the pearls, and they lost interest in the Dhamma talk.
And the second time was gold coins.
And then a third time, it was dancing girls in the sky.
It's anything to distract the crowd from listening to the Dhamma.
And then Mara, as a kind of a mocking gesture,
he approached Upagupta and threw a garland of flowers over him.
And Upagupta took the flowers off and threw them over Mara's neck.
And when he did that, they changed into rotting corpses of men and dogs and other animals.
It was a foul, disgusting thing, and Mara couldn't take it off.
And he left, he fled away, and he went to all these various devas,
to Saka, and to Asawana, and to all these other devas,
and asked them to help him get this off.
And they said, we can't get it off.
You'll have to go and make amends to Upagupta.
He's the only one who can take it off.
So he went back to earth, and he paid homage to Upagupta,
and declared himself now to be a follower of the Buddha.
So Upagupta caused the foul garland to disappear.
And then Mara asked him, is there anything I can do for you now?
And Upagupta said, well, there's one thing you can do that I would very much like.
I know that in the Buddha's time, once you assume the form of the Buddha to trick someone,
and I have lived my entire life following the teachings of the Buddha,
and I know his Dhamma body, but I don't know his physical body.
And I would very much like to see the Buddha,
if you could transform yourself into the appearance of the Buddha.
And Mara said, I'll do it on one condition, that you don't bow before me.
Because if you bow, it's such an unworthy thing for Arhat to bow to,
such as I, that it might kill me.
So Upagupta said he wouldn't.
But then when he changed into the Buddha, with his 32 marks and radiance,
Upagupta was overcome with reverence, he couldn't help himself, he bowed.
But Mara wasn't destroyed.
But this further encouraged his faith in the Buddha, Dhamma Sangha.
And he then went around the town ringing bells and crying out,
everyone should follow the Buddha's teaching.
Everyone should listen to Upagupta.
And so he became a devoted follower of the Buddha.
But my own loss on that, I would say,
that may be the end of the Mara of previous age,
but it's pretty certain that there's still a Mara,
because there's still all kinds of temptations in the world.
Yeah, Mara is an office in the universe,
which has a continuous need to refresh itself.
When Mara disappears, another arises.
One is always waiting in the wings.
One might almost compare it to presidential elections,
or things like that.
Or, you know, the king is dead, long live the king.
So there's a continuous succession of these.
So they're very, very familiar in that time with this idea of succession.
And we are as well.
Somebody's got to fill these offices.
It's the same with the other deities, like Sakka.
That Sakka has a certain lifespan,
and then when he passes away, another Sakka arises.
And there's a story where the Sakka goes to see the Buddha
because he knows he's near the end of his lifespan.
And they have a very deep conversation on Dhamma.
And then during their talk, towards the end of the talk,
Sakka dies.
And because of the karma he's made by becoming a follower of the Buddha,
he's instantly reborn as the new Sakka.
And this whole company of devas,
the only ones who realize that it happened,
is Sakka himself and the Buddha.
So it is possible to be reelected.
Yes.
Well, on that note, we will end our discussion on Mara
with the re-election of Sakka.
