Buddhist Cosmology (7): Brahma Realms

BUDDHISM • Beliefs • Life
6 followers
1 Video View·Jan 14, 2025
Part 7 in a continuing series on Buddhist Cosmology. In dialogue: Ajahn Sona and Ajahn Punnadhammo.
We're climbing into the exalted realms of consciousness.
These are realms of the Brahma, Devas.
And consciousness here is very refined
and significantly different than the sensuous heavens.
So these, and they're called the Brahma realms.
Brahma Viharas.
Now, Brahma Viharas are the contemplations of Metta and Guru and so on.
And so these are?
Brahmaloka.
Yes.
Yeah, so describe a little bit about them.
Well, the first principle to bear in mind is that this is an entirely different plane of consciousness.
That the Devas we discussed before, the sensuous Devas,
are actually closer in their nature of their being and their state of mind to us
than we are or they are to the Brahmas.
This is an entirely new plane of being.
And it's called the Rupa plane, the plane of form,
to distinguish it from yet another plane, the formless, which are mind-only beings.
The Brahmas do have bodies.
Sometimes you see in English, they're called the fine material plane.
That's a very loose translation, but it does have a point that they do have bodies,
but they're much more subtle.
It's a different sort of matter.
They're a very subtle form that is not visible even to the Devas,
unless they choose to manifest what's called a coarse body, a gross body.
They can choose to do that and then they can manifest to the Devas.
But normally they're invisible even to the Devas.
And they exist, the Brahmas exist, and there's quite an actually complicated hierarchy,
but it could be simplified to say there's four levels equivalent to the four Jhanas.
And their state of consciousness, their normal default mode of consciousness,
is equivalent to being in Jhana.
So it's a form of extended ecstasy.
Yes.
The ecstasy of Jhana.
Sometimes people understand Jhana as a kind of anesthetized kind of state,
but actually, at least in the first three Jhanas, there's a quality of joy.
And even the last, the fourth Jhana, with equanimity, is a very refined form of ease and joy.
So they're in a very heightened state of...
And the lifespans in that realm.
The lifespans are very, very long.
They're longer than, at least for the second and higher levels,
they're longer than an entire world age.
Yes.
They exist in a high plane where they can contemplate the worlds below,
the Chakrawalas, this world of humans and Devas.
They can contemplate thousands of them below them,
like a man holding sesame seeds in the palm of his hand.
So I like to make this point when I'm teaching about Samatha meditation,
that it's not a narrow little mind.
It's a vast, expansive mind,
like the mind of a Brahma that takes in thousands of world systems.
So it's closer to the Hubble telescope than it is to a laser pointer.
It's not a laser pointer.
It's the Hubble.
It's the vision of the universe through the Hubble telescope.
Yes.
Vast galaxies like dust in the sky.
Yeah.
Yeah, so very helpful because it tells you a little bit about the way...
If you're misdirected to a narrow-pointed kind of concentration to begin with,
you're looking for the wrong thing.
This is...
Maybe it's closer to what we call focusing a telescope,
like the lucidity and the focus,
rather than any kind of laser-like pointing.
Yeah, so the...
Descriptions of the Brahma realms, you were saying,
are helpful to the idea of Samatha meditation,
Samadhi or Jhana meditation,
that the very descriptions themselves kind of induce a sense of that cosmic ease.
Yes.
It's very good, you know, to be talked into it.
Yes.
I sat down in an uncomfortable room and said,
Concentrate.
Yeah.
So this is, for those who are watching,
who want to practice this Jhana meditation,
it might profit you to listen to descriptions
or read descriptions of the Brahma realms,
which are said to be the resultant of the practice of Jhana.
Another relevant point in that regard is that
entering into Jhana one is transcending
or leaving behind the sense sphere.
And this is the nature of the Brahmins,
that they are increasingly, as you advance through the Jhana realms,
they're increasingly divorced from our ordinary sense experience.
Even at the lowest level,
they don't have division into genders.
There's no male or female known there.
They're all just reckoned as beings.
So they don't have any sexuality.
And they don't eat ordinary food.
Even the Devas consume very refined Deva food.
But the Brahmins, Brahmas only feed internally on bliss.
They feed on bliss.
Yes, it's a bit disturbing to have to deal with food, isn't it?
Yes.
I think when people are really interested in something,
they will often forget to eat.
Also children, when they're engaged in play,
they really don't want to come in and eat.
Your mother's calling you,
but you just don't want to be bothered with food.
Yeah.
So it's interesting that food,
which is a sensuous pleasure,
but of course it's necessary,
Of course the other end is excretion.
Yeah, excretion.
So you don't want to be bothered with that
when you're in these divine ecstasies
that are lasting eons.
So the name Brahman or Brahma,
Brahmaloka,
is not invented by the Buddha.
It's not a new word,
but he redefines it in some way, doesn't he?
Yes.
It comes from a Sanskrit root
that was related to the verb to be
or to grow.
Baba?
Yeah, that's from the same root.
Like cultivate, to become.
Yes, yes.
There is in non-Buddhist usage,
there's a difference between Brahman,
which is neuter,
and Brahma, which is masculine,
representing Brahman was considered
not a being so much as a cosmic principle.
And Brahma was kind of like
the anthropomorphic manifestation of that,
the supreme being.
And we still see a trace of that
in the etymology of the word in Pali.
The word Brahma,
though it's a masculine noun,
it is declined with some neuter forms.
So it's kind of indeterminate
whether it's masculine or neuter.
So Brahma, he or it itself,
they're kind of advanced.
Christianity is sort of now saying
God and whatever she looks like,
that sort of thing,
or whatever it looks like.
So they're kind of ahead of the curve
with this not genderizing too much the Brahma.
And Brahma in the previous sort of periods,
the Vedic periods,
or the Upanishads perhaps,
is a deity.
And something like perhaps the Yawa,
Jehovah or whatever it is.
Yeah, well it's a bit later.
Brahma as an entity or as a being
does not appear anywhere in the Vedas.
It first appears in the Upanishads.
And it's difficult to know
historically at what point
it became considered the supreme being.
But it's very likely that was before the Buddha
because we have references within the Buddhist canon
of when non-Buddhists are either being addressed
or describing their own beliefs
that they seem to take Brahma as a supreme being
and as the creator.
Let's talk about the Buddhist
flipping of the universe
regarding Brahma
and the description of Brahma
that Brahma himself or itself
presumes to be the creator,
the creator god.
But Buddha begs to differ.
Yes, that's a very important
and significant insight
which is the Buddhist explanation
of how monotheism comes to be
as a belief system.
At the beginning of a new world system
as the world cycles through creation and destruction
at the beginning of a new world system
a Maha Brahma, a great Brahma will appear alone.
This is first Jhana level.
Brahma will appear alone in a palace
as the first being in that level.
And after some long period of time
by the force of their own karma
other beings will appear as lesser Brahmas
in his retinue.
And he has the belief
because he wished for company
he has the belief that he created them by his wish.
And they believe it when he tells them that.
So they worship him.
So he then has an increasingly large retinue
of these lesser Brahmas that worship him.
And he's the supreme being of that level.
And then he sees the earth
and the other realms lower than him
and he convinces himself he created them too.
He's the overlord of everything.
And then when one of these lesser Brahmas
lifespan expires and they die
from that realm they reappear on earth
and if they become an ascetic
and they have visions of their previous life
which they interpret as visions of heaven
and the supreme being
and then they teach that.
And there is the supreme being which created
all the beings.
Yes.
And it's just a basic mistake of memory.
Yeah.
And it's just sincere.
There's no attempt to deceive.
The Brahma has deduced this.
And in some ways Buddhism has some doubt
about the validity of reasoning processes
and deductions because you can just be wrong.
Yes.
The assumptions that are made.
Yeah.
The whole history of Western thought
and even in science of course
that we keep making wrong assumptions
and we develop theories
out of these wrong basic assumptions.
There was presumed to be a kind of medium
which light traveled through
which physicists assumed to be there
and worked with it and then it was discovered
that there is no such thing
and it's not necessary to provide it.
And at its time it was not an unreasonable view.
It was based on actual reasoning from evidence.
Yes.
And you were once telling a story about the
I think it was the French Academy
that was trying to estimate
how long the sun would last.
Oh yeah.
And they had based it on the idea
that the sun was a lump of coal burning
and it would burn for a certain length of time.
So they probably had it correct
that if it was coal it would burn.
They knew of no other hotter fire than coal.
Yes.
But the actual calculations would be off
by exponential factors.
Yes.
And this caused in the 19th century
this caused a split between the geologists
and the astrophysicists
because the astrophysicists had this idea
the universe can only last so many hundreds
of thousands of years
and the geologists were saying
well we have rocks that are hundreds of millions of years old.
Yes.
That comes up in Buddhism
and is that you can just be wildly wrong
and science almost is proud of the fact
that yes of course we're wrong all the time
but we are allowed to correct it.
Well that's very nice
but it's not very comforting to be wrong
and not know it
and to presume and base
a lot of very important decisions
on wrong information.
Yes.
And the idea that it's a self-correcting system
may be wonderfully
may be proud
scientists are proud of that
but this life is going by
and we have to make some very important existential choices
and it could be based on wrong deduction.
Yes.
So there is a story of the Buddha
going to meet with one of these Brahmins
Baka
because the Buddha had
because he had with his Buddha knowledge
he had memory of all his past lives
he had a deep personal connection with this Brahmin
this Brahma
when they were both humans
aeons ago
and the Buddha had actually been at one point
the student of this Brahma
in his human form
when he was a great ascetic
and he had attained with his ascetic power
the ability to be reborn
he had deep mastery of fourth jhana
and he was reborn in the highest Brahma world
and as aeons of time went by
he fell from that
down to
eventually to the first level Brahma world
and he was the first one to appear
in the cycle
just as explained before
and the Buddha saw that he'd fall into this delusion
so he wanted to help correct his view
so he went up to that realm
and there's some comic touches in the story
when the Buddha appears in that realm
this Brahma's disciples
it says that their mind was occupied by Mara
and so they challenged the Buddha
and they said you should bow
Samana
you should bow before this great lord
or you will be reborn
in a stunted, dwarfish form
as punishment
you have to show respect to this lord
and Baka himself then
lists out his epithets
I am Baka
I am the Maha Brahma
I am the overlord
I am the creator
I am the all victorious
it's like I am the great and mighty Oz
don't look behind the curtain
and the Buddha of course is like
be that as it may
and he starts
and he tells the Brahma
you are not supreme in the universe
there are these other levels above you
that you know nothing of
the Brahma's not at first convinced
and there's some argument
and then Baka, the Brahma
challenges the Buddha
to see who is the more powerful
I can disappear from your sight
you can't disappear from mine
and of course
the Brahma cannot disappear from the Buddha
but the Buddha can disappear from his sight
simply by transferring himself up to the second jhana level
which this one has no conception of
the commentary
goes into
that's from the sutta
and in the commentary
goes into a little more detail
of how the Brahma tried to disappear
he says at first he
reverted to his natural state
rather than have assumed
like a created body
that a human could see
his natural state
the Buddha could still see him
then he created a great pall of darkness
and the Buddha
dispersed that
with a brilliant light
and finally in despair
he ran from his palace
and hid behind a tree
and his followers all
mocked him
is that you great Brahma
squatting behind a tree
and this is really about
levels of knowledge isn't it
that higher levels of knowledge
are just
not known to
one until
you
that realm is open to you
so
we learn
addition and subtraction
but we don't know multiplication
then we learn multiplication
but we don't know algebra
and we don't know trigonometry
we don't know calculus
and these realms
how they would calculate these things would be
just hidden knowledge
but the lower knowledges would be
obvious to one who has higher knowledges
yes
so this is
this happens again in the history of science
you have
Lord Kelvin
the
which he gives his name to
the scale of
temperature scale
he's the foremost
physicist
about the age of the earth
and he's got it somewhere in the 20 million
range
and this is in the early 1900s
and then
they start to see that
the
the process of
nuclear decay
and they realize that
the earth is probably between 2 and 3 billion years old
and
a young physicist
has to go to the conference
Kelvin is 90 years old by that time
the most esteemed physicist
and he's sitting in the front row
and this
physicist
who's 25
has to get up and say
that the age of the earth now
is about
probably between 2 and 3 billion years old
and
Lord Kelvin is
sitting there at 90
the most esteemed physicist in the world
smiling benignly at the ignorance of this
upstart
so it jumped
exponential factors
just like that
and of course that didn't
you know I've
discovered that the
sort of last best estimate of the age of the earth
was somewhere around 2005
the year 2005
something like 4.38 billion years
but they really needed
material from the moon in order to really
pin it down but
just in the last decade or so
we've kind of
narrowed it to
that recent
so these are forms of knowledge
and lack of knowledge
and the Buddha is
is
trying to inform
the society and the structures of the time
about this much more expanded
universe that people
a universe within consciousness
so talk about a little relationship between
how do these Brahma
how do the Brahmas arise
what is the cause in the
in the Buddhist
explanation
what is the cause of this
well the
on a personal level
the
entry into the Brahma realm is Jhana
one who has the mastery of Jhana can be
reborn into the Brahma realm
on a
cosmological level
the
it represents a
plane of existence
higher than the central sphere
and when the worlds are
world systems are destroyed
and new ones arise
the Brahma realms are the last to go
and the first to appear
and there's a
there's a very complex
cycling
there's
the world is
can be destroyed by fire
water
or
wind
and
destruction by fire destroys everything up to the
first Brahma level
and that happens
15 times
and then
on the 16th time
destruction is by
by water
and that destroys everything up to the second Jhana level
and then there's
15 of those cycles
you know with
fire and
and water
then
on the 64th time there's destruction by wind
that destroys everything up to the third Jhana level
and there's a relation of that to the Jhanas
that
in
one
ancient text
makes
makes explicit
that
destruction by fire is like
thought
and
thought
ceases at first Jhana level
that's the last level in which there's any thought
formation
water is like
peaking
rapture
and that
that reaches up to the second Jhana level
that's the last place that occurs
and then
wind is like breath
and breath is supposed to cease altogether at fourth Jhana
so the last place it occurs is in the
it's very
very clever
I mean
I come across these
explanations and it's just
marvelous how they work these things out
yeah
yes
yeah
and but of course
I mean the basic
is that
the
the cause of
appearing in these
Brahma realms is
is
Jhana itself
yes
so they're not
they're not simply spontaneous
they're not
appearing out of nowhere
or not created by a
a deity
no they're reborn
they're
they're born there
beings that were reborn into that realm
right
usually from the human realm
having attained to Jhana
yes
so that
that makes a
a very distinct
and clear causal link
between these realms
and human consciousness
yeah
and the
the
first Jhana level
is
the only one
where we have
names of individual
Brahmas
and stories about them
and there's
you know
several
stories
that involve
Brahmas
like
Brahma Sahampati
coming to see the Buddha
and
urging him to teach
these are all
first
Jhana level
Brahmas
because
thought formation
only exists
up to first Jhana
so the second
third and fourth
Jhana
Brahmas
we don't have
have
we don't distinguish them
as individuals
they have no stories
about them
doing anything
because they're just
blissed out all the time
right
there's not
there's not a
activity
discursive activity
going on
they're just in a
state of suspended bliss
yes
let's go to the
this realm of
the
of
non-perception
the Sanya
Sanya Satha realm
yeah
this is a curious
corner
of the cosmos
it's
in the
mapping
of the cosmos
it's put in
the
level
with the
fourth Jhana
means
but it isn't
really
fourth Jhana
it
it's said
to be
heretics
or
non-Buddhists
that
meditators
who
came to the
conclusion
that consciousness
and perception
are the cause
of all suffering
and we should
eliminate that
factors
those factors
so they develop
a kind of
self-anesthetic
you know
in their
meditation
and they're
reborn into
this realm
where they
appear
from the
outside
as
beautiful statues
sitting in
chairs
and they
persist for
hundreds of
kappas of
time
without a
single
moment of
consciousness
and the
first time
consciousness
arises they
cease to
exist in
that realm
when they
appear
some lower
realm
right so
they
theoretically
or objectively
have been
existing for
this enormous
length of
time but
there's no
experience of
it no
so the
last moment
of the
previous life
and the
first moment
of this
life are
next to
each other
yes and
that's actually
discussed in
the commentary
it's an
interesting
reflection on
the nature
of time
and the
nature of
consciousness
it says
how because
the in
the ordinary
run of
things each
moment of
consciousness is
a proximity
cause for
the following
moment so
that it can
be visualized
like falling
dominoes one
consciousness
arises and
then the
next immediately
after but
how could there
exist a
continuity of
consciousness with
a gap of
500 kappas of
time and
it said that
the gap of
time is
irrelevant the
continuity is
unbroken and
it's it's
like the
implication is
that there's a
continuity of
moments in the
outer universe and
there's a
continuity of
moments of
consciousness and
they're normally
more or less
synced but it's
possible for the
continuity to
continue even
with this
external break
i know i
remember the i
think was the
uh
analogy they
made was a
hunter is
tracking a
deer through the
forest and he
follows the
footsteps and
then there's a
large space of
rock where the
footprints disappear
and he walks
across the
rock and he
looks on the
far edge and
he finds the
footprints appear
so that this
although the
footprints disappear
on this end and
they appear on
that end he
he does not
presume that there
was no existence
of the deer
between the
two so that
very apt yeah
i think a good
modern analog for
this state is
general anesthesia
if anyone has
had a surgical
procedure with
general anesthesia
they know and
understand this
you get
they
mask with the
gas on your
face and
tell you to
count to ten
backwards and
you go ten
nine eight
seven and
then you open
your eyes and
you're in the
recovery room
and it's a
quite different
experience from
deep sleep because
when you're asleep
no matter how
deeply you sleep
or how long
when you wake
up there's a
sense of time
having passed
even though you
don't remember
any of it there's
a sense of time
having passed but
that's completely
gone with general
anesthesia it's
like the moment
in the operating
room is followed
by the moment
in the recovery
room yeah yeah
and then you
ask when does
the operation
take place
oh that's
all over
dear
would you
like some
ice cream
yeah
so any
other
corners of the
brahma realm
that you'd like
to talk about
uh well we
should mention
the um
the higher
brahma levels
because this
is also
contemplating
the details of
these higher
brahma levels
is also very
informative for
one trying to
develop jhanas
the comparison
between the
different levels
already mentioned
that there's no
thought formation
in first jhana
now it's said
that the most
beautiful sight
in the universe
is a
maha brahma
sitting in his
palace and
then the second
jhana level is
equivalent to
second jhana and
it's said the
most beautiful
sound in the
universe is
heard in this
level because
the brahmas are
all the time
crying out
ah ho
sukho
oh the
bliss
oh the bliss
they're
overwhelmed
with the
sukha
and the
pity and
sukha
and pity is
very thrilling
and exciting
and it's said
that their
their radiance
flickers like a
torch
and then the
third jhana level
is said to be
the greatest
happiness in
the universe
but it's silent
because they are
experiencing only
bliss without
rapture
sukha only
so it's a more
peaceful oceanic
kind of experience
without the
thrilling aspect
so their
radiance is said
to be steady
like the light
of the moon
it doesn't
flicker like a
torch
and the
fourth
brahma level
is the
level
of great
fruit
wehapala
level
where
equanimity
is the
dominant
factor
so they are
in a state
of profound
peace
and their
realm is
not
destroyed
at the end
of the
universe
and this gets
discussed too
and in one
of the
texts
one of the
later texts
says
asking the
question
does this
violate the
law of
impermanence
and it
said no
it isn't
because
it's only by
a convention
that we
even consider
it a realm
it's not a
place
it's like
each individual
brahma
existing there
is
you know
his own
entity
it's not
the other
the lower
realms
there's like
a structure
like they
have a
ground
a jeweled
plane
so a
jeweled
plane
and they
have dwelling
places
we have
pala
brahmas
in a
state of
individual
seclusion
and bliss
the
boundaries
of the
body
are kind
of vague
there's no
real sense
of a
body
or a
place
for a
body
yes
and this
is parallel
to what
we discussed
before with
the sensual
realm
sensuality
becomes
increasingly
subtleized
and then
you make
the leap
into the
non sensual
level
of the
brahmas
likewise
in the
brahma
realms
the
physical
form
is
increasingly
subtleized
and then
the level
beyond
the
fourth
um
fourth
jhana level
is the
realm of
the
formless
where they
have no
bodies at
all
mind only
right
so you
see this
beautiful
orderliness
and symmetry
and
exquisite
uh
exquisitely
beautiful
thought
processes
to shape
this
gradual
transition
up the
scale of
sensuous
happiness
subtle
sophisticated
profound
right off
the end
into
the
rupa
jhanas
and
uh
brahma
lokas
and this
the body
becoming
fading
and the
also the
quality
from joy
fading
into
equanimity
and then it
just goes
right off
the scale
into these
these
uh rupa
levels
there's also
one more
uh for
we should
mention for
sake of
completion
there's one
more like
slot in
there
is the
sudawasas
the um
uh
pure lands
the pure
was where
anagamis
go
yes
uh which is
also
technically
classed in the
fourth jhana
level and
these are the
the
at the very
summit of
corporeal
existence
there's nothing
so the highest
one is called
akhanita
which is
like the
summit
peak
it's like
the peak
of the
whole
universe
um
these
ananagami
is one who
has attained
to the
third level
of awakening
so they've
uh overcome
the lower
fetters but
they still
have the
subtle desire
for becoming
so having
destroyed the
uh root
of sensual
desire
there's impossible
for them to
be reborn
in the
sensual desire
realm anymore
there's no
energy there
for that to
occur
but they still
have the
desire to
be
so they have
to appear
somewhere
and there's
these um
five levels
of
the pure
abodes
where they
exist in
a state of
great subtlety
and happiness
until they
become arhants
and cease to
be reborn
altogether
yeah
what a
journey
through the
world
that's
the
rather brief
um
description
of these
immense
stations of
consciousness
and
their
manifestations
as
uh
realms of
existence
and the
incredible
uh
descriptions
of these
in the
buddhist
suttas and
also in
the commentaries
so yes
we would
appreciate
that
the amount
of
study that
goes into
this and
the
articulation
of this
as well
