Buddhist Cosmology (2): Asura Realm

BUDDHISM • Beliefs • Life
6 followers
7 Video Views·Jan 14, 2025
Part 2 in a continuing series on Buddhist Cosmology.
In dialogue: Ajahn Sona and Ajahn Punnadhammo.
One of the most fascinating realms is the Asura realm and I really think that a lot of people can
learn from the Asura mentality because it's fairly common and it's a fascinating area
and we'll talk about this Asura realm. First of all, what is this word Asura?
Where does it come from? There's one mention in the commentaries of the derivation of the name.
The Asuras were thrown out of the Tawatingsa Heaven after getting drunk and they were thrown
down the side of the mountain and they regained consciousness halfway down the mountain as they
were tumbling down and they cried out,
Nasur Bawati, Nasur Bawati, meaning that we will not drink liquor, we will not drink liquor.
So it's kind of like the human beings that get drunk and get in trouble and the next day they're
all, I'm never going to drink again. Yeah, and they were drinking at the highest level, weren't
they? This was champagne of the highest quality. They're thrown out of aristocracy or the highest
realms of maybe intellectual and artistic capacities because where are they living
when they're thrown out? What are they thrown out of? Okay, well, we go back to the origin story of
the Asuras. They were the original inhabitants of Tawatingsa Heaven at the peak of Mount Cineru
and Saka and his 33 gods had been human beings who made much merit on the earth
doing various kind of building projects and things for the common good and then when they
died from a human birth they came to rebirth in Tawatingsa and the Asuras were the inhabitants
of Tawatingsa at the time, welcomed them and held a feast to honor them which included
copious quantities of this liquor that they brewed.
Is there any specific name for this liquor? Dibapana. Dibapana. Divine drink. Divine drink.
Now, I'm sure we're going to get a lot of speculation on what form of drug that is.
Well, it seems to have been alcohol basically. It may have been
extremely exquisite like you say like champagne, heavenly version of champagne
and Saka told his crew, don't drink any of this liquor. It'll make you heedless and the Asuras
drank and drank and drank until they passed out and lay snoring on the golden sands of Tawatingsa
and Saka said to his companions, pick them up by the heels and throw them down the mountain.
We shall not share heaven with such as these. And they were tossed down the mountain and they
came to rest at the root of the mountain under the ocean, which is a curious detail because
their existence in their Asura Bhavana, the realm of the Asuras, is not described as being
aquatic in any way. They weren't like mermen or anything like that. They were air-breathing
terrestrial sort of beings but they were under the ocean. So the way I come to interpret that
is that the surface of the sea acts as a kind of a magic gateway or passageway to enter their realm.
So they're in this Asura Bhavana at the bottom of Mount Sinuru and the Tawatingsa Devas are at the
top. And the two realms are kind of mirror images of each other. The Devas at the top of the mountain
are primarily sensual beings, so they're caught in sensuality. The Asura beings
are caught in the opposite defilements of ill-will, aversion, anger, jealousy.
So the Tawatingsa Devas looking down see the Asura Bhavana at the bottom as a kind of distorted
mirror image of themselves, a kind of funhouse version of the Tawatingsa gods.
And the Asura beings forget that they're not in heaven until their tree, there's a
world tree in each realm, a characteristic tree that lasts for the entire world age,
called the Kappa Ruka. Kappa is a world age. So Kappa is like an aeon, the entire duration
of a world system, and Ruka is a tree. It's very interesting that they have these beautiful
symbols. They use symbols so well, and each realm has a symbolic tree. And how many of these
trees are there, how many realms? There's seven. This is very good for memory as well, isn't it,
to help pin down the characteristic of each of these realms. Yes, there's one tree on each of
the world islands, and one in the realm of the four great kings, one in the Tawatingsa, and one
in Asura realm. What is the name of the one in the Asura realm? Chittapatali. Chittapatali.
The one in the Tawatingsa heaven is the Parichataka tree, and it's probably the most
famous, comes up the most in the stories, and it's very beautiful, blossoms. And for example,
when the Buddha entered Parinibbana, the Tawatingsa, they showered the site with blossoms.
Falling out of the heavens into the human realm. Yes. So when this tree comes into flower,
then the Asuras see their tree doesn't have the same beautiful flowers, and they realize they're
not in heaven anymore. And then they swarm up the sides of the mountain like ants up a pillar
to attack Tawatingsa and try and get back in. Right. So there's continual wars between the
Tawatingsa gods and the Asuras. The Tawatingsa heaven, we can say, is the highest realm in which
conflict occurs. Right. These battles between the Devas and the Asuras. It's so interesting,
just the psychological ramifications of this, the idea of having fallen out of a more divine
or a better state of existence. And every now and then you're reminded,
because your ordinary states of mind become the norm, but every now and then you remember
what it was like to be at a higher level of being. This happens a lot with drugs and alcohol
for people. And then they might go on a strict program to regain their former state of grace or
their elevated condition. And it seems though the motivation is wrong, that it's a motivation of
anger. What's happened to me, maybe they're angry at themselves, maybe they're angry at
the world, but you can't get it back through anger. Yes. Yeah. Yeah, they can never succeed,
they can never conquer heaven. It's an intrinsic... They always get beaten back.
Yeah, so it's an endless Groundhog Day kind of... Yes.
So this battle that they have, now they come up out of the sea, they pass through this magic
surface of the sea. Now, you were talking about, as we investigate what they mean by
under the ocean, it seems to be not underwater, but kind of through almost a mirror surface that
you step through the mirror. Yes. Almost Alice in Wonderland, you step through this mirror surface
into a different realm. I know in the Greek mythology, they often use the sea to represent
above this ocean is the conscious mind, and then the unconscious mind. They have
beings living and functioning in the unconscious world. So maybe the Asuras have fallen into a
certain level of unconsciousness as well, subconsciousness. Yes. Yeah, I think that's
a valid interpretation. And I think all these stories have multi levels of meaning.
And it's certainly one valid interpretation. We also find this similar story in
the idea of an older race of gods that were overthrown by the newcomers in Greek mythology,
and also in Norse mythology with the Asgard and the Storm Giants. And this is a common, I think,
Aryan heritage. All these pantheons have this story of the old gods
being overthrown. It's another level of meaning there. Yeah, there's a reference,
some sort of reference to an earlier innocent, perhaps, condition, which, of course, that's,
in North America, as alcohol came to North America, the natives did not handle it well.
And they tumbled out of heaven as well. Yes. Yeah. So let's go back to the Asuras' attempt to
regain heaven. Who are they fighting with? Who are they attempting to get back?
Well, they're fighting primarily with the Devas of Tawatingsa. But the Devas of Tawatingsa also
have allies in the realm of the Four Great Kings. Ah, they have allies. Yeah, well, they're the
vassals of the Tawatingsa gods. So they have lines of defense all up Mount Cineru that are
protected by Nagas, Supanas, Kumbandas, all these sorts of beings. And if the Asura gods get past
all these lines of defense, they get up to the gates of Tawatingsa, then the very last defense is
these statues of Saka in his form of Indra, the wrathful thunderbolt-wielding deity. And
when the Asuras see these statues, they become terrified and run back to their home.
So this explains maybe some of the statuary around Buddhist temples. You sometimes see a
Naga or a dragon as the... Yes, the idea of this is to keep
evil, malevolent beings away, frighten them away. Right. Yeah, it's very interesting that it's been
really embedded in the architecture of Buddhist structures. And somehow in European, you have
these gargoyles and so forth. You see them in monasteries, temples, cathedrals. It's amazing,
the universality of this. Do they manage to get past the realm of the four great kings sometimes?
Yes, yeah, they get it. And the relative strength of the Devas and the Asuras
is in a large degree controlled by what goes on here on the earth in the human realm. If humans
are keeping good morality, then when they die, relatively more of them are reborn in the Deva
realm, and the Deva host is increased. But if people on the earth are behaving immorally in a
heedless way, then more of them are reborn as Asuras. And the Asura army grows in strength,
and they experience victories in their battles. Similar to this Christian idea, as in heaven,
so on earth. So the Buddha also mentions that when people go to the monastery, take the eight
precepts for day and the night, that the strength in heaven, the population in heaven grows. And
why the Tavatimsa Devas notice the decrease in population is because people are not going to the
Buddhist monasteries, keeping the eight precepts. You must go, take the eight precepts,
because you do want to be in the Tavatimsa heaven, you don't want to be
an ex-Tavatimsa person thrown down into the realm of the faded glory.
So do they ever succeed in this battle? No, neither side can ever have a complete victory,
because it's said that the two cities of the two sides are impregnable. So the greatest victory
they can have is to get to the gates of the opposite city, but they can never overthrow it
or enter in. So it's a perpetual, endless conflict that can never be fully resolved.
This little reminds me a little bit like Athens and Sparta.
Yes.
And the Athenians are not harsh and militaristic, they're more egalitarian and artistic and
philosophical, they have democratic votes. But the Spartans, although they're just
always militaristic, they can't seem to take over Athens. It's an insight really into what it is
that makes a higher dwelling of existence. And one of them is the ability to cooperate and to
appreciate beauty. So they manage to get to the gates there. So what happens when the Asuras
get to the gates? Well, at the very end, they get frightened away by these statues of Inda.
They lose their nerve. Yes. They don't seem to be very brave,
actually. They're full of bravado and bluff. That's interesting as well.
There's also a story about one of the wars where Saka was coming down the side of the mountain to
attack the Asuras in his chariot, and they were passing over the Symboli Grove, which is the
grove of trees on the slopes of Siniru, where the Tsukanas that we talked about,
the giant bird creatures, live. And as he was flying over, he heard cries of distress,
and he asked his charioteer, Matali, where do these heartrending cries come from? And he said,
we're destroying the abodes of the Tsukanas with the passage of our chariot, and they're tumbling
into the sea. So Saka said, we can't destroy innocent beings for the sake of victory,
turn the chariot around. And when he turned the chariot around, the Asuras thought that
was some kind of maneuver, and he had reinforcements coming. In one version of the story,
they thought there were other Devas coming down from Tawatingsa, and in another version it says
Sakas from another world system are coming to aid him. And they lost their nerve and ran back to
their palace under the sea. Maybe it's a little lesson for military strategists,
the interpretation. Your enemy is always imagining that there's three levels of tactics deep,
and sometimes misunderstand the innocent moves. But it's interesting also that they're interested
in minimizing collateral damage, so they're not going to destroy the evil and have collateral
damage on the innocent. So this is a kind of an ethical standard that they
adhere to. That's a lesson also for the modern world. You see this in
even high-speed car chases and so forth. It's like, do we really need to do this?
Does this matter? Maybe we should just let them get away this time.
The Asuras didn't always keep that same morality. They were a rougher,
pruder sort of approach. There's another story about the Asuras in one of their passages
up the mountain on the shores of Siniru where it breaks the ocean. There are communities of
holy seers, Isis, or Rishis. The leader of one of these communities asked the Asuras for
protection or safety because they tend to just rampage through these villages and knock
everything down on their passage heedlessly. The king of the Asuras, who at that time his
name was Sambara, he said, no, we know you're partisans of Saka, so we're not going to spare
you. And so they cursed him. Later he woke up in the night screaming, and the other Asuras came
to see what was the matter. And he said, oh, nothing, nothing. He was trying to
minimize it, but he had pain in his head like a hundred spears were piercing him.
And then his name became Wepechiti, broken mind. After that he would have bouts of madness.
Very interesting mental health repercussions of this. And he is feeling the repercussions of
transgressing the sanctuaries of the Rishis. Yes. And it's kind of a bit of a warning about
holy people and sacred people and so forth, don't mess with them. It comes back to you in the form
of mental pain. So let's continue. Anything more about the Asuras that we have?
Well, the relationship between Wepechiti and Saka is an interesting one.
Because besides being enemies, they were also relatives. Saka had married the daughter of
Wepechiti. So what does that make him? His father-in-law? Brother-in-law?
Yeah. Wepechiti is Saka's father-in-law.
Yes, father-in-law. Yes, his father-in-law. So here we go with the family dynamics.
Yes, yeah. So sometimes they would travel about together in a friendly way in between the wars.
And sometimes they would be at war with one another.
Like Stalin and whoever it was, it was the American president at the time,
you know. Roosevelt. Yeah, they were, what do they call them? Odd bedfellows.
Yeah. You have to, real politics is that you have to deal with, sometimes you're in open
conflict, sometimes you have to fake friendship as well.
There's a great story about Saka and Sujata, the daughter of Wepechiti, how they got together.
She was originally one of the human wives of Saka when he was still a human being. He had four wives.
And three of them made merit and were reborn in Tawatingsa alongside the other Dewas. But his
favorite was Sujata and she was this kind of frivolous, sensuous bad girl who never did
anything meritorious. Her next birth after that was as a crane, a bird. And Saka went looking for
her in the realms and he saw her as a crane in some mountain pond. He took her in his chariot
and flew her around the shore of heaven and said, you know, this is what you've missed.
So you have to from now on keep the five precepts and maybe you can be reborn here.
So then he tested her by transforming himself into a fish and floating in the pond as if he was dead.
And the crane saw this floating fish and thought, oh, this one's dead. I can have this one without
breaking the precepts. And then he started flapping and she dropped him right away. So
she was keeping the precepts. So then she went through a series of various other births and
finally got reborn as a daughter of the Sura King. And when she came of age, they had a
ceremony where all the Asura lords were assembled and she had a wreath of flowers and she was to
choose her husband from this wreath of flowers over the neck of her husband. And Saka came into
this realm in the form of an old broken down Asura. And everyone was laughing at him, you know,
they're never going to choose you. And because of her past karmic connection, she felt compelled to
throw the wreath over Saka. And then when the wreath went over his neck, he transformed back
into Saka. And this enraged all the Asuras. Here is Saka, he's fooled us again. And they all start
chasing after him with their weapons. But then just at the nick of time, his charioteer, Matali,
came down with his chariot. The bride and groom leapt into the chariot and escaped.
So in these old Pali stories, there's even like car chases.
Yeah, that's fabulous. So many things to unpack in that story of relationships as well.
The emphasis on if you want to remain in a beautiful relationship, you have to both
remain moral. And that occasionally you get tested as well.
Saka's appearance as an old Asura, an old ugly Asura, is also maybe the Asura's ideas about
that they tend to judge unsuperficial qualities. And that he genuinely is internally beautiful.
He has a genuine beauty to him, which they fail to, they're mocking his physical appearance.
Yes. But he has this higher, this beauty of virtue. And then that becomes revealed.
Yes. So that's not just simply on a political level at these things, but also on a personal
level. And, of course, you see this, that individuals can influence whole groups of
consciousness. The consciousness sort of starts to take over a whole society. Whole groups fall
into this whole attitudes. It's amazing. Such subtlety and beauty and nuances and levels of
these stories as well. And they're not stories, they're not really fiction, they're actual
realities that beings live in. And they live in, you can see them preparing themselves. And this
they're really saying is that they are already preparing the consciousness for full immersion
in these realms. Walking around as humans, this is where you're preparing your consciousness for
entering into these realms of consciousness. And these are not real. They are as real as it gets.
In fact, the material world is simply a backdrop, a stage for consciousness to act out on. The
reality is consciousness and the mere background in the consciousness. So one who is in a depressed
state of mind or an angry state of mind cannot see the beauty in nature. But one who's light,
unburdened and feeling well is endlessly appreciating and seeing the beauty of the
opening of the sky, the sun, the blue casino of the sky, and so forth.
Yes. There's a story about the Nagas that illustrates this point very well. One of the
motifs that comes up in several of the stories is the Nagas want to reward some virtuous human
and they take him into their realm. And he lives in a palace and he's being served by all these
Naga maidens, all in beautiful human form. And there's music and food and all this sort of sensual
pleasures. And the way the story usually unfolds after a hundred years in the Naga realm,
because of his innate virtue, he gets beyond the desire for sensuality and he has to be returned
to the human realm and he then becomes a hermit or an ascetic. But in one story there's a low
evil sort of scoundrel who tricks the Nagas into thinking he's virtuous and he gets down into this
realm but he can't enjoy the pleasures. The Naga maidens seem to him like ferocious yakkas and the
palace like a dingy prison and the food is distasteful and coarse. So he's unable to
experience the sensual pleasures and it's the same as we might say objective reality, but his
subjective experience is entirely different. It's just the incredible wisdom. It's like taking a dog
to an art gallery and all the dog smells is the obnoxious smell of oil paint and he sees nothing.
He does not see art or anything like this. And in the human consciousness, if one has not developed,
one does not see that reality. It's simply not there for one. But as one develops, suddenly new
things emerge into reality. Sometimes I get the question when I'm talking about this stuff,
people want to know, are these realms real? I tend to think that's a rather naive question.
I like to turn it back and ask, well, how real is this realm and what do you mean by reality?
It is naive and I think that it's only since the last 200 years that anybody could think to ask
such a question. Yes, it's true. That everybody before that knew that would be a childish question
and maybe children know enough not to ask such questions either. They're enraptured by these
stories. They're absolutely real. But it's only in the scientific materialist linear
annihilationist kind of attitude that you can ask, is this real,
immeasurable in the chemistry tables?
Is there anything else about the Asura realm that you'd like to add to that?
We could mention one particular, another particular Asura of some importance is Rahu.
Ah, yes, Rahu. Rahu, who is the largest of all beings with a body. He's so big that he stands
in the ocean and the water doesn't reach up to his knee. And he says, people say this ocean is deep.
I don't know where they get that from. And he is the being who's responsible for eclipses.
When he sees the sun or the moon, he grows jealous of their radiance. And he tries to
either cover them with his hand, which is a partial eclipse, or he swallows them, which is a
total eclipse. But he's unable to stop their progress and he has to release them.
So he's the, is this maybe jealousy? This is when one sees a shining intelligence or talent
or spiritual capacity. There's some agency in nature that wishes to impede the radiance
and jealous of the radiance. And it's a massive presence. It's a large thing.
One of the things that I take from the story of, remember Rahu is attempting to swallow the moon
and the devas of the moon come to the Buddha and they're concerned about this. He says,
your protection is in faith in the Buddha, Dhamma, Sangha, and in virtue,
and that the Rahu cannot, and if he really did, the moon would move through his head.
And you see this in part of Asian culture, a kind of response to eclipses to come out and
bang pots and pans and fire off firecrackers and things like making noise to scare away Rahu.
And people of the scientific disposition tend to dismiss this as like a very old kind of
superstitious. But actually, in some sense, it's a preparation because what is in every culture,
when you get tyrants and dictators attempting to overcome the political system,
there is only one possibility is to protest in large numbers. And so Rahu is also the
mentality of tyrants and dictators. It is Stalin, it is Hitler, it is Rahu. They're enormous.
They're enormous powers, aren't they? And it's only by kind of cooperative noise, protest,
the return to virtue and faith that overcomes this. You see this both in Russian history and
German history. The first thing that went was religion. They had to annihilate the religious
structures or twist them. They had a reformation of a Lutheran church and some of them became
Nazis and so forth. And then, of course, in Marxist Russia, they just squashed the orthodox
things because that is the source of pushing back on this attempt to swallow.
Notice that neither Stalin nor Hitler is around anymore. No matter how many times they do,
it passes through their head. And then you get this rebound, this reformation,
return to the church, return to this kind of see what happens when darkness surrounds you.
So to just briefly recap the geography that we've covered so far,
we've been looking at the inhabitants of Mount Siniru, which is the central world mountain,
this massive mountain, 84,000 yojanas high and 84,000 yojanas below the sea.
Halfway up the mountain are the realms of the four great kings and various kinds of
fantastic beings live on the slopes like the supanas, the giant birds.
At the peak of the mountain is Tawatingsa heaven, the heaven of the 33, the devas or the
gods overseeing this whole world system, ruled by Saka. And at the base of the mountain,
under the sea, is the realm of the Asuras, who are the inveterate enemies and rivals of the
gods at the peak of the mountain and continually trying to storm the slopes of the mountain and
take back the kingdom of Tawatingsa.
