3 Realities Of Retiring With A Pension

Finance For The Future
12 followers
1 Video View·Jan 13, 2025
If you're retiring with a pension and over $1 million saved, you are part of a very small and unique group of retirees. In this episode of Joe Knows Retirement, Joe discusses the realities of retiring with a pension and talks about what you need to know so you can plan accordingly. He shares the actual value of a pension depending on how much you receive and how long you receive it, and explains a strategy you can use to save money in taxes even with a higher net worth.
Pension planning. One of the most popular topics that we get on this channel, one of the things
we do the most for the clients we work with is pension planning and helping them plan
for this in retirement. We work with a lot of federal employees. We work with a lot of state
employees. We work with a lot of people who have a pension or expect to get a pension
and are known as the Midwestern millionaires. And so these are people who, they never made
a million dollars a year, right? Typically when you have a pension, it's been a hard working job
where you just made a suitable amount over the years. You just put in a lot of time and effort
into that same company to build up that pension over time. And so these people that we work with
have a million dollars or more. They are diligent savers, they're frugal, they're hardworking,
and they have Midwestern values. And so we have clients all across the country,
but the ones even on the East Coast or West Coast or down South, they still resonate with those
Midwestern values. So if that's you today, you're going to love this video. We're going to talk
about some of the most important things to be aware of on pension planning. And we've got a lot
of other videos on this channel. So if you'd like to subscribe and like this video, then we'll keep
more content coming your way on pension planning and retirement planning for those who have been
that Midwestern millionaire. Joe knows taxes. Joe knows the market. Joe knows social security.
Joe knows income planning. Joe knows pickleball? No. This is Joe Knows Retirement.
So let's first start off by just understanding that if you have a pension, you are one of the
few. We get a lot of people that reach out to us, like I mentioned, who they say,
you're the only one that does videos on pension. No one else does videos on pensions. And I'll tell
you why is because there's not a huge market out there for people with pensions. So most advisors
just don't really specialize in that area because there's not as many people out there. Luckily for
us, we form a niche where we have more people wanting to work with us and we can actually take
at this point because of our focus in pensions. And I think they always say there's riches in the
niches. People want to work with a team who knows what they're dealing with. They know what they're
going through. If this is your first time retiring, you don't want to work with a team that's never
seen that situation before. You want to work with a team that's seen that hundreds of times and is
experts in that case. If I go get a shoulder surgery, I'm not going to my family doctor
who's never done a shoulder surgery before, even though I really like him and he's a good person.
I'm going to the expert. I'm going to the specialist and I'm going to get the job done.
So I don't have to worry about it anymore and I can enjoy the rest of my life. So hopefully that's
helpful for you as well as you look to get help. And maybe you want to do this on your own and
that's great as well. We see a lot of people reach out to us with pensions where we call them their
big DIYers. And that's awesome, but they're typically worried about their spouse because
if they pass away, they want to make sure their spouse is taken care of. And so if that's you,
just make sure you stay tuned to these videos and you get the help that you're seeking for.
But keep in mind only 20% of people have pensions. That's not very many. And then for the crowd that
we work with, we don't just work with people with pensions. We work with people with pensions who
have been diligent savers. And so the fact is that people with a million dollars or more,
it's about less than 10% of the US has over a million dollars. So you're telling me less than
20% has a pension and then less than 10% has over a million dollars. That is a very small crowd of
that our firm serves. And so if that's you and you're in that category, this is the exact channel
for you. And we're going to talk about more of these pensions moving forward. But the thing to
understand with all this, with your pension is your planning is different. If you're that unique
in that situation, your pension is going to put you in a much higher position from an income
standpoint in retirement from what we see. And then if you have social security on top of that
as well, you may never be in a lower tax bracket in retirement. We get that question a lot or that
thought a lot of, Hey, all my life I've been told I'll be in a lower tax bracket in retirement.
And that may be true for most people that don't have a pension, right? Because if you don't have
a pension, all you have to worry about is investment withdrawals and social security.
Well, in that case, you're probably never going to be in a huge tax bracket situation unless you
have multimillion dollars saved up. Then maybe that's the case, but in most cases, it's just not,
it's not going to be a problem. But if you have a pension, let's just run through the example.
Let's say you have a pension that pays you out $40,000 a year, right? And real quick,
let's just do the math. If that pays you out $40,000 a year for the rest of your life,
that's almost equivalent in my mind of having a million dollars. And so I'll do the math of why,
right? So if you have $40,000 and that pays you out for, let's just say 10 years,
how much total does that pay you out? It pays you out $400,000, right?
Well, what about a 20-year retirement? Well, now it pays you out $800,000. And what if you live out
a 25-year retirement? So let's say you retire at 60 and you live till 85, which is very reasonable.
Well, there's a million dollars that was paid out to you just from that pension. But that's only
part of the story because if you had a million dollars right now, there's something called the
4% rule. And that says in year one, you could take out 4% of your investment, which is 40,000,
and you can have that last you 30 years. You can get $40,000 a year for 30 years and never run out
of money is what that said. And some say, well, that's true, that's false. You get the idea. It's
somewhere near close enough, depending on how the investments do, inflation, all that stuff.
But within that 4% rule, it doesn't just say you can take out $40,000 per year. It says that you
can take out 40,000 plus, it's called a 3% inflation. So each year you're going to be
able to take out more and more and more and more. And so just understand that your pension
on top of that, we're talking about how great it is, but just be aware that that may not adjust
for inflation. I'm not trying to talk bad about it, but just make sure you're aware of that
within your planning. But even with all that, like I said, you're still getting about a million
dollars paid out to you over your lifetime if you live that long. If you only live five years,
well, that's not the case. And especially if you don't have a survivor option on that pension.
So I'm just really trying to paint the picture that you're in a great spot with these pensions.
So back to the example here. If you have $40,000 from your pension, and then let's say you're
married. Let's say maybe only one of the spouses have a pension. And let's say you both have
social security. Well, let's say that your social security is set to be, let's just say you came
close to maxing it out. It's about, or just under and about $40,000 a year as well. And then let's
say your spouse never worked. And let's say they get half of your social security due to what's
called the spousal benefit. So the spousal benefit says that if that spouse has no earned
income, well, they can still claim up to half of your benefit. And that only goes up to age 67. So
if you wait until 70 to get your benefit, they will only get half of 67, not half of age 70.
So just real tip there for you. And so if that's the case, you've got 40, 40, and 20. So you're up
to $100,000 of income that is guaranteed for the rest of your life. A lot of clients that we work
with, they may never see over $100,000 a year that they've made in their lifetime. I think the
stat I just saw is that only 18% of people make $100,000 or more per year in their lifetime. And
so you're telling me you're going to make that in retirement. It's pretty awesome. And that's
not even including your investment withdrawals. And like I said, if you're that Midwestern
millionaire, you've got a million dollars saved. Well, 4% rule says you can take out 40,000 as I
just went through that example. Well, now you're up to about 140,000 that you can live off of for
the rest of the year without any concern of running out of money is what most people would suggest.
And if you have 2 million, well, now you have 180,000. And so you can see where that's a
generous amount that you may never even have made that much in your lifetime, or maybe about the
same as that during your lifetime. And so to that saying of, hey, you're going to be in a lower tax
bracket retirement, well, it's just probably not going to be the case because you actually may be
in a higher tax bracket retirement considering your income. So that's only one part of the story.
The other part of the story is what is going to happen to tax rates. Right now, tax rates are
among historically low that we've ever seen. The highest bracket right now today is 37%.
Historically, the highest tax bracket was 94%. And if you went back to 1981, it was about 70%.
And so you can see that, hey, we're $37 trillion in debt. Our country likes to spend money. We do
have Social Security and Medicare as a huge liability right now. What do you expect tax
rates to do moving forward? We do know that the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act is likely going to get
extended. We don't know that for certain, but we do know that's probably going to get extended with
President Trump in office with a Republican House and Senate as well, probably going to be able to
keep that trucking along just like they implemented in 2017, probably have that implement longer than
2026 to keep tax rates low in the near future. But what are they going to be if Trump gets out and
now it's a Democratic House and Senate? What's going to happen? And so a lot of people are
suggesting tax rates just have to increase because we need more revenues. And if no one's going to
stop spending money, regardless of who's in office, well, then they really only have one
option there to get the revenues we need or the debt's just going to continue to increase.
And so that's a consideration is that if you expect tax rates to be higher in the future,
and you're going to be in a high income situation, who are they trying to tax the most?
It's high income individuals, right? Biden had his number at about 400,000 is who they were
trying to tax more. I would argue that's even lower than that is where they're trying to tax
people more of high income earners. And the reason I say that is because social security is fully
taxed at a certain point that's not 400,000. Medicare premiums start to become more, cost more
at a point that's not 400,000. They all happens sooner than those points, right? The tax bracket
increases go up before $400,000. And so those are the things you just have to be aware of that they
could tax anyone more. And so we call them that Midwestern millionaire and better known as that
middle-class millionaire, right? Because we had a client in Florida who said, I'm not in the
Midwest, I'm a middle-class millionaire. I said, that works too. But if that's you,
you may find yourself paying a lot more in taxes and retirement because of the increases.
And so what we try to do with a lot of our clients there is, hey, right now, tax rates are
historically low and very low for that middle-class crowd, right? 12%, 22%, 24% brackets are pretty
generous brackets right there that we could be taking advantage of right now and making sure that
we can get ahead of knowing we're going to be in a higher income situation. Don't be just blinded
in the future and say, oh wow, I guess I never really thought about my pension and how that
works. And I joke about that. We actually have people come to us who are 60 to 70 who haven't
really got ahead of the planning, which that's fine. You can't change the past, but you can't
change the future and it's never too late. And so we're able to help a lot of those people.
Actually, the majority of our clients are between the ages of 55 and 70. And so it's never too late
at all. But the key is just get started on it now. We have a huge opportunity where this window's
closing with tax rates increasing, knowing our income's going to be the same or higher. Let's
get ahead of it is ultimately the consideration. So hopefully that gives you a really good idea
of understanding how important it is to plan for this because that's all the considerations, right?
And so one of the most popular strategies that we're doing with our clients right now to plan
for all that that I just talked about is what's called a Roth conversion. I mean, we have people
that come work with us just specifically for this strategy because they want to make sure that they
have everything placed from a tax planning standpoint. A Roth conversion impacts so many
different things. Like I've already mentioned, it impacts our requirement of distribution.
It impacts Medicare premiums, which a lot of people with pensions who have been diligent savers are
worried about. It affects social security tax, right? Because the higher your income, the more
you're going to have to pay on social security tax. And so it impacts all these different things.
And so what a Roth conversion is, you take money from your tax deferred dollars and you move it
over to a Roth account. And so let's say, for example, you have a traditional IRA, you've never
paid taxes on it. You've got a million dollars in a traditional IRA. Well, what happens when you take
out money from there is you got to pay taxes. And so the question you have to ask yourself to see
if a Roth conversion makes sense or not is, do you want to pay those taxes today or do you just
want to wait into the future and pay those taxes later at potentially higher rates, at a potential
higher income or same income and have to pay tax on all that growth that you see over time?
Whereas you could just do it now at lower rates at a time when you may be in a lower income or
same income and do it now before the growth happens, right? Pay on the seed versus the
harvest. So I'm a country boy. I grew up in the country in a rural community. It's called Carroll,
Ohio. There's 500 people in the village and there's a lot of farmland down there. My best
friend actually owns an apple orchard. And so if I asked him, would you rather pay tax on the seed
you planted at the beginning of the year or the harvest at the end of the year, what do you think
he would say, right? So that's one of the advantages of doing a Roth conversion now as well.
And another thing that many people don't talk about with a Roth conversion is that
rules could change. So like before 2010, there was limits on how much you could Roth convert.
Now there are no limits on Roth conversion, but who to say that could change? And you've already
kind of heard some legislation here recently that they're trying to remove and force people,
if they have a Roth, for that not to be advantageous as much for them ongoing.
Now that's only impacting the very, very ultra high net worth people out there. But who's to
say that they could do that to people here as well. And they're not necessarily making it
less beneficial that they have a Roth. They're just making it less beneficial moving forward.
So one question we get all the time as well, Roth is great, but what if they change the rules?
They can, they probably will. Tax rules written in pencil. But what I can tell you is it won't
put you in a worse position. If you look back in all of tax history, all of tax changes,
they typically either grandfather in or just change it moving forward. They're not going to
penalize you. They just may not make it as advantageous. And so in that case, I still
am fully behind a Roth and a Roth conversion and a Roth IRA, if it makes sense for someone at that
time, because they're still going to be able to see some sort of benefits from it moving forward.
They just may not be able to see all the benefits. But in my world, Roth has got a lot of benefits
that I wouldn't doubt could change, right? One of them is there's no required minimum
distribution on a Roth IRA. You're not required to ever take out money from a Roth. I personally
think they should change that just like they do for the IRA. I don't see why they have a separate
set of rule for the Roth versus the IRA. I know why they don't is because they don't get any tax
revenue from the Roth, so they don't really care about it. Whereas the IRA, they want that tax
revenue. They're in debt. They want it. They want more money, right? And so that's something that
they could change with a Roth is they could just put a required minimum distribution on that.
Again, that would impact you, but I don't know if it would change our decision of doing something
this year. And so that's what you want to consider there. But with this Roth conversion,
let's just say you have a million dollars there as an example. Let's say we convert 100,000. Well,
now we have 900,000 here in our tax deferred. That is helpful for you because now you're going
to have a lesser RMD because now that RMD calculation, when you turn 73 or 75, when the
government forced you to take out that money is going to be off of 900,000 instead of a million.
And that's going to mean that you're going to be forced to take out less money, which is
advantageous for your planning down the road, right? We want to be forced to take out less
than more so we can have more flexibility. If you wanted to take out more from the tax deferred in
retirement, you could, but the good thing is you would have the choice versus the government having
the choice. And that's why we like the option. And a lot of our clients, they like to have the
option of having that balance of tax free and tax deferred so they can choose which account they
pull out from. In retirement, they look at their tax planning situation that year, see where social
security tax is going to lie, see where Medicare premium is going to lie, and then they look to
make a decision at that point. And then the other reasons is for Medicare premiums and social
security tax. I've already kind of touched on that, but with Medicare premiums, you would have
to pay more in Medicare if your income is at a certain point. And some of our clients, where
maybe both of them were public employees, federal employees, they get really large pensions. I mean,
their pensions combined may be well over $100,000. I mean, we have clients that $100,000, $200,000
in pensions is not unheard of. And then they may have social security on top of that, especially
with the whole WEP, the Windfall Elimination Provision, and the GPO. I call GPO grumpy partner
because it has to affect the spouse who has that government pension. And it's government pension
offset is what it's called. With that coming back, now you're going to be entitled to your
social security benefits if you earn those. Now you have that on top of things as well. I mean,
we have clients where it's $200,000, $300,000 of income guaranteed throughout the rest of the
retirement before we even factor in investments. And that's obviously a great place to be.
But it comes with a lot of issues. I know in some of the comments here, people give me the hardest
time. And I'm like, man, I'm just trying to educate people. I'm not trying to do anything
bad here. But they criticize me because they're like, well, people with pensions and people with
a lot of money saved, oh boy, they have to pay all this money in taxes. Who cares? And I'm like,
I get it. They're in a fortunate position. I'm not trying to downplay that. But what I'm saying is
that just because you're in a fortunate position doesn't mean you should not plan the right way.
You want to make sure you're taking advantage of any situation you're in, whether that's good or
bad. We just want to maximize that situation. Now, if you don't care about maximizing it and
you want to do whatever you want, go for it. No one's going to be impacted besides yourself.
But just a quick rant for you there to understand that, hey, you're in a great position, but that
just means there's more opportunities to plan and save money and do things the right way.
I'm a believer that you should be the best steward of your life-saving dollars. And so
if that's the case, we need to make sure that we are doing the right strategies today, but we also
need to make sure when we're no longer on this earth, that it's going to make a kingdom impact,
whether that's going to be left to our kids or a charity or a church or an organization or whatnot.
That's for your heart to decide what that's going to be. But let's make sure it's done the right
way. Let's make sure it's done in a way that we don't overpay in taxes. Because taxes, they have
rules in place so that you can take advantage of the loopholes, so that you can pay less.
You're not forcing you to pay as much as possible. And so if that's the case,
you just have to understand how all this plays together.
So hopefully this video can be really helpful for you just to understand
how to think about when you have a pension. A lot of people come to us and come by these
videos and just say, man, I never really thought about how important it is to plan for a pension
and how different it is. So if you are looking for this type of planning specifically, you have a
pension, you have at least a million dollars, feel free to reach out to our team and we could see if
can guide you further if you're looking for this type of planning. We can't work with everyone that
reaches out to us at this point, but at least you'll be able to fill out a questionnaire and
we'll be able to schedule a call to see if this could be a good fit. And so regardless, if you're
not looking for help or whatever your case may be, just make sure you subscribe to these videos and
we'll make sure to keep them coming. And we do a lot of pension content, a lot of content on taxes
and just general retirement planning as well for that crowd that we've talked about,
that Midwestern millionaire. And that book should be out here soon. So be on the lookout for that
as well. So enjoy the rest of your day. And that's all I have for today's episode of Joe Knows Retirement.
