Bank of America CEO Brian Moynihan's Tenure of "Responsible Growth" | Wall Street Week

Financial Freedom
10 followers
Jan 12, 2025
Under Brian Moynihan's leadership, Bank of America has achieved steady growth for the past 15 years, but the path to stability started with the fallout from the Great Financial Crisis.
We begin with a story about tenure, not the kind that guarantees you a job, but
the kind that you have to earn day after day and year after year. The kind that,
looking back after 15 years, may look obvious, but that at the beginning was
anything but. You know I never really thought about, I knew I had to be here a
substantial time to work with the team and drive the company what it could be
and that's that's great, but I it never was like to do this job five years. I
think you have the time has to be where you have the place from where we were in
a place that's great condition. When Brian Moynihan took over as CEO of Bank
of America on January 1st 2010, the place was definitely not in great condition. It
had just gone through a series of mergers, including the one that brought
Moynihan to the bank through its acquisition of Fleet Boston just six
years before. Before Fleet Boston deal, legacy Bank of America at that point
probably had a hundred thousand employees. Fleet Boston had 50-60 thousand. You know then
Merrill had 60,000. We'll say 15,000, 20,000. Countrywide had 40,000. More people came
from the outside than not. And so one of the things that the team and I had to
settle down is what is the culture, what are the values. Forming a single culture
from such disparate parts would have been a challenge all by itself, but this
all happened as the great financial crisis was in full bloom, putting
enormous pressure on all the big banks. A year into his tenure, Moynihan faced a
mountain of losses from the subprime mortgage business he had inherited when
his predecessor, Ken Lewis, purchased Countrywide, leading to losses of over
$30 billion. Its stock price had fallen nearly 10%. Its price-to-book value was
down to 0.45. And the government was putting into place fundamental changes
in the banking system overall, including upping the capital requirements for the
banks, requirements some doubted Bank of America could meet. You have a lot ahead
of you. You also have a lot behind you. And we think about what the banking world was,
what Bank of America was in 2008, 2009, 2010 when you took a job. It was a different
world. So a lot of people don't remember that in 2007 and 2006 is actually when
the financial crisis started to come through. The property value started going
down. The over-lending and the consumer side became exposed. The ripple effect
through some of the CDOs and things like that. The impact on the Bear Stearns and
Lehman and Merrill and other companies and the acquisitions that took place in
2008. What you had was non-banks that weren't governed by the rules. They were
all brought in the banking system and the net was thrown over. The tent was
thrown over a lot bigger group. That's what made it different coming out the
other side because suddenly, you know, the group of my peers were Goldman Sachs,
Morgan Stanley, JP, Citi, ourselves, etc. It wasn't just the banks and then, you
know, the securities firms over here or the insurance firms over here. And that
then required all the rules to change fast and all the reach to change fast.
The stuff people hadn't thought about, you know, the Volcker Amendment and, you
know, this stuff, you know, stuff that hadn't people hadn't thought about. And
that was because suddenly you took all these people who were governed by
different regimes, different rules, threw them in a pot and said, we're going to
put a tent over a hole.
Moynihan's management team at the time knew that the challenges could make or
break his new leadership. Anne Finucane served as chief marketing and strategy
officer at Bank of America in 2011 before becoming the vice chair of the
bank and chair of its European operations.
This was a moment, if you will, in financial services. We were in a near
recession that was the likes of we had never seen before. And B of A had a
million problems. And we had issues with regulators. We had issues with
analysts. We had issues with clients and customers. Elected officials were
questioning our viability. And, you know, the stock price was very low. And
there were questions about the company in general. And this is what Brian
Moynihan stepped into. And he stepped into it, I have to say, eyes wide open
because he had done almost every executive job in the company. So he was
prepared. I think he was prepared in a way almost no one else could have been.
And he was also willing. And he was certainly able. So this was a moment for
this company. And he assembled a crew around him, an executive management team,
and we were going to work 24-7 for what turned out to be at least a few years.
And we recovered.
To bring his bank back from the brink, Moynihan focused on what was working,
where it could win, and what it could do without, cutting billions in expenses
and tens of thousands of jobs.
We got rid of $300 billion assets, 50 operating businesses. We were down to
operating efficiency made sense. We said, now we got to grow. And so the first
part of response was grow no excuses. But what you had in the base that was
these eight lines of business we talked about, Jack Walsh or somebody say, you
got to be top one, two, three in the business, we were top one, two, three in
all the businesses across the eight lines of business. But what you had is a
lot of other stuff that was not as interesting. And then we had the
regulatory issues. And then we had the mortgage issue. So we had to just push
all that away. But all those acquisitions left us with a franchise that is a top
consumer banking franchise, the top wealth management franchise, the top
commercial banker in the United States, a global large corporate banker and a
global markets business, that we were able then to start to invest in growing
them organically.
We had to decide what we're going to do in terms of everything from customer
care, if you will, employee morale, dealing with elected officials dealing
with regulators, and then what businesses we're going to lean in on, and those
that we were going to perhaps exit. So Brian is got a bit of the engineering in
that he is an exacting person. He, we laid out every line of business, we laid
out every geography we were in, when you look back on it, you can be a bit
nostalgic, but at the moment, it was very difficult. And he was so determined.
He's a very good leader because he's calm. And he's thorough. And he's also
human. And what I mean by that is he got when everybody was kind of frazzled. And
we just kept at it. But there was a camaraderie around it that I think would
be maybe unexpected.
Even as Moynihan and his team were rebuilding Bank of America from the
ground up, concerns about the bank led others to make sure its problems didn't
further risk the entire financial system, leading the government to insist Bank of
America and the other money center banks take large infusions of cash investments.
And even for mega investor Warren Buffett to pitch in with a $5 billion
investment.
So in 2011, August, when the United States had been downgraded was close to
defaulting. At that point, the US was short, it didn't have enough money and
was starting to run out of money. We were also getting knocked around at the same
time. And he came in August and said, here's 5 billion. I know you don't need
it, but it'll stabilize in the 250,000 plus people we had at that time, came to
work the next day and said the smartest investor put $5 billion in a company in
24 hours.
That was an interesting moment. At that point, we had actually recovered enough
that we had sufficient capital. And and by the way, he knew that. And in fact,
that's what he said to Brian, I know it, that's why I'm investing. It helped us
enormously with the analyst community and elected officials and even our own
employees. If Warren Buffett was investing in us, it was such a boost of
confidence that we didn't maybe otherwise have at the point. So it was
reputationally really beneficial.
Under Moynihan, Bank of America has not only survived, it has thrived, earning
over $15 billion a year over each of the last 10 years, increasing its
assets from 2.3 to $3.3 trillion and its share price from $13 to $44. And that
price to book ratio, it's gone from .45 to over 1.25. But even as it has come
back strong, it has not grown as fast as its biggest rival, JP Morgan, whose
share price has led the pack of the big banks, while Bank of America remains
somewhere in the middle. Some have suggested that Moynihan's steadfast
commitment to responsible growth may have held it back.
Did you leave any money on the table because of the responsible part? And
does responsible growth look the same today in 2025, as it did in 2010?
So one of the things we always talk to our team, it's about is responsible
growth was a call to growth, not a call to be responsible. We're already pretty
responsible, I think from 10 to 15. And the idea was, we we've done all the work,
we reshaped the company, we said now we got to grow. And so you never disrupt
the company's ability to keep going. And we have businesses which offset each
other. So the markets business has done well, and the interest rate environment
changed. Now the consumer and global banking business will kick in. But the
idea of responsible growth is that you got to grow no excuses, you got to win
in the marketplace. Responsible growth is like a dual thought, if you will,
demonstrating responsibility, which is sort of an extension of good governance.
And also the contract you make with your clients and your employees that
you're going to be responsible to them first and foremost, all along the way.
And remember now where we came from. And then the second thing was that we would
grow. So responsible growth, I mean, responsible growth can be a modifier to
growth. But it's actually two thoughts, we will be responsible in all the ways
that clients and regulators and the community would want you to be, and we
will grow, maybe more conservatively than others. But I just repeat again,
B of A has had 10 years of 15 billion plus net income consistently.
Where is Bank of America today? Give us a sense of how you grade yourself.
Well, we have great potential. But there's a phrase that Jim Collins, a
great business writer uses and what I say. So I got a lot of people asking me,
I just had our market presence on. What about 15 years? What are you proud of?
What did you do? I said, it's a nice start. What this company has ahead of us
is a lot because of what we've done for the last 200 years, but what we've done
in the last 15 years as a team.
As you look forward to the next 15 years, what do you think that may hold for
Bank of America? And what kind of person would need to lead it going forward as
opposed to what's led in the past?
I think if you look ahead, the changes will come from the data, the technology,
the ability to transmit that data, the compute power, the ability to imitate
our human's thinking. Those are ahead of us. That implication of voice
recognition, computational power, algorithmic analysis, mathematical
analysis, combined with an understanding of how humans can drive it makes the
next 15 years a whole nother sea change in how we operate. And a person that
will be operating that has to be that wise and that current, that balanced
and that aggressive. And that's the key, which is how do you push?
As Moynihan positions Bank of America for the next 15 years, one of his
priorities is to ensure that it is both a global bank and a local one, that it
is thoroughly integrated into the communities it serves.
The whole idea was that we would set up a situation where you'd have top line
executives, but you'd also have market presidents. And the idea behind that was
that market president would have a beat on that community, that economy, how we
were going to contribute to it, and by the way, how we were going to get our
fair share of business from that community. So he's been very focused and
he takes it all the way down to the community level to make sure that not
only is the reputation good, but the numbers are good.
And that's where we turn next on Wall Street Week to one of those communities
Moynihan works to serve and a market president who illustrates what
responsible growth means in practice.
During his 15 years at the helm of Bank of America, Brian Moynihan has nurtured
an alternative structure within the bank, one focused not just on its eight lines
of business around the globe, but also on the individual communities it serves
across the United States. That alternative structure is built around 97
regional presidents who add to their regular banking jobs specific local
responsibilities. It's all about serving the client. And when you think about
Brian's tenure in his 15 years, he worked hard to build the culture of Bank of
America. He wanted to simplify this organization. He helped us focus and have
everything center around the financial lives of our clients. So it sounds like
common sense, but when you're an institution of our size with eight lines
of business, that takes a lot of coordination and it takes that local
understanding of the communities.
Jennifer Chandler is the Dallas market president charged with focusing on her
region in addition to her job as head of B of A's philanthropic solutions team.
One of the things that we started, this is like 30 years ago, we started
thinking about this question, which is if we bought companies and pulled the
corporate headquarters out of town, we pulled out the senior leadership, too,
because the company became a subsidiary and a part of a whole. And that became
acute in the 80s when the acquisition started building up into the 90s. And so
after that, we said, how do we think about having our cake and eat it? How can
we have these national business, which are run nationally, not locally in the
disparate parts, but run nationally, a wealth management business and a
consumer banking business and a little market business? How do we knit them
together? And so we started this idea of building the same kind of cooperation in
the markets with a leader, a market president who would replicate me in that
market and replicate what used to be.
They've had market president for my full tenure here, as long as I can
remember, at least in the 25 years. But I have seen it really improve under the
leadership of Ryan Moynihan. And as you know, he celebrated his 15 year
anniversary as our CEO. So early on in my career, it was more around the giving
in the community, a check presentation, you know, maybe some volunteerism. But
under his leadership, it was far more about delivering this exceptional
experience to our clients, to take this massive institution, to make it feel
more local. He was very thoughtful in that around who we had in those
positions. It's quite the honor.
The regional president system is B of A's way to have the best of both worlds,
all the capacity of a big money center bank, together with the local
connections of a regional bank.
How do you compete with regional banks? Because often regional banks would say
that's exactly what they do. They're located there. They know they have all
those client relations, personal relations with the society, with the
culture. How do you compete with that?
So the way we think about it, we got out local to locals and out national to
nationals. So our team in the local market has the authorities to do things.
You have credits up to 30, 40 billion dollars, all approved locally, no other
approvers, even higher than that in some cases. So the idea that's competitive
locally. So we think about what the power of that team has that's managing
locally, the personnel they have and how they work together. And that's where in
the market president through the 97 teammates we have to do this, they have
scorecards to make sure the business is moving. Those line up with our line of
business scorecards. And so the idea is to give them authority and power and
then advertising and charity money, all that they replicate the president of a
bank. And that's what they did.
You mentioned 97. How do you pick 97? Why isn't it 80 or 120? How do you pick
where you need a regional president?
Oh, we put it wherever we have a business. So we actually are in probably
another 30 or 40 markets that are small that aren't as distinct. So we look at
the M.S.A. and we said our goal in the company is to cover the entire
population by historical accident. For example, we didn't have anybody in Ohio.
So we now bet on Cleveland, Columbus and Cincinnati dating a little bit. We
didn't have a little Kentucky, you know, just because there was never a bank
required. So we're building all these places. But it's all M.S.A.
As Dallas market president Chandler competes against regional banks, but she
also works with them.
They all play an important role. And I love our regional banks. I'm dear friends
with many of the CEOs around town, and it takes all of us. And I think they
would tell you that. It starts with understanding our clients. It is very
localized, everything we do. So while we have 14,000 teammates and a very large
presence here, every week I'm in a financial center, whether it's in the
center of downtown or it's in a suburb. And I'm there as the doors open. And I
will tell you, the person that our clients are walking in to see are people
from the community there. So when you think about regional banks knowing
their communities, when I can tell you I had a receptionist that just
celebrated 57 years, I think that would reassure you that those clients know
exactly who they're going to walk in and see. And those stories are not small.
Our folks stay here. And whether it's fiduciary planning on the private wealth
side, we helped write the fiduciary documents with the estate planner. I
wouldn't say one absolutely has that secured better than another. We think
the regionals are very important for a lot of reasons. But I firmly believe
with the approach we take and the approach at Bank of America, we
understand our communities and we have very strong relationships with the
clients we serve. Dallas became a financial hub in the 1930s, after the
discovery of oil in East Texas, and went on to become a manufacturing center
during World War Two. With the tech boom of the 1990s, it has become part of
what some people call the Silicon Prairie, supporting a diverse group of
industries, including financial services. Schwab announced that it was
moving to Dallas from San Francisco in 2019. All of this has meant steady
growth for the Dallas area, with a current population of nearly 8.5
million people, up from around 5 million in 2010, when Moynihan became
CEO. It is an exciting time. And I'm third generation Dallas site. And so
I've seen just the history of this community. And we've always been a
can-do city when you think about what we've done. And we were very forward
thinking many years ago, whether it was the railroad, DFW airport. So we
continue to think for the future and see what the needs of the community
are. Why I raise that is that's what's worked to bring this diverse economy to
North Texas. So examples include technology. Well, Texas Instruments was
here many years ago. So when we think about technology, that was for us the
60s, the 70s. So always being forward thinking. Now that looks like biotech.
Many people don't think of Dallas necessarily as a technology hub. They
think of some other city here in Texas. Well, that's Dallas. And we're
attracting the talent from the East Coast, from the West Coast. They're
coming here. So it's diversity in every industry. Technology is a large one. We
also see a large presence of global companies who either bring their
headquarters here, or they want to buy shore, maybe have population here or
overseas. And I attribute that to, again, the great climate we have. We're
centrally located. We're favorable when it relates to taxes. And it runs a
gamut manufacturing. One that you may or may not think of is the sports
industry. We're number one when it relates to sports, and it's not just
the usual suspects. We, of course, are the official bank of the Dallas
Cowboys. How do you know that it's working? Or maybe more important, how
do you know when it's not working? We keep track of all the things that
happen. There's metrics for every market. We go through them constantly,
and they've been building on building on and building on. But how I really
know it works is when I go into market and watch that team tell me about what
they've been doing together, what's on the volunteer side, what's on the
business referral side. And so they were always telling me that. And I
don't rely on just what our statistics say. I rely on them also feeling good
about it. And what can we do? So when a natural disaster comes up, Western
North Carolina, the market president there, that Augusta, Georgia, the
Florida, they also the people help us deploy in those markets. And sometimes
it's the people working branches and commercial bank. Sometimes it's a big
big operations center. So and they basically lead our efforts in our form
to help bring those employees. And so what you see is the success around all
that. So it's not just business referrals and that tough. It actually
gets into them, leading the market and also helping us do what we do. So when
the horrible floods came in Western North Carolina, we found every teammate.
We brought our Star Lake branch up. We bought our ATMs up. We brought food in
and water. We brought water to help. But we're working through that market
presence. Say, what do you need it in Augusta, Georgia? The same thing with
our parish or down in Florida with the various markets. What do you need? And
what are you hearing? How do we connect through you so that we could not only
have his national relief teams are tremendous that are monitoring this and
doing that they do it through the eyes of local and how we could help Chandler
credits CEO Moynihan's leadership with avoiding the recent upheaval in
regional banking in the wake of Silicon Valley banks collapse. If we think
about commercial real estate and we think about that example, it goes back
to if we had not had responsible growth, not six months before, not a year
before. If we hadn't driven that for a decade before, would we have had far
more challenges? Absolutely. But it wasn't only the commercial book. And if
you look at our balance sheet, we're responsible in our lending. We had
smaller exposure on the deposit side of the balance sheet. If you look at the
regionals and some of the others that had challenges, we weren't concentrated
on the deposit side either. So it goes to client selection, making thoughtful
decisions. But I'll tell you, in hindsight, thinking back a few years
before, were there a few deals and opportunities we may have looked at that
wanted to do at the time that looked attractive? Of course there were. But how
did we feel going through that experience when we could not only ensure
our clients, but we were able to step up and help some of those other
institutions that needed us at that time. So it takes some care and feeding
that is important. I talked to the team. I just talked to him today. You know, I
talked to him every month to make sure they give me any input of what we can
do. And then we advertise locally and we use their presence locally, so their
names appear in all the press. And so that when somebody says, I got a
problem with Bank of America, I got an opportunity for Bank of America, they
know who to go to. As Brian Moynihan looks forward to the next chapter for
Bank of America, he emphasizes the history of the bank, its tradition of
connections to the communities it serves, and above all, its connection to
its clients and customers, driven by a team that's learned to pull together.
Great businesses that have a common purpose to be great for the clients of
those businesses, each other, the shareholders, and the communities they
serve, and doing it in a way that, frankly, you know, we're very proud of.
Our customer delight scores are as high as they've ever been. Our teammate
scores, our attrition's down. That's all good stuff, but it comes down to
serving those customer and clients every day. And all that's worked to where
we have driven this company, you know, from here to some places, kind of fun.
And the next generation after I'm gone, we'll take it and drive it even
further.
