Secrets d’allaitement : quand la science et les mythes se rencontrent |L'Histoire nous le dira # 271

L'Histoire nous le dira
69 abonnés
32 Vues de vidéo·11 janv. 2025
What do Queen Blanche of France, French-Canadian Julie Pepino, and American model Jerry Hall
have in common? Not easy, actually. You can guess after clicking
on the video, they all breastfed their children. Well yes, breastfeeding is as old as the hills.
So much so that when you think about it, breast milk is the original food. Just so we can
agree on the terms here before we get started, breastfeeding is the act of a woman who breastfeeds
the child she has given birth to. Not to be confused with solidarity breastfeeding
where a woman feeds another woman's child altruistically without compensation or mercenary
breastfeeding where a woman feeds another woman's child either in exchange for a salary
or because she is forced to. Before going any further, I would like to
thank Jean Visey Bergeron who wrote the script for this video, and for those who would like
to go further, will I recommend the books by Ivan Kinveler, Marie France Morel and Didier
But also all the references you want to have. Well they are in the description of this video.
So today, history will tell us, we parliament, one of the oldest human food practices.
Women's milk is essential to the survival of children from prehistory. The many statuettes
that have survived to this day lead us to believe that the nourishing function of women
is vital. More than 2 million years ago, we know that
women breastfed their children during the first years of life, yeah. In the plural.
Very concretely, it is the tooth enamel that confirms to us that bed rest was practiced.
How so? But in the enamel, we can see growth rings like for trees. And it is these rings
that give growth. Scientists have been able to isolate the barium that accumulates in
the child's teeth. Barium is a chemical element contained in maternal A. This dating
has shown that the duration of breastfeeding varies greatly depending on the prehistoric
era. From 6 months to 4 years. The introduction of complementary foods is done around 6 months.
Although it depends on the context. For example, when there is a scarcity of food, the introduction
of other foods can be delayed. Agriculture and especially animal breeding will have a
significant impact and the introduction of food does not rhyme with the complete weaning
of the child. Breastfeeding can continue for a few more years. It should be noted that
mortality rates increase when something other than breast milk is offered to the very young
and not just in prehistory. Potentially contaminated or indigestible complementary foods make children
particularly vulnerable to gastric problems. In ancient Egypt, breast milk has great symbolic
value. Indeed, through milk, the goddess Isis gives her son the pharaoh thus metaphorically
receives his power and legitimacy. It is his birth as pharaoh. And at his death, it is
still the milk of Isis that gives him immortality. The cult of Isis is not limited to the elite.
She is evoked to become pregnant or to protect a newborn. This is also the reason why statuettes
of Isis, being her son, are so popular. Isis is the mother goddess of Egypt. She is the
figure of the universal mother who transforms into Ara for the Greeks, Juno for the Romans
and Mary for the Christians. She is the one who nourishes, fertilizes, protects and accompanies
in the afterlife. But let's not go too fast. Antiquity also offers extraordinary breastfeedings
like Zeus, fed by the goat at Maltese or the twins Romulus and Remus, founders of Rome,
fed by a she-wolf. Although reading this last myth, it could be a prostitute. She-wolf and
prostitute in Latin were said the same way. Lua, let's go back to the Greeks. Did you
know that it is to Ara that we owe the milky way above our heads? Yes, milky. Milky as
in milk, I tell you. Heracles, illegitimate son of Zeus, would have been the Saint Desat,
wife of Deus, during his sleep. As he is hungry, he suckles too greedily, which wakes the goddess.
On seeing Heracles at her breast, Ara would have pushed him away, horrified, which would
have caused a maternal spurt in the sky the milky way.
We also find the same story among the Romans with Juno and Hercules. We are talking about
Dean or their women who are very much alive. The Greek mother would go regardless of her
social status. However, elite women often limit themselves to that. Other care and education
of children are entrusted to servants who will often remain devoted their whole lives
to protecting them. Even when they have become adults, the Romans for their part, did not
go. Infants are entrusted to slaves and this regardless of social class.
The wet nurse is housed in the home of her masters or in one of their secondary residences
with the child entrusted to her as well as her own in the best case. This is how one
becomes brother and sister of the eye. Roman law recognizes a legitimacy to the bond created
by the elitma. Indeed, a young master can free the slaves who served him during his
childhood as his wet nurse and his foster brother.
It is during antiquity that the theory of humors takes its foundations and it is absolutely
necessary that I tell you about it. Yeah, I've already talked about it in quite a few
videos and we need to come back to it. Yeah, you need to understand that the theory of
humors can explain a lot of things in the relationship that people of the past had with
their bodies. Especially because it's much richer than that, you'll have understood.
Okay, what's the link between the practice of breastfeeding? I'm getting there.
Breast milk is a fundamental liquid with blood and sperm. It has been explained since antiquity
that lactation is caused by the blood from the womb, from the uterus which after birth
flows to the breast through a special vein. It will be cooked and blanched and it is thus
transformed into milk. Breastfeeding is the logical continuation of pregnancy since it
allows the child to be finished being made after childbirth. This is also what explains
why there is an absence of menstruation during breastfeeding. The body uses blood to provide
milk. Consequently, a major taboo develops around breastfeeding, namely that surrounding
the sexuality of breastfeeding women. According to the theory of humors, breastfeeding is
incompatible with sexual activities. It is believed that the sexual act itself disturbs
the moods. This is well known. Passion heats up the milk and the child must absolutely
not consume it since it has become poison. The risk of a new pregnancy is also a major
issue. Blood is necessary for the fetus and the milk spoils with a new pregnancy. In summary,
a woman cannot simultaneously fulfill her duties as a wife and her duties as a nursing
mother. Breast milk, like blood, transmits heredity. But not only that, through milk,
the child suckles the character of the woman or animal who feeds him, her physical and
moral qualities as well as her faults. Therefore, a virtuous mother will necessarily give
a virtuous child. Hence the importance of choosing the wet nurse well. Diet, exercise
and emotions must be regulated in order to have quality milk and not transmit disorders
to infants. Their health and even their survival depend on it. Animal milk allows it to improve
or correct the nature of the child. The idea remains the same for a sick child. It is the
nursing mother who will follow the prescribed therapy, diet and medication included. And
the child will consume all the benefits through milk. That said, breast milk is also considered
a medicine in its own right. According to Galen, the Greek physician, women's milk,
especially if consumed at the source, was effective against senile diseases. As late
as the 19th century, milk was considered to treat diseases such as tuberculosis or hemoptysis.
The Christian religion spread across Europe. When the Middle Ages began, the cult of Mary,
Mother of God, had just been authorized by the Church. This is reminiscent of the various
goddess cults like Isis. In addition to having carried and given birth to Jesus, Mary also
fed him with her milk. Which reminds the faithful that Jesus has a dual nature. He is man and
God. Metaphorically, the Virgin's milk is associated with a spiritual and celestial
food, with the Word of God, no more and no less. For Christians, it goes without saying,
Mary occupies a privileged place to intercede on their behalf with God. The Virgin's milk
the life of certain saints like Saint Bernard of Clairvaux who is said to have received
a squirt of milk while he was praying to the Mother of God. Ordinary mortals are not without
rest since it is possible for them to meditate before the relics of the Virgin's milk.
No fewer than 70 church sanctuaries at the beginning of the 20th century aimed to possess
this precious white dust. The Virgin's milk can make a woman's milk flow when she doesn't
have any or cure the illnesses of the saints. The saints, not the saints, that's becoming
mant in any case. Oh yes, and let's also remember that swearing by Mary's breasts
is blasphemous. During the 13th century, many presentation of Mary to the pond can be found
throughout Europe. These are the Maria Lactans. This style is popular and even the mistress
of the King of France, Aigna Sorrel, will have herself depicted as a tempting virgin.
The great painters of the Renaissance up to the 20th century rub shoulders with it, such
as Auguste Renoir and Marie Cassatt. And if praying to Mary is not enough, there are a
host of breasts, saints, not saints here, who can come to the aid of mothers. You understand
there, we can turn to St. Agatha, St. Bridget, St. Christine, St. Trephine, St. Gondron and
St. Maman. The medieval woman inspired by the mother of God can only breastfeed unless
she belongs to the aristocracy. Since antiquity, as I told you a moment ago, elite families
in particular have resorted to wet nursing. The Middle Ages are no exception. The nobility
retains the services of wet nurses for their children. The mother is relieved of her maternal
duties to devote herself to her aristocratic commitments and especially to guarantee the
lineage by producing other children. We recall that sexual relations are prohibited during
breastfeeding. Dynastic issues are particularly important for this social group. In addition,
the Church prefers the wet nursing of infants to having a husband in a situation of sin
of infidelity. In France, the bourgeoisie will follow suit in the 17th century. Then
in the 18th century, wet nursing reaches all classes of urban society, including artisans
and workers. But I'll talk to you about that again in another video. It was in the Middle
Ages that the Church began to prescribe that infants sleep in a separate bed, a cradle.
The risks of suffocation, particularly during nighttime breastfeeding, worried religious
authorities. However, mothers continued to share their bed with their children, the practical
Moreover, in New France, we still face this situation. In 1742, Monsieur de Saint-Vallier
reminded the Canadian women that the Church forbade sleeping with infants. Mothers used
the harsh climate as an excuse to disobey. From the 16th to the 18th century, major societal
changes took place due to the time of the Protestant Reformation and the French Revolution.
Protestants had a completely different relationship with women's bodies and especially with the
For Protestants, the saint was first and foremost a nurturer. Even the taboo of breastfeeding
and sexual intercourse seems less restrictive in Protestant Britain. In addition, the mother
has the sacred duty to breastfeed her children as well as to raise them herself. She nourishes
them in the physiological and spiritual sense. The countries of the Protestant Reformation
will not adopt the fashion of wet nursing which spreads in Europe and particularly in
France. In Protestant England of the 18th and 19th centuries, medical knowledge is widely
disseminated in magazines and newspapers such as The Gentleman's Magazine. Doctors make
observations in two particular contexts. First in the foundling hospitals, orphanages where
infants are entrusted to wet nurses or fed with animal milk. They experiment with different
methods of feeding infants. Then in the lying hospitals, charitable hospitals for mothers.
Doctors note the positive effects of breastfeeding on women's health. They publish their findings in
the press of the time and thus highlight the risks of not breastfeeding. There is a culture
of writing and reading that allows families, even the working classes, to be informed quickly and
therefore to adapt their care according to the most recent scientific discoveries. Moreover,
cholelithiasis, the first milk, was unloved until the 18th century. There could not be a flow of
after childbirth and good milk at the same time. According to the theory of humors, a fast of a
few hours to three days was recommended for the new nose where he was offered different
preparations including sugared water. The lying hospital in particular observed the many advantages
of early breastfeeding for both mothers and babies. In 1748, Dr. William Cadogan published
an essay nursing management of their birth age of age. This work encouraged mayors to breastfeed
and follow the laws of nature rather than resort to mercenary breastfeeding. Cadogan,
like the French surgeon Amboise Paris centuries before him, placed great emphasis on the pleasure
of breastfeeding. The work was reprinted in about 20 English and American editions until
the beginning of the 19th century. With the 18th century and the Enlightenment, doctors,
moralists and philosophers advocated breastfeeding by sea since that was what nature intended.
Moreover, mercenary breastfeeding had become dangerous and unnatural, even immoral since
the wet nurse could exert a bad influence and transmit her life as well as her defects. Not
to mention infections such as syphilis. The philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau and his
Émile published in 1762 advocated breastfeeding by the mother. The philosopher would have an
influence on elite women who were used to putting their little ones out to wet nurses. But this did
not last. Paradoxically, it should be noted that Rousseau abandoned the five children who would
be born with his marriage to Marie-Therese Levesseur to the children. An institution
that took in abandoned or orphaned children. Yeah, that's it. Well done for the consistency,
Rousseau. Several initiatives to encourage breastfeeding will emerge. In Rouen, poor
mothers with large families are subsidized for one year so that they breastfeed. An ancestor
of maternity leave. Before 1760, children were placed with wet nurses. In 1765, it is estimated
that more than 70% of children stayed with their mothers and were breastfed. Even in a hurry in
where the author Boucher created the charitable institute for poor mothers. In 1784, during the
French Revolution, breastfeeding by the mother and Republican values were contrasted with wet
nurses and the decadence of the aristocracy. Furthermore, from a patriotic perspective,
it is the mother's duty to take care of her child and contribute to the nation by raising him or
her as a future citizen, as a worker or as a soldier. Three social phenomena particularly
marked the 19th century industrialization, urbanization and immigration. It rhymes with
densification, promiscuity of populations, poverty and deficient or even completely absent health
infrastructure. Living conditions are particularly difficult in large cities and it is the children
who pay the price. Infant mortality rates are high throughout the West. The main cause of mortality
is diarrhea, also called infant cholera, which is generally more virulent in summer. It is too
often caused by animal milk, mainly from cows, given as a substitute or by the introduction of
porridge itself composed of cows. The solution remains breastfeeding by the mother, but the
growing child must begin to share family meals. And that brings me to talk to you about weaning.
Weaning corresponds to the moment when the family introduces complementary and varied foods.
It ends with the end of breastfeeding. Weaning is done over a short or long period depending
on the context and makes the child vulnerable to gastric problems due to food contamination.
Weaning is intended to be a symbolic as well as a practical gesture. Let me explain.
Since prehistoric times, porridge made of flour and animal feed has been used
in particular to vary the diet of young children. Porridge is given as a supplement to breast milk.
Depending on the era and the community, this is done in the first weeks of the infant's life or
much later. For example, in the 16th century, it was introduced around 7 to 9 months. In the 17th
and 18th centuries, it was rather around 2 to 4 months. If the mother works or if the child is
placed with a wet nurse, porridge is introduced sooner rather than later. It is given to the
child to pre-chew. Pre-chewing food possibly facilitates digestion. The enzymes in the
parent's saliva are transmitted to the child. Porridge is intended to make the infant grow
faster and to introduce the father's share symbolized by cereals in the baby's growth.
This allows the mother to be absent since the porridge can be given by someone else such as
an older child, a grandmother or a neighbor. Three reasons force abrupt weaning. A new pregnancy,
the return of menstruation or the appearance of teeth. The child will already be used to boiling
it if it is given early. However, very often, weaning is gradual and ends with the appearance
of full teeth around 2 years old or even later depending on the child of course.
In an attempt to reduce the infant mortality rate, several initiatives are emerging. Among them,
the establishment of medical and community clinics which aim to raise awareness among
mayors about good practices in infant care. We are particularly targeting poorly educated mayors
in working class and urban areas of course since these are the environments where we know high
mortality rates. In Europe as in Canada, milk drops proliferated in the late 19th century
and early 20th century. The staff of these clinics gave advice, encouraged mayors and
promoted breastfeeding. The milk drop was a silver medal to the working class mother who
was offered weighing in order to monitor the child's development and eventually vaccination
was added. But milk drops were best known for their distribution service. Pasteurized milk
and sterilized bottles. The trend was there in urban areas. Mothers used cow's milk and baby
bottles, but they had little knowledge of sterilization and hygiene, which made it deadly.
It was at the end of the 19th century and the very beginning of the 20th century that doctors
began to recommend training children, a completely new approach of which Dr. Tribie King was one of
the great promoters. Traditionally, the child is fed on demand for a variable duration of time
during the day and night, from 9 to 11 times during the day and 4 to 6 times during the night.
Yes, all this requires a great deal of availability of the sea, but infants cry little and do not use
objects to satisfy their suction needs. From now on, the new nose must learn to control its needs
from birth and to be disciplined. Strict schedule, fixed duration, controlled quantity. Science is
invited into infant feeding. Breastfeeding remains for the entire 19th century, the safest method of
feeding for infants. However, many scientific and technological innovations at the end of the 19th
century and the beginning of the 20th century will change the situation. It starts with pasteur and
pasteurization, then microbiology, which gets mixed up. In the space of about 50 years, cow's milk was
pasteurized and improved to resemble human milk. It was offered in a sterilized and safe container.
Also, from the 1940s, perinatal care became medicalized, which meant taking care of women
during their pregnancy and childbirth as well as newborns. But who took charge? Doctors, nurses
and hospitals. Hygiene standards recommended keeping babies in the nursery to protect them
from infections. And the organization of work also made it more practical for the nursing staff to
keep them in the nursery and bottle feed them according to a routine at a fixed time than to
take them to their parents. The separation of mothers and children as well as bottle feeding
in the first hours of life did not encourage breastfeeding. It was the Who's Baby Friendly
Hospital initiative in the late 1990s that helped initiate a change in the way hospitals did things.
After the Second World War, breastfeeding was in decline, especially in the West.
Companies that produced industrial infant formula launched aggressive promotional campaigns for
their products. Doctors began to recommend this scientific diet that was reliable with known
ingredients rather than breast milk, which was variable in composition, unstable and deficient
in certain nutrients essential for the child's development. Marketing and medical recommendation.
Mothers themselves came to believe that substitute milk was equal to, if not better than,
breast milk. And for those who wanted to breastfeed despite everything, they had to follow
a strict diet and have a healthy lifestyle. In addition to giving their children a supplement
of cod liver oil and orange juice against rickets or scurvy, the abandonment of breastfeeding,
coupled with a significant decline in infant mortality and economic prosperity,
explains the post-war baby boom. It would take the 70s and the counterculture movement,
among others, to see a gradual return to the practice of breastfeeding.
In Canada, for example, between 1965 and 1971, approximately 10% of Quebec women and 30% of
Canadian women breastfed in hospitals. In 1982, it was nearly 60% of Quebec women and 70% of Canadian
women. Data published in 2013 indicate that nearly 90% of Quebec women and Canadian women undertake
to go. However, the battle is unequal between those who have huge budgets to promote commercial
infant formulas and those who promote breastfeeding. In 1981, the World Health Organization adopted the
International Code of Marketing of Breast Milk Substitutes to restrict their promotion.
Canada is one of the 118 signatories to this code. In particular, it prohibits companies from
marketing their products under the name of infant formula or humanized milk. Breastfeeding in the
21st century is taking on a green color. The environmental impact of breastfeeding is less
compared to commercial infant formula. According to Dr. Natalie Senker of Imperial College London
and her colleagues and I quote, breastfeeding a new nose for the first six months of its life
would prevent the production of 95 to 153 kilograms of CO2 caused by the use of commercial
infant formula. An economy class flight from Montreal to Paris generates between 300 kilograms
and 900 kilograms of CO2, not counting the accessories necessary for the use of commercial
infant formula. Breastfeeding and non-breastfeeding are also part of the headlines from time to time.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, health professionals recommended breastfeeding. It has also been shown
that the mother transmits the antibodies of this disease to her child, whether she developed them
following vaccination or the disease. In the spring of 2022, a shortage of commercial hypoallergenic
infant formula hit North America. This shortage was caused by a recall of potentially contaminated
products at the factory. Even today, the risks of contamination of commercial infant formulas
are also current in countries where access to drinking water is an issue. Breastfeeding remains
a key element for infant food safety, particularly in developing countries and even closer to home
in disadvantaged families. Thanks to June DFC Bergeron who wrote this video and to go further,
I recommend the books by Ivan Nibb Beller, Marie-France Morel and I.D.I. All the references
are in the description of this video. Come on, I'm Lore from History Will Tell Us and I'll see
you next time. Come on, bye.
