Principles of Geologic Fieldwork on Planets

Archaeological Discoveries
22 followers
Jan 11, 2025
Watch Prof. Kip Hodges from Arizona State University talk about the principles of geologic fieldwork on planets. This talk was part of the Keck Institute for Space Studies workshop "Space Science Opportunities Augmented by Exploration Telepresence" on October 3, 2016.
Well, welcome everyone.
I'm glad that most of you could make it to this week,
or at least these short courses this morning.
This ought to be a very challenging
and a very interesting topic that we've decided to do.
I have the pleasure of introducing
the four topics that we chose.
What we did was we tried to focus these courses
on what we think is the major issue here,
with a lot of it has to do with science
that you can get from telerobotics
and from what we're doing right now on the actual surface.
So I'm not going to go through too much
of a giveaway of what we're doing,
but so I want to introduce the first person.
First one is my co-lead, Kip Hodges,
and I have to read this for the,
because I've been instructed to.
After 20, not by Kip.
After 23 years of faculty at MIT,
Kip moved to Arizona State University in 2006
to become the founding director
of the School of Earth and Space Exploration.
Kip has done research in the Arctic,
Western North America, Peru,
and the Himalayan-Tibetan orogenic system
of India, Nepal, and Tibet.
His laboratory products include development
of a new laser analytical techniques
for noble gas isotope geochemistry,
and the application of these
and more traditional methods of geochronology
to terrestrial and extraterrestrial problems.
He is active in the development of new approaches
to planetary field geology using human
and robotic exploration strategies.
And just on a side note,
he has been a valid friend in putting this together,
so I'd like to welcome Kip.
Hi, everybody, welcome here.
I'm Eileen's opening act today.
So she's gonna do a fantastic job talking
about actually doing planetary field geology.
I'm gonna talk about actually doing field geology
here on Earth, and the sort of lessons
that it might lend to us when we're thinking
about how to think about new and exciting ways
to do planetary field geology on other parts of the world.
A lot of my engineering friends,
and even some of my geology friends,
have a tendency to believe
that this is what it looks like
to do field geology on Earth.
And it's usually one person working by themselves.
They may take some notes.
They may be excited enough about new technologies
that they might use things like digital compasses,
and they might use GPS to locate themself,
like I'm doing here on this particular shot.
But mainly what they're there to do is
to look at small outcrops,
or look at outcrops in some detail,
and then collect a bunch of samples indicated
by the sampling bags you see below with rock hammers.
It's a very traditional way of doing things.
And other than that little handheld device that I have,
it's not very much different
than somebody might have been doing field geology
in the early 1800s.
But it's a very, I wouldn't say sedentary,
but a contemplative way of doing science.
This is actually the kind of science I do.
This is Everest from the north side
from about 18,000 feet, 18,500 feet, something like that.
And it's an extreme environment
in which to do field geology.
And we have to get around a tremendous amount in the field.
We have to have tremendous amounts of mobility.
This is another mobility strategy in Peru,
coming down the Cotahuasi River.
Those of you who are at NASA might note
the pressurized rover that we're using
for this particular expedition.
But it's a challenging thing
to do this kind of field geology.
And I think it helps us think very carefully
about how we might do field geology on other surfaces.
I want to get out of the way
telling you might take on terrestrial field geology,
that it's primarily an adaptive observational science.
And I think that's very important
when we think about making plans
to do missions to other surfaces.
It's one in which we have to make a decision on the rocks
as we go, as we're doing the science,
how to change the experiment.
And so it's a difficult procedure in that regard
compared to some other types of laboratory science
or even observational science here on Earth.
It relies on abductive and inductive reasoning.
So it's a complicated process of trying to decide
what the relationship is between rock types.
And if you're interested in collecting samples,
what kinds of samples you want to collect.
We don't grab samples.
We go out and collect them purposefully.
It involves progressively disproving
multiple working hypotheses,
which is a concept that was brought to science
actually by the geological community
back in the early 1900s,
with the notion of when you're in the field,
you do not have one hypothesis that you're testing.
You have many hypotheses
and you're trying to reduce the plausible alternatives
for an explanation of a process.
It benefits greatly from having varied perspectives
and it is not simply a matter of collecting samples.
I mean, I think that's one thing
that we have to think about very, very carefully
as important as it is to collect samples
on planetary expeditions.
That's actually sort of the last part of what you do
when you're doing field geology.
I wanna illustrate what some of the complexities are
in doing this kind of geology
when you're thinking about it in terms of,
is this mic working?
Do you think it's working?
Still testing?
Now it's working.
I hear that.
Okay.
So I wanted to start out with a little bit
of sort of a thought experiment for you
about how field geologists
sort of actually go out in the field and do field work.
And here's an example of a topographic map.
I hope you can see it up there.
It doesn't really matter what the contours look like,
but the main thing is that there's one hill
and a slope that comes down from that slope in particular.
And so nowadays, what we'll usually do
is we'll usually use remote sensing data
of one form or another,
and we'll try to make some kind
of a preliminary geologic map of an area
before we go through.
For those of you who aren't familiar with geologic maps,
I'm not gonna go into much detail about them,
but you'll know that all of these dots are contacts
and all of those contacts in there are dotted
and they're dotted because we don't really know
they're there.
We assume that they might be there
based on the observations we make
from the remote sensing data,
but we don't really know they're there.
And so if I'm a geologist and I go into that area
to try and understand what the distribution
of these rock types really are,
I'll probably start at the highest point on this map.
And so I might plan before I ever get into the field
some kind of a traverse that I wanna take,
and maybe it looks like that,
where number one is the place that I start,
two is the place I go next,
the dashed red lines in between
are sort of generalized traverses
about how I might wanna go.
So based on that map,
I might create that kind of traverse in my mind,
okay, before I ever went there.
And you can think about this a little bit like
these are the traverses that were planned out
for the Apollo astronauts, for example.
Okay, it's not much difference in that regard.
But here's the biggest difference.
The biggest difference is that when we get to that high point
in that particular area, point one in this case,
there may be things we see that we did not see
from the remote sensing data.
And we will take advantage of opportunities,
the sort of adaptive approach to field geology
to go from one of those localities
to a locality that's as near to you as possible
to sort of give you a sense of what that geology might be
and allow you to work very much better
when creating a map in particular.
So in reality, I might go from one to two in this case,
and then recognizing that there are other units
that I had not seen before,
farther down the hill toward station number three,
I might go there next.
And then at that point, I have to make a question
about where, I have to ask the question
about where I might go next.
And I'm gonna take advantage
of the route of least resistance.
I'm gonna contour around the hill,
side contour around the hill.
So my path is gonna be substantially different
than the path that I originally started with.
And so it might go three, four, five, and so on.
And at that point, I could potentially get back on track
with my original traverse,
but I probably actually wouldn't.
I would probably continue to contour around,
go look at other outcrops like six and seven and eight
that I might be interested in.
And if I go through that entire process,
I end up with a traverse map after the fact
that looks something like the one on the left hand side.
And based on the observations I made
and perhaps the samples that I took
and the things I looked at and outcrops specifically,
I wind up with a geologic map
like the one that's on the right hand side
that's color coded for different units.
But what's important about this
is that geologic map looks a lot different
than the geologic map that I started with.
Otherwise, why did I even bother
to go out and do field geology in the first place?
And the second thing is that the traverse I ended up taking
is radically different
than the traverse I planned before I started.
And that is totally unlike the Apollo missions, okay?
It's a completely different way of doing field geology.
So as I see it, the problem before us
as we think about doing field geology
on other planetary surfaces
is that the goals and the activities
for the most transformational scientific research
that can be done by humans or their robotic agents
on other planetary surfaces
are the same as those as field geology on Earth.
So field geology on Earth gives us a good place
to think about how we wanna do that in the future.
But the problem is, a problem is,
that the reliance of terrestrial field geology
on novel technology has been extremely limited.
We've not done a lot of good hard work
trying to integrate these kinds of new tools
in the field geology that we do on Earth.
And so I believe we are actually poorly prepared
to take maximum advantage of new and emergent technologies
to develop an advanced approach to planetary field geology.
And so the question is, how do you rectify that?
So to me, future field geology on other planets
may permit few or no second chances.
So that's a design constraint for us.
I mean, honestly, we don't know how many opportunities
we're gonna have in the next many decades
to go to specific exploration targets.
So we're not gonna have many second chances,
and we've gotta do as best we possibly can.
It's not like we can go back out
into the field next weekend.
We'll require extreme efficiency in order to do that
because of the cost of all consumables
and the cost of health and many, many, many other things,
just plain cost.
It could be encumbered by technology if we're not careful.
Those of us who teach field geology
and are trying to use new tools,
even like little handheld GPS sort of devices,
all of us have stories about how it actually got
in the way of teaching the science
because we use those technologies, okay?
So right now, the level, the technical readiness level
of those technologies for field geology
is actually very poor.
It slows us down a lot.
So they could be enabled by technology.
We at least hope that they would be.
They would allow us to do things better
and more efficiently.
And I think that doing field geology on other planets
well in the future is gonna require collaborative,
and I mean direct collaborative efforts
among scientists, engineers,
and astronaut explorers themselves.
I don't think that any one of those groups
is gonna be able to pull that off.
And the goal is to be better than Apollo.
It's not to be like Apollo only in different targets.
It's to be better.
So one of the things we can think about
that we'll probably talk about in the sessions this week
is field observations with augmented reality.
We may be able to do a lot more
than we have been doing before
if we can get those technologies to work
and actually add to the process in the field.
A second is using telescience as an exploration strategy.
And what I mean by telescience is basically
being there doing scientific work in near real time.
So cognitively from the perspective
of doing the work in near real time.
And a third thing that I'm very excited about
is the notion of virtual field geology.
We can download our cognition
to a particular planetary surface,
but we can also upload the planetary surface to us.
And so I think there are lots of opportunities
in that regard as well.
Whatever we do, for sure,
we're gonna be using a lot of robotics.
We use robots as scouts, we use them as collaborators,
and we use them as surrogates,
as we do now in some cases.
And these are going to permit autonomous
or coordinated scientific activities with those agents,
and it'll improve the scope,
it'll minimize our risk as we go forward.
We'll have better options for human surface mobility
than we have had in the past,
certainly than we had at Apollo.
And we'll probably have better options for that mobility
than we do right now
when we're doing terrestrial field geology as well.
I prefer this pressurized rover
to the one that gets you wet, for example.
And so how do you go forward with this?
So number one to me
is that we have to explore technology alternatives
rather than just come up with new technologies
and then take them out in the field and see if they work.
The approach that I would take to this
is to define and refine the science goal.
I'd lead with science,
as in the upper left-hand corner of this diagram.
And the color coding on these diagrams
is that that sort of burnt orange sort of a color
is where I think that science input is absolutely critical,
and the blue is when engineering input
is absolutely critical.
So I'd start with refining and defining science,
and then I would move over
to identifying plausible enabling technologies, right?
So basically, the technologies derived from the definition
and the refinement of the science goals in particular.
Then we build and we test those possible instruments
on lab benches to a certain extent in the field.
But then finally, we get the scientists
and the engineers back together
to assess and refine those instruments specifically.
You know, this is an instrument I can use.
This is an instrument that will do me some good
when I'm trying to do field work.
And that feeds back into a refinement
of the science goals again.
And then we just continue going through
this kind of a loop in particular
until we have a set of tools
that seem like they're gonna be an effective set of tools.
To make this work,
we're gonna have to do some basic training, I think.
And the first kind of basic training
is scientist basic training.
Scientists have to understand the engineering
and operational challenges of planetary field geology.
I mean, I think it's interesting
that I've heard so many conversations
among field geologists or planetary field geologists
and engineers that sort of have this expectation
that there will be a tricorder
that they'll be able to use, you know, somewhere.
And it will be a very easy, interesting thing.
And I think a lot of scientists, myself included,
don't fully understand all of the constraints
that are placed by those guiding principles of engineering
and what's possible now
or what might be possible in just a few years.
The curriculum for that kind of training
has to include the risks and cost of planetary exploration.
I think that's very important as we go through.
It's not a blue sky kind of a situation.
There are constraints.
And the pedagogy has to emphasize optimization of activities
to minimize risks and costs,
like energy and oxygen consumption
and all that sort of thing.
On the other hand, the engineers need basic training too.
So the first is that engineers have to understand
the challenges of planetary field geology.
It's not like a simple sortie that we plan ahead of time
will do the trick.
It's not like collect any old sample will do the trick.
So the curriculum has to include scientific motivations
and practical goals for planetary surface exploration
so we feel like we're all in this together.
And the pedagogy has to emphasize
optimization of activities to maximize the scientific return
not just to, if we wanna do scientific research
on other planets and make that a fundamental goal
rather than something we do in addition
to other kinds of things,
we have to figure out how to make the activities work
in such a way that they optimize the scientific return.
The other step that I think we need to do
is I think we need to look at science operations
or what I'll call sci-ops today as a research problem, right?
Not as something that we can just go out in the field
and do this, we already know how to do the science
because I think we don't.
So we have to treat science operations
on planetary surfaces as a research domain
rather than just something we already know how to do well
and just need practice at it.
We have to design, execute and assess the results
of integrated laboratory and field experiments
in a meaningful way.
So for example, if you say that it is an important thing
to collect samples on a planetary surface
so that we can come back here and run them,
then you'd best know that the techniques
that you use to collect them will actually give you samples
that will give you important scientific results.
And that's something that's missing
in many of our planning structures today.
So I think you have to integrate
not just the collection of the samples
but the actual analysis of the samples
and the evaluation of whether those were good samples.
And we also have to focus experiments
on technology enabled adaptive problem solving
where the problems are defined
by larger science goals in particular.
So I would like to see all of that kind
of science operations research be motivated
by specific science goals.
Do we know we have to collect samples for geochronology?
If we do, then we best start doing geochronology
in collaboration with the process
of doing the science operations.
So when we start looking at planetary surfaces
and I'll show you a few views of Mars here,
I wanna give you a sense of what the problems are
when I look at these things,
not as someone like Eileen who's involved in Curiosity,
I look at it as from the perspective of somebody in geology,
what would I do if I were dealing with this on Earth?
And if I see a landscape like Mount Sharp on Earth,
what I'm looking for,
I look at that as an extremely daunting enterprise.
And I begin to think,
where am I gonna go with these traverses
very quickly up those ranges
so that I can get the best possible understanding
of what's going on in an area.
And you're limited by technology right now
in the way you can do this,
but if you have better mobility,
if you have either astronauts acting virtually
or you have robotic assets that'll be able to do it,
the goal is to do very fast, rapid reconnaissance
over a relatively large area
if you wanna understand this kind of a landscape
moving forward.
If you move down to outcrop scale science,
there's a lot of things that we can say
looking at an outcrop like this
that invites questions that you might not have been able
to see from orbit.
And in this case, I think if you look closely,
let's see if this does work.
So if you look closely,
you'll see a lot of little white veins
that are cutting across the rocks
in this particular area,
dominantly dark rock, white veins cutting across it.
And that's a relationship that as geologists
immediately piques our interest
because we know there are two different generations
of material in there,
and we really wanna know what the relationships are
between that white material and the dark material.
You can tell that from here.
You don't need to have a photomicrograph of an area
to be able to see that.
You know where you wanna look.
You can target your research on that particular area.
And what we need is we need to make sure
that the engineers working on the problem,
the scientists working on the problem,
the astronauts who are actually gonna do the work
already have a sense of that, boom,
as they go into the process.
And then if you look at a much smaller,
kind of a much closer in kind of a thing,
there are all kinds of questions that this asks,
and a lot of them are process-related questions
like what's causing this kind of cross-bedding
that you can see in those rocks up here?
A lot of people in this room already know this,
but it's interesting how many people
don't think about these things that way.
So it's gonna require multi-perspective approaches
and a change in the way you do science,
a change in the science ops,
depending on what scale you're looking
at a particular problem.
And this is my favorite of all.
This is a photograph from Mars
of what is very clearly a sedimentary rock, okay?
It's a combination of a lot of different rocks,
a lot of different pebbles, different combinations in here.
And just like on Earth,
there is a wealth of information associated with that
in terms of the age of the materials,
the relationship among the materials,
what was the history of the sedimentary rock
after it was deposited?
What does it tell you about the source region that you see?
It's an amazing, amazing rock
that you would make a very, very high-priority target
of collection if you were going to collect samples
going into the future.
So the way I would do science operations research
is a little bit like that, like this.
I would start out by designing an operations experiment.
Here's a question that we want to retire.
We wanna understand more about the answer to this question
with regard to doing scientific operations.
And then I would go into a mode
of working with engineers and scientists
to define and refine the operations protocol
in a particular example.
Then I would next evaluate the efficiency.
Is that protocol gonna be fast?
Is it gonna be agile, okay?
Again, in collaboration with the scientists
and the engineers.
And then I would move forward
to trying to evaluate the quality of the science return
that we're getting back.
So in many cases, it means things like
collecting the samples
and going through the science return,
figuring out whether it's high science return
or low science return.
And then put these two things,
this evaluation of efficiency
and the quality of the science return back in the box
and continue to optimize this
until we feel we've got a good stable system
that's working well.
And then finally go out
and evaluate the experimental outcomes,
both from the perspectives of engineering
and the perspectives of science.
Step three, which I think is really important,
is effective astronaut basic training.
Here's a photograph of some training
that Jose and I were, Jose up here,
we'll see him later on this week, sitting right over there.
And Jose and I were working on
with some of the last class of astronaut candidates
in Northern New Mexico a couple of years ago.
And some of the things we were doing,
most of the things we were doing with this exercise
were classic traditional field geology.
They're no different than I would use
teaching graduate students and undergraduate students
how to do field geology 30 years ago, okay?
But that's what we were doing with the astronauts
just a couple of years ago.
I think we can do better than doing that kind of geology.
So first, astronaut explorers,
only some of whom might be geologists,
must be schooled in the essentials
of planetary field science.
And they have to be schooled with the advanced technologies
that we might be able to use.
So that's why they need to be in this process
of science operations development.
The curriculum needs to include scientific context,
field observation, instrument deployment,
and sample collection,
not just going out in the field
and looking at samples in particular.
The pedagogy has to emphasize the value
of multiple perspectives
and multiple working hypotheses going in.
It's a fantastic way to think
when you're doing field geology,
and it's not a difficult thing for people to learn.
And they need to understand the notion
of doing on-the-fly problem solving.
It's not just about collecting data.
It's about solving problems on the field in real time.
And a goal should be to educate them
to contribute to science ops experiment
as part of their preparation
for future planetary surface research, okay?
Not just learn how to use it,
but help learn how to develop it.
And I think that many astronauts would be stoked for that.
Right, Nick?
Right, okay.
So here are my takeaway messages for today.
The first is we are ill-prepared
for optimal planetary field geology.
We are not there yet.
The second is that care has to be taken
to avoid adding complexity just because we can.
We have to add and not subtract
as we move forward with technology.
Because it is possible, I guarantee you,
to subtract if you use technology in too cavalier a way.
The effective preparations are gonna require
recursive efforts among scientists,
engineers, and astronaut explorers.
It has to be a recursive process.
We cannot throw these ideas over the transom
from one of us to the next, okay?
We can't have engineers,
here's my new technology, go out and try it.
We can't have scientists say, here's my science goals,
figure out some way to make me be able to do this.
I think we can do better than that.
And I also wanna say that there's a great value
for field geologists who only work on Earth
to be involved in this process
because of the feedback associated with it.
I also think that right now we do field geology on Earth
in an extremely rudimentary way.
I mean, we go out, like I said,
and we do it not much different
than the way it was done in the early 1800s.
Little bit of new technology, but that's about it.
And so I think that we can begin
to take the new enabling technologies
that are built for, in a prototype sense,
for field geology on other planetary surfaces,
and we could interject those directly
into field geology processes here on Earth.
And that is the fastest way to make sure
that we troubleshoot them,
we get them working really, really well.
And I personally think it could revolutionize
terrestrial field geology.
So with that, I'd rather have a conversation
than continue to talk at you.
So thank you very much for listening,
and let's, questions, answers, comments?
Let's go.
Thank you.
