Supreme Court Hears Arguments Over TikTok Ban

China in Focus - NTD
3.8K followers
94 Video Views·Jan 11, 2025
Welcome to China In Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer. Our top story.
The Supreme Court hearing arguments over TikTok's fate in the U.S.
The Chinese app is teetering on the edge of a ban that's just nine days away.
We have the key takeaways.
The Central Intelligence Agency tripling its budget for China-based targets.
CIA Director William Burns details the challenges that lie ahead.
Chinese-made connected cars might soon face their final days in the U.S.
Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo said a rule to crack down on the high-tech
imports is in its final stages. That's to tackle concerns over data and national security.
And reports from two Chinese mothers highlight a concerning trend.
Too many people are sick in China and hospitals are struggling to serve demand.
What we know so far.
To ban or not to ban. The Supreme Court hearing oral arguments over TikTok's fate Friday.
A law dictates the app be banned in nine days unless it divests from its Chinese parent company.
President-elect Trump has tried to postpone the deadline.
NTT's Jason Blair has more.
Does the January ban on TikTok violate the First Amendment?
The nation's highest court heard oral arguments on Friday.
That they would use that information over time to develop spies, to turn people,
to blackmail people, people who a generation from now will be working in the FBI or the CIA
or in the State Department. Is that not a realistic
assessment by Congress and the president of the risks here?
Well, your honor, I'm not disputing the risks. I certainly acknowledge
the risk, but I think there are lots of reasons, not just the one I just gave,
but there are lots of reasons why that risk still can't justify the law.
The legislation enacting the ban argues that TikTok poses national security risks,
cybersecurity threats, and could be an avenue for propaganda.
This is due to the ability the Chinese Communist Party has to control the app.
TikTok and ByteDance's arguments aren't primarily against the risks the ban is citing. However,
even with the risks, they argue that the law is violating free speech.
So are we supposed to ignore the fact that the ultimate parent is in fact subject
to doing intelligence work for the Chinese government? It seems to me that you're
ignoring the major concern here of Congress, which was Chinese manipulation of the content
and acquisition and harvesting of the content.
The government's real target rather is the speech itself. It's feared that Americans,
even if fully informed, could be persuaded by Chinese misinformation.
That, however, is a decision that the First Amendment leaves to the people.
When the court will make a decision on the case is not yet clear,
but if TikTok's parent company, China-based ByteDance, does not divest from the app,
by January 19th, it will be banned in the U.S. starting January 20th.
Any entities that still carry TikTok after then could face big penalties like $5,000 for each
user determined to have downloaded, updated, or maintained the app through a store's platform.
Reporting outside the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., Jason Blair, Entity News.
The CIA tripling its budget for China-related targets. In an NPR interview,
CIA Director William Burns detailed the agency's plan to
counter China's growing influence in tech and its cyber threats.
Burns revealed the CIA has tripled its China-focused budget to 20 percent of the agency's
total funding, reflecting a commitment to addressing China's rapid technological advancements.
He called China's tech revolution a pivotal challenge in the global power competition.
He also highlighted efforts to, quote,
Burns cited a cyber attack from Chinese hacking group Salt Typhoon last year,
targeting two U.S. telecom companies.
He called it a reminder of China's cyber sophistication and the need for urgent CIA focus.
Outgoing Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo says her department has a new regulation in the works
and will target China's auto imports as early as next week.
She said there are at least two million Chinese cars here in the U.S.
that could pose threats against American people, and the government needs to address it.
NTD's Flora Hua is following the story. Flora, what can you tell us?
Yes, Tiff, the new rule mainly takes aim at Chinese software and hardware used in vehicles.
Roughly a year ago, the Commerce Department launched a probe into imports of what are
These connected cars can communicate with other devices, and they can collect data
on both the roads they drive on and their passengers by linking up with smartphones.
Here's a concern. The government says that collected data could pose a major
risk to U.S. national security if it ends up in adversaries' hands.
The Commerce Department specifically called out China in a statement about the new regulation.
Officials say the new measure is now in its final stage before being implemented.
That's after the department opened a channel to collect public comments from the industry.
The new rule could essentially ban Chinese-made connected cars from entering the U.S. market.
A push to prevent U.S. biotechnology from falling into Beijing's hands,
the House Select China Committee is urging the Biden administration
to restrict exports of U.S. biotechnology to China's military.
They say American companies should have to get a license before working with Chinese military
hospitals. That's over concerns that Beijing could weaponize biotech to develop toxic pathogens.
Here's a closer look.
They raised concerns about risks to national security,
health care and medical data in a letter to Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo.
The move reflects growing alarm over China's expanding role in biotechnology.
In August, lawmakers called on the FDA to increase scrutiny of U.S. clinical trials in China,
citing intellectual property theft and reports of forced Uyghur participation in those trials.
They say U.S. firms have worked with Chinese military-run hospitals,
including in Xinjiang. Human rights abuses against Uyghurs have been documented in the region.
Next, some updates on a recent uptick of another virus inside China,
influenza A. A local Chinese news agency recently shared a report from a mother living in Beijing.
She was trying to book a doctor's appointment when her child came down with a fever and started
coughing, common symptoms of respiratory diseases. She discovered that getting medical attention
wouldn't be so easy. She said two hospitals she visited were over capacity. One of them
said there would be a three-hour wait for the emergency room. The third hospital she went to
finally accepted her child, but said there were 1,000 patients waiting to be seen ahead of them.
Another mother from Wuhan said she encountered the same challenge when seeking a doctor for her son
who displayed similar symptoms. Likewise, she described the hospital's lobby as
full of waiting patients. Both mothers' experiences happened in recent weeks.
China's foreign ministry dismissed concerns Friday after some suggested a recent surge of
a different virus called HMPV could lead to a global pandemic. Beijing argues the virus is
just a common respiratory disease. Beijing has a history of covering up the true data on
catastrophes and pandemics. We'll keep you updated on the latest about the virus through
NTD's exclusive channels, which allow us directly to talk to people living in mainland China.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford has called China the primary concern for trade imports and is urging
a shift in focus from tensions between Canada and the U.S. In a Fox News interview, Ford accused
China of using Mexico as a backdoor to import cheap goods into the U.S. and Canada, harming
both American and Canadian jobs. He also criticized China for hijacking global supply chains to
unfairly benefit its own companies at the expense of U.S. industries and communities.
U.S. lawmakers have echoed concerns about China's control over global supply chains,
identifying it as a top priority. Efforts are underway to de-risk the U.S. economy from China
and its global proxies. It's an ambitious shift and a dramatic one compared to recent decades.
Amid the tensions, Ford reaffirmed Canada's commitment to support the U.S. as an ally
during this time. The U.S. has taken steps in response to China's massive breach into
major U.S. telecom networks. That's according to U.S. National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan.
In an unprecedented breach months ago, Chinese hackers accessed AT&T and Verizon's networks,
tracking locations of millions of Americans. Does the hack suggest that China could cripple
the U.S. network in times of war? Casey Fleming, CEO of Black Ops Partners, weighs in.
There are growing reports of Chinese state-backed hackers lying in wait in critical U.S.
infrastructure. This is from Volt Typhoon to Salt Typhoon, the names of these hacker groups,
which was making headlines in regards to the telecommunication hacks we saw recently with
Verizon, AT&T and other major networks. First, what do you make of the potential scale of these
attacks? Significant. They've been at it for many, many years, and they've perfected their
craft. So the scale, I think, is beyond what most people realize. It's something that's
extremely significant. Don't forget, we trained all these youngsters in our U.S. universities
alongside our own kids in cybersecurity. So they've got degrees in MIS, cybersecurity and so on.
So we've trained a lot of these PLA soldiers to come back around and hack us, not to mention to
train the trainer once they got back to China. So we helped create the problem by educating them,
thinking that they were on a peaceful rise, but they certainly weren't.
In a secret meeting at the White House in 2023, National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan said,
this is according to the Wall Street Journal, that, quote,
to shut down dozens of U.S. ports, power grids and other infrastructure targets that will,
adding the attack, could threaten lives. Now, what is the likelihood that the Chinese
hackers have the ability to do that? 100 percent. Like I said, they've been
doing this for years. They've perfected their craft. Before, they were kind of just clumsy
inside the networks. Now, they're kind of experts in our networks. And on top of that,
our networks are very complex. They're very human driven. And there are a lot of holes within
our networks, the hardware, the software and so on. The biggest thing is the patches. When we
find vulnerabilities, companies are always way behind on installing the patches. And that's
usually how the CCP and the Russians, North Koreans, Iranians get into our networks,
is through known vulnerabilities that are not patched.
And given these vulnerabilities and Chinese hackers flying in, what would that look like
in times of a war? Could it cripple our entire network or what would that look like?
100 percent. Remember, our entire economy and the entire, pretty much the world's economy,
is based on computers now. And computers have that vulnerability. Unless you section them off
and protect them, which we haven't done and haven't had the capability to do for quite a long
period. Like I said, we have to go back to the building blocks of hardware, software and networks.
But yes, in a time of war, which by the way, we are in a war right now with the Chinese Communist
Party and China. It's unrestricted war. It's not conventional war yet with planes, guns,
bombs, ships and troops. But we're in a war. This is a cyber war. This is an unrestricted
war. It's a drug war. It's all those type of things. But in times of conventional war,
absolutely, they can shut down sections of our supply chain that we supply our military.
They can shut down cities as far as water, electricity, natural gas, gasoline,
all these type of things, hospitals, even trading exchanges. So think about that,
airlines, trading exchanges and so on. Once they get into these networks through vulnerabilities,
remember this software is not sold just to one customer. The software is sold to hundreds and
sometimes many thousands of customers. So the vulnerabilities are beyond most people's
comprehension. Casey Fleming, thank you so much for your time. Thanks for having me.
Coming up, Britain's treasury chief is seeking to build up economic ties with
China. This despite recently exposed security threats traced back to alleged Chinese spies.
Germany charging three people as alleged spies for China. But they're accused of stealing to
help advance China's maritime power. And Japan's foreign minister scheduling a rare visit to South
Korea. This after its new prime minister postponed a visit to the US and expressed wishes to visit
China. A closer look at Japan's diplomatic dance after the break here on China In Focus.
Welcome back to China In Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer. Britain is seeking closer trade ties with
China. The UK's top three finance chiefs are visiting the Asian nation alongside senior
bank heads. This despite recently exposed security threats tied to alleged Chinese spies
and economic turmoil in the UK. NTD's international correspondent Malcolm Hudson has the story.
British Chancellor Rachel Reeves is in China seeking to boost trade relations. It's part of
the Labour government's broader aim to reset ties between the two nations. She will be visiting
Beijing and Shanghai. Reeves' trip is expected to restart the China-UK economic and financial
dialogue. It's an annual bilateral talk that has been suspended since 2019 due to the Covid-19
pandemic. As well as by deteriorating relations between the UK and China in recent years,
the trip comes amid market turmoil in the UK. Government borrowing costs have gone up while
the pound has dropped in value. The British Treasury said the delegation to China includes
Bank of England Governor Andrew Bailey and the UK Financial Conduct Authority chief executive.
Representatives from some of Britain's biggest financial service firms will also join the trip.
Officials did not provide details but media reports have said senior executives from HSBC
Holdings and Standard Chartered were included. Reeves' visit comes after Foreign Secretary
David Lammy travelled to China in October and Prime Minister Keir Starmer met with Chinese
leader Xi Jinping in Brazil in November. Officials said Starmer wants a pragmatic approach to working
with Beijing on global security and climate change. However, some in the opposition conservative party
have said trade should not come at the expense of national security and human rights concerns.
British political leaders and intelligence chiefs have warned repeatedly of the security threats
that China poses. Calls grew louder last month when it emerged an alleged Chinese spy had
cultivated close ties with Prince Andrew. According to officials, the alleged spy carried out covert
and deceptive activity for the Chinese Communist Party. Malcolm Hudson, NTD News, London.
A case of suspected Chinese espionage in Germany. Prosecutors charged three German nationals for
working with a Chinese secret service. They're accused of stealing maritime technology with
potential military uses. Here's more. The three suspects are a married couple and another man.
They allegedly used a company owned by the couple to get in touch with companies and scientific
institutions. Prosecutors say the goal was to gain knowledge that could be useful for the expansion
of China's maritime power. The three allegedly collected information on boat engines, sonar
systems, aircraft protection systems and more. They then allegedly passed this information onto
a contact person from a Chinese spy agency. The three Germans are now facing espionage charges.
Japan is greenlighting new sanctions against Russia over its invasion of Ukraine.
Japan's sanctions will freeze assets tied to dozens of individuals and groups.
Worth noting, Russia is a close partner to China. Let's dive in.
Exports to organizations in Russia and several other countries that have allegedly helped to
evade sanctions are also banned. The new sanctions follow Japan's previous rounds,
strengthening pressure on Russia. The latest measures add 11 individuals,
29 organizations and three banks to Japan's asset freeze list.
Japanese foreign minister will visit South Korea on Monday to strengthen security ties.
He will meet with South Korean officials to discuss coordination on North Korea
and broader regional concerns. His visit is the first by a Japanese foreign minister in seven
years. It comes amid growing tensions with China. Japan is performing a delegate dance between
relations with the U.S. and China. The country's new prime minister recently delayed a planned
trip to the U.S. while expressing wishes to visit China. The Chinese foreign ministry responded,
saying Beijing is willing to continue dialogue with Japan on all levels.
That's all for today's China In Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer. If you have any feedback on the show or
have something you'd like to see us cover, send us an email at chinainfocusntd.com. We'd love to
hear from you. For on-the-clock original news coverage, visit us at ntd.com or download our
NTD app. Thanks for watching. See you soon.
