Can better connectivity boost rural business?

IT Pro
169 followers
75 Video Views·Jan 10, 2025
Anyone who works outside of a major city or has ever tried to get work done while on a trip to a
more rural location knows that rural connectivity can be patchy. Despite the UK's high population
density and relative lack of difficult terrain, rural connectivity remains an uneven picture.
Many rural businesses are still struggling to receive fibre optic cables, let alone leverage
5G signals to keep up with the demands of modern business. Is UK connectivity improving and how
far have we still got to go? You're listening to the ITPro podcast. Hi, I'm Jane McCallion.
And I'm Rory Bathgate. Today we're speaking to David Happy, non-executive director at Jet
Connectivity and non-executive chairman at Transport for Wales, Fibre, and Colin Wood,
innovation lead at Dorset Council, to unpack the state of rural connectivity in the UK.
David, Colin, welcome. Thank you. Hello.
So, a nice easy start to the conversation. What is the current state of UK connectivity?
Well, it's, from a rural perspective, slightly frustrating, I think. We had the Telecommunications
Act right back in 1984. Enshrined in it, and in the subsequent 2003 Act, was always the desire
to try to avoid two tiers of connectivity quality. It's not just enough to have coverage, we want
capacity as well. It was never the intention, I don't think, on the part of anybody, to lead,
to end up in a situation where rural was lagging quite considerably behind urban. But unfortunately,
that's where we're at. And two things, certainly on the mobile side, the recent 3G switch off
has actually meant coverage has been slightly worse. And I'm going to hand over to Colin to
explain a little bit on that. And of course, within BDUK, that programme has also had some
impact to the good, but perhaps not as much as we might have liked. Colin, you had some specifics
on that, I think. Yeah, we've got one of the most elderly populations in the UK. And clearly,
a lot of our technologies to support those older people are built around cellular technologies,
and traditionally have used 2G and 3G signals. Obviously, if that signal is repurposed for very
good reason, but disappears from a particular location, that can be a real problem for local.
So yeah, something that we're kind of conscious is done for the right reasons,
but in the short term is leading to some difficulties. So those are the kinds of
issues we face in rural locations, but probably in urban ones as well. Yeah, I mean, that's another
one as well. And I think there's good intent on everybody's part to try to fix this. But it's,
if it was easily fixable, we'd have fixed it 40 years ago, because that's the number we're
talking about. BDUK, for example, even after that work has finished in Dorset,
there'll be a roughly 80,000 trends that don't have adequate connectivity. And that's really a
problem. The last thought I'd leave you with, look at how on the regulatory side things have lagged.
I think it was only from memory 2017, 2018, that we had a broadband universal service obligation of
a whopping two megabits. Before that, I can remember universal service obligation for a
telephony line at 64 kilobit. And I'm willing to vouch safe that I think current capacity statistics,
most people would easily be using hundreds of megabits today. And we want to do the same in
rural areas, just like people can in urban ones. And I don't see any technical reason why we can't.
We'll come back to the 3G element. But looking at the kind of the infrastructure side of things,
the capacity side of things, you know, this can be a problem in rural areas. One of the things
about not just England, but the UK is that you can go from a urban environment to a very rural
environment incredibly quickly. Is this due to, or is it connected to some of the wider issues
around investment in infrastructure more broadly in rural areas? Like it's a lot easier to lay
broadband cable when you're digging up a road. If you're not digging up the roads,
then you don't really have that opportunity to just do everything all at the same time.
Are these two, is there a link there or am I barking up the wrong tree?
Well, I think I got the question, but I might put it slightly differently.
Okay.
I phrased it along the lines of, well, what is the problem here?
McKinney is one. And what you're talking about is key to the invest 2035
and green paper, which we can come on to in due course, if you wish. But essentially,
there are two variables here. One of them is the cost to build a network. It's going to cost
to build and to operate it. The next one is how much revenue can you extract from that network?
And is there an element of trade off between the two? And can you stack additional revenues in to
make more money? So that's at the core of the problem. And it's been the same problem on and
off for 40 years. It's just, how do we optimise that? So, we've done some innovative things,
including, we took particular heed of the minister's comments that connected Britain
relating to things like track to train. And I think Colin, you've been doing some work on the
train side, haven't you? Yeah, we've been doing a really interesting project with the department
for science, innovation and technology. And hopefully, we have created certainly the UK's
first Wi-Fi connected steam train. Maybe the world's first, we can't find another one. But I
don't want to make that claim unless I'm 100% certain. But yeah, this is essentially a project
to provide passengers on the Swanage railway with connectivity as they pass through the beautiful
perfect Dorset countryside. Lovely project, but obviously done for a very, very kind of
broader reason, which is can you connect a vehicle, something that's moving, using low
earth orbit satellites and cellular connectivity? And if you can do that on a train, could you do
it, you know, in a fleet of cars that deliver social care to elderly people in very rural
locations? So how can we use those technologies to deliver our services, you know, in a more
future-proof way in a more efficient way? And let's face it in a cheaper way, because
local authorities across the UK are up against it in terms of their finances. So yeah, interesting
project, and done for hopefully broader reasons than just the steam train, but it is a nice thing.
And also probably worth mentioning, Wi-Fi 6. And with a view to looking at upgrading to Wi-Fi 7 once
we can get equipment at prices that look more reasonable than they are today, because
obviously bonding of frequencies would mean that we could begin to deliver some serious capacity.
And I'd mentioned just in passing in Wales, we've been looking at what we might be able to do with
millimetre wave, because now that we have trackside fibre throughout the core valley lines,
that's a really useful thing. And if you put that knowledge together with what Dorset's doing,
then we begin, Jane, to tackle your question, because there is a circularity in the relationship
between urban and rural. There always has been. If you want to keep eating in London,
you better keep making sure we drive our tractors in Dorset. It's really quite simple.
So I think that's an important angle. The stackable use cases is still an issue,
but I think we should focus a little bit on the cost to build these networks. So discussions
around neutral hosts, fibre and water. If only we could have got the drinking water inspectorate to
approve something a couple of years ago, we'd have been able to look at something in that domain.
But I think they were concerned about the age of the plant that they have, and they were worried
about the health quality side of that. And I accept that. I noticed that it's been deployed
in at least 10 other countries in the world. I also note that the patents were all from the UK.
So kind of sad that sometimes tech comes up that you can't exploit that would have helped a rural
area. But, you know, you can't win them all, I suppose. I love what's going on with the
railways. You talk about future-proofing, Colin, using a kind of very antiquated technology at
this point. Nice, because I've been down to Didcot as well. It strikes me that it's a good example,
just kind of more broadly, of how you can do something that is innovative and quirky to
make a point and to show how something really can work, even if it's not necessarily something
that you're going to replicate across the entire rail network. Yeah, so, you know, we've talked
about disseminating the learnings across other heritage railway networks in the UK, but that's
kind of missing the point in a way. It's how do you transfer the learnings and the technology to
other moving things in a rural context using the technology that's available to us today,
whether that's cellular technology or the latest generation of satellites. So, interesting stuff,
but kind of not really about trains, as you say. It is about a train in this case, but
could be about social care vehicles, could be about bin lorries, could be about anything that
moves that needs a connection to be stable enough to do something interesting. And in a rural
context, that could be anything from, you know, vehicles moving to something that's static,
actually, like a wind farm, you know. We think about rural locations and a lot of the things that
urban locations depend on to survive, like sustainable energy, are not done in urban
environments but in a rural context. So, the connectivity is needed in the rural context
almost more than, if not as much as, in an urban context. And I wonder how easy it would be.
I know it's not as easy as it seems, but if you think of the number of terabits of submarine cables
that flow between Cornwall and London, if only I could have a couple of them for myself, I'd be
really happy. All my farms would be really well connected along that particular part of the route.
If only we'd have got the chambers in earlier. No, so never mind. I think the other thing to mention
with the train stuff, clearly, safety must always be paramount. Nobody must ever be placed in any
kind of risk or in any kind of danger. So, intelligently thinking about what equipment
can be sited where is very important. And if we're able to make sure that we could put up a
mast that's safe and secure and that might be able to, for example, not only face up and down the track,
not only receive satellite services, but have a fixed radio access connectivity that serves the
local old folks home or the local tank museum, Bovington being an example. I'm thinking of real
places here. We can see cheaper ways of filling that gap where there's 80,000 premises that are
unserved by the UK. I desperately want to mention, well, I mentioned it now, rural bus services
are possible for connectivity. But before we, we're going to go very far down Jane's special
interest route if we carry on going this way. I was going to say, I think the image of the train
is also something that will resonate with most people in the UK, you know, especially getting it
working on a steam train is kind of a good thing to light fire under innovators because most
people have been in a situation where the train Wi-Fi just doesn't work. And it's a great kind of
symbol for the connectivity failure that we are seeing that you've been describing.
I was wondering, David, if you could explain a little bit more about fibre and water, and then
we can talk a little bit more about LEO satellites as well. But just for those who don't
know, what are the main benefits of it and what is it an alternative to? Sure. Fibre and water,
I think today would be more of a niche technology, particularly well suited to rural areas.
And the concept would be that you've got this inert glass fibre inside a polytube,
which therefore isn't going to, everything is fully inert. So the idea would be since everybody
has mains water, wouldn't it be great if the mains water infrastructure in the United Kingdom,
in particular in rural areas, is capable of safely making this deployment work? Now,
it appears in other countries where the core network of the water industry is perhaps more
modern than it is in the UK, that it's much easier for them. Now, given that we've got all kinds of
mixtures of iron, lead and goodness only knows what else there, I'm sure that in some cases,
the water companies are probably wondering sometimes exactly what might be there, because
it might have been there for a considerable number of years. And I have sympathy and I
respect that. But I was very surprised because there was a court that I think it was in the
DCMS days. And we did look at doing some tests in Dorset to see whether or not that would be a
quick and easy way to get fibre to really remote locations. You know, I'm thinking in Wales,
Sennybridge, clearly in Dorset, we've got a huge amount of area, Lulworth Ranges, places where
this technology could really help people really quickly. And it's easy to get it into the tubes
and to get it to serve end users. But the technology never really took off. Not that
it doesn't have a role. I think in the access network, it very much does still have a role.
But the numbers of places that are going to now require it and are going to be reducing slowly
with time. And by the time that the UK's plant will be perhaps suitably resilient to cope with
it, I think the opportunity may have already gone. And I believe the company that held the
patents, I don't think is UK owned anymore, which is a terrible sadness. Because, you know, we do
all this work, we come up with all this innovation in the UK. Time after time, there's people like
Colin and I doing our Heath Robinson bit on the train, trying to find cheap, sensible, practical
ways to get common sense solutions out to the people that were there to serve and help. And
it's really frustrating sometimes. I think fibre in water fits into the really frustrating category
for us. I wish that the boat has sailed. I was just wondering, this kind of taking us back a
little bit to an earlier part of the conversation. If part of the problem here, you know, just is
return on investment, a lot of the infrastructure that is laid in terms of fibre in this country,
if not all of it, is privately done. That's, you know, for better or worse. If you are
laying fibre out to one of the villages that I know in sort of South Wiltshire, North Dorset,
where you've got a couple of hundred people live there, and obviously most of those are families,
so you've got like 25 to 50 houses, getting back the money that it's going to take to put that
infrastructure in is going to take a really, really long time. And there is no guarantee that
whoever it was who laid it will be the ones who get, you know, finally break even down the line.
Is there anything that can be done to square this circle, you know, either incentivise
private companies to lay better infrastructure into truly rural areas,
or somehow compensate them for doing so? Yes, I think there is. We saw the beginnings,
or we've seen the beginnings in the past few years of local authority in co-invested fibre
optic spines. Okay, I can think of about a dozen, Liverpool, Stoke, Spring immediately to mine,
I think historically there may have been one in Colchester. And these were areas where there was
evident market failure. I know Surrey and Hampshire looked at one through their LEP,
but as a result of the LEP being abolished, the thing never actually happened. That would have
happened because it was agreed and part of the funding was contributed by the then MHCLG,
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government. Now, also, I look at Sweden,
and I see, for example, in the greater Stockholm area, that the local authorities and municipalities
actually own the fibre. Now, there's no rule that says if somebody is not willing to make the
commercial investments or don't think that the returns are adequate, that we should not be
thinking about looking at this in the context of market failure. Clearly,
BDUK is putting public money in in a certain way, but fibre optic spines, I think,
could provide an enormous help. And not only that, especially if you can look at other coastal areas,
because we may be increasingly in the future having to deploy more submarine fibre cables,
because it seems that lots of people keep trawling them and digging them up. That affects the UK's
resilience for its whole internet infrastructure. And guess what? Those cables always land on a
beach, and Dorset's got some really good beaches. There has to be a way to try to think about this.
Direct burial. Direct burial, I believe, was trialled by BT back in the day. I think even
the Isle of Wight had direct burial. I think there's direct burial of some stuff in Dorset.
There's less deep digs. There are ways to address this. But at the end of the day,
if we don't make it a lot easier for people to do it, it's not going to happen. And on the evidence,
Jane, in the last 40 years, it simply hasn't happened enough. And there is a role for the
state in here. There has to be. And you don't see that clearly coming out, I don't think,
yet in the Invest 2035 strategy, which is a bit sad, really. I think the intent was there.
And I think it might change. It's only a green paper. But in that process,
might be the answer to this question. Can you tell us a little bit more about the
Invest 2035 green paper that you've mentioned? Because I'm sure some of our listeners won't be
quite familiar with it. Sure. I mean, it's occupied me quite considerably.
When I first read it, my impressions were that it hadn't really been looked at that closely
by someone from a telecom and internet background, but that the general strategic
objectives were sound. So, for example, I'll give you a couple of key statistics.
Telecoms is mentioned twice in the whole document. Once is in a graph, once is in a footnote.
There's no mention of the word cyber that I could find, and yet it was in the King's speech.
Spectrum, there's no mention of spectrum. Is spectrum pricing even relevant in a world where
we no longer want to have a solution that isn't deep fiber and where higher frequencies don't
cause harmful interference? So the rationing effect that justified it has been undermined.
That's a thought. The other thing I think I would flag up in this, there are two statements,
because that sounds like they didn't even think about communications. Well, that's not entirely
true. But the two things I picked up, and one of them was the words on page 34 somewhere, I think
it said, infrastructure underpins all economic activity by connecting people, goods, services,
energy and ideas. Well, they're not connecting them in some rural points right now. We welcome
that. The second quote was, the core objective of the industrial strategy is unleashing the full
potential of our cities and regions. So for example, wouldn't it be great if I could get on
my train in Dorset, right, and have a good sustainable signal all the way to Cardiff
Central? Why not? Why are we making this so difficult? What people want is good coverage
and good connectivity, and they want it. It's not a case of either or. And when I hear mobile
networks sometimes say, well, we've got some coverage there. Well, I respect them. They've
got a massive job to do. It's a difficult job, and I don't envy them. But I want capacity too.
I want to be on an even footing with everybody. And just because my village happens to be called
a train and it happens to move between two points, are we seriously saying that in 2025,
we don't have the capability to address this technical problem? I rather think we do.
My rant is over, and I suppose I would leave it to Colin to draw a thread on. But what could
you sum that up as in one word? How would we do that? One sentence that looks at what I'm
trying to say, Colin. I can't find the words. This is a PG show, Colin, before you go ahead.
Yeah, so I echo what Dave says about the document, Invest 2035. Support was thrust a bit. I thought
there was a lot of good stuff in there. Disappointed to see the lack of telecoms and
digital infrastructure mentioned. We want that to be at the heart, not just a part of that strategy.
However, ambitions are great. Saying that we want to support these sectors and saying that
we want to support the regional economies of the UK is fantastic. But in a place with no motorways,
we need those digital motorways to be able to do that. And we just don't have those at the moment.
GVA, the kind of economic growth that we've experienced in Dorset over the last 10 years,
is quite frankly pitiful. And that's down to the fact we have quite a lot of old people. But it's
also down, I believe, to the fact that the infrastructure we have here to support economic
growth is just not adequate for what we need today. And I think if this strategy is to become
a real living thing that happens over the next 10, 20, 30 years, we're going to have to address
that as a nation. There's one other thing, one other really super quote I picked up from this,
and I led on it in some of the response work I got involved with. And it said on page 23,
that half of global trade is expected to be digital by 2050. So if half of global trade
is going to be digital by 2050, and we're a trading nation, it logically follows that we
need to be putting a considerable part of our efforts into addressing digital infrastructure,
because if we can't, we're not going to be able to participate in that global trade effectively.
That undermines our economic future. So it's even bigger than just rural. So I think what I see
there, I see seeds of hope. I guess it's a great rural analogy. I see great potential. I think
people are trying to think about some form of information strategy, much like Korea had,
something that is a long term, not 20 minutes, but 20 years, looking sensibly at a sustainable
future. So we can get the UK involved in standards, we can look at the optimal spectrum solutions,
we can play an active part in AI and all the other developments that are coming forward.
And we can use the natural creativity of these islands to do great stuff in agrotech,
and as we've been doing in Dorset. And what we constantly end up doing is always we do it with
as little money as possible, on a small scale, and we then fight and do our best to make it
happen. I guess, Pink Floyd crying out in quiet desperation is just the English way,
but it's so frustrating sometimes, because this is a nation of greatness, of great people,
of great inventions, of the internet itself, of submarine cables, of the origin of the
telephone itself. And yet here we are trying to have a discussion about how to make sure
that people can have a basic service, which frankly, should be their right.
Colin, there's something that you've mentioned a couple of times that I wanted to reflect on,
which is the sort of ageing Dorset population. And the phenomenon of younger people leaving
rural areas to go and find work in urban areas is a common phenomenon. It's well known.
And I wonder how much of that is driven by the fact that say you are a younger person,
the kind of person who is going to set up your own business or join a smaller business,
how much there not being the connectivity that you can get in our urban areas is going to be
a barrier to you wanting to do that in the place where you grew up?
Yeah, it's one of the main things that occupies the minds of our councillors,
the people who run the council. We had a change of administration quite recently,
and got a new corporate plan. And it talks about wanting to keep our young people in the locale.
So in order for that to happen, there have to be a number of different things.
You need to have a job to go to, you need to have an interesting job that's going to occupy you,
is going to make use of the skills that you've learned during your education.
And we're trying to make some changes around that, trying to change the focus of the Dorset
economy from one that's built around perhaps agriculture and tourism, to one that's built
around the idea that you can run a successful business that's innovating and producing
niche and boutique products and services. Because if you have the digital infrastructure available
to you, you can do that from anywhere essentially. So that's kind of part of the story we're trying
to tell as a county. But yeah, long term, yes, what we see is people from, young people from
Dorset going to university, getting a great education, because you know, our universities
are the best in the world, as we know. And then they go where the jobs are, or they stay where
they've been educated. And we don't have a university in our part of Dorset, we certainly
have one in Bournemouth, but that's not our part of Dorset. So what we really want to achieve is
people either going to university and then coming back here to live and work and pay taxes, let's be
honest, to support local services and pay for the care for those elderly people that we talk about.
Or they come back here and actually set up their own business because they've got the connectivity
and the infrastructure that enables them to do that. And they start to employ more local people,
and then you get that circular economy that hopefully is self-generating.
There's another thing that may be useful to mention. On a current BCIT funded programme,
the Dorset Open Network Ecosystem Activities, I'm actually responsible for mentoring
an undergraduate student from the University of Exeter, which is my own alma mater, so
happy days and home territory for me, specifically with a view to making sure that she has the
skills and access to knowledge and experience early in her career that will maybe help her
to assist, to stay in the area, to have the knowledge and the network, to see what we're doing.
This is the second time. We did the same in 5G rural Dorset, had a fantastic lady called Daisy.
The new lady is called Justin Knapp. I think she's recently released a little blog on this.
And what we'd like to do is to try to persuade the DCIT to change the rules when they fund
grant funding programmes to simply say that 1% of the available budget that's awarded
could be donated to funding a student, and then forcing people, the grisly old people like me,
and incidentally to me, Colin still is a young person, by the way, but forcing us to go out,
reach out to our local universities, and instead of offering them yet another training course,
let them see what really goes on. Let them do it on their terms. Let them do it on ways that fit
with their working diaries, because they have degrees to pass, but step back and make it a
friendly experience, because the UK has a skills deficit which is terrible. But who wouldn't want
to work in Dorset? If what Colin and I can successfully achieve is better fibre coverage
in Dorset and better radio coverage in Dorset, and we might do that through tourism, we might
do it through the Ministry of Defence, the work we've been doing on the Battle Lab down in Dorset,
and the fantastic developments and sales opportunities for great businesses at the
Dorset Innovation Park. Had to get that one in, Colin. You know, it's something that we can do,
and we are making a difference. We can't do that for every young person, but DCIT, if they change
the rules of these competitions in the grant funding agreements, will simply have a line that
1% of that now goes, find a student, find a university, find a young person that you as a
group can help adopt that young person, and you suddenly find it might not be one. So, we adopted
Daisy on our previous programme. Her flatmate now works Jet Connectivity, and Jet Connectivity,
which was a start-up itself, proving that UK innovation does happen, started, has its roots
in Dorset, and that's now got 30-odd employees, and I can tell you with complete certainty that
all bar one of them are much younger than me. I guess there's one other thing I'd like to say on
that, which is there's a little bit about inspiring and opening the eyes of our young people to what
is actually on their doorstep and what potentially they could achieve by staying at home. Not
everybody wants to go to university, so we do a lot of work around highlighting the potential of
career in STEM, with primary school children actually taking them to locations in Dorset
and giving them experiences with local companies. So, I'd like to shout out people like ExNet and
Atlas Electronic and the MOD locally, who essentially make it interesting and fun for
them to say, okay, I didn't realise this thing was on my doorstep. I now do, and that might
change one person's mind out of the class of 30 about whether they follow the traditional
route into doing a job that's very essential, but something that's quite traditional, or whether
they perhaps look at a different career going forward, especially people who face challenges
in traditional educational settings. We find a lot of people who are perhaps slightly autistic and
on the spectrum, they have many of the skills that local companies that are working in
digital and cyber security kind of environments really value, and we've tried to foster that in
Dorset, and hopefully that will reap benefits. Colin, something you've mentioned several times
now, you mentioned it when we were talking about the train in particular, is LEO, Low Earth Orbit
Satellites. When we last spoke on the podcast, David, I think we spoke a little bit
about Starlink. Obviously, Starlink has massively expanded since then. Amazon is expanding its
Project Kuiper constellation, and the EU is looking at launching its own LEO constellation as well.
I guess, what is the benefit of Low Earth Orbit Satellites? How usable is this? You know,
some people might know of businesses that use Starlink already, perhaps smaller businesses in
extremely remote areas. Does it have a more day-to-day use as well?
Yes, certainly. We've been using satellite technology for some years in some of our
projects, and you've mentioned the Wi-Fi connected steam train. So, what we're doing on that project
is essentially blending the available cellular network connectivity with Low Earth Orbit
Satellite connectivity, and picking the best of both worlds, if you like. So, using Starlink
or providing connectivity on platform and in car parks around the places where people get on the
trains. But we'll be using the warm web technology on the actual train itself, so we can compare and
contrast between the different services that are currently available. Hopefully, we're quite proud
of it. It's hopefully one of our firsts, and we'll be doing more work on that later on this year.
But hopefully, we can translate that quirky use case into one that can inform the decisions at
a national level about how we connect trains going forward, which I know is something that
Dave's been working on in the background with his other role. Yeah, actually, thanks, Simon.
One of the things that's troubled me about this is, you know, a village on the move is the concept
the way that I look at it. And we did look at a village in South Wales, about 250 to 300 people,
and when they were allowed to have unmetered access, they were typically consuming about 1.5 gig.
So, is there pent-up demand? Yes. I then wonder, and I've not seen any research on this, right,
if your bum's sitting on a seat on a train, your ability to be distracted by anything else,
like the fact the kettle's just poured over in the kitchen, or the children were screaming, or
whatever it might be, you know, the wallpaper's peeling off, and you've suddenly got an
overwhelming urge to fix it that actual second. Surely, there's a potential that people would
actually want to use connectivity even more intensively. And then I looked at the next
date of the UK's frequency allocation table, and mid-band spectrum is pretty damn hard to find.
And what we're going to be moving into this new, and I'm not going to use the other G word,
you know, the one that comes after five, because I'm not even sure it's appropriate.
What I'm going to do is say, we are going to be sharing spectrum more. So, one of the things of
interest is, who might we be able to share spectrum with in a rural area, to greater effect?
And for the trains, could we find a way that I could do my call from Cardiff down to Dorchester
South via lots of changes, and through all the cuttings, and what have you? Would it work on
satellite alone? No. But if it didn't, and I'd electrified the line, the thing that's always
held back good train connectivity in rural areas has been the difficulty of doing it cost-efficiently.
Well, as fibre begins to extend across other parts of network rail telecom on a larger scale,
and I'm lucky, my core valley lines in Wales are already fibred up, 170 kilometres, bang, done.
So, in that zone, I could, in theory, deploy a millimetre wave tomorrow.
And then I could look at probably approaching 10 gig and more to a train, and the current
Ofcom-approved frequencies, I think it's 60 gig and 71 E-band, something like that from memory.
So, is that equipment available? Yes. Are there UK vendors? Yes. Does that improve
sovereign capability in line with UK desires to have more supply chain resilience? Answer,
yes. Do people want it? Clearly, yes. Would it encourage more people? Would it mean they
wouldn't have to travel as much? In some cases, it would. But on balance, people will always want
to travel. People are increasingly being forced to go back to work. And therefore, the situation
is getting quite urgent. So, to my mind, I think in the next two to three years, we will see a
greater, more initiative in this space. But it comes down to who's going to pay for it.
Guess what? It's the same old problem we did at the start. Cost to build and operate a network,
revenue is available. We've been here before, haven't we, folks?
We've discussed lots of different solutions here, and we've also talked a bit about some specific
dates by which people hope things will get better. So, 2035 has been mentioned a lot.
In the next few years, if you're a rural business in the UK, is there real hope on the horizon for
your connectivity improving? I think you always have to have hope. But I would go back to the
point that many, the majority of people who live in rural locations like Dorset, certainly in Dorset,
don't have full fibre. Many of them don't even have very good copper-provided connectivity.
And that needs to change. Satellite offers an option. You know of people who buy a £75 a
week connection, because that's essentially all they can do. But that can't become the norm,
I don't think. And I think fibre always has to be what we aim for, because there has to be equity
of access. If we're going to deliver what the government says it wants to deliver, I think
equity of access is basically where we need to point ourselves at, because everything else is
a compromise. And we shouldn't be settling for compromises. So, to the question, should we have
hope? Is there hope? Yes. I'm an eternally hopeful individual. I might be old, but I haven't lost the
desire to make all of this happen. And for as long as there are people like Colin and I about,
that are determined enough, crazy enough, and stubborn enough to fight through all of the stuff
that has to be done, wade through masses of government documents, and actually still,
in our hearts, genuinely care about this stuff, then there has to be a future. We will be sharing
more radio. Neutral hosting will come in some form. Even if it's not fibre in water, fibre will
be increasingly deeply deployed. And I'll just leave you with one thing that I don't think will
happen though, and this is from the 2035 Green Paper. And it specifically says, continued investment
is needed to meet our ambitious targets to bring gigabit capable broadband to all of the UK,
and standalone 5G to all populated areas by the year 2030. And I'd just like to close, given that
we're talking about rural, standalone 5G to all populated areas, well, doesn't really ring quite
so nicely with all the other bits that we've been talking about, and the comments about place in the
document. Because, sorry, the last time I checked, we want connectivity, we want coverage, and we
want capacity too. And that's for standalone 5G by 2030. I think in the current economic climate,
I admire their ambition. I want to give them hope too. I will help them to get there, but it ain't
gonna be an easy ride. But keep hoping guys, and don't be afraid to invest in Dorset, because if you
come, we'll find a way to do it. And when you want to use your train in Wales, you will find that
connectivity will improve, because you will make it so. Determination is everything.
Well, unfortunately, that's all we have time for today. But David, Colin, thank you so much for
joining us. As always, you can find links to all of the topics we've spoken about today in the show
notes, and even more on our website at itpro.com. You can also follow us on LinkedIn, as well as
subscribe to our daily newsletter. Don't forget to subscribe to the ITPro podcast wherever you
find podcasts. And if you're enjoying the show, let us know by leaving a rating or a review.
We'll be back next week with more from the world of IT. But until then, goodbye.
Goodbye.
