String Theory is Falsifiable After All, String Theorists Say

Math for our world
17 followers
String theory, our best hope for a theory of everything, has been criticised for being
impossible to falsify. But a group of string theorists now says that this isn't so.
They just came out with a paper titled How to falsify string theory at a collider.
Well, that sounds like fun. Let's have a look.
String theory, as a theory of everything, should contain all the elementary particles
that we have already observed and that we collect in the standard model of particle physics.
These particles are not all independent of each other. They're related by symmetry
transformations that we collect in groups called U1, SU2 and SU3.
No, wait, don't leave. I swear you don't need to know exactly what that means.
Just that the numbers in the group names tell you the size of the group.
The smaller the number, the smaller the group. As you can tell,
the real world seems to make use only of very small symmetry groups.
This brings us to the new paper.
In string theory, one, strictly speaking, doesn't have particles.
Everything is made of strings. It's just that some of those strings resemble particles.
But they still must be related by these symmetry groups to correctly reproduce the standard model.
No one so far found a way to exactly reproduce the standard model from string theory.
However, string theorists have found a lot of similar models.
And once you have these models, you can calculate how many particles should appear
together in sets at a collider. These sets of particles are called multiplets.
The quarks in the standard model, for example, form a triplet.
The authors of the new paper now say, let's conjecture that particle models derived from
string theory only have small sets of particles. So, small multiplets.
I doubt that this is correct, but let's just go with it.
Then, so they say, we should never find a large set of new particles related
by a symmetry group with a large number. So, if a particle collider found evidence
for something like that, this could rule out string theory.
Well, this is just nonsense. Let's say I have a theory according to
which the Large Hadron Collider will not produce unicorns.
If it does produce unicorns, that'll rule out my theory.
Therefore, unicorn theory is great. That's the logical equivalent of their
argument. Except that they covered their nonsense up with maths,
distributed it over 30 pages, ran a computer simulation to go with it,
and got paid for doing all that by the US Department of Energy.
Though I have to give it to them, they invented an entirely new sort of nonsense.
You see, the normal nonsense in the field is to invent new unnecessary things,
claim that they make predictions which can be ruled out,
and then pretend it's great if they're ruled out.
The authors of the new paper, on the other hand, invent unnecessary things,
claim they're something they don't predict, and then they pretend it's great if we don't see
what they don't predict. Imagine the potential.
No longer do you need a theory that predicts something new.
It's sufficient to predict nothing new, which you could just have done by sticking with the
standard model. You might think that this is a particularly extreme example of physics gone
wrong by a basic misunderstanding of how science works, but in the foundations of physics,
this is unfortunately the rule rather than the exception.
To just give you two other recent examples, take the paper that made headlines with the title
Dark Matter May Have Existed Before the Big Bang.
If you look at the paper, you'll see that the lead author is the same person who claimed last
week that dark matter was produced in a second big bang after the first two ideas that directly
contradict each other. This isn't all that uncommon in this field. You can just make up
some new maths, calculate some things, and publish a new paper. The stunning thing about this is that
it doesn't even occur to them that this isn't how science works.
This research was funded by the Swedish Research Council and also by the DOE.
Another paper which I read last week, hoping it'd be interesting enough to talk about,
is about a pixelated universe, something with dark energy, a top-down string theory construction.
It's the classical example of adding unnecessary assumptions that don't solve any problem,
and then making predictions to claim that it's science because it can be falsified.
This was financed by the NSF and the DOE. Most of this paper production in the Foundations of
Physics stems from a very basic misunderstanding of the philosophy of science, is that they think
it's sufficient for a theory to be falsifiable. But just being falsifiable doesn't make a theory
scientific. Most importantly, a scientific theory should not make unnecessary assumptions,
like particles are made of strings, or dark energy is pixelated, or maybe God made it so,
but then I repeat myself. Now look, I'm not saying that everything in the Foundations of
Physics is nonsense. I'm trying hard to find some interesting things to highlight in my science news.
But damn, it is hard. Did you know there's a free and easy way to learn more about the science
behind all the videos that you've been watching? Yes, there is. Have a look at Brilliant. Brilliant
offers courses on a large variety of topics in science, computer science, and mathematics.
All their courses have interactive visualizations and come with follow-up questions. Whether you
want to know more about large language models or algebra, want to learn coding in Python or know
how computer memory works, Brilliant has you covered. It's a fast and easy way to learn,
and you can do it whenever and wherever you have the time. And they're adding new courses each
month. Sounds good? I hope it does. You can try Brilliant yourself for free if you use my link
That way, you'll get to try out everything Brilliant has to offer for a full 30 days,
and you get 20% off the annual Premium subscription. So go and give it a try,
I'm sure you won't regret it. Thanks for watching, see you tomorrow.
