Big Debate: మోడీ ఆంధ్రాకు ఇచ్చిన హామీలు ఎంతవరకు నెరవేర్చారు? | Modi Visakha Tour | hmtv
Здоровый Образ
3 followers
Jan 8, 2025
Hello, welcome to the Big Debate special discussion
program. The
visit of the Prime Minister of India continued today in Andhra Pradesh.
Along with the laying of the foundation stones for the works worth about two lakh crores, the
inauguration ceremony of the works of about ten thousand crores of rupees was also
done.
It is going to be done under NTPC as well as
a bulk at a cost of around two thousand crore rupees Drug
Park will also
make arrangements for infrastructure. In relation to many other roads and railway
projects, the Prime Minister has
virtually inaugurated the laying of cones today.
Special
status or otherwise
package like Uttarandhra Rayalaseema KBK
or other aspects were not mentioned
especially In the context of this program
being held in Visakhapatnam,
no statement or
reference regarding the Vizag Steel Factory has come from the mouth of any of the leaders. There
is also concern about the future of that steel plant. On all these issues, Big
Depend is discussing today with us in the discussion.
Dr. Tulsi Reddy,
senior leaders of the Congress party, former
members of Parliament are with us, and Rama Raju, a
prominent political and social analyst,
is here in the studio. Lakshmani is another
political and social expert. Analysts, senior
leaders, they are also with us, Anjaneya
Reddy, Bharatiya Janata Party leaders,
Mallela Lingareddy, TDP
leaders will also join us soon,
Ayodhya Ram, Steel Factory
Porata Samiti leaders are also with us.
Ram
garu Modi's visit today is a special steel because Visakhapatnam is
in the middle of many as it is the Prime Minister's visit In
any announcement regarding the factory, the
assurance
is announcing about its fate. You have been
protesting there for almost years.
After the new government comes, there is hope that there will be
a clarity on this after the NDA government comes.
Why is there no
announcement today,
so the factory will be safe because there is
no announcement. Do you want to be privatized? It
seems that you are getting ready to worry. Say
hello to all your privileged elders.
Now we We sat for 36 hours protest
initiation from yesterday morning
till eight o'clock.
Umm, Tulsi Reddy or Lakshminarayana who are in the panel
or all elders know that
since four years Visakha Ukku Telugu has been
fighting. The
media and Telugu people have
fully supported the movement
till now. On 18th December
my
delegation including myself met the Union Steel Minister
OK Kumaraswamy. Garu
said that it is because of your struggle that your plant
has stopped until now, otherwise they said that your plant would
have been sold at some point. In
this
context, the protest
started yesterday at eight o'clock in the morning with some hope. They
did it without
coming out, without moving on the road, without
coming out of the tent, okay,
in the end, even if the bus leaves the heroine, they
ask where are they going. The
situation is visible. Ok, in this
background, we listened to Modi's meeting through mobile phone and
asked him to say anything about the steel plant. We were
very interested for hours. They
didn't even talk about it.
They are saying that crores of investments will come, the
five thousand crore rupees given by the government 50 years ago and we have
accumulated three lakh crore rupees assets, do
you think that someone will make the Visakhapatnam steel plant rich overnight?
Okay, this is the government.
If the steel plant will be privatized then he said that there is an app and he
said ok what year 2020
21st January 26th
Tab In the same year when the sale was announced,
we made a cash profit of 940 crore rupees.
OK,
you are selling the company that made a cash profit.
Since then, banks have started non-cooperation.
Everyone started non-cooperation and the
losses have disappeared.
Annam
means not today, Prime Minister Modi is
not going to the plant today Garu my question
Garu Garu has mentioned Garu there is
no raw material for Visakhapatnam steel plant which is running since years there is
no minimum mention for the plant there is
no minimum mention for railway flakes
ok since four months
we are producing without salaries without food
workers
are producing stomachs ok December If you
sell two thousand crore rupees in a month, then 360
crore rupees are taxed,
but the GST rupee is okay from there. There
is no permit salary of contract workers even in this situation even though the steel plant
is producing 110% of the targets given by the govt. even if
such proposals are doing this we
feel it is very evil.
Thank you very much
Tulsi Reddy for joining. Well today the Prime Minister
came to take oath after the formation of the new NDA government.
After that he also said that it is
time to show my love to all of you. He
also said at the start of the meeting.
It will take years, 180
thousand crores,
a foundation
stone has been laid on this, which is related to a future. It is good that there is a hope that all that we
have done today will be completed at least someday,
but the main thing is that
after the formation of the new government regarding the division guarantees, today there
is a joy, but there is
a confusion regarding this Walther division.
What do
you mean by including funds for Amaravati?
According to the Prime Minister's meeting today, is it
possible to get clarity about them in any future? As
you
said,
it's like a toy coin is a toy bag. It's okay to start a
project worth two lakh crore rupees in the energy
sector, railway sector, roads, utility sector,
industrial sector.
Definitely had to come and
welcome, it's okay, but
where did the meeting take place at the same time?
Visakhapatnam Visakhapatnam is fine there, I
think our state has problems.
Regarding Visakhapatnam, the
main problem from Uttarandhra is Visakha steel
plant. Now you say that it is two lakh crore
rupees. If that one plant is
worth more than two lakh crore rupees, we will
come and sell the plant which was in the public sector.
If you have two lakh crore rupees projects in 15-20 years, already
established Visakhapatnam steel pant.
It is clear that we are going to do it in the private sector, if the steel pant that costs more than that is coming and yes, we are going to do it in the private sector.
If it was a public sector company without private sector,
they would have definitely said yes today, so they
did not say that, so it will come 100% and
they are the
leaders of the state. You may not like it but
it is
inevitable as long as Modi is the Prime Minister,
it must be private. If the form
seems to be there, then one is OK and the second is
related to the partition law,
but one is not in the law, but as per the then
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, the
special status is the lifeblood of the state. In the
same way, you put
your manifesto saying that it is not for five years but for 10 years. It
is said in the chapter that there is no situation to come and say about it either
before or now in this meeting.
Okay, secondly,
many aspects of the rest of the law
have to be given.
According to
what is clearly stated in sub-section two that it is
here by declared that it It is
experian it is experian in the
public interest that the unions should undertake its
control the regulation
and development of the Polavaram Irrigation
Projects for the purpose of irrigation
ok it is experian
saying that it is necessary to do it quickly he
used stel in September ok but 10 years have passed
Then came the condition of it which is
still unknown The
Chief Minister has
expressed that Amaravati will be completed quickly and
he requested you to come.
He also said some of them, but the
response from the Prime Minister is that there will
be help.
Mention also about Amaravati As I have said
regarding Amaravati it is not debts it is section
94 sub section three what says in the act
the Central Govt. Shall Provide Yes
Special Financial Support For A
Creation Of Essential Facilities In
The New Capital Of The Success State
Of Andhra Pradesh OK Including Raj Bhavan
High Court Government Secretariat
Legislative Assembly Legislative
Council And Such Other Essential
Infrastructure So
Given The Responsibility Of The Central Government To
Borrow Funds In The Form Of Coastal Cant
So the law of this came Amaravati is a
desperate betrayal of the capital. What is AP for the capital?
Amaravati P means Polavaram. Chandrababu Naidu is
repeatedly saying, OK,
here Amaravati has been betrayed.
So
Bundelkan Then there is
no mention of how many for the special development package, there is no mention.
Okay, the rest came and the Krishna River
Management Board office
should be put in Andhra Pradesh within 65 days.
Line O
will come to the south coast of this or not,
it will almost certainly not come.
OK, if it was true,
they would have said now that the
South Coast Railway is with the right line, the South
Coast Railway is not with the K Line, the South Coast
Railway zone is OK, there is no guarantee.
So one side will come ok we
will invite but on the other side extreme injustice will
be done even after years there
is no mention of these I will come to you again
Tulsi Reddy Garu Lakshmi
Reddy Garu You have heard that all this is what
we all
have been talking about for 10 years but this time it
is expected. Well, new projects are
coming. Let us want them to be completed
quickly. Either Kadapa Steel Factory or
Uttarandhra Bundelaka Package special
status. Let us talk about what is in the law.
At least in terms of what is in the law,
this is just the
development Projects The Prime Minister talked
about three or four things about the Visakhapatnam Machchikars. He
talked about national schemes. But he or the Chief
Minister already knows
what will happen there.
How can we understand that he can talk and not talk?
Patel, I
first visited the projects
worth 28500 crores.
I whole
heartedly invite you to inaugurate some of the establishments.
28500
crores have been invested at the field level ok that
does not mean that seven and a half lakh people have got employment ok action
speaks lovely than words ok today the
words
have been heard very loudly ok when they
come to the field level people
will experience the results then let us really rejoice
ok today one three four things
to mention Let's say today a
private company puts
raw material for a steel plant They said that
it would be good if we bring it underground through a pipe and if
the Prime Minister
suggested that the Chief Minister said well done,
they said that it is good. If another
industry comes there,
no one would object. It is a backward region of Uttar Andhra. There
is a port nearby.
There is also a neighborhood in Odisha and Jharkhand. If the
central government itself
announces a policy statement, it is like
32 people
have achieved martyrdom against it The right of Andhra people is the right of iron and
steel
and this is a guarantee that this industry will
continue in the government sector and that we are going to allocate money for the raw material needed for it.
Why could not the Prime Minister give a specific guarantee?
I think the people of Andhra Pradesh have the right to ask. Those who would have
spoken if they did not speak, can it
be taken as a sign that it will continue in the same line, Laxman garu
why me I am only questioning the fact that the guarantee has not been given.
Ok, all the leaders of
the alliance have repeatedly said that they will protect it from privatisation.
Therefore, starting from the Chief Minister, the Deputy
Chief Minister and the
Minister of Finance have also told the central book.
Yes, secondly,
there is Kadapa Steel Factory in the Reorganization Act and that Kadapa
Steel Factory is also to be set up. Rayalaseema is a
backward area
where there is no industrial development ok
raw material is available for that too ok Anantapur
district has plenty in Bellary borders
we have seen it how did Gali
Janardhan Reddy
earn thousands of crores by smuggling it yes
why did not talk about it ok
if not from today we would
have mentioned about Koppatenu all of them are small Yes it is
good that small industries can come there
but why are people asking for
what is guaranteed in the Biggest Industry Act as a right? They
kept silent,
ok, why are you not talking, ok,
secondly, the construction of a city
industrial city near Krishnapatnam in the Chris City
Chennai Bangalore Corridor.
Um, it
will cost more than 2500 crores. It will be located in a few thousand acres.
SS I am good here because
krishnapatnam border is there highway there
are all these also airports chennai
tirupati all these but
that's what i ask NTPC BHCL electrical
equipment industry was established by Dr. Manmohan
Singh as the prime minister and
spent some money.
What happened to it near Mannavaram? Is it
lifted or forgotten? This is a
question that the people of Andhra Pradesh are asking, especially the people of Rayalaseema region.
184 thousand crore rupees out of crores is
green Hydrogen energy is only
related to hub yes all the rest
20 thousand crore rupees 24 thousand crore
rupees no national highways if not railway
projects all these also here
about railway railway zone ten years
have passed yes today the foundation stone of the building
was laid yes i
read it yesterday yes approval for DPR means comprehensive study
report still railway The board
did not inform OK means that if the building is installed without giving approval to DPR then it is
railway zone Ok,
how long will it take? Ok, Tulsi Reddy
has mentioned today that they have established a writing cone.
They are ok, it has gone. Ok, what
is being asked today is whether they will
leave the railway part and continue the part of the railway line as the
rest of the Walther division. It has not been
said. While
welcoming the establishment of the office, the PINR should be approved immediately and
implemented
Officer, today central universities ok
educational institutes are run in separate houses in different places.
Yes, tomorrow they will be closed for a while.
If not, there is a divisional office.
From there, start the railway zone.
I remember that people are asking why they are not doing something that will benefit Andhra Pradesh to introduce new trains for the development of railways. I
am doing right sir right sir
I will come to you again Laxman garu
Ramaraju garu you are a representative of an MSME It
was done that means they asked for special status,
even in those days it is
different to invest two lakh crores in NTPC, if all people like you
put in 10 crores or 100 crores out of
five crores per head,
the intention is to provide employment to thousands of lakhs of crores of people.
No,
even though they are in the law now,
North Andhra Rayalaseema has no problem in giving the KBK package.
What is the reason why what is in the law which has been accepted by everyone is not being implemented Ramaraju garu tell me
what do you think today as an industrialist
that now Tulsi Reddy
garu Lakshminarayana garu has already
created some things ok also today I
have seen the whole thing from starting to ending you too CM Ramesh
I have seen the whole thing from the beginning of Gari. Okay, well,
that word may or may not be used, but everyone is
the prime minister Good bhajan was given to Gari. Ok
happy. What I am asking is that what
you are saying in the Partition Act,
there are financial matters and they are not done.
What is not related to them, there
are things that are not related to property transfers. Some of
them are okay.
Is it okay for you that
costless affair is not costing
but it is great for both of them. They
didn't even do that because of the cost of meals. Then they
gave an opportunity to set up a big major port shipping unit on the coast. They
said yes, it was Dugarajapatnam,
Ramayapatnam, another city.
They say that they will build a refinery together with our BPCL
All these things
are on paper and
calculations are being made in lakhs of lakhs of crores. Ok, now
this same NTPC will put in some green energy with 1 lakh 80 thousand crores. Isn't it the
same NTPC,
combined with BHLs? OK,
so far near Manavaram, Lakshmina said, they have
collected around 800 acres near Manavaram and
started a unit, ok around 300 Crores
have been put in. They have announced that the cost is 6000 crores,
about 200 retails. 300
crores have been invested and it has been made like a forest. If there is no
board outside, then there
is nothing. Ok, if you look there, the thorn feet have
completely destroyed it. Ok,
so these corridors are announced as
Chennai Bangalore Corridor. I don't understand
where Krishnapatnam came to the center of Chennai Bangalore.
Ok,
technically, those things. Even if you don't talk, it's okay, actually the
Sejal that you have now is also now in
our Sri City, it is private,
so they are looking for something. They are
running very successfully in many
places, government lands have been collected, sejas have been set up and
industries have been set up there, they are asking how much percentage they are able to set up industries there.
Just a conference is held in Davos.
There is no review of what is happening.
Who does not talk about that? Okay, now
Narendra Modi has also talked about all this.
Okay, what are his central schemes? Yes,
what else have you talked about? This
Visakhapatnam steel that you mentioned, at least the public
sector companies are not
running with profits. Do you think that some
specific ones
are making any effort to shore them up
without trying? Why are the ideas of selling and cross-selling
okay,
who says that you should start the company as a profit, yes,
you should try it and increase the efficiency.
It doesn't have steel mines,
it's main, it's been done for a long time,
it hasn't been done,
if you don't try to put it on the road, then sell it, ok, it's also
selling, it doesn't mean selling normally, it shouldn't
be sold at
cross rates.
Killing ok ok slow step by
step step by step now Even so,
he said, the union leader
banks are not cooperating, we have no file, the
employees have been saying since four months that the
defense is overflowing and
orders, yes, there are huge orders to BDL or HA,
they are not able to do it, and to use these facilities,
there are huge facilities in the public sector, yes, there are places that It is
particularly a one-
two industry if they sell everything without using the infrastructure and trying to screw them up. Selling to them,
giving everything to them, ports,
airports, giving them all to one company, I
don't understand how it goes.
That it is part of the law
where everyone is welcome new on such things
Sir, now
one hundred thousand crores is okay, not ten years,
even if it comes to 20000 in 15 years, let's
go for expansion. Let's assume that there is a big future. Who doesn't want it,
but since ten years, you all have hoped and
we all have hoped. Regarding Andhra Pradesh,
when the same government comes again, the same
NDA comes again, whoever
came to power after giving assurances. The combination
will continue again but even now
if there is no clarity about these then what should people
understand Lingareddy
Garu Greetings to all the seniors, the
Kadapa
plant is in the division act, then
Chandrababu Naidu garu um,
those thousands were given to it, it is
being established, the government has
changed, then the power has also been
given completely, I
have changed it, even if the location is changed, it
has not been completed there.
That is not a work that can be done
because those lakhs of elders can't take out the government gazette and
put lakhs of crores this time.
80,000 crores
was announced and it was supposed to be a project in the air,
that means it was not realized.
They are saying that all these things would not have been released if they were on pickled paper.
It means not only that,
it is not the same thing, it is not the same thing, what will happen to it,
that is, the private
investors, whether this is China or another country,
here or there, these marketing rates will all
come into view.
Lingareddy is not asking for small things. Now there is
no Bundeka price package. If there is no price package, Kadapa Steel
Factory, the other big things like this will be
given.
Now the Chief Minister has spoken and
merged the seven mandals.
Some of the
things that happen are two lakh
crore projects and the state budget is
about 2600 three
lakhs which is about 75% of the state budget.
All these projects have come,
it is not a small matter for any state, okay, is it
another exile, and since time immemorial,
money has
been given to all the losers that are related to us. Not
even a single
word was mentioned about Lingareddy garu,
you will have noticed that the whole discussion has
been confused for the last few days and
the question is what is the future of the division? When they
are coming, there are any positives,
where do they mention about it? No leaders have spoken about it. The Chief Minister
has not spoken. The Prime Minister
has not spoken.
division is here
like that division is zone like that is
impossible that is unconstrained so
ok that's right sir
so chairman is there no. Lingareddy
sir, your voice is correct,
Lingareddy garu, Lingareddy garu, you
will come again, even if your voice is cut,
Anjaneyudu garu, you have
heard everyone's opinions. Well, it may
not be possible today. It may be six months since the formation of the new government.
Who does not deny what they are giving, Lingareddy
garu is not welcoming, but
now he has said that these things will land before long. About Mannavaram,
this same NTPC BHL has invested
6000 crores not lakhs thousand crores but they have
invested 6000 crores and spent a few hundred crores and they are
saying that the status is zero.
Now they said the same, it would be
good if there was a chance to continue, this time people gave them a chance.
Again Lingareddy came to you
Once we took Anjaneya Reddy to him, everything
I
did was done by the government, ok,
now
is not the time, I don't care about it,
you take your time, but if it comes,
the question is, at least now, these
announcements, this is what you will do.
Isn't that
right, now there are lakhs of crores of marriages,
okay, they are using it,
now they are doing it, right, okay,
I will come to you again, Anjaneya. Reddy sir, I
will give you one again.
Lingareddy sir. I will come to you again.
Anjaneya Reddy sir. Government is a
continuous process. There
is a Congress government, there is a BJP, NTPC,
BHL, central government sector organizations have
now spoken about the positive things they have put together.
Also said about it
means how new things are being done, these are
a bulk drug park
Occupancy will come, how many
industries will flourish, is it enough if you set them
up, the incentives needed to come up industries are
special, that's why
everyone asked that taxes and concessions will
come, well, I didn't talk about that.
Either about the steel factory or else
the package near Bundela is crucial When the
Prime Minister is coming, I
hope he will say something about them. Since yesterday, HM TV has been
running on Vizag Awaaz.
80 out of 100 people
talked about the steel factory. You can see that
they ask people's opinions.
Your response on this
Sir Anjaneya Reddy sir
seems to be muted once
unmute it ok ok
Say hello to all of you. There
are many elders. There
are many people who have studied many things in depth.
Many things have been
talked about.
Why did the Prime Minister not make an announcement directly about the steel plant? The
question is whether we should give a confidence. Even in our discussion,
OK. Last time, the steel plant.
Thirigaru gave an assurance to some of them that we
are studying it in depth and also told them to take decisions in a hurry.
The center will study the steel frank case
in depth. Whatever decision is
taken, whatever decision is taken to protect the interests of the employees or others depending on the steel plant, whether
it will be private sector or will
continue to be a public sector company. There is
no doubt that the central government's decision will protect the benefits of the plant.
We have been discussing this for many days or not.
Ramaraju garu Ramaraju garu
said a good thing in the beginning all
the sajjas in this public sector
are also confused but Sri City
admitted that it is somewhat better because it is a private
sector. It is
known that
governments have no business to do
business.
Let's go to the church,
how many countries in the world have only
defense currency or land order and
all the rest
are in private hands, those countries are
economically very developed,
today China is also following the same path,
China used to have the most millionaires in the world today, and now if
NTPC is put in place, this is the government.
What do you mean by business to do business
sir, you
are making a new announcement, I am saying that the
government has no business to do
business to save the existing ones. What am I saying
sir there should be a healthy competition between the
private sector and the public sector
we have seen it
today today
there are flaws in the privatization of education s there is no doubt that there are flaws in each and every one of them there is
no doubt
due to privatization new new
universities engineering colleges
software engineers are there in India all over the world
when
After privatization started, Mrs.
Indira Gandhi also said that
you did not want to privatize all the banks, sir.
Sir, what I
am saying is that what I am saying is that there is a question of
how many years white elephants should be kept
and before there
is a white elephant, for how many years the
government should support it.
There are instances we
have discussed but
we
have an emotional attachment when it comes to the Visakhapatnam steel plant because the steel
plant was just built without any struggle.
No, you said that at the beginning, 12
people lost their lives. It
was like an emotion for us. The entire state is on a large
scale,
is there any effort to increase efficiency?
Party Srinivasa Rao also said that we have
studied deeply on this matter, don't
worry, we will not
take hasty decisions, whatever decision
is taken, the benefits of the steel factory and the
benefits of the employees there
depend on it. Tell them that they will be protected for their interests.
Sir, the rest of the
steel
factory is the Kadapa factory. They said that
you should read the Partition Act,
Srinivasa Rao. Srinivas,
what I am saying is that
in the case of the Kadapa steel plants, we will examine the possibilities. It is
not that we will fix all the shets
Let Dugarajupatnam be the port, let it be Kadapa steel plants. All
these should be checked for feasibility and
feasibility. It
is very clear that Kadapa is related to that, but the
raw material is
not of good quality. Even if thousands of crores of rupees are invested on a large scale,
it is not feasible. There are many problems with the output. They have
also given a report. The
committee gave the report,
if an empowered committee was formed, they came and
gave it, so according to the report, the
government can take a decision with one fourth of the government.
What are the losses or gains in that decision?
What will happen because of this? Is
it a benefit to the people or is it a
benefit to the government? All these are one, two,
two. Today, he is the prime minister.
Discussion There is
still a lot to be done about Andhra Pradesh,
one point, one point,
sir, both of them have been made, cooperation
is pending. All of them
one is there are many problems in the partition act one is
legal problems second there
are problems between states today our
chief minister and his disciples Revanth
Reddy said he is not my disciple I wonder
what people will think Revanth
Reddy Chandrababu Naidu has
two old friends in the same
organization and in the same party today
Two people can sit and finalize, there is
no problem in that, they
can take help from the center but the home minister of the center will
come
Sir
190 property division meeting should be organized by the central home department,
now if you
hold meetings about Godavari waters, they will not
come ten times, they will fight for Andhra Pradesh five
times, if any Krishna water meeting is
held at the center, they will not come five
times, we are your responsibility. They say whether
they have come or not, I
have to think about what to do, Mr. Srinivas, Mr.
Srinivas Rao,
we have ten thousand crore rupees in electricity dues.
Do we know from Rawala Telangana, in the
cases where the government has heard anything,
arrest them and put them inside and
tell them that they will be released only if you collect the money or if the
funds are stopped, the
rights of the states will start immediately, but the rights of the states are
being taken away, we are not getting funds.
Center said that GST will be given, then what is the discussion,
finally they counted 20 about the package to the states and
said that They have also said on many occasions about the fact that old districts should give 20 two thousand crore
rupees to the seven districts which are completely backward within days.
Even the previous government from 2018 to 2019 has
not given utility certificates.
Since 2019, 24 governments have also not
given utility certificates.
Rupees
have been given since 2014 and there is no accounting for them.
The Chief Ministers are here without accounting If the finance ministers
go to the center, they put money in those bags and
send them. Anjaneya Reddy garu
system is one, the second is the Amaravati matter. For a
minute, Tulsi Reddy garu says that nothing has been done to Amaravati. Tulsi
Reddy garu
says that it was arranged by taking 15 thousand
crores.
They say
that the central government has given a guarantee.
Said we will do it if we give a guarantee will you
pay sir right anyway overall the
main tour is for some new projects Although
there are blessings related to the
partition guarantee, there is
no mention of the guarantees given by the then prime minister, only
about one railway zone, except for the
foundation stone for the construction of a building, and the
DPR has not been completed.
Otherwise,
other factors are a shock that the states are not cooperating,
but the center is close, but the
states are really weak If they don't cooperate
or if they don't submit the utility certificate or
why they
don't get the financial assistance they should, people
should think about it. Special thanks to Ramaraju,
Anjaneya Reddy, Tulsi
Reddy, Aizoram, Lakshmana,
Mallalinga Reddy, who participated in the debate.
This is their debate.
Let's meet again.
