Type 214 class | Why has it not become popular like its predecessor, the Type 209 class?

World of Submarine
9 followers
The Type 214-class combines the features of highly successful Type 209 and Type 212A-classes.
Yet, the diesel-electric submarine with an air-independent propulsion system, shortly
AIP, has experienced many technical problems and has yet to become a shining star in the
international market like its predecessor Type 209-class.
As the Weapon Detective, we are now investigating the Type 214-class and what might cause this
outcome. The Type 214-class is currently the most widely
preferred diesel-electric submarine with an AIP. Although this is a noteworthy achievement,
it is far behind the Type 209-class. We will first mention the features of the Type
214-class, then continue with each subclass' program histories and individual differences.
Hvortsverke Deutsche Werft, shortly HDW, developed the Type 214-class exclusively for export.
As mentioned, the submarine combines the design principles of the Type 209-class and some
features of the Type 212A-class. Still, the company did not apply classified technologies
of the second one. The pressure hull of the Type 214-class is
made of HY80 steel in the inner frame and HY100 steel in the outer hull, significantly
increasing the diving depth compared to the Type 209-class. Its smooth design with minimal
surface openings minimizes the flow noise during submerged cruises.
Moreover, some sound-absorbing materials are applied to the hull to further reduce
the acoustic signature. The fin sail is made of carbon-fibre reinforced
plastic. The hallmark of the Type 214-class is undoubtedly
its Siemens AIP system with proton exchange membrane compressed hydrogen fuel cells.
Since the Type 212A-class has a double hull, its oxygen and hydrogen tanks are separate
outside the cruise space between the pressure and outer light hull. It was the first HDW
submarine to be equipped with an AIP, and as such, the company preferred a double hull
due to concerns about the risk of hydrogen storage areas.
However, as design know-how was accumulated, the Type 214-class was made into a single-hulled
AIP. The gases are piped to the fuel cells, and their reaction generates electricity and
creates only water and oxygen as waste. The Siemens AIP does not emit heat and pump noise,
which makes passive tracking difficult when travelling at slow speeds.
The proton exchange membrane compressed hydrogen fuel cells have a much lower risk of leakage
than liquid electrolytes. They have low operating temperature, which allows them to reach a
suitable temperature with less heating than other fuel cell types. They offer high energy
densities compared to solid oxide ones. On the other hand, water management of proton
exchange membrane compressed hydrogen fuel cells AIP is difficult since water in the
membrane is attracted toward the cell's cathode through polarization.
The submarine can operate submerged for approximately two weeks without surfacing or snorkelling.
It can also carry food, fresh water, and fuel for 84 days of operation.
It has streamlined sails and cross-shaped rudders. The Type 214-class has eight 533mm
torpedo tubes and can carry up to 16 torpedoes and missiles.
On July 24, 1998, the Hellenic Navy chose the Type 214-class as its future submarine.
The contract to build three boats was signed on February 15, 2000, and a fourth one was
ordered in June 2002. The first of its class, also known as the
Papanikolis-class, H.S. Papanikolis, was laid down on February 27, 2001, launched on April
22, 2004, and commissioned on November 2, 2010. She was constructed in Germany.
The local Hellenic shipyards built the remaining three submarines in Greece.
The last, H.S. Katsionis, joined the fleet on June 23, 2016.
Yet, as you know, the program did not progress smoothly.
During her sea trials, H.S. Papanikolis experienced many problems. The Hellenic Navy claimed the
submarine suffered excessive rolling when surfaced in bad weather and extreme propeller
cavitation. Besides, fuel cells were overheated. Later,
new problems occurred. The output power of the AIP was inadequate.
The periscope was inappropriately vibrating, the sonar flank array did not work correctly,
and the seawater leaked into the boat's hydraulics. HDW claimed these problems were fixed in 2006.
The company stated that the Hellenic Navy kept complaining about the submarine to justify
its demand for a price reduction. HDW refused to deliver H.S. Papanikolis until
Greece paid all debts. The company even announced the cancellation
of the contract on September 21, 2009. Yet, Athens confirmed its intention to accept
the three boats built in Greece. This way, the problem was solved. The Hellenic Navy
initially intended to acquire six Papanikolis-class submarines. After this dispute, the plan for
two additional boats was naturally dropped. Still, Greece paid the list price for six
submarines. The Papanikolis-class has the I-band sphinx
low probability of intercept radar mounted on a hoistable mast that does not penetrate
the pressure hull. Its sonar has only bow and flank arrays, not towed ones.
The submarine also has the Tinex II electronic support measure system and the Chirche torpedo
canor measure decoys. Its weapon control system is the ISUS-90.
Four torpedo tubes of the Papanikolis-class are suitable for launching the UGM-84 sub-harpoon
missiles. According to Jane's Fighting Ships 2015-2016
edition, the complement of the Papanikolis-class is 40 people.
The submarine has a length of 65 metres, a beam of 6.3 metres, and a drought of 6.6 metres.
Its surface and submerged displacements are about 1,730 and 1,830 tonnes, respectively.
The propulsion system consists of two 1,810 horsepower MTU-16V-396 SE-84 diesel engines,
two 161 horsepower HDW-PEM fuel cells, and one Siemens-Permozun electric motor.
Its top surface and submerged speeds are 11 and 20 knots, respectively.
The range of the Papanikolis-class is 12,000 nautical miles, in other words, 22,000 kilometres.
Its maximum safe operation depth is 400 metres. In November 2000, South Korea ordered the
first batch of three Type 214-class submarines, also known as the KSS-2 or Sonon E-class.
Eight years later, Seoul signed another contract to supply six boats of the second batch.
HDW transferred submarine building technology, including construction plans, materials, and
other equipment. The local HD Hyundai Heavy Industries built
three boats of each batch. The remaining three submarines of the second
batch were constructed by another local company, Taewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering,
today's Hanwha Ocean. The first of its class, RRKS Sonon E, was
laid down in October 2002, launched on June 9, 2006, and commissioned on December 27,
2007. The last boat, RRKS Shindulsaab, joined the
fleet on January 31, 2020. Although some sources claim that Sonon E-class
also suffered excessive noise problems just like the Papanikolis-class, the Republic of
Korea Navy later denied the accusation. The Sonon E-class has a submerged displacement
of 1,890 tons and a complement of 27 people and a towed array sonar.
The first batch of submarines have the UME-100 electronic support measure system, while the
other six are fitted with the UME-200. It is armed with the locally developed 533mm
K731 Texanor torpedoes. The South Korean submarines have the ISUS-90
weapon control system and the Sphinx low probability of intercept radar.
On April 24, 2004, Portugal ordered two Type 214-class submarines, also known as the Tridente
or Type 209 PN-class. The agreement also included a third boat as an option.
The first of its class, NRP Tridente, was laid down on March 7, 2005, launched on July
15, 2008, and commissioned on June 17, 2010. The second and last boat, NRP Erpon, joined
the fleet on April 28, 2011. They initially had the UGM-84 Harpoon Block
1 launching capability alongside 533mm IF-21 Black Shark torpedoes.
After 2014, the Tridente-class submarines were modernized and received the new Block
2 missiles with land-attack capability. The Type 209 PN-class has surfaced and submerged
displacements of 1,840 and 2,020 tons, respectively. It is 67.9 metres long.
The Portuguese boats do not have a tow-the-right sonar, but are fitted with a mine avoidance
sonar. The Tridente-class has a 33-percent complement.
It can also carry 14 marines. The submarine has the UME-200 Electronic Support
Measure System, the ISUS-90 Weapon Control System, and the KH-1007 radar.
On July 2, 2009, Turkey ordered six Type 214-class submarines, also known as the Type 214TN or
Raise-class. According to the agreement, HDW would transfer
submarine building technology, including construction plans, materials, and other equipment.
At the same time, the boat would be modified to meet the Turkish Navy's requirements
and be fitted with locally developed subsystems. All Turkish submarines are being built in
Turkey. The Turkish Navy initially planned to receive
the first submarine in 2017. Yet, the program experience delays.
The first of its class, TCG Piri Raise, was laid down on September 28, 2015, launched
on December 22, 2019, and commissioned on August 24, 2024.
The last, TCG Selman Raise, is expected to join the fleet in 2029.
The Raise-class has a hydrodynamically improved hull design and a length of 68.5 metres.
Its surface and submerged displacements are 1,845 and 2,023 tonnes, respectively.
The boat's complement is 27 people and it can carry an 11-person special forces unit.
The Raise-class is currently armed with 533mm DM-2A4 and Mk-46 Mod 6T torpedoes and UGM-84
sub-harpoon missiles. The locally developed Akya torpedo and a submarine
launch variant of the Atmaca missile will replace them.
The submarine's navigation, data management, data link, torpedo countermeasure, and electronic
support measure systems are also locally developed. The Turkish boats have a towed array sonar.
The Type 214-class has lost some former Type 209-class users, such as Brazil, Chile, India,
and Indonesia to the Scorpene-class. Why? As mentioned in the Papanikoli's class section,
the submarine suffered some critical problems. Incorporating a proven design with proven
high-tech subsystems is generally efficient. Yet, it can occasionally backfire. Starting
from scratch sometimes makes design work more manageable, while combining already existing
parts could cause complications. This problem affected the Type 214-class.
HDW intended to offer a familiar design with proven high-tech subsystems to the former
Type 209-class customers. Yet, integration work brought many complications. Without solving
them, the company signed an agreement with Greece, making H.S. Papanikolis a prototype
rather than an end product. This business model has naturally caused suspicion for new
customers. Besides, HDW make another business mistake
by forgetting the main principle. Customer is always right.
The fight over the Papanikolis-class saved the money that came from Greece by demanding
the cost of six submarines for four boats. Yet, this attitude caused anxiety for potential
buyers. They probably thought that if a problem occurred, the supplier would not be helpful
resolving them. The Germans should have managed the crisis better.
The Scorpene-class efficiently used the gap until the German HDW company cleaned its name.
Yet, it would be unfair to claim that it was the only reason for its success.
An AIP gives a diesel-electric attack submarine a significant advantage. But, nothing is free.
It brings a sizable cost. A country whose operational areas are near
waters does not need the advantage of an AIP. So, it does not have to pay for it.
Many former Type 209-class users do not require a highly expensive diesel-electric submarine
with an AIP. The Scorpene-class offers such an option, while the Type 214-class does not.
Egypt and South Africa's choice of Type 209-class, while the Type 214-class was available,
was not meaningless. Still, India and Indonesia, which already preferred the
Scorpene-class, are among the potential customers of the Type 214-class.
However, according to our analysis, this German submarine will likely be less successful than
its predecessor. Many countries do not require its state-of-the-art design,
which makes the boat unnecessarily expensive for them.
Besides, it will take some time for HDW to clean up its bad reputation for its poor business
approach. Thanks for watching our video. And please don't forget to subscribe to our channel
and click the bell button to be notified of our new videos. Also, you can now click the join button
to support our channel. And as always, we would greatly appreciate all of your likes, comments
and shares.
