Morningstar’s Alarming Report About Retirement

Retire Rich
11 followers
Jan 7, 2025
I read an article recently by an organization that I have a lot of
respect for Morningstar. And they're sounding an alarm that I want to share
with you, and then share my views on it. So their article is titled, almost half
of those who retire at 65 could run out of money. And as somebody that's been a
financial advisor for over 20 years, as somebody that talks about early
retirement on my channel, I thought it was critical I share this article with
you, and then share my views. So let's jump into the article. And it says that
this crisis is heightened for those without access to a 401k. So they're
saying access to a 401k is important. But what is this research? The research is
from the Morningstar Center for Retirement and Policy Studies. And it
came from using a simulation tool. So this is not actual data, this is a
simulation tool that looks at individual characteristics, and what their health
care costs are going to be, what their projected long-term longevity is going
to be, to determine the sufficiency of people's retirement income. And then they
go on to say that their model, this simulation, paints a clear picture.
Participating in an employee-sponsored defined contribution plan, which is a 401k,
it's defined contribution because your employer is contributing to it, and it's
defined because that's all the money the employer is giving us. They're not giving
us a pension. Those are called defined benefit plans. The defined contribution
plan significantly lowers the risk of retirement shortfalls. And the person
saying this, Spencer Look, the report's lead author and associate director of
retirement studies, goes on to say, so does working a little bit longer and
delaying Social Security as much as you can. Now, the problem with working a
little bit longer is, how many healthy, active years do we have? It's easy to
say, you know, instead of retiring at 65, retire at 67. It's easy to say, instead
of taking Social Security at 62, 65 or 67, wait till 70. But it has big impacts
on our lives and our ability to enjoy what I call the youth of our senior
years. So let's go on. The article, my final part that I'm going to share about
the article, is the key to funding retirement is to take advantage of the
401k plans or similar retirement tools that your employer may offer. And I
think, you know, the focus on the employer offering is because it's super
hard for any of us to save money. And so by taking advantage of the employer plan
that oftentimes has matching, it makes it easier for us to meet the retirement
savings goals that we might have. Now, so I would argue that this title was
super catchy and it caught my attention, but it's really not what the
article is about. What the article is about, what Morningstar's research shows
is how important saving money for retirement is. And if you have a 401k,
it's easier to do it. If your employer is doing some matching, it's easier to hit
your savings goal. It's a simulation. They're not saying that almost half of
people do run out of money. In fact, there is a study by the world's largest
asset manager, BlackRock. And BlackRock study is called to spend or not spend.
And this was published in originally in 2018, but it was updated in 2023. And the
major findings are the same. And here's what's important on this. They found
that the majority of people in their study, regardless of their wealth level,
they break it into three categories of study, the lowest wealth level, the
medium wealth level, and then the highest wealth level. Across the board, the
majority, over 50% of people, still have 80% of the assets that they retired
with 18 years later. So what that tells me is what my life experience as a
financial advisor has shown is, is many of us are waiting too long to retire.
Because there is uncertainty in retirement. There's uncertainty in many
ways, but specifically right now I'm talking about uncertainty when it comes
to how much money you're going to need to retire. So the BlackRock study gives
us a lot of comfort to know, you know what, most people are not running out of
money. It's not the 50%. At least that's not what BlackRock has shown. BlackRock
has shown that over half of the people almost 20 years later, still have 80% of
the assets that they retired with. There's there's another source that I
want to share with you. And that is by it's an op-ed piece in the Wall Street
journals by Andrew Biggs. And Andrew, Andrew Biggs is a senior fellow at the
American Enterprise Institute. He's a smart guy. And the title of his op-ed
piece is, you don't need to be a millionaire to retire. And I agree with
that title. Now, the subtitle is, among seniors with 50 to $100,000 in savings,
86% were doing okay or living comfortably. And that's a fact by, we'll
go over this in a second, self-reported people say that that they're doing okay.
But I do think that retiring with 50 to $100,000 is awfully thin. I think it
comes with a lot of risk. And I think our future self will really thank us if we
can save a lot more than that. So let's look at Mr. Biggs op-ed piece here. He
goes on to say, how much does a retiree need to feel financially secure? And the
Federal Reserve shares that the median 65 to 74 year old who reports doing okay
or living comfortably had between 50 and 100,000 in savings. So this is a
Federal Reserve study. And the median retiree that reported living
comfortably had 100 to $250,000. And he goes on to say, it's impossible to find
any evidence that seniors need even a fraction of the $1.46 million in
savings needed to feel financially secure. There was a study done by
Northwestern Mutual that said that the average American feels they need just
under $1.5 million to feel financially secure. So Mr. Briggs point here is that
Americans need less than they think. I agree with that point. But I do think
like the Federal Reserve data shows us that the the median net household net
worth for people 50 to 64 years old is about 365,000. Now that's net worth that
the value of your home, which for many of us is the biggest portion of our net
worth. But I do think it's it would be, I mean, you have what you have. But if
you can save up closer to that median, or more than that, it gives you more
cushion, it gives you more flexibility. And I do like the fact that Mr. Briggs
goes on to share his view. So why do seniors report such high level of
security? And he talks about Social Security payments being higher now than
what they were in the past, and that being helpful in providing a cushion,
which is exactly why we have Social Security, we want to have that as a
cushion. He says the average couple retiring in 2022 receive total annual
benefits of nearly $46,000. That seems high to me. But again, Andrew Briggs is
a smart guy, I believe these numbers. And he says that's up from around $34,600
in today's dollars from $2,000. And while hardly extravagant, a typical
couple can expect an income more than twice the elderly poverty threshold
before they have it have to touch a penny of their savings. So, so that's
good news. Getting back to the Morningstar report, which was startling
for me, I want to share that with you. Again, we are where we are, we strive to
do the best that we can. And if you're wondering what does the average
retiree have an income, that's why I made this video up here. The average
retiree income in the United States. Thanks for watching this video. I'll see
you in that one.
