圍棋人機大戰-官方解說 15 分鐘覆盤【全五集】::Match 5 15 Minute Summary - Google DeepMind Challenge Match 2016
_科长_
1粉絲
6 次觀看·2025年9月9日
Hi, Chris Garlock here with Michael Redman for the match highlights in the fifth and final game of the Google DeepMind Challenge.
Michael, Lee Sedol had won Game 4, snatching victory from the Jaws of Defeat, and came into this final game with a pretty clear game plan.
Can you explain what the plan was and how it worked?
There were already signs of it, I think, from Game 2.
But at first, Lee Sedol was just playing it with white.
Kind of an Amashi strategy, like taking territory and then invading the moyo, which is usually played with white.
But in this game, he was playing it with black.
I did foresee that. I was thinking maybe he would do it.
But since it's usually not a strategy that's played with black,
I was not quite sure whether he would play for territory, as he did.
We can already see that black is taking territory in two corners.
Playing an opening that is very oriented towards territory.
But still, maybe he would try a fighting style opening, which didn't really work in the first game.
And it didn't work in the third game either.
So I think in the fourth game, he really decided that he could take territory and exploit the weakness, maybe, of AlphaGo
by invading the moyo and getting into a complicated fight there.
So after all, it was the game plan in this game too.
I was sort of suspecting it, but I wasn't sure.
So I was interested to see him actually using this plan.
It's a bit unusual for white to ignore this.
But white is playing for the whole board.
So it's maybe a valid way for white to play.
White plays the hane.
This is the strongest attack.
And with this move, white is basically already thinking of just sacrificing his stones.
So black extends.
White plays there.
Now white has a base here.
Black has a nice territory here.
Locally, it's quite a success for black.
White did get the extra move here, which is going to influence the area here.
And white has sente, so white put one stone here.
In return, black has a very nice territory here.
There is the point that he already had a solid territory.
So he's just building on a solid territory, which is not the most efficient thing.
But I would be happy to be playing with black because of all the territory.
And then black slides.
This is also a natural move.
And white pincers.
This is a pincer to make influence in this area with this behind it.
So this is a very natural move.
If white had played in the corner like this,
it would have been just perfect for black to extend here,
making a stable group in the place where white had hoped to make some,
well, if not territory, a moyo at least.
So white plays here.
At this point, Lee Sedol played this move,
which I sort of doubt actually.
It's hard to say which is better.
But since the ladder is good for black,
I would have probably just played here.
And if white plays here, black can connect underneath.
And the ladder here is good for black.
So white will either play here,
or sometimes you see players play this.
But in that case, this leaves a lot of potential
for these two black stones to move out later in the game.
There's still the invasion in the 3-3 point here.
So I would be happy to play with black in this opening.
In the actual game,
black gave some territory back to white by playing this and pulling back.
This move basically makes miyai or interchangeable points.
So either that move, which is where white played,
or if white plays on this side,
black will play here, white extends.
And again, this shape is kind of a double extension from the start point.
And it's sort of inefficient when black jumps into the 3-3 point.
So this is more or less what black was aiming at.
So it was correct for white to play on this side
and allow black to cut.
And in this shape, black has slightly more thickness
compared to this shape, which is a common joseki.
Black has more thickness towards the center.
But white has these extra stones here,
which sort of forms some extra territory here.
So black has lost some territory
in return for this double, this line of stones here.
Which are facing towards the center.
So he's sort of afraid of a center moyo a little bit.
It's not really consistent with his plan
to take as much territory as possible.
So that's why I sort of questioned this move.
But it is a kind of a balanced play here.
Then white plays on top here.
This is a natural follow-up move
for this whole shape, the throwing away.
Because it's sort of planning to squeeze
using the aji of these stones.
Maybe not the connection, but at least squeeze black,
reduce black's territory while building on the center.
So it's a very natural move.
And so black resists a little bit.
And pushes through once now.
And now black points out to the left.
That reduces white's potential in this area of the board a great deal.
Now something odd happens.
Something odd happens.
He cuts first.
The whole sequence here.
Just to point it out in the beginning.
The whole sequence here will end up with black
being very, very strong in this area.
So the drawback of white's sequence
is that white's going to make black very solid here.
And that makes a difference when white plays moves like this.
Or moves like...
In the game, white chose this one.
In either case, there's an entry point here.
And so I would calculate white's loss on this side
to be about five points
when white starts playing moves like this.
Here.
And here.
And white connected.
Played a hane.
And we can see the black position getting stronger and stronger.
And none of this actually works.
It doesn't work.
Actually, white is gaining a couple of points on this side.
So it depends on how you count the gain that black has on this side.
Which I think is pretty bad.
But if, for instance, if this becomes black's territory
or if nothing special happens here,
then there is a slight gain for white on this side.
So it sort of depends on how the game continues.
In some cases, this is not going to be a loss at all.
The general idea is that white's lost so much on this side
that usually it's bad for white.
But we can't really be 100% sure yet at this point.
So sometimes this doesn't have such a terrible impact on the game.
And there was a little concern when this was being played out during the game
that maybe AlphaGo was going on tilt a little bit again.
Well, I didn't think so.
Well, the local moves sort of make sense.
And even if you assume that it was a genuine mistake,
it would be a mistake such as the mistake in the center
after the white move 78 in the fourth game
where maybe AlphaGo didn't have the capacity
to read one of the moves that was a low profile.
So of course the programmers will be able to dig into the program
and find that out later.
And then after this white plays here,
this is a standard sequence here,
throwing one stone away like this
just to get the extra forcing moves on the outside
to reduce black's territory.
This is more or less forced.
And white can play an atari on the top and then atari on the side.
So by sacrificing this one stone,
white gets some extra forcing moves
and a nice wall there.
Now at this point, black has something in the vicinity of 40 points here.
About 10 points here, more than 10 points there.
So well, slightly over 60 points.
It's a lot of cash.
It's all solid territory.
Well, this is actually, if you only count the very solid territory,
it's slightly less than 40 points.
But in either case, black is in the vicinity of 60 points.
So Lee Sedol's plan is kind of working.
He's got white to create this big moyo.
And he's not going to jump in, I guess.
And this is not really territory yet
because black can jump in here.
White has some territory here and some territory here.
All of white's territory doesn't really add up
to more than 30 points at this point.
So black has a huge advantage in territory.
And he played here, which was probably a mistake.
This turned out to be a bit deep.
One would hope that white would be answering something like this,
in which case black could jump.
And this would really completely reduce white's potential in this whole area.
And even if white made some territory in the corner here,
it would be good enough for black to win.
And this works nicely with this rock-solid group.
And we're sort of seeing,
if you assume that white is continuing to try to take territory,
you can see that the center is just disappearing quite nicely.
This would be too easy.
Actually, what black should have done
is black should not have been so greedy, maybe,
and played something closer to the center,
which would be not as effective when white,
compared to the diagram I just showed,
the variation I just showed,
but it's much more safe.
Because white really can't...
It's more difficult for white to break in through there.
And next black does have a very nice move here,
which puts pressure on the corner.
If white plays something like that,
this move alone,
without even following it up,
has already reduced white's territory here.
And it's very difficult for white to successfully attack now,
because black can sort of just dodge away.
And it's a move on the top for a move below.
Very difficult for white to surround it now.
So black has a choice then.
He could play another move towards the center,
or he could jump in here,
which is a very big territorial move.
So this would be...
I think this is a slight advantage for black.
This move, it looked really natural.
But if you assume moves like this,
or moves like this,
it's easy for black.
But the move white played,
this capping move,
was very, very good.
It's a move that, actually,
human players would play too.
It's not as if it's
especially a computer move.
But it's just perfect for this.
It's an example of AlphaGo's strength.
So anyone who is afraid that AlphaGo
would sort of go berserk at this point,
should be relieved of that worry
by seeing this move.
And I think your analysis and commentary was
that AlphaGo really just plays this whole sequence
really nicely.
It's very nice.
It's sort of good style, you might say.
It's very natural moves.
And white didn't even try to kill black.
For instance, at this point,
if white had played here,
this would have been a more serious attempt
to kill the black group.
And it would entail some danger
because after this,
there would be the cut here later.
And white's stones in this area
are not so strong.
That means that black could possibly use that
to sort of move out into the center.
And this move would be rather small
as far as territory is concerned.
So it was probably a wise way for white to play
just to play on the top
and sort of make the width of this area thicker.
Black plays the key point.
And now black is alive.
White continues to sort of squeeze black.
And now there's no doubt
that this black group is alive.
And white plays on top again.
Again, it's good that you see
that white is not connecting.
Connecting is a bit heavy.
Actually, once white has forced black to live here,
you can say that these two stones
are not really all that important.
It's not that white's going to give them up too easily.
But in some cases,
white can afford to throw them away.
So they're not as important as they were before.
And white plays on the outside.
Actually, I think black played once here first
and then lived.
But it's the same thing.
White plays on the top.
The point is, white gets a big...
This is already looking almost like territory.
I think if we added one white move,
it would be territory of close to 50 points.
And so black had to come in.
And white still had potential on the side in this area.
And this territory is very difficult to count, actually.
Because it decreases
with every time black plays a move there.
But it also takes some time for black
to get rid of the whole territory.
So it becomes a very difficult endgame to execute.
And very close already at this point.
And I think towards the end,
it was a half-point difference at some point.
But at least it'll last a little bit.
AlphaGo, after its win was clinched,
I think it did play some questionable moves.
But again, it's a question of...
It was winning anyway.
So maybe it was just playing the safer route.
So this game from here,
and you were counting,
and the score was really interesting
because there was a lot of moves.
There were some swaps.
But in the end,
the score didn't really change for a really long time.
Not very much.
All the time, it was something like
7, 8 points on the board.
So it was really, really close.
It was a great...
We thought we were actually going to have a countable game.
Well, it was countable,
but they didn't count it.
They just didn't bother.
I think they were saying it was like a point and a half.
One and a half points, yes.
Well, yet another amazing game.
I want to say thank you to you, Michael,
for all of your incredible analysis,
these game commentaries.
They were all just exciting and tough games.
Appreciate that.
And congratulations again to the entire AlphaGo team
and to Lee Sedol.
This was an amazing week.
Really appreciate the attention to Go.
I think it's really going to, as you said,
open up a new era for the game,
for players and for artificial intelligence.
So we look forward to that.
So I look forward to the next time
I see you across the board.
And thanks, everybody, for watching.
Hope you enjoyed.
Thank you.
