Steven Bartlett, please stop spreading misinformation

Steven Bartlett
3 followers
Jan 4, 2025
My open letter to Stephen Bartlett to stop spreading misinformation now has
over half a million views so firstly thank you to everyone for the support so far.
But the obvious follow-up question is why has this resonated so strongly with so many people
and I feel the answer to that Stephen is that people want the truth.
We are fed up with living in a world of sensationalized claims where the primary
purpose of someone's social media post is to get clicks at the expense of the truth.
Promoting controversial opinions that attract attention in order to boost
notoriety and fame this is what I feel your show is doing.
To illustrate my point I'm going to use a comparison to a fellow podcasting titan
Chris Williamson and his Modern Wisdom podcast.
Now before I do this I want to ask you a direct question Stephen.
What is it you value?
Because it feels like you value status notoriety and playing the media growth game at all costs
but comparing your podcast to the likes of Chris Williamson's it feels like he values education
truth and integrity all while experiencing incredible growth as a podcaster.
Stephen you started your podcast in the business and entrepreneur space
but through personal interest you ventured into talking about nutrition and health.
So in my opinion you now have a responsibility to provide advice based on evidence and ensure
the appropriate amount of context is given should claims not be based in evidence.
It is a dangerous world where those with the loudest voices are allowed to promote health
claims that are not only unfounded but are contrary to what the research proves to be true.
It is evident you are very early in your personal journey with health and nutrition and as a result
being uninformed about the truth means you aren't able to appropriately challenge
your guests on what they say.
It's apparent when you listen to Chris Williamson on his show that he has a lot of experience and
background in evidence-based nutrition training and health and as such he is able to act as a
primary filter when guests make claims on his podcast.
He can respectfully push back on a guest on topics he feels doesn't sit with the body of
existing research rather than provide an uncensored platform for guests to push their unfounded
agendas which you currently do.
That combined with his due diligence for doing background research on his guests allows Chris
to ask appropriate questions that leads to a balanced conversation and a consistent message
throughout his shows that is aligned with the known science.
As a result you're not left confused after listening to the Modern Wisdom podcast.
Every show builds on the last and anchors itself around a respect and understanding
for the existing evidence such as calories being king for weight loss.
Unfortunately calories in versus calories out isn't all that sexy, uniquely marketable or profitable
but it is the truth.
So when an expert has a product or a service to sell they tend to ignore the truth and
twist the narrative to increase their sales.
Tim Spector being a prime example here, he chooses to ignore and skirt the research on
calories to push his agenda with gut and blood glucose testing.
Stephen is evident that you're no expert in nutrition and fitness, is evident by the way
you talk and how easily you're led by what sounds like the truth.
As long as an expert is to speak with confidence and clarity to you that's good enough to believe.
But you have a duty to question what your guests are pushing as the truth.
What's their agenda?
How do they benefit by going against the accepted facts?
How could their message impact your audience and could this lead to negative outcomes?
So I'll return to the question again Stephen, what is it you truly value?
Is it status, notoriety and growth at all costs?
Or is it education, truth and integrity?
If it's the latter something has to change.
Stephen please get someone on your show that is a hundred percent evidence-based
and can set the record straight.
I can imagine you'll look at my social media and think meh, who's this guy?
So my top recommendations as guests for your show, Elaine Norton, Mike Israetel,
Menno Henzelmans, Ben Carpenter, Dr Rhonda Patrick or James Smith who's been on your show before.
My last post has hit half a million views.
It shows a lot of people care about this and want to see you
elevate the presentation of evidence-based nutrition and health on your show.
That or go back to talking about business which we all see you as a credible voice for.
Your podcasts current unchecked additions into the world of health and nutrition podcasting
may be doing more damage than good.
