Housing Market Flashing Red for 'Miserable' Economic Reality in US

Prosper Property
1 follower
#homeprojects
#business
Melody Wright and Jack Gamble see all kinds of warning signs in the housing market that lead them to believe that the economic picture in the U.S. is far more dire than talking heads and media pundits would have you believe. The duo break down the indicators that have them concerned, discuss the speculative mania that is taking over a variety of markets and how it ends, reveal areas where they are looking for opportunity, and much more.
Hello everybody and welcome to the VRIC media channel,
our flagship event.
The Vancouver Resource Investment Conference
is coming up January 19th and 20th
at the Vancouver Convention Centre.
We have an incredible lineup of guest speakers,
keynote speakers, company CEOs, and more.
And the best part of all, it is completely free to attend.
So get your tickets by clicking the link
in the description below.
But of course we are bringing the VRIC to you
each and every week with our series
of expert online panels.
And I'm very excited for the one
we have lined up for you today.
It's Jack Gamble, host and producer
of Nobody Special, finance,
and Melody Wright, author of the M3 Melody Substack.
We're going to be talking about real estate,
which I'm stoked to dive into
because it's a topic I'd like to be educated on.
It's great to have both of you on the show.
Jesse, thank you so much for having us on.
Melody, always a pleasure to see you as well.
Thank you guys.
Yes, thank you so much, Jesse.
Looking forward to this.
Well, I want to start with a broad question
and that is what are the main themes and trends
you're currently watching
when it comes to the real estate market
and you can stick to the American real estate market.
If we want to look out on a global basis, feel free as well.
But what are the main themes and trends
that you think more people should be paying attention to?
Jack, I'll start with you.
So the two big trends I think
are the constants in real estate.
You've got employment and on a much higher level,
just overall affordability.
We're seeing slow but steady rises in the unemployment rate.
Chair Powell just earlier this week made several references
to some continued unwelcome softening in the labor market.
That was some unusual, a little dooming language there
from Chair Powell during that press conference.
He mentioned that the labor market is now less tight
than we were pre-pandemic.
So not a good sign for the employment statistics there.
We're also seeing things hidden
within the employment numbers
that I think are somewhat masking
just how miserable conditions are.
Things like loss of full-time jobs
being offset by gains in part-time jobs.
So that's not good for the housing market
because that typically comes with lower pay, less benefits.
Also things like a rise of multiple job holders.
That's a sign of desperation among homeowners.
I lost my full-time job.
I got to get two lousy part-time jobs
to still make the mortgage payment.
So that pain is cumulative in the housing market.
It's not like a one-off.
It gets worse and worse as people eat
into their savings month after month.
And we're yet to really see that show up
in the housing market.
And then the other big one, in my opinion, is affordability.
And Melody's better in touch with the statistics
than I am on the housing numbers.
So she could probably correct these numbers for me.
But just doing some looking before we went live here,
National Association of Home Builders earlier this year
had said that the median home now costs
for a single-family home, the median home costs 38%
of the median take-home pay in the country.
And that was a first-quarter 24 number.
So it may have gotten a little bit worse.
Now, I mean, historically, all the traditional wisdom
is never go above 30% of your take-home for housing costs.
And right now, median, where most people lie,
is significantly above that level.
So affordability is really stressing the housing market.
And on top of that, the problems in the employment market
will only add to those affordability problems.
And Melody, I'd love to hear your thoughts.
I know you specialize quite a bit in the real estate market.
You've got a fantastic account on X
where you discuss it in depth.
So I definitely recommend people follow you there.
But give us your thoughts at the moment
on the main themes and trends you're watching
when it comes to the real estate market.
Yeah, there's just so much going on, Jesse.
And I think so few people really understand
how complicated the housing market is in the United States
and just how much government intervention there is.
85% of outstanding mortgages are sponsored
by one of the government agencies,
be it a GSC or government-sponsored enterprise,
that's Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac,
or an agency like Ginnie Mae, who those are fully insured.
There's a lot of problems with that, though.
So I think I wanna talk a little bit about history,
and Jack's absolutely right on affordability.
We'll get to that.
But history, post the great financial crisis,
essentially what happened is the banks said,
we're not doing mortgage anymore
because Basel III came out
with all of these stringent capital requirements
around those mortgages.
Not to mention, they really got burned.
The banks did, as well as my company,
partnering with those government agencies
because they will do things like delay claims.
They will also nickel and dime you.
And so this is important to what I'm getting to,
but essentially, and this is the mortgage market
that is backed by mortgage-backed securities.
This is what makes the U.S. housing market work.
And what happened after the GFC
is that all of that went to these non-bank entities,
and the banks were happy to be like, okay, go away.
But they don't have deposits,
so they can't really lend based on their credit.
They basically lend based on the full faith in credit
of the United States government,
so they immediately sell those loans
off to one of those agencies,
and they use these large revolving credit facilities
to be able to do that.
And so the fact, a lot, so there's a lot about that,
understanding that without that government intervention,
we wouldn't have a housing market.
So that's one thing I just want everyone
to kind of understand.
So what happened, to Jack's point,
is that essentially conventional wisdom,
everyone would tell you 28%,
30% is what you should put toward housing, okay?
So unfortunately, what our government did
are those in charge.
So you had this thing
called the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
that came out with all of these rules
through Dodd-Frank after the GFC,
so we could never do risky lending again.
That was the battle cry,
no risky lending, no risky lending.
Well, guess what happened?
Instead of it was the private markets,
actually the government market
started loosening requirements, loosening requirements.
And so in reality, all of that legislation after Dodd-Frank,
the teeth were pulled out of it in 2021.
And so what you've basically had
is you've had the government step in
to that subprime market and our non-prime market.
And so what we're seeing right now is that non,
if you take the government portion,
and that's the big Ginnie Mae,
plus the privates, 25% of the market
is 9% delinquent right now.
But if you look on any schedule out there,
be it from Fred, who only tracks delinquencies
at the big commercial banks,
or you use Black Knight, who only has 30% of all mortgages,
you get a very skewed picture of delinquency right now
because of those.
And then something that the governments do,
and I'll be done in just a second,
because I just want to lay this foundation,
they also do these things called non-performing loan sales.
And they've been doing them since 2004.
And what this does is they buy up
any of these delinquent loans
and they sell them off to private hedge funds,
believe it, okay?
So then delinquency,
if you go look at a Ginnie Mae loan performance report,
or Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac loan performance report,
delinquency looks great.
Well, where do those loans go that are delinquent?
Well, they go off into a big black hole that we don't know.
So my point in all of this is,
I'm watching all of this under the covers
because so many people misunderstand
what happened in the last crisis.
They believe it was subprime, all, you know,
well, subprime was really non-prime,
non-traditional products for investors.
Yeah, there were some arms,
which that's, you know, the issue kind of in Canada,
we can talk about that.
You know, there were some arms that were done,
but usually those were for high credit quality,
believe it or not, like an 800 credit score.
They just, you know, essentially didn't have any other,
they didn't prove income.
But so you're seeing a lot of that happening as well now
in the private markets.
And so I think what's happened
is you had a lot of people think
that everything was done a whole much better
and the credit quality picture
is a lot better than it is right now.
And I'm watching that deteriorate.
And what's important is that, you know,
essentially non-prime didn't take the housing market down.
The prime borrowers did.
That was the big share of the foreclosures.
And essentially that didn't peak until 2010.
And we are just now starting to see delinquency increase.
And I'm sorry that was such a long answer,
but I kind of want to give that, you know,
I'm watching those things that are happening underneath
because it's really important on top of these things
we talk about like rates and aggregate affordability.
I believe that we're already in a lot more trouble
than most people realize.
Don't worry about long answers.
We love those on this show.
The more detail you can go into the better.
So it sounds like a pretty negative outlook
from both of you.
With that in mind,
are there any areas of the real estate market right now
that you see as an opportunity
from an investment perspective?
Because people hearing what both of you have said
would probably think,
well, I'm staying out of the real estate market then.
But is there anywhere that is not affected
by all of these negative trends you're seeing
or that you think could now be undervalued
because of these negative trends
where there could be opportunity out there?
Jack, what are your thoughts?
So this was a hard one.
I kind of struggled with this one
because you may have noticed I'm pretty bearish
on real estate with my first answer.
And I agree with everything Melody just said.
So I'm avoiding anything pertaining to housing
like the plague right now.
That being said, real estate isn't just housing.
One area I find interesting is energy.
In particular, with the real estate spin,
things like not so much what's on the land,
but what's under the land.
Things like oil, gas, and mineral rights.
We've got a new treasury secretary coming in, Scott Besant.
Besant, I don't know how to pronounce his name.
But part of his plan involves big increases
in domestic energy production.
And on top of that,
we've got rising electricity prices in this country.
In certain regions, they've doubled,
like in Northern Virginia.
As part of this big build out in artificial intelligence,
which I've talked a lot about on my channel,
we've built these data centers full of thousands,
in some cases, hundreds of thousands of these Nvidia GPUs.
Well, every one of these GPUs uses as much power
as a household of four people.
So a data center with 100,000 GPUs
will use as much power as a city of 400,000 people.
And so retail electric rates in Northern Virginia
have doubled in the last year,
which means we need a lot more electric.
And what's going on, we're spinning these stories,
like there's companies out there
like this nuclear startup, Oclo,
which in my opinion is just a big,
let's sell stock to suckers kind of company.
They're talking about nuclear.
I spent 15 years working in nuclear power.
I can tell you nuclear energy will not arrive in time
for these data centers.
It just, it moves so slow, that industry,
and that's on purpose.
They're nuclear notoriously careful.
So even though all the talking points about nuclear
and even pipe dreams about fusion are being sold out there,
what's really gonna power these data centers
is gonna be natural gas.
We're gonna have to produce
a lot more natural gas domestically.
We've got a resource friendly administration
coming into power here.
So things like obstacles to pipelines, fracking bands,
I think those things are largely behind us
and we're gonna start moving in the other direction.
So oil, gas and mineral rights
is an interesting twist on real estate
where there may be some opportunity,
even though real estate as a whole
is largely overvalued right now.
Now I would throw one little caveat in there.
A question is the Saudis and what did the Saudis,
the last time the United States was gaining market share
in the energy space in the early 20 teens,
the Saudis threw a fit
and they flooded the market with oil supply.
It crashed oil prices, it dragged down natural gas with it.
And that was more painful for the Saudis
than for us in my opinion.
And it's questionable whether the Saudis
would wanna do that again, but they could.
And if Saudis decide to do that,
if they pull back and they open up the valves,
decide to flood the market with supply,
that could put a real damper
on domestic energy production here in the States.
Interesting.
Melody, any thoughts you have on any areas
you're potentially seeing opportunity right now?
Well, I just wanna congratulate Jack
on coming up with an opportunity
because I'm not gonna have one.
Yeah, yeah, no.
Listen, there's always opportunity
if you know where to look, right?
And unfortunately what happened during the COVID boom,
the housing boom, was speculative mania
and everyone went wild wanting to buy a short-term rental.
First, they started with long-term rental
because that was the gig at the end of the last crisis.
Wall Street came in,
they bought up all that long-term rental
and everybody was like,
hey, maybe I can get that passive income.
And then you had fix and flip become just
the order of the day.
And then COVID comes and we get the fiscal stimulus
and these low rates and the Airbnb jocks are like,
listen, the social contract has been broken.
I got fired.
I'd worked there for 10 years overnight.
So people were like, how am I gonna get passive income?
Because I'm really sick of being taken advantage
by my company.
And everybody just went bananas buying all of that.
So what's happening right now
because the census moves so slowly
is people are not aware of how much vacancy is out there,
how much speculation actually exists.
But if you take a look at the coast of San Diego
and all of these places,
you can see they are just riddled,
infested with short-term rentals.
And so we are unaware of the speculation.
And actually the Philly Fed put out a paper last January
that said, hey guys,
speculation didn't end after the GFC.
And by the way,
when investors are involved in the housing market,
it's 30% more likely that there's going to be fraud.
And so you have things like non-owner occupancy fraud.
I've heard from veterans.
I've heard from all kinds of people
who have used their benefits,
not legally,
to get Airbnbs and rent them out.
And so this bug was massive.
And we don't understand.
So Sevierville, Tennessee is just a tiny little town
right down the street from me.
They have over 8,000 Airbnbs there
that you will never need that many Airbnbs.
And so right now is the time,
if you're smart and you go around
and you can sniff and you know the tools,
like you know how to look at county records,
there's some services out there
that'll tell you about delinquent tax liens,
things like that.
You might be able to find a deal,
but it's gonna take a lot of work.
If you are just new thinking about getting,
investing in real estate,
right now is the time to just sit and watch.
And perhaps follow someone like me
because I look at it from every single angle,
not aggregate.
I track 80 cities.
I track delinquency, credit quality profiles, employment,
all of these things in these cities
because real estate is local in many respects
except for the financing, right?
And so it is very,
so what happened,
let's take somewhere like Raleigh, North Carolina,
for instance.
Apple announces they're gonna move their,
they're gonna do a brand new headquarters there.
This is during COVID fever dream time.
Everybody goes bananas.
I think Intel was there as well, somebody else.
And so they just start going.
I mean, they go around the perimeter
to all these little sad little older towns.
They buy everything up and you drive around these, Jesse,
and these towns are a complete disarray
because they're flipping all these older homes.
But then you have all the new build communities
that are on that outer perimeter
pulling people out as well.
And so what happened?
Apple's not coming.
So they're still saying, okay, we're delaying it,
but this is like the third delay.
They're not coming.
And the other company I was talking about
just announced as well,
they're not getting their money from North Carolina
because they were supposed to bring like 3,000 jobs.
They brought like 400.
So everybody just went wild with speculation
on the commercial real estate side and on the residential.
And those two are inextricably linked.
And I think our commercial real estate problems,
everybody is aware of,
the problem is they don't see the link between residential
and they don't understand
because we don't have updated stats
what the vacancy looks like out there.
And we know we just built
the largest amount of multi-family
and we don't have the demographics to support it
even with immigration.
So right now, I would be just learning,
learning, learning as much as I could about real estate
and be ready for when those opportunities come.
I'd like to get both your thoughts
on kind of the speculative mania that exists
across a lot of markets right now,
because we're seeing crypto meme coins
get pumped to really unreasonable levels.
We're seeing single day call options on companies,
the highest level of participation,
I think in a very long time
and that sort of basically gambling day to day
on the price of the stock.
Is this sort of an environment that was created during COVID
when pandemic stimulus was put into so many people's hands
who maybe normally wouldn't participate in the market?
Do you think that's a big driver of that?
And do you think it's going to take
some sort of extremely big correction
in both the real estate market,
perhaps the broad market as well
to wash out this kind of speculative fever?
And Jack, I'll start with you.
100% Jesse, this is absolutely a mania
that's being driven by easy money.
And we have this mistaken narrative right now
and we've even heard it from Jerome Powell this week,
over and over again,
he talked about how monetary policy
was sufficiently restrictive
and we wanna dial back our restraint.
They've been telling us monetary policy has been restrictive
but since October of last year,
the money supply in the United States has been increasing.
It's been increasing rather dramatically.
And monetary policy was sufficiently restrictive
starting in 2022 and we saw it,
the stock market was heading lower.
We had the mass layoffs at the beginning of 2022
in big tech.
And then all of a sudden, 2022, November comes along,
we get this AI bubble starts,
private credit starts lending like crazy.
We passed all these rules that say banks
can't make risky loans unless they hold extra capital.
And then we create this whole new cottage industry,
we call it private credit,
which are basically banks that aren't banks
and they're doing exactly what the banks
aren't allowed to do.
And they're doing it with me borrowed from the banks.
So really it's the bank's money anyway,
they're doing exactly what they told us
they weren't gonna do anymore.
And the money supply is growing.
On top of that, you've got fiscal dominance
over in Washington where government spending
is offsetting quantitative tightening
by the Federal Reserve.
And it's ultimately resulted in more money
sloshing around in the system over the last year,
significantly more.
And in a shocking turn of events,
you get things like fart coin and hop to a token
and that end up going to like billion dollar valuations.
People think this is different.
This is new and unique.
This is the same crap with a different smell
that we've always seen during speculative manias.
And there is no painless way out of things like this.
Unfortunately, all these people who like cab drivers,
shine boys who are now day traders,
they need to be washed out.
They need to get wiped out in order to stop that FOMO.
I hate to see it, but it's probably gonna happen again.
Yeah, very interesting thoughts.
And when it comes to, I've spoken to several of my friends
who had never really invested before.
And now all of a sudden they're taking gambles
and all these different things.
I just say, oh, that's cool.
And I changed the topic because there's really
no convincing anybody in that position
that what they're doing doesn't make any sense.
And they should spend a tremendous amount of hours
studying and understanding markets,
which no one's willing to do.
Melody, what are your thoughts on this issue
of such a speculative mania that we're seeing these days?
Can I interest you two in some tulips?
I mean, this is just, this is insane.
I mean, I think I had to walk away
from social media a little bit
because I couldn't believe it.
I think this is exactly what happened
during the GFC for housing.
It's like, everybody got a little hurt, right?
The little hurt, but not hurt to the point of destruction.
And so what happened?
It came back on steroids.
And so I think exactly what Jack said,
we were heading into a correction
and then we had the bank spell,
and then we had the BTFP,
or I like to call it by the effing put,
so that's basically,
that turned everything around from a sentiment perspective,
in my opinion, and when people are like,
oh, wait, I'm gonna get backstopped.
Oh, well, let's just go.
Let's just, you know, let's go.
And so I also believe we're gonna have to let
the destruction fully play out this time.
And I honestly believe we never let it play out
from the GFC, you know, we can't,
that's why we still have all these huge,
massive buildings that are empty out there.
You can go to Dallas,
they have all this empty commercial real estate.
What did they do instead of like rehabbing a building
or bulldozing it?
Oh, I don't have time for that.
I'm gonna make much more money go,
you know, building this shiny skyscraper
that by the way, nobody's ever gonna be in.
I mean, you can see these in Austin, they're everywhere.
We have so much bulldozing to do, like it's insanity.
And a lot of that happened because we extended
and protected, you know, at the end of the crisis,
we never fully recovered in my opinion.
And let's talk about commercial real estate for a moment,
cause you touched on it there.
And we spoke maybe a little bit more
with more focus on residential earlier
when it came to the overall picture
of the real estate market in the US.
How do you see things from a commercial perspective?
In that particular sector,
are there any opportunities at the moment?
Is this just kind of the same,
you wanna be sitting on the sidelines for now?
Melody, I'll start with you on this one.
Oh, you will, okay.
Yeah, everybody that's out there saying class A,
class A is gonna be fine.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
You gotta look local.
I mean, so Jesse, I don't know how many of you know this,
but I've driven over a thousand miles across the country
looking at these markets.
And I'll just give you an example of people like class A.
Okay, well, I was living in Pittsburgh
and it's called Canonsburg,
but it's a huge live, eat, play location
where they had a nursery.
They had all these,
about 12 class A commercial real estate buildings.
They had everything golf course.
They had the condos on the golf course.
And before COVID, they had a few good tenants.
Well, guess what?
They're all gone.
That's all class A.
And it will never be inhabited again.
The only way is if someone comes up
with a creative solution,
like doing a university there or something,
or maybe creating a senior community, something,
but no one's thinking like that right now.
All they're thinking about is how do I make quick money?
They don't wanna invest.
They don't wanna create solutions.
They just want to make return.
And so I, again, maybe there are opportunities out there,
but I would caution you, anyone,
especially from the sell side on this stuff,
dig in and really look at that market
because I don't care if it's class A luxury
with a pickleball table and arcade
and all this kind of stuff.
If you don't have the right industry there,
that building will never be occupied.
But this is what happened during COVID
is everybody got a brochure in the mail that said,
buy your class B multifamily
and you're going to make millions.
And they got on a bus and they went down to these cities
and they picked their one and they did no other research.
And I think that there are gonna be smart players
that make some good deals in commercial real estate,
but it's only if you truly understand
all of the dynamics of that market.
Very well said.
Jack, your thoughts on commercial real estate at present?
You know, I would like to just like kind of wander
into Blackstone headquarters one day
and just kind of stand in the corner
and shout, the floor is price discovery
and watch everybody jump up on their desk.
Watch Steve Schwarzman hugging this giant printer
to avoid price discovery at all costs.
Because the commercial real estate industry,
like we know this stuff isn't worth what they say it's worth
and for whatever reason,
how many years into the CRE crisis are we now?
We'll say two and I think that's optimistic.
It's been 20 years in the making.
And still these guys are carrying this stuff on their books
as if it's still worth 2018 prices.
We all know it's not,
but they're still putting it on the books at that.
I mean, are we gonna talk about what the emperor is wearing
or lack thereof at some point,
price discovery will catch up with them
and it's gonna be a mess when it happens.
I'm amazed how long they've been able to avoid it.
It's really a testament to the froth
and the greed and stupidity and just corruption
in our financial system
that they've been able to get away with it.
Every time one of these buildings goes up for sale,
it's almost always at an auction.
It's almost always handing the keys back to the lenders.
And it's for, in some cases, single digit percentages
of what these buildings sold for in 2015.
And yet Blackstone, Starwood, all these outfits are like,
we're doing great, our portfolio is robust and strong.
Well, maybe it's because they're able to pass off
all these losses onto the pension funds
and the retirement accounts
that actually own the shares in these things.
And they're somehow able to just walk away from the debt.
Now, there was a really interesting story
I just talked about in my morning live stream today.
I'm not sure when this is gonna air.
But Big Lots just announced yesterday,
they're filing for bankruptcy.
They're closing all 900 of their remaining stores,
27,000 people out of work.
See also earlier comments
about the labor market and affordability.
But think about what that means
from a commercial real estate perspective.
A Big Lots store tends to be
one of those big anchor locations
at like a strip mall, right?
Well, all the rental contracts at a place like that
for all of the smaller stores in the strip mall
typically have riders attached to them,
where if an anchor location goes vacant,
it triggers a big substantial drop in the rent
for the remaining tenants.
And just in this one story that hit the tape yesterday
about Big Lots closing 900 stores,
you're talking about 900 of these locations
around the country where not only are they not gonna be
getting rent from Big Lots,
but all the remaining locations at those strip malls
will also see lower rents.
So those owners and the people who own the debt
backing those buildings are in big trouble.
And that's just one anecdote of Big Lots.
Now rinse, repeat that across all of these other
retail chains and other operators
that are running into problems here.
This commercial real estate bubble is still getting worse
despite daily calls from a bottom
or for a bottom from the people on CNBC.
Well, Melody, you mentioned Canada
earlier in the conversation.
I'd like to touch on that as well.
I live in Serbia, but I go back home
and visit Canada every year.
And what I've been noticing is the house prices
climbing higher and higher to the point
where now what a million dollars can get you
is really not all that impressive.
And of course, that depends on jurisdiction.
If you're willing to live kind of out in the wilderness,
Northern British Columbia, for example,
maybe you can get something decent
for half a million dollars.
But if you want to be anywhere near a city,
you're paying a very high price.
What do you think has caused this?
Many people are pointing to it.
We've taken on too much immigration.
And so they're projecting that out into the future.
Although apparently there's been some changes
made to immigration policy
and there'll be less people coming in.
But people are saying the house prices
aren't really going to drop
because we just have too much of a population
entering the country for the amount of inventory
that's available.
Others would say, no, it's more of a real estate bubble
that will pop eventually.
I wonder what your thoughts are.
Yeah, so I'm not a specialist on Canada at all.
I'm too busy tracking the U.S.
But I would recommend people follow Ben Rabideau on Twitter.
He is very well-versed in this market.
But, and the Bank of Internet Settlements
does a great, every quarter they do a deep dive
into all of these issues,
cross-border, collateral, things like that.
But they focus on housing.
And Canada has been on a watch list for some time,
but they talk about how the local,
what's happening locally really makes,
is important as to when that might happen.
What I can say about Canada,
just based on the little that I know,
and it is very, very little,
is that it's the cost to carry the underlying debt
on this is getting to a point that is untenable,
in my opinion.
And as they reset this, every fight,
I mean, I think you're about to see some real trouble.
What the cause of it in Canada is, I can't say exactly.
But I think what you just mentioned,
if I started digging,
I would be able to combat a lot of the narratives
that you just said.
Because I think in the United States,
a lot of the pushback I've gotten is on immigration.
I don't care.
I've seen the inventory, it's out there.
I don't care how many people are coming in.
We could probably house Mexico at this point down there.
So it is just insanity.
And so I think in this mania that we've been,
and I think we're a globally synchronized economy.
And so I think we've all been in a state of mania
for some time.
And also in this state of, I need to get mine.
I need to get mine.
And however that is, buying a house, whatever it is.
And so the narratives to support that
have been very, very strong.
And so few people actually know what's really happening.
And so I'd love to, Jesse, at some point,
have some time and go debunk them in Canada.
Because I guarantee you, it's a lot of narrative,
whatever it is, masking what's truly going on underneath.
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
Jack, do you have any thoughts?
Yeah, I mean, on the immigration front,
you're always gonna have people
with pre-existing political dispositions.
It's a very emotionally charged topic.
And you're gonna have people who come in
with pre-prepared remarks one way or another.
So politically and emotionally, it's a minefield.
Look, to uproot yourself and move to a different place
where you don't even speak the language,
a strange country in hopes of a better life,
my hat's off to anybody who would even try that.
That's gotta be scary as all get out.
And not for nothing, the kind of people
who are willing to do that are probably,
arguably, the kind of people
you wanna have in your society.
You get people who are willing
to put the work in and do that.
Now, all that being said, when you bring people in,
if there's a roof over their head,
they're adding to demand for housing.
So let's not act like immigration is not affecting
the supply-demand dynamics in housing.
If they're here and they're living in a place,
they are adding demand.
But the other facet, I think,
and I think what's more important
towards housing bubble dynamics with immigration
is not so much the added demand
as it is what they do on the supply side
in the labor market.
See earlier comments about affordability
and how the average person is spending 38%
of their take-home on housing.
Well, one of the reasons why the cost of inflation
has outpaced wage gains is because of the influx of people,
at least stateside.
I don't know if it's as big a deal in Canada,
but you can see it in the jobs reports in the United States.
Millions of Americans have dropped out of the labor force
and millions of, the term used in the BLS reports
is non-native born workers,
which includes both legal and illegal immigrants.
It also includes American citizens born in other countries,
but the majority of that is gonna be illegal immigration.
So when you add mass amounts of labor supply
and the demand stays the same, labor prices go down.
So it's preventing wages for everybody else from rising,
which is adding to the affordability problem that exists.
So yeah, immigration, it doesn't just hurt
on the demand side, it also hurts on the supply side
in the labor market.
So it squeezes the labor market at both ends
and I think it's causing problems
and it's adding to the cumulative hardship of inflation.
Well, let's step outside of the real estate market
for a moment because it doesn't look like
there's a lot of opportunities there.
Maybe in foreign jurisdictions, say here in Serbia,
you can get a really nice house
depending on where you're at for 160,000 euros
with a big lot and everything like that.
So maybe in some of these emerging economies,
there might be some opportunities out there,
but for the time being, when it comes to markets in general,
where are you currently looking for opportunity
outside of real estate?
And Melody, I'll start with you.
Jack would probably be better at this,
but honestly, I think that,
so I'm gonna say something that's gonna be the opposite
of what you're probably asking me, Jessie,
but I'm just kind of passionate about it.
It's like, firstly, there's no debt.
Like we are entering into a time
that I think that we might see the play out of the GFC.
We might be in such hard times and so I would say,
make sure whatever you're doing,
just pay off as much as you can right now
and because that's where it's gonna hurt the most.
Seeing those credit card rates, right?
So if you were investing using leverage,
I just don't think that is a really good idea,
but so I'm gonna say something else as well.
Make sure that you have, I believe in lifelong learning.
Make sure that your skills are up to date
because in a challenging economy,
you're going to need to be able to pivot.
So always be out there learning new things.
The other thing I'll say is hard assets.
Yes, land, your gold, things like that.
However, that's tricky right now
if you don't have that stuff already,
so you're gonna have to be careful
and then of course, just getting the return you can
and sort of the money market accounts
while we still have rates at these levels.
So that would, I'm not, I stepped out in 2022
from the markets and honestly, I don't,
I think right now it's tricky for long-term treasuries.
I think, yeah, you'd still be okay in the short end,
but I would say short, short end, four weeks, eight weeks.
I mean, you look at what just happened is all of a sudden
we were talking about the Fed,
and they came out and they did something
nobody was expecting, but then front page the next day,
Trump's talking about the debt ceiling.
And I mean, and it's a lot of political drama,
not saying that anything's gonna happen,
but this stuff brings volatility.
And so I personally would say
on the very, very short end in buying T-bills.
That's some great information there because yes,
investing in yourself is so important in times like these
and tightening the belt and making sure
that you're living below your means
and that you actually have some cash on the sidelines.
Like you're saying, maybe in short-term treasuries
to get a little bit of a yield, which you still can get,
you know, around four, four and a bit percent at the moment.
So I love that.
Jack, your thoughts on where you're looking
for opportunity right now in the markets.
You know, it's kind of funny.
I'm going to the same place Melody went,
but I'm gonna get there by a very different route,
but it's destination is the same.
Everybody that, pretty much everybody in financial system,
right, that run the financial system,
they're surprisingly young, they're 20s, 30s, right?
And a lot of millennials,
people who have never seen higher rates.
Their entire life is based on lower interest rates
just by rates are going down, they're gonna print,
they're gonna lower, all right?
We're watching governments collapse
around the world right now
because that doesn't work anymore.
Germany, France, to a lesser extent, South Korea, right?
The circus going on in Congress right now.
There is pushback on this.
Now, if you zoom way, way out on the charts,
go all the way back to World War II.
Post World War II, you had about a 40-year period
of substantially higher interest rates.
If you look at the US 10-year yield,
go all the way back to the end of World War II,
interest rates rose pretty much from the mid 40s
all the way up until 1980, higher interest rates.
That was a 40-year cycle of higher rates.
Then, obviously, at the end of the Volcker era,
we had the 40-year era of Zirpenberg,
of lower rates and money printing.
And that's the era that everybody in the financial system
is basing all of their experience on,
is that 40 years of substantially lower rates.
Well, 2022 came along, the inflation post-COVID
changed that, and in my opinion,
we're in a new 40-year period of steadily higher rates,
possibly for decades.
And everybody, people like in commercial real estate,
oh, the lower rates are gonna save the day,
the Fed is gonna save us.
Well, have you seen what's happened to the 10-year yield
since the Fed started lowering?
It's done nothing but go up, all right?
The Fed doesn't control the long-ended yield curve.
Interest rates are going higher.
So yeah, you don't wanna be in debt right now
because debt's getting more expensive.
And there's one guy, one big name in finance,
who was around, go back two of those big cycles
to that post-World War II era.
There's one guy that made a name for himself
back in that day, Warren Buffett, all right?
He came up in the 60s, right in the middle of that.
And you know what Warren Buffett is sitting on right now?
Last I checked, $325 billion of cash.
He's selling tech, he's selling banks,
he's selling everything and he's buying nothing.
And he's the only one out of all these big names
in Wall Street and all these arrogant A-holes,
in my opinion, he's the only one who's ever seen higher rates
and he's sitting in cash.
So if you're sitting in cash,
you might as well park it in T-bills
and make a few percent while you're doing it.
So Melody, I get to the same place you did.
Very interesting insights from both of you.
This has been a fantastic conversation.
Greatly appreciate both of you coming on.
Melody, tell us about the M3 Melody sub-stack
and anywhere else you want to direct people online,
feel free.
Sure, so this is a sub-stack
where I try to craft a narrative, Jesse.
I do a lot of data, a lot, but the data, in my opinion,
can become so overwhelming, right?
If you don't have context of what's going on.
So I rely on my experience of managing the last crisis
and I worked both in finance and in default operations
during the crisis,
as well as with our bankruptcy when that happened,
as well as with the Fed on the consent orders
when the mortgage industry got into trouble.
So I bring that perspective to what I see now
and things that people just don't even know to look for.
Because if you don't understand the way
that the whole system works,
you're gonna be surprised every single time.
Like the person that's surprised right now
who was told, date the rate, you'll be fine.
Date the rate.
And how many people were told that?
They're not gonna be fine.
So if you had been reading my sub stack,
you would have known that the Fed
doesn't control mortgage rates.
You would have understood that.
You would have understood what to see signals.
So I would recommend that.
I'm also on X Twitter, M3 underscore Melody,
as well as on YouTube more infrequently,
M3 Melody YouTube.
Right, I'll put links to all of that
in the description below.
Jack, tell us about Nobody Special Finance.
Anything else you do?
I know you do spaces on X as well.
Nobody Special Finance is the name of my YouTube channel.
I do a daily live stream every morning,
9 a.m. Eastern time.
Financial news, market snapshots.
That live stream also goes out to X.
I'm at JG underscore new on X.
So you'll see my content there as well.
I like to do market news.
And also I have a big chip on my shoulder
and I cannot stomach liars, crooks and thieves.
So I also like to do investigative reporting on frauds
and just the people who are preying on average people
who don't want to be speculated,
they don't want to be gamblers,
but they're forced into this crap
by these people who are getting rich
off of this endless inflation and endless money debasement.
And so I like to dig into that and call those people out.
And hopefully we'll have something to say
about some of this more ridiculous stuff
like fart coin that's going on in the market right now.
I'm digging into that one
and finding some rather amazing things.
So let's just say it doesn't pass the sniff test
to put it mildly.
I'll go ahead and put links to both your X account
and Nobody's Special Finance YouTube channel
in the description below.
It's been a pleasure having you both on
and thank you so much for sharing all your knowledge.
Thank you, Jesse, so much.
Always a pleasure to talk to you, sir,
and Melody, you as well.
Thank you.
Yeah, thank you so much, Jesse.
And thank you, Jack.
It's great to see you as always.
