Happy New Year OR Maybe NOT! Real Estate Crash Incoming.

Wealthy Realty
2 followers
Jan 3, 2025 #homeprojects #business
#homeprojects
#business
After years or punishing real estate prices and unaffordable housing will the stars finally align in 2025 bringing in lower prices and home buying opportunities? I say YES, this weeks data supports a major housing downturn and economic pain for many in the new year. Don't miss out on this weeks real estate news as we end 2024.
Hello again and welcome back. Thanks for tuning in this week and happy new year.
Happy 2025 or maybe it won't be depending on what side of the fence you're sitting on.
Before I get into this week's stats that show why 2025 is most likely the year
when everything's going to fall apart, first a message from this week's top fan.
The funny part about this is it actually is a message, a voicemail,
and I posted it on my ex a week or so ago but I'm going to play it for you now.
Hey John you got a great blog but I'll tell you what I can't watch it anymore.
The problem in this Canada is not the supply of housing whatsoever.
The problem here is we've got people that don't belong here and that's what you should address.
We don't need more building or more supply so the whole premise of your blog is a bunch of baloney.
We need to deport numerous tens of thousands of people and students who overstay their visas.
Why don't you say that? Who are you actually working for?
Your customers? The people? Or what? Why don't you say that? That's the problem.
We don't have people coming into this country legally. Who in their right mind would do that?
I've been here 50 years, a lot longer than you're alive.
74 years old. I live in Vancouver. I live in West Vancouver. I live near Maggie Trudeau.
I know a hell of a lot more than you do and I just cannot stand it when I watch YouTube and
watch people like you lying and not telling the truth and not representing the market the way it
really is. We don't need supply so fuck off. Alright so I think someone had a little too
much to drink but this is not uncommon for people like myself and other people that you know have
some followers on X and YouTube and whatnot to receive messages like this. I receive them in
comments usually but you know sometimes you do receive a voicemail but I actually thought this
was kind of funny because maybe I'm a little sicko but I don't know. He really wasn't making
sense in my opinion. I've always said that supply was never an issue and he's trying to say
what are you doing? We don't need more supply and I say that all the time. It was the demand that
was the problem. He goes on about immigration a little bit too much there. I'm an immigrant myself
so you know I understand where he's coming from but I just don't think the approach was right
there. Anyway let me know what you think in the comments and hey let's move on. There's a few more
posts that caught my attention in the last week or so and this is from Andrew Buzari MD. Thank you
Mr Bernadinetti for telling your story. An honest reminder that too many people are not far from
being unhoused and this guy was a Toronto City Councillor an MPP and he ended up in a homeless
shelter and he told his story to the Toronto Star. I didn't read it. I don't know why but yeah he was
unhoused and after becoming like I said an MPP and a Toronto City Councillor which is crazy. Who
would have thought that you could become homeless after occupying one of those public positions but
anyway it happens. And while we're on the subject of Toronto, Toronto residents could be in for
another property tax hike Toronto Mayor warns. Mayor Chow outlined budget priorities in year-end
interview which is again not going to be uncommon in my region. I think they're going up nine percent
or something. They've already been announced so yeah property tax hikes are still going to continue
as inflation and the cost of living still continues to bother us. This next story is pretty much
everything that's wrong with the real estate market. Well maybe not everything but a BC man
who flipped 14 properties between 2011 and 2014 has been fined more than two million dollars for
failing to report nearly 7.5 million dollars in earnings. The Canada Revenue Agency says in a
given a conditional sentence of two years less a day on December 19th and fined about 2.15 million
dollars matching the amount of unpaid federal income tax. So this guy did jail for flipping
houses also and not declaring those those proceeds. And from economic woes here I see the Canadian
real estate influencers and grifters are claiming housing is going to go up while Canadian shits the
bed. That's cute. How did real estate do in the 90s? And of course 1990 I think was the peak of real
estate in Canada after a big run-up and there is the US to Canadian dollar and of course 1991 it
peaked and yeah it went down it went all the way to 72 cents by 1997 there. So as the Canadian
dollar collapsed so did the real estate market and it stayed down the whole time too. So yeah
again when people talk about this Canadian dollar in the real estate market it's just speculation
it's like saying the interest rates when interest rates come down prices are going to go up well
they've been saying that and they're still continuing to say that into 2025 now like nothing
else in the world matters it's only interest rates going down is going to make house prices go up
even though unemployment's going up and all these other things are happening you know that's
irrelevant and there's no data to back up these claims either so yeah this is again just another
one of those claims to get you to buy a house or to get you a mortgage or whatever the case may be.
This one here from td leaker this is pretty interesting now this guy knows somebody a
staffer with the government of some kind and the liberal party or something but he's had a few
posts and he gives us tidbits of information here. Had a bev with my staffer friend again
it's strictly forbidden within the party to even mention how many homes have actually materialized
from the billions dumped into housing programs why because the math is catastrophic hundreds of
millions spent per home instead they citing to the total amount spent as their twisted measure
of success they know full well this is a death sentence for the party so yeah they always do
talk about that and how many billions they spend we've invested billions into this and billions of
that well how much did you spend or how many houses were built and what's the cost per home
but yeah they don't obviously talk about that so that was a pretty interesting post there from td
leaker and lastly before i get into the stats from don johnson my driver this evening is a realtor
that sold one home this year he's been doing it for 40 years and i asked skip or uber i'm guessing
that's what he's talking about right so yeah it doesn't matter how long you've been doing real
estate uh you gotta supplement your income when the times are slow and uh yeah i think i used to
limo when i had uh i don't know 15 years ago the guy didn't pay me actually i was driving limo for
like two weeks i had a kid on the way and yeah the guy didn't pay me but yeah i was doing it at night
just you know i was nesting making more money for when my kid was going to be born
but you have the flexibility to do things like that in real estate when the times are slow
but uh it doesn't look good for your business when you're out there i guess uh drive an uber or skip
the dishes for for low income when you're supposed to be the successful realtor all right now let's
get into some stats and prove why 2025 will be the year that things finally collapse in real estate
a lot of things have been happening but it actually hasn't materialized into a recession or
a significant housing downturn sure we've had low sales numbers but the prices have held
significantly high for too long now so let's get check out these stats all right first i just want
to get into some december these were done on this december 30th some stats from the toronto real
estate board usually i take all the data they have and i give an update or whatever the case
may be but this week i couldn't because we just merged a bunch of data and a bunch of boards have
merged with the toronto real estate board so when i combine them all the price actually went up in
december which is kind of odd and then so i separated we can separate the gta or outside the
gta so when i separate it outside the gta this data here is going back to january 2022 you can
see here with the arrow so according to this data our average house price went up 117 thousand
dollars or 17 month over month from november this year to december this year in december and this
was done yesterday december 30th which is of course not correct there's obviously an issue
with the data merge so i'm going to go over some quick stats before i get into the fun stuff but
mind you this is just the gta not the surrounding areas right now just to see how the market's doing
in one of the biggest or the biggest place in canada okay so here is just the gta durham halton
peel toronto and york and of course december has trended just like every other december the first
line on the chart the first bar there i should say is last december so this is a 13 months total data
and again this was done on the 30th of december yesterday so minus 35 000 dollars month over month
or 3.1 percent decline from november and up five thousand dollars from last december or 0.5
percent so nothing significant there really markets flat and it's doing what it does for
this time of year now looking at the number of sales we still do have one day left of course
we are lacking a little bit of sales but it's fair to say 3480 last december 2023 and 3388 this
december so it would be very similar sales to last year so with all those rate cuts that happen
this year and whatever else those new mortgage rules the sales have remained flat at best now
looking at the days on market days to sell again this is all just in the gta not nowhere outside
37 days to sell the average house in the gta up two days from last year which was 35 and it is
the same as january this year so the highest month is january and december 37 days to sell
now this next chart i did post on my ex this week and uh yeah this december the 2023 37 days this
was uh when did i do as of december 27th but it hasn't changed now since i did it last night
on the 30th 37 days is the highest days on market in the last 10 years you can see they're 2014
so yeah when everyone tells you or when these agents or mortgage brokers whoever the case may
be these people tell you the the market's taking off and sales are picking up well it is taking
longer and longer to sell your home which is a reflection of the overall market now moving on
to new listings new listings up significantly just like sales this was done on december 30th
and look 5 088 new listings in december this year compared with 3 899 for last year so big
uptick what's that 20 higher 25 more listings this year than there was last year so inventory
is increasing we do see the months where it's down and you know it's hard to go month to month
but uh we are seeing a consistent trend of more listings come online okay now let's get in to why
2025 is going to be the year when things finally shit the bed in canada when it comes to real
estate sure sales have been slow but prices have maintained pretty well up until now although there
has been slight declines but i'll get into that in a minute so this is pretty much my home buying
recipe but with more of a timeline on it and looking at some other data sets here so i'm
not going to go into the home buying recipe per se but again it's all relative here and this is
the key indicators to it now this first one actually isn't included but this is the canadian
the yield curve right this is the 10 year minus the two year and and you know if you if you listen
to anything you know when it inverts when it un-inverts there is usually always a pending
recession now ours un-inverted in mid-october and of course we looks like we're have a looming
recession uh i think we had a 0.1 percent gdp in the october i think it was in november it was
released that data below expectations but we're going to get into some negative gdp i'm guessing
sooner or later but just to put this in context let's look at this next chart here this is the u.s
10 year treasury minus the two year and yeah you can see every time it un-inverts i've circled
them there back in the 80s i'll get my head out of the way here back in the 80s it actually
un-inverted during the recession both times there was two recessions there in the 80s
but looking at 1990 there the second red circle you can see it un-inverted and into a recession
same with the 2000-2001 dot-com bubble helped that obviously and of course 2007-2008 financial
crisis un-inverted into a recession and it takes about four to nine months on these charts here
for this to happen right now we're two and a half months into that un-inversion territory
so again it puts us in that timeline for early to mid 2025 when we actually finally see a recession
could be sooner but when they actually call the recession now that does take you know however
many quarters after them for them to look back and say oh we were in a recession so this next
chart i actually have posted before but i haven't talked about it in the context of 2025 and kind
of that exact timeline here so unemployment rate and the interest rates which are both on my home
recipe both ingredients there let's start with the bank of canada overnight rate the one thing
i want to point out here is when that green line that bank of canada overnight rate reaches its
floor when they stopped cutting rates uh i don't care if it's in the 2000s the 2010s or just before
the 2010s or uh 2020 whenever it was look at unemployment unemployment is almost exactly
within a few months it peaks right when they hit the bottom so when uh interest rates are supposed
to stop or supposed to reach their bottom at some time in 2025 who knows when exactly when that's
going to be but that's kind of looks like the trajectory they're on unless they have to raise
them again due to some inflation issues but regardless it looks like they're going to keep
going down until some point in 2025 before they reach their floor and unemployment will spike
and which makes sense because right now when i did this chart we're about six probably almost
seven months six and a half months or so into that cycle of when they started cutting rates
unemployment's on its way up and look how long it takes for unemployment to spike anywhere from 12
to 19 months let me move my head here that was 18 12 19 so 12 to you know 18 months or so and
so mid-year we were going to see unemployment spike give or take three months so it could be
first quarter second quarter it could be sometime in 2025 but again all signals point towards 2025
for that to happen and uh yeah this is this one this chart actually tells you a lot by looking at
it look also here at the trajectory that the unemployment increases right it's usually not
a smooth you know upward trajectory it does it pretty quick it's not going to be a long drawn
out peak i believe it's going to be like all the rest of these okay so house prices declining i talk
about this all the time and some people don't think they're declining they keep telling me they're
going to go up and they've been telling me how many times ask yourself in 2023 and 2024 have you
been told that house prices are going to go up and how many times in the comments have i been told
that i'm wrong and house prices haven't crashed look at this chart here the peak price in 2022
was 815 000 that was the peak of the market in historical prices in canada then we get into
may 2023 which was the highest priced month average price in canada for 2023 728 000 the
highest we reached this year and december is not going to break any records let me tell you
but the highest we reached was april 2024 703 000 so every year prices have gone down in canada
and they're going to continue into 2025 now we haven't even had a recession yet okay now lastly
we have the mortgage arrears now mortgage arrears are still historically low look at them there and
they're not even at the lowest from the last time the last cycling like 0708 but they are increasing
but again when mortgage arrears take off they take off quick now mortgage arrears as opposed
to 6 to 12 months they take up to 2 years to reach their peak but the trajectory is intense
you can see there from 0708 in the big circle over in the middle of the page to 2010 they just
went up like a rocket and prior to that back in the mid 90s this data only starts from 1995
i wish i could have seen the data from 1990 to 1995 but anyway of course they would have went
up like a rocket ship there too now one thing that we're going to look at on this chart is
look at when they peaked they peaked in 2010 at the last economic downturn we had a major economic
downturn i should say now i want to go back to this chart here when you look at the unemployment
on the same time right in the middle there 19 months it said that unemployment spiked around
0809 so mortgage arrears continue on after so mortgage arrears won't spike or won't peak
until probably 2026 i'm guessing but we're going to see that upward trajectory in 2025 which is an
early warning sign that yeah all hell has broken loose so yeah let me know what you think in the
comments about 2025 do you think 2025 is going to be the year based on data like this or do you
think it's going to be a happy-go-lucky interest rates come down and prices go even further to
the moon i guess uh anyway that's it for this week and i'll see you next time
